12-18-19 144 N. Orange Street - Architects Orange Stairs and Patio (DRC 4924-17)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM DECEMBER 18, 2019 Anna SUMMARY RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION gBACKGROUND INFORMATION Aant/Own:prtyL:Galangn:Znifi:Ex:rtySz:uC:PUBLIC NOTICE JkS,ArhiOg44OanStr11-.GtrazHriOwnMU(OMIX15)OwnMU15(OMU-580SFtw-ry mb20SF -ry wirianurkin169 SF3,65SF N6,0Nbgnw
Design Review Committee Staff Report December 18, 2019 Page 2 of5 ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties PROJECT DESCRIPTION EXISTING SITE mmyyEXISTING AREA CONTEXT NGri-tw-dangrdanfioznmm,ard'riary,rv,anaryputtgurrgzgOwnMU-5.EVALUATION CRITERIA OMuniM77wj.wipantrngohtuFatu.htecturturty
Design Review Committee Staff Report December 18, 2019 Page3 o/5 ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES MowtryfromthTkPPG"Whi"dgnoppwiaianDRCaSafffiypoADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION ffart(MAR)ejwidi9,7REQUIRED FINDINGS Thurtfi"Fing"thyakakfinakigy"akFd"drws a hrgn(y, evrnmnum) nrtThrt thFndthtww ulimyhhakithkTh"Fg"lw(f) amtruf yakiy maiy annakthF
Design Review Committee Staff Report December 18, 2019 Page 4 o/5 Design Review tubruurrny,mbwHt.'Suli(OMC1...)PunbrmHPOwnyrbrmn.IrmSdar10,iwrufrmibuppoorm3Tpjtguutytsuuftsngrsgntsstntppifipl,bgqujig(M1710.G3)POwnHrimumpyHPrvgnarOdS(b).Abbpkmar4.Ffisn,ifidintCtyOgnfiGulisuuionbssgn,ufuugnillrvxsgb(OM1.1G. 4)rpmCtyIfilDGiyfigbCONDITIONS llmm:I.pllcompyCoAbyCommttnjunowN4924-17anMinanRviN.0916-17Nmbe62019
Design Review Committee Staff Report December 18, 2019 Page 5 o/5 ATTACHMENTS anarrhistranCA66<bfohiN:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4924-17 The Courtyard\StaffReport 2 - DRC 4924-17 - AO Stair.docx
Vicinity Map 144 N. Orange Street & 141-149 N. Glassell Street DRC No. 4924-17 221 222 ,,,..---.-------;'\ r 193 � ,n I � tm I r����u N s City of Orange ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4924-17; ARCHITECTS ORANGE STAIRS AND PATIO VICINITY MAP December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting Community Development Department
DEPAR!liMEN1' OF AND RECREATIC:>N PRIMARY RECORD NRHP ORA lD #: D B.M. ii m_E/ ---------- rybrckcommrcwthcortivcorcdfa9d,whchextendsto.Gsl!.hiaddessccssedfromrfbildn(HP)commibudngs�D D D D O *1.prttao:rngCoutyAssesoRcods().ChttArchitct()HtorcRorcrvey.GI()HstoricBldInvtoryUpdt.HeitgCutyInc.()OranHstricurvy.bpif2011#) *6C/AocD D **SRcydrs)D.Gst.vlyD.MtsumtoChttelrchtectr7VtBlvd.hrmnaksC*9Ddy,*0rvyyp:(Describe)ReconnsancAttchments:D D D D D D D D D 5)AITACHMENT NO. 2 RCNO92-17;ARCHITECTS ORNE STAIRS ANPATIOHISTORIC RESOURCE SURVEY FORM December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting
BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD HRl1# 30-158656, 30-162521, 30-161903 073710, 096898, ]12141 lD ��---------------------------� •es. 192 3 c � Historic O Prehistoric O Both No O Yes O Unknown ------ 7-):_A_c _ ConiuP.4)tulItyIitypprtnDiged6b,niBadshSDPRfof.afrfratiothchi811.AdditionalResourceAttributes:(Listattributesandcodes)-------------------------------*8.rDyw83.Remk(ContinusnPg.3.)Sgvy:orviyitd7oti.G):seSkeMwith Nrtrrwqui.)*814.Ealua: Rbrt*af Evaluaon: ptbr,25-----------------------� (Ticservorfficlcments.)DPR 5238 (1/95) qIrm
Stiti Cl:0NTINUA111GN SHEET HRI# ORA 3 3 {Assigned by Recorder) o. VntrBvd.ShrnOkCA9423O May,25�----------------------� d22sripinfPht1991ListdInNatinalgit1982,199-------------------------- GnllannningZnLtAcicipaBildingqft------ 86.ContrutinHistry(Ctindrm.2)813.mks(ntindfrmg.2)3.Dsipti(Cntinmg.1)DPR 523L (11/98) 1 2 2 *qidIrmtiOTMIX-15#ofBuildings:OTMU-15#ofSries:.1638#ofUnis:23
PRIMARY RECORD HRI# 10 �------------------------- 0 -e. ���������- -- of . - u.3.),cmmwhdtvndfca,whchxnaThaddfmafbud.urceAttibues:(HP6)--Cmmelbulng(Ltttriuss*e�BuigO ruteO ObjeO �EemtfiO DiO h(Isole,ec)rtC(Csurvyprtoheu".'OngCuntyAssRcord()ChteAhitect(2)HtcRucSuvyEI()HocunInvUpdt.HegeageCty,Inc(8)OangHSvyb.pP2 O l O Vwccsso#)*6eAg2�HtoO PehiO Bth7.weAdd*Bdby(Name,ffllodadds)Dst,PLav,DMatChatrhtcte37VtuavdShnak,CA9. edeay,2*0rvy Typ(Derb)RAttachmnts: 0 NOE O Mp � CioShe()� Buing, Srue, ad jecRcO Ahaolgl RO Ded O LeeeO Millig aoRecoO Rck Art RcrO ArtfaRed O haphRod O the(Lis)DP52A (1/9) *qInrm
Bl.lll:lll>ING, S�Rl!JGifURE, AND OBilEGT RECORD ARI# l.D #: -------------------- * c � Historic D Prehistoric D Both No D Yes D Unknown --------- ------------------- liusB.Badshw(Achitct)chtectueitfgmmeal--------------- grityCtuP.4.)cdTe:EarySetteet(c.187-)ApplicableCriteria:AC-------- uulItyItyOpprtDesiedn6bachitect,rus.Brashaw.SDRfmfrlsslfrnfmtionothearchtct.8AnAttbe(Listattributesandcodes)' ------------------------------------------------------ *B2fcranDalyNs.83Rk(ContinuesnPg.3.)SttuschsncSuvy:rvusystdn9(sstwthN.Gss!)as:lss!.(SkMwith Northrrowreqr.)*814EvaluaRobethattl*DaofEvaaon: Septmb,25(Tpaservedffiialomts)D5238 (1/95) *Rqd In ---- -- --
CONl"INUATION SHEET (Assigned by Recorder) � ....... ����������� VnBvd.SnOk,C4D daYrsSurveyed:82,,DesriptionofPh1991ListiNationalRgisr98,199OTIX-15#ofBuilings:.OTMU-2 2 ofSri# fUitsGlPinZne:LtAPiniplBuilingSqft----- BG.suiHitry(niurmPg.2)613.Rerks(iuefrPg.2)P3.Dipti(inudfPg.1)DPR 52L(11/98)*RquieIri
DEPARTMENT 0F PARKS AND R.ECREA"Fl0N PRIMARY REGQRB 0RA rn Ditil: #: D map T,14o- -- NALOrange14ST,# City:OrangeZip:d,UTM:(Give..mo•r
•e•lh•an•o•---------- arOerarrrbuts:(HP6)--CommercilBuldng(Lttricods*P4.ResourcesP�BuilgD ruO bjeD �EemeDsD D e1OrCrrrre1rnnOraeCn1nrrDooo #) D eD aeaarer11neanaCeaTnanD D u)�Bdg,tru,dbjedD agidD DriD LFuedD MlligaRdD krtRD rtifD grapdD D9)*eqe
of BUILlDfNG, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD #: � Historic D Prehistoric O Both 2011, (#1002-061). No O Yes D Unknown -------- wArchecreCiyagmmecallTwe:Eayee(.1870 __ -_1_9,.2_0_)______ i.A_c_g.4.)gtyeegtypprt811.AdditionalResourceAttributes:(Listattrbutesandcodes)-------------------------------812eeegDilyw.813.Rmarks:(ContinuesonPg.3.)(SketchMapwitNortaowequied.)chgvy:R.814.Evaluto: RbethaelDatoEvlution: Septeber,2005 -----------------------� f Tparvfrffioments.)DPR 5238 (1/95) qelnformationJ l
State of Toa Ci:ONlilNUATION SHEEli al 0RA #: (Assigned by Recorder) D ������������� ,,tINtit8,GlTMIX-# fBis:Z:TMU-# fStiLtAce88# fUnts:icipBiligqft:86.strcttry(tief.2)81.k(tifm.2):.scpto(Cotg.1)DPR 523L (11/98) 1 1 1 Dsptifht2005*eqidIfto
VIEW WEST LOOKING AT PATIO OF BUILDINGS 141,143 &149 GLASSELL ATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC NO. 4924-17; ARCHITECTS ORANGE STAIRS AND PATIO SITE PHOTOGRAPHS December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting
VIEW NORTHEAST LOOKING AT PATIO OF BUILDING 149 GLASSELL VIEW SOUTHEAST LOOKING AT PATIO OF BUILDINGS 141 & 143 GLASSELL ---- 111-149) GLA�l=E =
VIEW SOUTHWEST LOOKING AT PATIO OF BUILDING 141 GLASSELL VIEW NORTHWEST LOOKING AT PATIO OF BUILDING 143 GLASSELL
VIEW WEST LOOKING AT REAR OF BUILDINGS 141, 143, & 149 GLASSELL VIEW SOUTHWEST LOOKING AT REAR OF BUILDINGS 141, 143, & 149 GLASSELL
VIEW SOUTHWEST LOOKING AT NEARBY PROPERTY (77 PLAZA SQUARE) VIEW NORTHWEST LOOKING AT NEARBY PROPERTY (112-121 GLASSELL) 1411-149 ��SSIE==
MOTION CARRIED hiltrmtimthjthRC-rijRTheCttqwgnwwiturnAwniypfzmmrnypgalmRecmmndfiningrntriATIACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4924-17; ARCHITECTS ORANGE STAIRS AND PATIO DRC MINUTES FROM 11/06/19 December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting Ree:834-844(5) DESIGN REVIEW NO. 4924-17-ARCHITECTS ORANGE STAIRS AND PATIO ArairmthetwhiazHtri4441-4GtrPazritriff C: r(714) 7447243@tygFRedtri, part gny gnfunb1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 112 13 1415 16 17 18 19 0 222 23 45 26 7 28230 31 32 33 3435 36 37 383441 42 43 44 45 46 47
MOTION CARRIED. STADJOURNMENT: 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 111123116718 9122 P6
o OJ
�
c
c:J ,,5 rn
0 ('"') rn- C1z -n c::::, rn Ci)
0 � 20
I '25 rn2 o-
u5
CJ)
0 o z
rn
n
n
co c
.... "tl w "tl
ID 5 ::a
I I "" s:: 'T1
£ :a:,
n
nn VI
I
....
2
oO :r: � VI
3 ,., p
:r: � "tJ I z
�z m- "tl �
er ,-
• n ::c �
m-
ID m Ill t �
� ::c
::c z G\ - <..n
.., <
§n :E -I
� z I
.... �
-I N
>!:!:I
.... -I
)> i" l>
zo -n
!¥J - ii ... n
'< m §5
zo On r
N O Ill � :I:
• n �5 3o m
Q 2 )>
0 r ::c �5
,_._2 )> s:
5 §; d := ::c
G)
::a m
ID C C nz
5> d 0 ::c m
c � "Cl = -I
::c s:: s:: !!2 d z
::i:, m � nl 2
d .!-" ):>
s:: s::
nc- !:I p
VI ri .!-" ):> Rs:: 0
s: .... 0 Ill U1
s:: :§ :r: � rl ��
ID N
�
ID ......._ 0
0
-...J :r: :E Q
:::!'. g �
n °' 0
::I ........
:c Cl) °' :c
Oii .... 2
� °' �
� C'I
�
m
::c •
�
::0
� r m s::
G) � ::c
� m
• ::0
VI •