02-05-20 166 N. Cambridge Street - Caesar Residence (DRC 4980-19)AGENDA ITEM
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
February 5, 2020
TO:
THRU:
FROM:
CHAIR MCDERMOTT AND MEMBERS OF THE DESIGN REVIEW
COMMITTEE
Anna Pehoushek, Assistant Community Development Directo�
Kelly Ribuffo, Associate Planner �
1. SUBJECT
2. SUMMARY
3. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
r 6,
4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
ppl pp 7 q ry Dllg Ui
(U)-.D vw Coe (RC)
d u tt pp of ao of t
pak u.T rvsd
u 3
DRCITEM 1 02/05/2020
5. EXISTING SITE
6. EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
7. ANALYSIS AND STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
s
g /
r l lyou.
C'3"l sg
g f he
d l lude as
3
s p q f h
Prv h DRC's
8. ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
j
9. PUBLIC NOTICE
N P N j
10. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old
Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, hfe
g C Quy A
(Q)CQ 33 (R/Rhn).
11. STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS
"F"c f aly
k "
F,"v (
)ud
DRCITEM 2 02/05/2020
Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne
112)
pp S #9 #1 Secretary of the
Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. g m
s uay
y pl w
rt Frt,
U ,mv i
w rt
p
pcifc
q (OMC
7173
U y g
x b
v f
z rt d
tilz mt m
v v mt o
d f
DRCITEM 3 02/05/2020
12. CONDITIONS
o bjc suqu
w y g R C.
y o,g po g t
o y ,b bm
C D I oy Dvm
w os
h c wu v b
s f y Dvom
D ay a q w bl .
3.e c g f,,a Cy,ff,
g y y bo
g y p,v x
a y C y'.
o p f co d
g h tt Bl D i fo
k
5 C oc w k, a qu i e
y h Cy f Og , Cy D D rt 'B i Dvs n.
F e q v f s
6 If z j tw -o .
Exess OM S i 17.08.060.
P B P l o
y s o p
./x P o
C S 6 2 s q su
e f /xc pp s by
9 y p j s
g I os o
DRCITEM 4 02/05/2020
13. ATTACHMENTS
Dcr ,19
4 Sff Rport u r N 19 Mting
5 D F f 66 N.ge S
cc:R
rr@g
ik
cuct@gc
V
v@
N \CDD\PLNGIAppl,cahons\Design Review\ORC 4980-19 Caesar Resrdence
DRCITEM 5 02/05/2020
Vicinity Map
DRC No. 4980-19
Caesar Residence
166 N. Cambridge Street
, --�-------------------
ORANGE= CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE
YELLO\V = NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE
CITY OF ORANGE AITACHMENT NO. 1
DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
February 5, 2020 DRC Meeting
VICINITY MAP
ijl ! i�� !tllil' 69Sl6 'VJ :;lJ'uu10 'lS ;lippqmu;J "N991 ii� I� 1 � .:, ii I i,I ... "' ,Hl'!' jil I.I� 1�t:Ei 11··1 •l r 3U!J]OMCT nov MON lbhl, 1ri » 1 (") Z 00 bQ J�i" � I • Ii 1 ob E l�} 111t11mj,11 j ", I LU N C ();)U()p�S()l:{ JtlS()tl;) " . ! ' E--< !9 C) +3 " - ul. Iii ! S I •" ,�l i- [ ·�, 1""",� <11 <,I<• '" I" V) ... QJ N ... c QJ ' •I• ' , I !" :! !ii :K i i ci 0:: ... � 0:: ... I.I I. ' � s' j < r I •r,i ! ! I' " ,, !I· z <( <( 0:: • ,., 'i i''I ... V) c ' l'; �t:i�;�� !i. ,t ��./� 2w_c ' ' i ! !! :, :1111·:11 iili 11111!! I! !1 ... i3 O') c:, � �1� .. � '" ._!. s z !'. ��i; • 0 ' ! 11,:,�t! • :,t, L!jll; :,:,�Lli � � i I'!� �: i�:1�;§s1� .i�3� i.iti;�i �t � :C :!l I:;:; N, � . , � � � .,J, s .. I �- s �! ���5 I t't� � e �' 11 .,ii< ,1,1 1,1: ,11a,j, 11 ii,i u.wlll ' ! � � Ii j;J"'� I !; ,1 i•hji,, 1,.c -,111 , •l �,�� t � " l i � G t� ti ! ., � 8 ' l 'h ii 1l:!!i1ll 1::1 !!ll!il II! �: ., a � 3 �;8; '?!- ij! � , .1 ' t' ,: � i!,, � o>.:C•L;,<l 0 ' " � u "I' . z 2 � < I r ! ., ;./ 'I � t !1 r l)i!'Li, 1•!! ti•,!· 'f ii"� 0 5 .c � � <•8 C5 B � I iii I 1it ,1l « 0 ;1 i,l ! 1=11111:1 1!a1 ihi1:1 !,i ii:�! z Q.. : ! � I.I ... Ill'! ji� I i iii ·1 ·i· , .!, 1 ,,i ce w' r .. � ;\,!, 0:: ...
' , I I ' i ;1! !· Ii! 11 !p!-1:·1 Ii·!, ,l! 11 1!1 , I i ., ' m C;;,;
;;� l Ii "" · "- "- � E l �>! § "' :!J, ·� t ,1,; ih1,i ii' l :.1" I;� I M !! , l!i!1lc Ji1 !iI!iM 111 ��g s gg """� g? .. g� t Q'w'"i'
}l:J'f'SL3S
LV .0-,01 ,,, .0-,9( :!NlllJM<l
'.!38 ')11�
.o-.�(M)
}l:J','!J13S lN())I�
.O-,££ Cf (3)
m· : .
: . -, ,,
; �;:; ; . "It If � ' ., ei
CON!ll!L f™(] ENGINEERS
s.;,am o. .. ,,,c.12160
1110J>O<'r"l•11Jot,csov1,.,, .
,<fl'<'(l .. ,.,,h,.t<�O<<"!'l•4
w'"'"'"'',""'"'""'r"'1>c
witlo<>l�A«1-"l!lhc
•fSlo.,on Y'l.i. c.,,.,..i .. 1 E'®[,ecr,
il) � "' o .sf ec " i::1 �
il) - cJ - '"O O} I ...... � v: i::::. il) 0 t> "" �
00
�
" en 'O
@ ·o
� 1 rr, u il) z z crj "' u :::
� J
L Re1isi<>R Sy
DRC
1 , T8.'!�\i8"" RS
lh' F.:.fcctic,ns R.S l!-06.]9
DRC R.S ill q,_�:li8"�
"'*�n..,.�,
Rolando Serrano
DOCIJMllNT
J.et.EM;ED !'OR TI-IB
™ o.\·ll·l'
o::,,:::�}(��lNAU
Ol'P.!tMIT D'<l>lSTIUX'"HON -,-_. ___
5ITI PLAN
"" AREA OF TABULATION
SHEET
T-3
JOO ;;,.
TOT"' •.
497 ss
�97
soc- sr. �
2,J7J' SF.
' • �gy·
I J09 SF".
""-'L
1,876'
1.�: §F·
497'
6,675' SF.
oco �f.
RJ-U
' Si.GI..E FN,IU
22 os
PROJECT DATA
AREA OF TABULATION
,oc1Tt
!\:Y.
1Y: fl
SITE PLAN REFERENCE NOTES
Nf)'I- Af'fA QF I QT COVERAGE
l,JJ[)[TJON rt N<f".A
Of
l(]T
!:" Of COVERED
2.106/6.67� - �1.5X
fXISDt!G AREA Y.B'!l'D:tJ
Sf.:C(ll,,{> (ElOl'll!S �OOII)
RC,\P
t/0'/ NXFSSQRI DWI I liG I pm '-OOO!QN
<(,-{-
t,Ew FlQDR hflFA MIKJ- {W!)
nssr
{N) �CCES5·� UNIT
"'1U,.•
!:" (FAA)
1,376/G.675 •
(N) 2,373/6,67� - .�5 Ml:
3. tci����fy s��
oj • /,:P. fF(
fllJl..[Mf!G
B"f
BT�IN
Pl:RF«lMi.G AAY JoND
N I IHl Pl R C1TY E',CH BUii.DiN
T SHAI.HA\IE TS OWtl 5ER\11C /!.IETER
5 AN APPl'IED SEIS�IC Gi\S 5 UOff YN._\IE WLL �IHSJol.LED ON THl flll
GAS Liht.DH THE OCJll\'11 STREAM SIO[Of I-E mJ
CONNECTED O H E E�TERIOO OF l-Ir EIUI.Dlf!G OR SPI.ICTURE
1>0 1M)(P ARA I
RE:QURED)
6 Tfl£ I RESTRICT A rec-rccr ctr.AA mo
.CCESS ro Af(( WATfR DISRtElUill
ES
l,pf'UllT£N�lolCf"S.C DR m rar. or IJE IIOOK-UP TI-E
NO H(i Oil KE
Oil
Hl'EN'iES.
u�rn
I
PLANTING .II;() SfW.l NO !£ P�\EO.
EXISTING SETBACKS
s' rr
0"
�.,
icr
LOT AREA
1 N.l. OJIMGEO ON F
.l.l1)N(l STRET
2.'ANY o.\MAGE Pl.lllLX 00 HE
RE�DU SI--W.L ll[ Tiii':
OEPAflTUlNT Of PUBLIC
PUBLIC WORK NOTES
�
ZOHi.G:
"TYF'E TRVCTION
"� E ltW
N A SSORY 01/£L w-lG �IT
J DW NG
PIM
NORTH
15' 24'
�(E) �·-o• �T
FE�CE
SCALE: 1/8' "" 1'-0" (!'\
(N) 13'-o'
SETBACK
o 4' a' �·.--
'/
• (E) &'-0' HTi7
LIH'"e o o'o'
32'-o"
. (Ni DRIVEWAY t
PROPOSED SITE PLAN 1scm·l/s"�1'-o" -1�
(EJ WATER_}
(N)5'-o"
SETBACK
(N)12'-o"
DRIVEWAY
I , .
I
I
I
I
(E) 11'-0' HT.-_
CMlJ Wlll.,
LANDSCAPE LEGEND
(N)LANDSCAPE ,'.RE:A
(GRAS OR WER BED)
Wt�;��1 (N) DRI\IEW,'.Y/CONCRETE
� (E) LAWM-TO REMAIN
MAIN
l
f1§1r-REES AAE soun F.El,DV£0 j
OR FRM SIT[
OUllltiG CONS RUCTION
-
�
,· -..f' - _,,- FLAT ROCk CAP I ,/ WI \" OVER.W.G
-'\c-·,a;a"i
24'
PIM
NORTH
16'
I WOOO FENCE
e' ••
. . .
SCALE: 1/8" 1'-0" 12\ ,•.·.-- -'
4 .. ,i •
(E) CONCRETE
TO BE DEl,10
S I T E
. '
..
·'
" . . .
EXISTING
,,,
CONCRETE TO BE; ·
DEI.IO/RE-P ... \IED
i . !
i i
j (E)REAR ADDITION i
• 1-S'rORY , a--------�-� --1 300' SF. i
I '
(E) ft'-0" HT.--...._
(�) LOOSE CRUSl1 GRAVE
8£REIAVE
(E) L ... \\tl TO REI.IAIN
(T REI.IAIN}
/CONCREE
(TO BE D IJO/RE PAVEO)
(E) 5"-0' HT.-_
CMU ALL
Li\NDSCIIPE LEGEND
CJ
D
�
(E) 6'-0" HTi\
WOOD FEMCE
PROPicRY L I "' E <. (I O 0'
' :A.: f\
.
c ,
A � . / \ . . / .. \ {E} LOOSE CONCR\ffr FAO . '\ Cf!IJS/--1' GR+.VEL / I '\ TO BE DEMO . \ ' .
"
ATTACHMENT NO. 3
DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE
REVISED SITE PLAN DATED 12/02/19
February S, 2020 DRC Meeting
AGENDA DATE:
To:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
NOVEMBER 6, 2019
RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION
fig fo th Dgn
d pv.
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
O:Van ar
ppan/Dg:o
pert L:6 amridg S
G s:L y a 6 /c
Znig sfi:S Fy t R6
Exg p:,87 SF -am y s e
P rt S z:,7 5 SF
pp:N
D v:Sp 5,an O 16, 0 9
E em:N
ATIACHMENT NO. 4
DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE
STAFF REPORT AND MINUTES FROM
11/06/19 DRC MEETING
February 5, 2020 DRC Meeting
PUBLIC NOTICE
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Categorical Exemption:
il,
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
ung an fix tu ws
6"
In ddio ctruo h ,xing iv grv ar
b rmvd d repd wh w rivy an ar An p -
t kg wi a he drwa
Poposd p c
popd r sanar --6
i r k
g
EXISTING SITE
pop g -s
r s w w h
o b r w g an sa an tu
pr g kg ar
vr h r 6 x
21 SF fl t rr w I 9 2 s rt
l 267 F y nkn a g s
Design Review Committee Staff Report
November 6, 2019
Page3of9
EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
ow
H Drit.
Ev ALUATION CRITERIA
O a (O)S 17.10070 a grl c DRC should
vi j wg:
Th j ery o,i ign tme,wc eflc
o :
1. Architectural Features.
a a
a l.
Landscape.
ri l c o
o
,c
ri
g l h
.
Signage. a ,c s
g.
4. Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. c g
as,an rm rs a i q b n m nn ,whh
tu c c u l ()
Design Review Committee Staff Report
November 6, 2019
Page4 of9
ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
Historic Preservation Design Standards for
Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation
m th p 584 SF ADU
much m th te a s cls pxy o xsg ue d t p t h
ADU u lg s.
To ads th Cmme'cmme pp h s
s U 5 F g p S
e u A U u d
t g 5 u
C y g h A h
.
AD s t
c o l h
g s c g gs a vs y strt .ri
and s gn ak fr m arc y o gh an
ru r l s c .
rt rm ,t s p ni o th cg an emt f t ADU
fr m th ma e h v s g D Stan ar
p rv f sc t p rns ghh.A p ,h p j
w l v rs m p ri gr y th rty or str p N
Cam g
I u 2:F A R
Th DRC at rns th h pr p FA j n c rm t h s
fi l c ruc q Dg s A hm 6)
Design Review Committee Staff Report
November 6, 2019
Page5 of9
cludd Atchme 7.
Sta l ta FAR rmai ut pert o
lk,Ahm 8 FAR prti Cmbdge St 0.15
38,wh a vrg 09
ma m F i R
c
vi a i h i i o
,R 0 3 d
A R i
FA
a t r av FR i u d
m a vi
h R i A l
FAR l
i d
rm t
al
F a u d
a d
i a d
al
p i
a a p cd c 0 1
OM 7 4 0 0 tt 90 F i qud l -fam y
i R-z c qu m ADU .
Design Review Committee Staff Report
November 6, 2019
Page 6of9
ft.
ftd h p f ADU twr h su prt l
addd a iing r an t o gt (rt)f uig rv
s xadd gr op sp th rt s prty
t s k w t ppn g h
t o t D
a a i o Aiis u
n s p lt l r i
and o pp n
a a o
p s
o s l s h pl
v
Privacy Between Dwellings
ot d t s
iss w b d tw h h U O s -n A-5,th
addd i th x g w w u diti an ju
li o m wi ow h U h gn i
Bedroom Dimensions
At i m ,Comm vs d th h arr w z p c
d m m y m g c qu n s dr n h
v h fl p rs s su
ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
Th j c w y y s y d
STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS
T rt fi "F "hi l s
m k r l z m fia s ak g y "k F "w
ncin ,thr g t fyi v (,s y,prt ,nvi n al
7
ur fidng a,as
ppbl,rm j h f th od raed o design
rv an rv gu:
A ppo,j f th gn o fi ontru a qrd
nd ll hav no advre
h ldn d
th o h on o dd
o h a a
f th th d
o n
h o rd
j d
ili.f a
f f th aa
aa and w l hav a
s b fr th g o ful o th ex in
,ADU futnr l o n v th ric
gr f
3 T pj i ups mmuy c hugh h us f an itlly
s,ig n m csi ith a adotd sifi plans,
pp ig , qui fig (MC 1 1 . . G.3).
T p ADU rnl gn an c l d s g and
o ty T gl a l f,d
lp g,n v rn trn l mae i l
rm z o tr hl .
,th nw structur()r ad are compe w a,msg,
orta,ad articuati f e urrunng dvlpm a wl prsrv r c
xistig ighborhd cracr (OMC 17.1.7.G.4).
RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS
pv,
ad as n f v by th gn Revw C gs m t
ov ans shll b sujt s vw v y sgn v
mm.
2.Aft any c h b e p gg la
alt f ny us stru t t
v v t
v
a n n t l e t p
un y v g
an s ty
any ly s t
f l f hs a l
fi v ds f v ri g
n run cums he g B k pss
5 Cn run rm s h fu r ru w k,y
f O g uy v p rt s B n vi Fl
q re b i wi v per
6 If n u il ze ,j p x w -ur m h fr m ap .Exss
m y b gr w OM S 1708 .060.T Pl nnig l ms
x unl Bu n P rms ar l w w ga ppv
Design Review Committee Staff Report
November 6, 2019
Page 9of9
n blw:
I.n a w ar u o n frn dr th
ADU s nh fi mm b o r,w
pn u nh pg ie lnr,p ns,
an ai.
ATTACHMENTS
I.Vy M
.Pan (S T-3) s amp 9/23/019
3.R vi A u P (amp 10/28/01 )
4.Rep rt an D ft M u fr m O 16 2 1 M
5. P P gr p
6.E p fr th Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne
.g A ri Ig s 8/8/1
8.F A R
9.DPR F m 166 N.a rige tr
: Ran Ser
1r @gm l.c
M keM
9 rnc @grri i .o
Van a ar
@ s .m
N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4980-19 Caesar Residence
AGENDA ITEMS:
Continned Items:
(2) DESIGN REVIEW NO. 4980-19- CAESAR RESIDENCE
aiffo@cyfoage.rg
DRC i:Fn Determination
ly Ribuffo,s Pn,prove vviw of prj
u r a
po i f
b n c a p
c co a .
fo o g
u n c
u p a
e o
D n a a ao .
ppv R o
b f a io
a
ppv i
C D:I en
,S h,o d F x
n
D nn
MOTION CARRIED.
(3) DESIGN REVIEW NO. 4898-17 - SHELL STATION AND CAR WASH
p furb h t fu s rv ,c u c v i f
e g i ,xpa f v c stre
bu d ,b off-site po ,o tru d a f
26 q ft.v h u u a bu ld , la d s e
r
• 4 58 a v r
g 6
PRIMARY RECORD ORA
D fi
--- - --- -- __ 1_6_6 Zip: __ 9_2_s_6_6 __
---- mEI ---- mN
"b.
concnuon, and budnans Connues on Pg 3)
(HP2)Si e fi p p
li ttr it cod)= C Jll
92
00
v' ::J
chit
7 V Blv
S Ok s,92
(Viw ,t ,o#
(Nme ffiliaion,and address)
D G ,Lav le ,D
am
A i ,5
(Describe)
Rc i
ort t (C rvey rport oh urce.r eer "nne ")
e R ()t chic (2005)
Hi i R u Sur . E IS (9 ) Hit i Bui i Iv t y
U . H Oe u ,I . (9)O Hi i Su v y
*tcnt
DPR 523A (1195)
=1
::J
::J a
v'J na S()!I...
..J a Fea R
=1 (i):
ilng,u a j d
lg Sati O k ecod
*q
ATIACHMENT NO. 5
DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE
DPR FRM FOR 166 N CAMRIGE STREET
February S, 2020 DRC Meeting
B1. Historic Name:Unknown
B3. Original Use:RES B4. Present Use:RES
*B5. Architectural Style:Bungalow
*B6. Construction History:(Construction date, atlerations, and date of alterations)Date of Construction:1923
*B9. Architect or Builder:Unknown
Period of Significance:Old Towne: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941)
*B10. Significance:Property Type:Residence
(Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.)
*B8. Related Features:
Date:Original Location:*B7. Moved?
ArchitectureTheme:Area:City of Orange
Structural Integrity:Good Condition - Minor and reversible or appropriate changes to original structure.
(List attributes and codes)
*Date of Evaluation:September, 2005
B11. Additional Resource Attributes:
(This space reserved for official comments.)
*B14. Evaluator:Robert Chattel
B13. Remarks:
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD
*B12. References:
*NRHP Status Code 1D
Primary #30-159273
HRI #038639
YesNo Unknown
Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or #:CAMBRIDGE_N_166__APN_386-074-16
(Assigned by Recorder)
PrehistoricHistoric Both
B2. Common Name:
Applicable Criteria:AC
Orange Daily News.
(Sketch Map with North arrow required.)
DPR 523B (1/95)*Required Information
Opportunities:
Status change since 1991 Survey: None.
Site Integrity:
(Continues on Pg.3.)
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
CONTINUATION SHEET
Description of Photo:
Primary #30-159273
HRI #038639
Trinomial ORA
Recorded by:
Date Recorded:April, 2005
P3a. Description (Continued from Pg.1):
DPR 523L (11/98)*Required Information
UpdateContinuation
Page 3 of 3
B6. Construction History (Continued from Pg.2):
Lot Acre:0.1561
Principal Building Sqft:1092
Planning Zone:R-1-6 # of Stories:1
Years Surveyed:1982, 1991, 2005
General Plan:LDR
# of Units:1
B13. Remarks (Continued from Pg.2):
1991
D. Gest, P. LaValley, D. Matsumoto
Chattel Architecture
13417 Ventura Blvd.
Sherman Oaks, CA 91423
*Resource Name or #:CAMBRIDGE_N_166__APN_386-074-16
(Assigned by Recorder)
Listed in National Register:1997
# of Buildings:1