09-16-20 425 E. Sycamore Avenue - Martin Residence (DRC 4967-19)AGENDA ITEM
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
September 16, 2020
1. SUBJECT
2. SUMMARY
3. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
rty Li:425 yc
G P e:L y 26 /
Zon C:S y (R)
Ex pm 50 q my h +/- 0 qu
gag
ppl e
P n v (R)P Rv J 5,209
4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
5 209 g R ,m d
pp d 30 qu r ph bu
r d c he mm pprt of
f h h h y m p
g c d a y h Hv m
c kg h v
DRC ITEM 2.·� 1 09/16/2020
5. EXISTING SITE
3 eprt The
a aff y tga prty
6. EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
uj p l -k f E Sycamoe
A ee N N Sff eed all
n --6 z a a e blck
a U.T y -ces wt h
-m . T rta t rd ta l
q e O H t
7. ANALYSIS AND STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
ff de j I a ff ht h
e a a i y
#f e p J 5 j a whl e
e
A v h a pe y t her
h D
8. ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
N v ry j
9. PUBLIC NOTICE
N P N ce qu j
10. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
p j Historic Preservation Design Standards
for Old Towne a Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. ,
p j g x o Calif
E Q (E Q ) S EQ 533 (H u ce
a /h )
DRC ITEM 2·2.. 2 09/16/2020
11. STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS
fr
h Ol D )
Og E S (OES
F a j B g
sat n s ff DR h
jct
I Ol T H ,
snr /b RC
vg o j M 17100701
h op j Historic Preservation Design
Standards for Old Towne. s
St #3 4 Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation S # 9 10
f r y
d
r
• I y Na p t
Sa ry I '(MC 17 100 7 F.2
j r d Secretary of the Interior's Standards
for Rehabilitation, #3 4,9 a d 10
t u p s
po rty w h l rt n pt
sl ta e
p
T oj d p
g i p f
i r q f (C
171 007 3
DRC ITEM 2.2- 3 09/16/2020
Historic
Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne
12. CONDITIONS
Cmy
D n p
3 a y ffc,
g d ly y y y g
y ,x
Cy'
4 f
c f y D R J
5,9.
5 f
n Bi in fo
.
6 b f k q
O,Cm rt'Bi
F o q
7 T c rt /x.P
Gn S 660
f /x T (90)
p I
,
y x G
Si 66.
8 z j p xp 4
Ex f y MC S 17 8 060
DRC ITEM 2.2. 4 09/16/2020
13. ATTACHMENTS
1. Vicinity Map
2. Architectural Plans date stamped 8/12/2020
3. Site Photographs
4. Design Review Committee Staff Report and Minutes from the June 5, 2019
Meeting
5. DPR Form for 425 E. Sycamore Avenue
N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4967-19 Martin Residence
DRC ITEM 2.. 2- 5 09/16/2020
Vicinity Map
DRC No. 4967-19
Martin Residence
425 E. Sycamore Avenue
427
423 ------�- 413
415
390
388
ORANGE = CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE
iYELLOW = NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE
CITY OF ORANGE
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
ATTACHMENT NO. 1
DRC NO. 4967-19; MARTIN RESIDENCE
VICINITY MAP
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
ARCHITECTURAL:
ARCHITECTURAL:
LOCATION
PROJECT
ARCHITECT:CLIENT:
SHEET INDEX
SCOPE OF WORK
PROJECT DATA
DESIGN CODES
PROJECT TEAM
VICINITY MAP
GENERAL NOTES ABBREVIATIONS
LEGEND OF SYMBOLS
RESIDENTIAL ADDITION
MARTIN RESIDENCE
425 E. SYCAMORE AVE.
ORANGE, CA 92866
SITE AND PARKING DATA:
N
+8'-0" A.F.F.
ACT CEILING
X
XX.XX
A
B
C
D
ROOM NAME
ROOM NAME
XXX
1
PL-1
01
1
101A
1/4:12
X
XXX.XX
X
XXX.XX
X
XXX.XX
X
XXX.XX
9.5
18-029 A010
COVER SHEET
A0.10
AS NOTED
JJ
N
JOB NUMBER:
CHECKED:
STATUS:
DRAWN:
CAD FILE:
PLOT DATE:
SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175Fountain Valley, California 92708Tel (949) 515-9600www.magellanarchitects.comageManllA R C H I T E C T U R EMARTIN RESIDENCERESIDENTIAL ADDITION425 E SYCAMORE AVENUEORANGE, CA 928661
2
3
4
5
6
1
E SYCAMORE AVEN CENTER ST
N SHAFFER ST
N CLEVELAND ST
E JEFFERSON AVE2
1
2
ATTACHMENT NO. 2
DRC NO. 4967-19; MARTIN RESIDENCE
ARCHITECTURAL PLANS
(DATE STAMPED 08/12/20)
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
18-029 A010
SPECIFICATIONS
A0.20
AS NOTED
JJ
JOB NUMBER:
CHECKED:
STATUS:
DRAWN:
CAD FILE:
PLOT DATE:
SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175Fountain Valley, California 92708Tel (949) 515-9600www.magellanarchitects.comageManllA R C H I T E C T U R EMARTIN RESIDENCERESIDENTIAL ADDITION425 E SYCAMORE AVENUEORANGE, CA 928661
2
3
4
5
6
18-029 A010
SPECIFICATIONS
A0.30
AS NOTED
JJ
JOB NUMBER:
CHECKED:
STATUS:
DRAWN:
CAD FILE:
PLOT DATE:
SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175Fountain Valley, California 92708Tel (949) 515-9600www.magellanarchitects.comageManllA R C H I T E C T U R EMARTIN RESIDENCERESIDENTIAL ADDITION425 E SYCAMORE AVENUEORANGE, CA 928661
2
3
4
5
6
18-029 A010
SPECIFICATIONS
A0.40
AS NOTED
JJ
JOB NUMBER:
CHECKED:
STATUS:
DRAWN:
CAD FILE:
PLOT DATE:
SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175Fountain Valley, California 92708Tel (949) 515-9600www.magellanarchitects.comageManllA R C H I T E C T U R EMARTIN RESIDENCERESIDENTIAL ADDITION425 E SYCAMORE AVENUEORANGE, CA 928661
2
3
4
5
6
PLAN NOTESKEY NOTES18-029 A100SITE MAP &FIRE INFORMATIONA1.00AS NOTEDJJJOB NUMBER:CHECKED:STATUS:DRAWN:CAD FILE:PLOT DATE:SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175
Fountain Valley, California 92708
Tel (949) 515-9600
www.magellanarchitects.com
ageM anll
A R C H I T E C T U R E
MARTIN RESIDENCE
RESIDENTIAL ADDITION
425 E SYCAMORE AVENUE
ORANGE, CA 92866123456SITE MAP & FIRE INFORMATIONSCALE: 1" = 50'-0"LEGEND NOTES:121234N22222344E SYCAMORE AVE
N CENTER STN SHAFFER STN CLEVELAND STE WALNUT AVE
E JEFFERSON AVE
56755566676
PLAN NOTESKEY NOTES18-029 A110DEMOLITION PLAN &NEW SITE PLANA1.10AS NOTEDJJDEMOLITION NOTESDEMO LEGENDJOB NUMBER:CHECKED:STATUS:DRAWN:CAD FILE:PLOT DATE:SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175
Fountain Valley, California 92708
Tel (949) 515-9600
www.magellanarchitects.com
ageM anll
A R C H I T E C T U R E
MARTIN RESIDENCE
RESIDENTIAL ADDITION
425 E SYCAMORE AVENUE
ORANGE, CA 92866123456NEW SITE PLANSCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"2SITE DEMOLITION PLANSCALE: 1/8" = 1'-0"1WALL LEGENDSHADED WALLS INDICATE NEW WORK:A101ALEGEND NOTES:DEMO KEY NOTES11123323112345678SITE INFORMATIONSITE AND PARKING DATA:ARCHITECT:CLIENT:9222234567777710101011111111111111121212131313991010NN88888
DEMOLITION NOTESDEMO KEY NOTES18-029 A200DEMOLITION PLANA2.00AS NOTEDJJJOB NUMBER:CHECKED:STATUS:DRAWN:CAD FILE:PLOT DATE:SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175
Fountain Valley, California 92708
Tel (949) 515-9600
www.magellanarchitects.com
ageM anll
A R C H I T E C T U R E
MARTIN RESIDENCE
RESIDENTIAL ADDITION
425 E SYCAMORE AVENUE
ORANGE, CA 92866123456DEMOLITION PLANSCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"DEMO LEGEND1101112110109105103102N1061042213344444444456566666781111599101058711551212121313141415151
1x6 FASCIA
NEW PORCH DESIGN. SEE 1,3/ A4.20
11
11
KEY NOTES18-029 A320EXISTING ELEVATIONSA3.20AS NOTEDJJJOB NUMBER:CHECKED:STATUS:DRAWN:CAD FILE:PLOT DATE:SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175
Fountain Valley, California 92708
Tel (949) 515-9600
www.magellanarchitects.com
ageM anll
A R C H I T E C T U R E
MARTIN RESIDENCE
RESIDENTIAL ADDITION
425 E SYCAMORE AVENUE
ORANGE, CA 92866123456WEST ELEVATIONSCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"4123A456A7AKEFGHHEAST ELEVATIONSCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"3SOUTH ELEVATIONSCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"1NORTH ELEVATIONSCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0"222222222223333333333335689988GENERAL NOTES+0'-0" HOUSE SLAB-1'-1" B.S.GARAGE SLAB±15'-6" A.S.T.O. ROOF+0'-0" HOUSE SLAB-1'-1" B.S.GARAGE SLAB±15'-6" A.S.T.O. ROOF±10'-11" A.S.T.O. ROOF+0'-0" HOUSE SLAB-1'-1" B.S.GARAGE SLAB±15'-6" A.S.T.O. ROOF+12'-5" A.S.T.O. NEW ROOF+10'-9" A.S.T.O. NEW ROOF+0'-0" HOUSE SLAB-1'-1" B.S.GARAGE SLAB±15'-6" A.S.T.O. ROOF±12'-0" A.S.T.O. ROOF+0'-0" HOUSE SLAB-1'-1" B.S.GARAGE SLAB±15'-6" A.S.T.O. ROOF±12'-0" A.S.T.O. ROOF10101111J1212113135DL
PREFABRICATED 10” DIAMETER
ROUND REDWOOD TUSCAN STYLE
COLUMN FROM PACIFIC COLUMNS
WWW.PACIFICCOLUMNS.COM
COLUMN TO BE PLAN
TYPE R- SPLIT IN HALF FOR
REASSEMBLY WITH
WATERPROOF GLUE
6X6 POST WRAPPED IN
PREFABRICATED 10” DIAMETER
REDWOOD TUSCAN. STYLE
COLUMN.
6 X 8 HEADER / BEAM ATTACHED TO 6X6 POST
WITH SIMPSON TEE COLUMN CAP
1/2” plywood ceiling2X6” Ceiling Joist
3 PORCH DETAIL
SCALE: 1/4” = 1’
SIDE VIEW
2X4
1 X 12
BARGE RAFTER
1X4 VERTICAL BOARDS SPACED 1/2”
OVER SCREEN
FRONT VIEW
1 X 12
2X4
SLOPED SIL
SLOPED SIL
1X4 VERTICAL
BOARDS SPACED
1/2”
MESH
SCREEN
2X6” Rafter
2X4” Rafter Tail
2 x 6 Barge Rafter
19
PORCH FRAMING
COLUMN COLUMN
NEW REDWOOD SIDING DETAILSCALE: 6" = 1'-0"6EXISTING SIDING DETAILSCALE: 6" = 1'-0"5NEW TRIM DETAILSCALE: 6" = 1'-0"9ROOF FASCIA AT RAKESCALE: 3" = 1'-0"1RIDGE BEAM DETIALSCALE: 3" = 1'-0"2TYPICAL WINDOW HEADERSCALE: 3" = 1'-0"4TYPICAL WINDOW SILLSCALE: 3" = 1'-0"8HEAD AT INTERIOR DOOR/JAM SIM.SCALE: 3" = 1'-0"7HEAD AT EXTERIOR DOOR/JAM SIM.SCALE: 3" = 1'-0"10ROOF AT EAVESCALE: 1 1/2" = 1'-0"318-029 A510DETAILSA5.10AS NOTEDJJJOB NUMBER:CHECKED:STATUS:DRAWN:CAD FILE:PLOT DATE:SCALE:10540 Talbert Avenue, Suite 175
Fountain Valley, California 92708
Tel (949) 515-9600
www.magellanarchitects.com
ageM anll
A R C H I T E C T U R E
MARTIN RESIDENCE
RESIDENTIAL ADDITION
425 E SYCAMORE AVENUE
ORANGE, CA 928661234561
425 East Sycamore Ave , Orange Ca 92866
Photos:
STREET VIEW FRONT HOUSE
STREET VIEW LEFT ANGLE
PAGEl
AGENDA DATE:
To:
THRU:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
JUNE 5, 2019
RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
s t +/400 SF
h
Port Sz ,6
p
NI A
ATTACHMENT NO. 4
DRC NO. 4967-19; MARTIN RESIDENCE
DRC STAFF REPORT & MINUTES
(06/05/19 MTG)
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
Design Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 2 o/8
PUBLIC NOTICE
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation
Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
s
n n
nu a wi nructo
l x a a
Wn framg s
N o xri y d ly os
N g,p,hi m x s esnc
O
Add bhr
,n ru Ahmn 2 f h po rt. A
p j n Att hm
s k m -6 z , uding F oo
Ar R R.) q
Design, Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 3 of8
EXISTING SITE
EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
f C Uy.
Ts arly m s o fam rt.Th
rr ar w q f O Twn H D
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Oa M Ce (MC)7.0070 b DRC huld us
v j T f:
j l v rn ,d , w fld th
i n :
1. Architectural Features.
T hi tur f ur fl s
.C iv fy l b a high
qu j i vi
2. Landscape.
Th , z j 'o r ll
e
L ru vl q a dr l u
h v e an xi o
Design Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 4 o/8
Signage.
Secondary Functional and Accessory Features.
ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne
Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation
g ,190s
bunw T rp i lb to
miz tur w oumn d b rplce
w m umn ni-p y sml yle
b
S rt drit.
dd h S tdad
pi j d c
o i um t e w
ann n u -d gn
Design, Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 5 o/8
ur x ,
fr g "ar
y
g rik b u
2:R A F P A
T p j u 0 ar of
u Ad prp t g f
b/1 /b fl
o w th
IS 9
N ,x ,run i
z y T k fr
b ,,
gy nm.
10
"N w j k u
nn fu,rm r rty
v nm un
Design, Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 6 o/8
An
ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
ar
STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS
fi "F"as cs
ak t fi "Fg "drws a
c hr fy (nmena
,)unu t uport
Fng ,ng the
"F",tme
(mm f)a jc.T
ru pj;b nn k
F
F j B ur d t , s
rm j dn
v rv :
wg pj (MC 7.0 070 G. l).
j Hii Pain Sadads
f d #3 an
Design Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 7 o/8
#
17.10.070.G.2).
4,
g p mty g u f lly
csn gr w p ifi p,
applicb g q fig (OC 17.10.070.G.3).
Hsic
Psva Dg S f O T
y
4.Fr fil e vpm pcifi Cty f O fi Ral
Dg Gu,w uu()r pb w ,sg,
oa u f uu vp prv c
exisg ng rac OM 17.10. 070. G.4).
l D G ar Hc
D
Design Review Committee Staff Report
June 5, 2019
Page 8 of8
RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS
rt B so.Fur bt he
q rm f rm
4 I zd,x -v .Exsn
OM S 708060 Pnnng mnts
r Bd Prm gi rvl.
ATTACHMENTS
V p
Pp Ac P (5//)
L e J fic
4 Pp rt Pp
5 W d D d S I
6 P R Frm 425 E S
: C B k
B G o
c @c o
)gn vw 967-1 -IN RESID
pl b p stru 3 sq f n t he ra
f bg -my O we Hs s.
4 .yca
S a Ky f,(71)7-722 kr
y p n n
s p
O p s
H n
s s w
s p e t
p
p
p s
p
s s
m m 4 1 -e c s n
g o s p t :
g g p turn f vew pi o
s f bg
E
BS
BSTIN
krp
mk krp D Im F
MOTION CARRIED.
RECESS: 6 -6
(4)gn N 497-19-RANG EIR HOUING
p -y fi ·ru 7 enor
5 C w qusted under
, , r q s.
49 E K A
: B dk , (7 ) 74-7238, dk @ n
: P nn s
y B , P nn j w te staff
rt
P , r O g S H In rp , a visual
j y , , str a
v q j fi
M V k rp y m w j ct p i ant prior
rm l
K n d K S , p p j ct due to
PRIMARY RECORD
30-159643
039009, 112470
ORA
lD
B.M. - # -------------�------------------------------------------------�------. ----------. -------- ---------
D
*a.
--------------�----
otius o Pg.3.)
Li ttu )
D D D D D
2 o o 5
Vw,d ,a #)
D D
s
S Reoed by N ffilitio and address)
prt :(Cit surv y rport nd ther sourcs ,or enter "none.")
y I (99 H Bu dng Inver
Up Oa Coy,I 98)Hoic Suvey.
9
5
*0 rvy ype (Describe)
R
*tmt D D
D Aae l R D Dt R D L F R D i Rcod D Rok Art er
D Art a R D g p Re D O (L :
DPR 523A 1/95)*l:.ian11irarl 1 ... 4'-·--•=--
ATIA(HMENT NO. 5
DRC NO. 4967-19; MARTIN RESIDENCE
DPR FORM FOR 425 E. SYCAMORE AVE.
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
B1. Historic Name:Unknown
B3. Original Use:RES B4. Present Use:RES
*B5. Architectural Style:Bungalow
*B6. Construction History:(Construction date, atlerations, and date of alterations)Date of Construction:1928
*B9. Architect or Builder:Unknown
Period of Significance:Old Towne: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941)
*B10. Significance:Property Type:Residence
(Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.)
*B8. Related Features:
Date:Original Location:*B7. Moved?
ArchitectureTheme:Area:City of Orange
Structural Integrity:Good Condition - No apparent change to original structure.
(List attributes and codes)
*Date of Evaluation:September, 2005
B11. Additional Resource Attributes:
(This space reserved for official comments.)
*B14. Evaluator:Robert Chattel
B13. Remarks:
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD
*B12. References:
*NRHP Status Code 1D
Altered as of 2005: Infilled/altered porch.
Primary #30-159643
HRI #039009, 112470
YesNo Unknown
Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or #:SYCAMORE_E_425__APN_039-223-15
(Assigned by Recorder)
PrehistoricHistoric Both
B2. Common Name:
Applicable Criteria:AC
Orange Daily News.
(Sketch Map with North arrow required.)
DPR 523B (1/95)*Required Information
Opportunities:
Status change since 1991 Survey: None.
Site Integrity:
(Continues on Pg.3.)
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
CONTINUATION SHEET
Description of Photo:
Primary #30-159643
HRI #039009, 112470
Trinomial ORA
Recorded by:
Date Recorded:April, 2005
P3a. Description (Continued from Pg.1):
DPR 523L (11/98)*Required Information
UpdateContinuation
Page 3 of 3
B6. Construction History (Continued from Pg.2):
Lot Acre:0.1272
Principal Building Sqft:1112
Planning Zone:R-2-6 # of Stories:1
Years Surveyed:1982, 1991, 2005
General Plan:LDR
# of Units:1
B13. Remarks (Continued from Pg.2):
1991
D. Gest, P. LaValley, D. Matsumoto
Chattel Architecture
13417 Ventura Blvd.
Sherman Oaks, CA 91423
*Resource Name or #:SYCAMORE_E_425__APN_039-223-15
(Assigned by Recorder)
Listed in National Register:1997
# of Buildings:1