12-18-19 202 South Main Street - Chick-Fil-A (DRC 4909-17)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM DECEMBER 18, 2019 SUMMARY RECOMMENDED ACTION tartyCrminrirtqBACKGROUND INFORMATION Act/Own:PprtyLc:thtrGs:hU(NIX42u/FARZnnga:hU(NUExinv:Frtyz:4,3FAsc:GAmdm; ZN8; Urm34; N4-; EnmN8j:
Design Review Committee Staff Report December 18, 2019 Page 2 of 11 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW PROJECT DESCRIPTION 27ar-hiurblnghdrithruurfki,urzfr464drocfrrnrtmjtStrAtrasnirvg/rihrvaryhidrkifrzknihiurwulalffiurpulurptrArchitecture hi-drihrugntparyhituryarihituraxknzartu"rwWhi" nitutr"FG" "S"nzniumturttarriardrihrutrurnry tuniaum
Design Review Committee Staff Report
December 18, 2019
Page 3 of 11
Landscape
Access and Circulation
y An An
Pra pty ar r cn hr an
ar pick an u ur .D tr fr
Amn Avn ain Str uran
Parking/Drive Thru
an w v 49 cs c pn
b pkg th .G n w al
hrn rj un an
ar c h fr
h S n
h rvhr ctr
r A A an
h w
i v c fr
pi h m n w p
An A p fr
h S n cn
Environmental Review
an y n n n
i .A
a c an
i an h y rc u p c i m ,
o ot ly g r T MN c e nin g a A
Qual y,B Rr ,C Rr e ,az z ,N i e,
anpi n/,Cul ur R rc l n rp i
f App I ur p
s fic m c t fi
S aff qu s h h DRC c fi y A hc S (P ),C l
R (Pg e 4.5 )ft MND a F D,
Design Review Committee Staff Report
December 18, 2019
Page 4 of II
EXISTING SITE
EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
th u Pj Jun 8 Mar 208
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Og Ma C (OMC)10.00 RC
ud u w v .th g:
T hl ,g th,hi fl
wi :
1. Architectural Features.
T art ur fl ar g yl i
b.Cv ug l g u
g q roj w an ur y.
2 Landscape.
T yp , z , an t j '
l g .
b. Lands n ru qr ,
b s p
c. Lan pg l break
x ar
3 Secondary Functional and Accessory Features.
s g , , , q
ll b c n mann ,
il ng()
ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF ISSUES
A DRC's S mb 8· 20 , C mm ro mm a
ou (tt hm 3):
Design Review Committee Staff Report
December 18, 2019
Page 5 of JI
fo y v,
y g j urrg t G (CG)
NMIX,w rg z G B )N T g
n g b y um p
an trans y w y an v
ary ,fi,j o Mai S
Anly,Su M tr b
w p M
t
M S
N
y j G
an u j T y
Su
r b v
y M )pp g
b b T
g G
y gg y
s p
g
M t
urb ar T ,,b ss
p
Design Review Committee Staff Report
December 18, 2019
Page 6of Jl
s nm nk ak
s th c b w al b wi x g
j fi se tr ,y g
c sw,p tran/fls e u
vs p,w q tr arkg m
li ur.
e rvd b t s
vs q h ,s
mx z o .
I 3 Ariu
As h P s , p
j , mi bk ar bz x
fi h x n wi p
ws Des n ar t u ain/L Dtr T x
e ur w p p
G v h b l n 't , ur b w art t
w w w w "B " w rn
v , w t fr y W g
k b nz tte fi , w d i y
b
S af k r R fi ng
, as w bk fi d hr py a e
p .
4
I o DRC ee a k, ap y fia ur
g s rt t Ia , p
l n b '
7
f qie t.h urry 23 t w 41
qi T al 7 e th cury Ah
t t i rt by 18 ,al ar um x z Wi
fal t f qu n,um y rg th r
conf t
f r
th
t
ar A
fb g
REQUIRED FINDINGS
t y
t al
t
e u e
t e t y s wig
th a "F "ar,c ,s
u b o f)j .
ru y j ;making y u i ann
F
F t Bw ur fi g t ,s
b ,w t
e pe :
by RC ig bodyfor
t pjt (OMC 17.0.070.G.l).
jt d O w H s ;e,g
y o t c t
2 I y Nai gi iti D,t li ith Sry f
te Inio'aa a guli (OMC 7.0.07.G.2).
h d i wi dopd p/fi pn,appb dsign
tadad,a i qdfidng (OMC 7..7.G.3).
an u ps r M Str
h p uran.Lans p an
t fr Mai S g .
T j S Rp Pj r,
w ar j Te c #3 Su
Main/La Va,w a rban ary .c
e fa ur y y,c at
s
4.F fill idtia vopnt,pcifid i Cty f Og Infi dt Dg
Gii,w tu()ddt ompib wit se,mssg
ii,ad aiion of th ding dvopm d wi p o h
xitig igbood (OMC 7..07.G. 4).
T p t
a la b C 'I Rst G ; th,F o
.
ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
C y a ff op i s tt l A 7, 2019,
a qs u je . C ty a
viw ev bm pan Dc 4, 2019 of
q j
CONDITIONS
af nd ng t DRC o an
v nm a a t C jc , l
i a apa y C t q fi n
e rv o uny st
1. T e j c l c sc conformance
l s an x b s e lab c 18, 2019 cg q ir
by f ppr,an n o y D R
Design Review Committee Staff Report
December 18, 2019
Page 9 of 11
r rvl I my D
d chg n ppoa
c,and h th v am s
ppr l Cmmuny r my v th
w q
3 Subsquen fi pp cur
bd vw pv Cmm c gn
Shu mdfic c fi
ov y D C
fic p c c
l D qm C
c l b r
a
dfic h w y
fic c p
h ll p
d
ldg pp
Cm v a
n d c
dg y r
hl b c fi p s
h c d
ly m n
su m r bl vm p fi o
s
v c
P d r ur a
l q p (Ch 52 B ur
S d d),ch cfi c ,,,,.
(d 7 ).wi O app y
u "S ur N .""p P L 1/8",wi ,c
ai
Design Review Committee Staff Report
December 18, 2019
Page JO of 11
al th L ar pfic
3 sane f rt y,th t g ng
nc th t v Bur.gg fi
dm gg x x ar.h
aan all e ld ur th g h qnts
OM Si 17 12030 y rt x ar
l x
0
l g nt
d t
x th
e r
y
sll
th th th r
ld q th
an v
ed ld th .
p
ia le dv n ,g
S D ,I m m
F Fa ,l F ,k A q ,S t as
q.
ATTACHMENTS
I.Vy M
D g Rev tt R 18,2019
3.Dg Rv M 18,2019
.A R mm
5 t M N ar N 188-18
F M N v ar N 188-18
7 L 18,2019
Design Review Committee Staff Report December 18, 2019 Page 11 of 11 cc: Robert Lombardi PE - President 4G Development and Consulting, Inc. PO Box 270571 San Diego, CA 92198-2571 rlombardi@4gdev.com N:ICDD\PLNG\Applications\General Plan Amendment\GPA 2018-0002 Chick fil AIDRCIDRC Report with MND.doc
Vicinity Map
Design Review No. 4909-17
Chick-fil-A
...... l... % m' 1'r,-r!-r TT'"
n t;C'�i! LLlii �
R-1-6 Portola
Middle
School
MAPLEAl/f.
C-1
CITY OF ORANGE
ATIAOiMENT NO. 1
DRC NO. 4909·17; CHICK-FIL-A
VICINITY MAP
December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT
AGENDA DATE:
To:
THRU:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
AGENDA ITEM
SEPTEMBER 18, 2019
I
RECOMMENDED ACTION
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
,F
prt z ,8 F
l Am 10;187
1;U N 7;
1;nm 8
u oj
PUBLIC NOTICE
N Noe q f AITACHMENT NO. 2
DRC NO. 4909-17; CHICK-FIL-A
DR( STAFF REPORT (DATED 09/18/19)
December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 2 of 10
ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
dg
,khn ar,v ,ar N s
i ar c frz,,s ,en
an fi fi c urp,a
ul ,
Architecture
h d C hru ur fi cy
t r um gt f
xmat ,,ar nz ,umu
,"Powerwall W " c d um fi
as c truc g masonry h
um
Landscape
Omta a ul d s t
g, ru y
(q pm )
u r ai ; g g
S S u l g s
c c t
g Mai St d M Se n
fr th fi x T x cc nry w
g rn un h c T jc d
n "dm " ar
h 'C O ' g c y pe
nh M Str u c n a
,qar
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 3 of 10
Access and Circulation
Parking/Drive Thru
rn j thru wrp un
ern an hi drhr
h rn thr p 7
pp w w fl 20
Environmental Review
ND j re
nvnm EQ G q ig
fi
fi n prm ,mn
al b n MND ur,h
C .Irp r h
u fi fi
S q DRC fi (P .)ur
R ur S (P 1) ND rm th y
r n th j
EXISTING SITE
n 8 79 q ru pp x y 5
x 70 n g
ur . T t y W
y n (f), y
dr t W
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 4 of 10
EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
EVALUATION CRITERIA
1. Architectural Features.
2. Landscape.
pp j '
p
Lg ru v u
tru p pxy th
Ls un pk ak
g x p
3. Secondary Functional and Accessory Features.
,,e q
nn w tu p wi p
l()
ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF ISSUES
Isu L U y Fk
A k n f w Ge Amdm Z
n g part j p y
a S Mai rr al , pj rn
t w o g w S S
v an un p a y
en v th rt px ,
fi p a e pun
c i pp ly j
G g j a N x U (NMIX), n
e s z Ng Mx U (NU)NU
an tg x -y M
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 5 of 10
z al
Mai
Wh n th tant '
an an tr t,z
qis uran l X um F
R (FAR)hi
d-n x tr
T p -fi t Pan Z
qui ,ar d an x
s ana ,j 010
zg
jt s R d P j
bj p an D ar A t D
an , j T D #3 t n/L V ,
an m y t d fi anl ,
fi
v , uran
y m m wi an
m mx-d,a an fi
l
: P ann g
W j t y
j an , an , an
ti tr , t uran w th
th , ar
un am mn ur d l
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 6 of JO
wi.T rt fi
gh fr wi n .B
x fi fi o
n tr rt
T fi
4:Lp
l fl e ,p
ce T x p w ar
ru T 24 S Lurl M S an d
Av,w 24 H Oaks th e T 24
un fi T x g
Q P m t g dr -T 24-W st rn
R wi A A 36-P V
w pl ""
S ai S A hru s
a g p ai . S q R
"u ". T rp
ai Str d A T DR '
h n
5 g
T w y
. H , t k wi g
h """O ", p t
fr h DRC, p
REQUIRED FINDINGS
rt fi "F " , th
ma u z m k fial A m "makes F ,"
c i , hr g (i.e., , p ort,
, ) srt T prt
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 7 of 10
)
3 T p h uty th e t ent,
t t cifi ,ig
,qu fi C .0..3)
R Pj a,
#3
n/L V,u T
pd u ,th
4 F fi t ,pifi e ty f rn fi R sign
,tut(),g,
,tu f uu a ill ce
x h (4)
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 8 of JO
ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
CONDITIONS
e p
5 C o O,n
s W art
,o ar,
u ar
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page 9 of 10
Od N -A O y
"S N"A "A L 1/08",,
0 rm ,ur
e c z n
na th P hr Evnm D E),
w nv ra ur,,
viliy ,,,dr,
11 s , v
O F
12 rm , l j
h 'W E L c G
IX O L s fi
13 s Cert O ,
n on im B rm
t x t x y T
an s s u q
O C S 0 30 rt 'x ;
urr un x
mum 0 -c d
4 i nm , , n y , ,
p y y
ar s t s , v x y '
c , ,
p ng y
15 c , , w , y
e gu ns. V nn
e rm
Design Review Committee Staff Report
September 18, 2019
Page JO of 10
pla l y ll
appcbl del ,l :Cy w nn,Orang
y S nn F Tn Sy Ir Pgam ,
F Facty,o F ,Pk A S n S ,a
q
ATTACHMENTS
I. Vny M
2.Mg Ng N.1858-8
3 Ps
:R L E -P
40 pm Cl I
O Bx 2051
S ,CA 92198-25
rl a @4gd v.
n:\cdd\plng\applications\gcncral plan amcndrnenngpa 2018-0002 chick fil a\drc\drc report with mnd doc
.
•202 u M Sr
•S Cct:Rbrt Grc (14)44-,ar@yor.rg
•DRC Aci:Rcmmn Pann mmn
Robert Gara,Se P r r n .
R mbr r o r
o
r r u
r r
e cm u o n g
• An c c r
•r om m r .
c Su n .
•r r n
n
i r g
u .
•r r .
•t S g
i
•r
•rr r
o e crr m r
.
•P r r m .
o be r c nn pr s no mp y
with the Southwet Ds g S a a ,f h Gn ra P z n g.I h g
wee c ld t n g br streetscape.
The app ican ask f c r r r r b d C mm e'
t
ATTACHMENT NO. 3
DRC NO. 4909-17; CHICK-FIL-A
DRC FINAL MINUTES (DATED 09/18/19)
December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting
ADJOURNMENT:
MOTION CARRIED.
b ,9.
Design Review No 4909-17 - Chick-fil-A
12/4/19 Hearing
36"
e e f c
rkg lt s w v 'G 'bf e ky i t
ry Rf i f n z o
piu a i .
3. C w Sw Dg Gu
gn d w,l s ws:
.A ca q w s v
.
r b w ss Gs
w u l .
.d u n
w f ss k
.
k l w b
g
w i
g w iu k
s
r r T a l s s
c ss t t w t d .4 T s
r ary wh w v d g w w
recommnd {.44)a [EIF]w l gs w i
o e .
1 ATTACHMENT NO. 4
DRC NO. 4909-17; CHICK-FIL-A
APPLICANT'S RESPONSE TO DRC
COMMENTS
December 18, 2019 DRC Meeting
gui lis (pg
8)
k.iva imvms ag A i,pr h DT a,cud 10
ca a,h ppi plt -6f l t (pg 8)
4 a h l sa-t
A p
.a a T t cs
m -a a pr-r h
p h -h f
.a a a
m f rt
aa a vh
l p f S A ia li l
t C t Rm r 46 1t a iy
6.R -i i
:
a.i i n r p h
t i sys m o l y
7.s o la ha ly D g Sa s ic g
,,h .
A o
.S b
i. M :C p 18'"v 6'mm D i S a (pg 7
M S i l e S n l 1 l s y a 'way
p D si S a (p .)I i i i S
t h v i T s
y h h j rty S
N
2
rt o Th n wi
h kc ren owa Al v g
d ,u -azi
e prkn rv a s y g g y iv pig
o mn T pak i o ig log
k f b p AD n
ive-s w c i u s p
c ig
9 o l w o h p s c
F e
h l in a bn a h o , l g
0 h e cmn y fe u on co ; eii y t
a y. Ci .
CFA p
a b dn g a i c i lg i
11. P j ct i -c l i l
F e
a e ve, w a i g pa g 36" B x v
t ut j c in L 5-l u t
fr her creen he pk l a as 'G ' e way m
n f p y a g s s
i l
3
k g a o
i p .
4