Loading...
02-05-20 173 S. Cypress Street - Clapp Residence (DRC 4982-19)AGENDA ITEM DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE February 5, 2020 TO: THRU: FROM: CHAIR MCDERMOTT AND MEMBERS OF THE DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE Anna Pehoushek, Assistant Community Development Director/)(& • Kelly Ribuffo, Associate Planner 0W(___ 1. SUBJECT 2. SUMMARY 3. BACKGROUND INFORMATION 4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION tt b gl xg Vrt b b z g W g DRCITEM 1 02/05/2020 5. EXISTING SITE fou fo h xng C r f y hn 3 f prt. c ff a y ooap f h pprty. 6. EXISTING AREA CONTEXT j rt c k S.Cypes S,tw W m v W bed e u by z SFy inal (R rt p S a d 7. ANALYSIS AND ST A TEMENT OF THE ISSUES i S S a a n m h y n mb c a y . v f k u a t s c m n a d,v b xt lp ig ff f fpn f h . •L fli •tt h v 952 •Cc 5 •mk n h n •U x d v y n i r r ,e rv ch •s f no w It p ff h w Saa # f h u p f uff t f l v pmn. DRC ITEM 2 02/05/2020 8. ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION 9. PUBLIC NOTICE 10. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW in Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, 11. STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS a ,g y (,, rt e rt s. e rt g tw w a y g c p T ",in r (f)T f j;y m y e g •O M M) •I G •rv D (l o D T) T j B fll Fis ees rt g v j •e D r v da r y RC y MC 7 0 07 .) DRCITEM 3 02/05/2020 Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. g ve rv x (M 4 j In De b 12. CONDITIONS j g c: k u d w Am 2 (e Jry 2 22)q e h D C j q w 2 A y ,e y ,sb y vp DRCITEM 4 02/05/2020 13. ATTACHMENTS u P 2 3 S P 4 5 A R P 6 PR m :R Ez p@ N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4982-19 Clapp Residence DRCITEM 5 02/05/2020 Vicinity Map DRC No. 4982-19 Clapp Residence 173 S. Cypress Street -------- " L---------- - _-- I T 1(1)1 135A-B 11-r I t I 1(/) I I0:::1 1,jr I I 10....I &+v Z1 '>-' 146 IQ, 1°: 155 153 156 l.2 I I I !WI J ,I -- 1-ll 'I 1 163 166 ) I I I I I I I J 1 1 J 73 176 : 1 I I ll------1��� I I I �I I 191 IBO / I I I Lt) "> I I I 193 � � I I \ I I _____________ .:» \ 154 128 ORANGE = CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE YELLOW= NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE CITY OF ORANGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ATIACHMENT N0.1 DRC NO. 4982-19; CLAPP RESIDENCE VICINITY MAP February S, 2020 DRC Meeting SMEET NO. xxxxxx SHE[T CONTENT o,a..-n by: A-1 Sool•: NOTED Oct•: DEC/02/2010 (\ z;--1- 6 R•IO•lon Dot• -ZS,�,- /\ Richard Clopp (949) 395-4a41 173 S Cypress St Orange, CA 92866 PLANNING DIVISION RECEIVED JAN 2 0 2020 CITY OF ORANGE eting sq ft SFR 1 STORY· -BEDROOM �J eq SITE ADDRESS 1a40 &q II ,q ft 212 sq ft 400 •q ft 100 aq n ARA ABULATIO LOT SIZE PROPOSED EXISTING GARAGE PROPOSED LOT COVERAGE I .. I • I I . 'I I t» r i A I J6'-0" . t') • CO,NCRETE A A 2�·�0· CYPRE:SS AT s. PROPOSED SITE PLAN I y/',�•' ·1 I I I I ,I .... �· .,, .... � � "' � "' ... (). "' "' "' ,., .... � "' ... ... ... .,, .... ... .... ... ... ... 20·-o· 21'-o" A to (e) �P)i,l,Lt IJR1�WA)' 4'-o" r . r , •· r I- I . I I ' I .·. I I i · . I r . 1.: I . I \> .• r ;, :� ., I n I . 'I 15'-0" EXISTING SITE PLAN I ,/'!'.' J0'-0" 24'-0" (E) COVER . . • • A S. CYPRE:SS Al' · · 1 ·-----'�--�"'-··+-h-r·-·-�·-· _ _,1 __ --'1<----'k I I I I I I I (E) 1tSTY SPR rq 20'-0" .,, .... ... .... .... ... ... .... ... .... ... .... .... ... ... .... .... .... . .... .... ... .... ... ... ... ... ... ..... ... ... .... ... ... ... ... ... � ... .... ..... ... "' ... ... t,. ,,.. ,, .... "' ... b ...... .,.. ,.. • "' "' • "' ,.. ..., "' "' ., .,.. • "' ..., • •v 21•-o· .(�) ASP.HALt .• IiRVEl'/AY 1. .. .• =·'_'tE)·.· .••. ! . . J . r . " .. • J •.. r . A • . , ·(E) ." J . ... CON�:--,,,.---.. ]" ALK'N'i'·t, . 1 . . · . • . • 1· • A I . . .' • • l' ·'J • • 1· 4'-o" • '·· r. t I I ,. I' r I ! ••• . . . . . 1 SHE:ET CDHTE:HT © 'WINDOW SCHEDULE CONTR�CTT OWNER see rn�, OPERATION u-�t�oR [ safx� I REM>.Rl<s OIT '"'· .... c, w1orn x HOGHT "- 1 2'6' x 4'0' wooo ci!i'S,1, 0.32 1 °-2� I rJi.E��E 00 8 2 2'6" x 5•0· WOOD &�B�r ,.,, I 025 I W�E�:E I 03 ' "!" " .c 0 i:Z IKI 'DOOR SCHEDULE SIZE FR.WE OPERA.TKlN U-FACTOR SHGC R[IU.Rl(S OIT PROJ[CT ""· ""· WIDTH x HEIGttT ""· '"'· A 2'6' x 6'8" FRENCH SWING O,J2 0.25 OU,t. P.t.NE " TEMPEREll B 2'6" x 6'8" SOLID SWING " " " .. i ccee - c 2'6" I 6'8" �r soxrr " " - or Cl) co D 6'0" • 6'8" �wr 81-P.,,SS " " WAAOROBE ot UIN - UI O'I ,_ I!! cC a '" <D • WINDOWS ANO DOORS TO BE MFG BY: a.u i RE!ABRANDT, BLAIR D'CALLAGHAN r; a "' "' Cl) z fl) m (L <( (") c ..... I! "1""0 i- (E) 60' VANITY 0 12'-10• 0 5'-3' 24'-0' l I 11'-2' 18 UOING ] a 0 ,,, '"' T -- -, � \ I t:lu 11 11 11 II II =r�===!.= \j '" [3- '�j r IE) KITCREN '" FAMILY RM. - PROPOSED FLOOR PLAN (0 PORCH r1 �D .�-++-n ---H-n ------,. D] - : :1 - SHEET NO. By: xxxxxx A·2 /\ Ro,1,k,,. �" Job: Fii•: xxxxxx scalo, AS NOTED Oroltn by: 1\1. Doto: DEC/02/20\B /\ /\ � NEW WALLS C:=::J EXISTING WALLS TO REMAIN L -- - 1 EXISTING WALLS TO REMOVE D PROPOSED ADOITION 212 sq ft WALL LEGEND EXIST'G WINDOW 10 '"""' EXIST'G WINODW 01 DEMOLISH {E) PATIO 02 DEMOLISH (E) BEARING WALL 03 REMOVE (E) VINYL WINDOW. DO NOT REUSE D4 REMOVE (E) DOOR, 00 NOT REUSE 05 REMOVE (E) SHUTTERS, 00 NOT REUSE 0 FLOOR PLAN KEY NOTES c:=:::::J EXISTING WALLS TO REW.IN C..-=... EXISTING WALLS TO DEI.IOLISH WALL LEGEND SCALE• V."· r-c-' '" ""' T r EXISTING I DEMOLITION PLAN ,,, Rovlolon �·· SHEET COtHENT PROJECT CONTRACTOR I OW�ER TOP 1'1.1 WEST SOUTH NORTH I .: ' EAST ELEVATION KEY NOTES 6 -',t,'�';i'snii'ic'�w�ooiiii'�'�";"""�'i',i'°�'�'�'�'�"�""�'·�'�'�'�'�"'�'"�=�--f:--'.,,.. orc/ca/aore HOT EUSE �u�" u u s XISTING PATIO S OI.IOI.ISHEO Scala:AS ND Jab:XXXX)()( Fii•• )()()()()()( EXISTING EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS SC�E• !/.''• 1-0· A·3 SHEET NO. �· ' . S�ECT COMTENT PROJECT CO�TRACTOR OW�ER @ Doto: Seale: @ Prawn by, "- Joi>: xxxxxx m., )()()()()()( ELEVATION KEY NOTES '""""'· WEST SOUTH NORTH EAST c�-s�=.::.-:.c�::�=c:-1101010w=g-=-=:::::::-::: ::'c=-.::s===-. tr .::.:.:==::-=·-� -- --------- ------ - - -- -- ---- --- --- - - ---- - - ---- - -- - ----- -- --- -- - - - -- ---- - - ------- - - .... . . . - ... ----- ------- -------- ---- -- . - ------ -- -- � �·�; ��c=: = =:. �·���= �-ilir� .. �=. " r .. D - � @TYPICAL WINDOW TRIM DETAIL @ PATIO COLUMN DETAIL PROPOSED EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS w·!'I'.' I ED W 1.ATIIC AI Vf.:N MULATE IIN A·4 SHEET NO. 17 3 s. Cy press s+ - s+r�c.+ V,·e� 1 ATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC NO. 4982-19; CLAPP RESIDENCE SITE PHOTOGRAPHS February 5, 2020 DRC Meeting : ' ' ·. \ :- 1'11 5. �pr�ss st- 173 S Cypr-e.ss 5+ Ne.��bors C ommerd:-::J:.t:- 3 ; 'i ,. :1 : l I :­ '' . ,; . t' '' l }-, ': r I ,. \' '' ! : I l, i • ! \ : l l i ;: ! ' : I I I I I , I ___ LL , , j. : 3 e.t..c.J_ 21h" x 4·1011 I �l'\e! 3 e<iJc:.l 2. I�; ,Ji '51D11 AlTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4982-19; CLAPP RESIDENCE MATERIAL INFORMATION February S, 2020 DRC Meeting Rembrandt Windows 10615 Lawson River Avenue Fountain Valley, CA 92708 714-968-6538 telephone 714-968-2738 fax info@rembrandtwindows.com Repair and Restoration Custom and Replacement Windows xampls of the me mm ty in w b ar: *sg ,bl hung *-wing -swg cam *any fix p a ard ,circ,vl ,t. O ru d p w l fir, o s w a m l l th e m n t a b g in t e i c t If it as n m ,R Wnd an l th y cus m bu l to plc an xiting n ty ,mpl ep ti n xi ting w wind ,ar h lp Ou aft u th l hn gy an im -ki g echnique t cr t u ty tr , hi w l l ns A l wind are m t ord and man ur z e ug as m wi h sult t t ill b as to h o igin l hist w i ssb b d y. Description sunport Sm fi o unda p hg , s ,d air t v ft 9 H vt r- bam o al snnrt p Ug y th $, bg rqi 1 HV h n 6, s armrooriatelv z th em d s rt 5 o a . r e m s , m g and r pir sidinz d 4 n fl g c , mo x y y O T wn o nb v y AL ,1 0 ATIACHMENT NO. 5 DRC NO. 4982-19; CLAPP RESIDENCE MILLS ACT CONTRACT REHABILITATION PLAN February 5, 2020 DRC Meeting 1 D DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION PRIMARY RECORD HRI# 30-158760 038126 ORA ::J - --- - -- 173 it ��������---,,--���......,.���--,,,,--�� ��� "b. 7.5' ea.i .arai ,siz.setting.and boudnanes.Continues on Pg.3.) Lis a nt>us a co)= = C .!l] L... ::J (Viw,a .access.on e) <ti' rJ LJ Ci urvy port n h soes .or enter "none.") ssss R s (05 ).t rc it t e (5 ) H R s vy AEGI ()Ho r i dig Iv nory Up H ran n Ic (8 )g Hisor ic S vy . M 5 p (Describe) R ian "t: DPR 523A (1195) ::::J NONE D R I Artt Re Lin Mp ii R gph Red �Ciutin et()� I Lia Fue R J O (Ls): Buiig ,tue ,a Oj R Mi g i R C Rk Art Red "qui Im ATIACHMENT NO. 6 DRC NO. 4982-19; CLAPP RESIDENCE DPR FORM FOR 173 S. CYPRESS February 5, 2020 DRC Meeting Style previously noted in 1991 Survey as: Craftsman Bungalow. B1. Historic Name:Edward and Minnie Enochs House B3. Original Use:RES B4. Present Use:RES *B5. Architectural Style:Bungalow *B6. Construction History:(Construction date, atlerations, and date of alterations)Date of Construction:1915 *B9. Architect or Builder:Unknown Period of Significance:Old Towne: Early Settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) *B10. Significance:Property Type:Residence (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) *B8. Related Features: Date:Original Location:*B7. Moved? ArchitectureTheme:Area:City of Orange Structural Integrity:Excellent Condition - No apparent change to original structure. (List attributes and codes) *Date of Evaluation:September, 2005 B11. Additional Resource Attributes: (This space reserved for official comments.) *B14. Evaluator:Robert Chattel B13. Remarks: State of California - The Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD *B12. References: *NRHP Status Code 1D Early, if not original, owners were Edward and Minnie Enochs. Dr. Enochs was a physician. Primary #30-158760 HRI #038126 c YesNo Unknown Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or #:CYPRESS_S_173__APN_390-662-07 (Assigned by Recorder) PrehistoricHistoric Both B2. Common Name: Applicable Criteria:AC Orange Daily News. (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) DPR 523B (1/95)*Required Information Opportunities: Status change since 1991 Survey: None. Accessory structure or major addition that is appropriate to the site.Site Integrity: (Continues on Pg.3.) State of California - The Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION CONTINUATION SHEET Description of Photo: Primary #30-158760 HRI #038126 Trinomial ORA Recorded by: Date Recorded:March, 2005 P3a. Description (Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L (11/98)*Required Information UpdateContinuation Page 3 of 3 B6. Construction History (Continued from Pg.2): Lot Acre:0.1758 Principal Building Sqft:1224 Planning Zone:R-2-6 # of Stories:1 Years Surveyed:1982, 1991, 2005 General Plan:LDR # of Units:1 B13. Remarks (Continued from Pg.2): 1991 D. Gest, P. LaValley, D. Matsumoto Chattel Architecture 13417 Ventura Blvd. Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 *Resource Name or #:CYPRESS_S_173__APN_390-662-07 (Assigned by Recorder) Listed in National Register:1997 # of Buildings:1