Loading...
11-06-19 166 N. Cambridge Street - Caesar Residence (DRC 4980-19)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM NOVEMBER 6, 2019 S5,20916,2.RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION SafmmjjqvdBACKGROUND INFORMATION O:Vt/D:SrrL:66SGnDg:LD26/Zn:SFamin16Ex:,76SFyPSz:6,675SF:P:S5216,20E:Nn Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 2 of9 Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, In prtk6zg,nFrArF)qurtykisgalmirtXGSTrtyuualoDcyBugwsru2sg,ggmiuunwThpprtygg,ki,rtygrgr.In 9,ppoxmae2FflaIn 992,anvertnan y2Fynknwalaga Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 3 of9 MAialsyR16zgmg-amiynhinalqOowHDEVLUARIERIAOgMal(OM)S1710070galDRvghiifwing:jalaaly,gmflg:1. Architectural Features. alalflmiargypbggahigqalpjvalal2. Landscape. yp,zalalj'saloLpalruyqg,altranxmisLarsalbvarkiaktarfgx3Signage. gsal()galrsalang.4Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. sloadiganfalqalbshicalmpalb() Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page4 of9 canmfippjanwHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne (Dgan)Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation (SO):ananarwgpv,hCmmipp58FADUoomtthxyttxttanADUwTmmi'mmmw:•FrtzDU587F(galppz633F);•aiaitwanADU9tvxg,v5.pwv;an•Ccy(rt)Uwirmval,DUvwwyuuparyyug,anwvvyanakalyoaianotherucanmais.FrtpangmzpmAUfvrnganrvvppspppojetwvanyypalNCamg2:FArTCFARjanfiruqDSar(6) Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 5 of9 #:Ofippgd/Ubpp,qx(20:1)OMC7lamil1zqADU Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 6 of9 hoADUaryliddgddg()ctxwD'anfiardwddADUhhmakitmm.Aehtxt,dmakfimb.gifihmmhiIss#4:RODCmmTDmmyartdmiPrivacy Between Dwellings TDRtqhtmicywADUOA-A-5,xwjstADUdBedroom Dimensions AmgCmmiarrytmtgdr.asflhiADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION TwydySTAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS Tcdfia"g"couwhidecmddisioakmakfialAmakigy"akF"drwhrgv(.myie Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 7 of9 ohiyhihlnpyybiguhavyhalgakhi.n,ARhrgoxort100-kNCbS2(O77.2).pjS#910SryISbiliaky.zmADUboyovvbytrbyxn,aneADUvytthhiyfhn.3juutyuufrnly,gifi,plb,requiredfindingsG3)ADUyinxhirthibanrnialfrmhzrtyhi Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 8 of9 M1710070G4)RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS 1. 019),ficoqsoDRCmmiAyananbjqvpDRmmiAygargy,anmmimmm.If CmmyDvDmiosan,ov,hCouityDvDuqunb3gmnarmlanyyaiyarvothimi,xy'4fioedcfaoarusmiBDoanh5miaifutrusqyCOg,mmuDart'BuFaiaiqunrmiuhirmi6If zjp-umExnygOMC1708.060PanBuPrmiaryarfv. Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 9of9 If lgxGvCo2.Sfrtmmwgmmno:1ndoanndfhADUommno,wmig,a,l,nATTACHMENTS 1VyM2SP(Sh-3)/3/213RdArP(1/8/21)4SfRDfMiOb1,019M5PrtPr6ErpfHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne GAIm8/8/18FArRoT9DPRF1NCbS:RSrrll@gimMkMynui@gmi.mVanCvn@vn.N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4980-19 Caesar Residence Vicinity Map DRC No. 4980-19 Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge Street I , MAPLE A .---.--,------------__,-�, (---------------...: J I I I 192 i I 0: 1 a2 I I �1--§J-------+-.;..;11 IL... I 1,- I 1 7 4 1(/) ! 1 7 5 �=-=--------------.1UJ)t--*'---...-.�--1- :c.9l 1 o7 166 ,01 I I ,__ --11_, 1 60 :o:: : 157 1-----.....J I co I l�I 149 150 l<() r-----""""''o' 142 I ! 141 / I r-·-----i� .i-------.1/ I 133 / I I I !-------&...;;; I I ! J 125 r I I \-.------J N � W�E s ORANGE = CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE YELLOW= NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE CITY OF ORANGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE VICINITY MAP November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting T-1 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S T-31 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S 2 LIVING AREA ENTRYREF.BATH KITCHEN CL. BEDROOM A-11 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S REF.REF.A-21 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S 2 ROUGHOPN'G.ROUGH OPN'G.A-31 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S 1 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S A-43579 2468 A-5 1 D C B A 1 2 3 54 1 2 3 54 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision ByProject For:SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S 4 23 BEDROOM LIVING ROOM BEDROOM KITCHENLIVING ROOM A-6 1 3 OWNER REVIEW PRELIMINARY REVIEW CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT 1 2 3 THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN RELEASED FOR THE FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S) ON ________________ X 05-15-19 Revision By SHEET Copyright-2019 expressly reserves its common law copyright and other property rights in these plans. these plans are not to be reproduced, changed or copied in any form or manner whatsoever, nor are they to be assigned to any third party, without first obtaining the written permission and consent of Shucri Yaghi Consulting Engineers. 112 E. Chapman Ave. Suite#D Orange Ca 92866 Tel. (714) 997-9120 Fax. (714) 774-3676 CONSULTING ENGINEERS SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI Rolando Serrano APPROVED Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU Dwelling. DRC Corrections 08-21-19 R.S DRC Corrections 09-16-19 R.S DRC Corrections 10-28-19 R.S 2 4567 AGENDA DATE: To: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM OCTOBER 16, 2019 RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION j,jqgDdBACKGROUND INFORMATION Vt/DgL166bdGDga:LDyd26/Z:Fy-6EgDv:76Fydyz:6675F5E:ATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE STAFF REPORT AND DRAFT MINUTES FROM 10/16/19 DRC MTG. November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 2 of9 Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, In An rtg-mirtyEXGSITEN-lHThn-Bru92hig,gl,mirtvkilrtrgIn 94,x42SflIn 992,x27knal Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 3 of9 6zgp-amiyuaralqaraOTowneHDVLUCRIRIAOangcal(O)c70070DRvjwg:j,g,flgs:1. Architectural Features. flgsyvanughqalvalhi2. Landscape. yp,zalj'vLgruyqanx.Lanpalvanpkigakpanx3Signage. Al(),,,alan.Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. gangartanananalqalian,whichisarhialug() Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 4 of9 Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation MDBARCg,mmi633FADUlxmiyxaAUwngIn ,Clllp""yTCmmi'mmangoj:•zADU633F58F;•InswADUf66bl;•AdgweADUval,AUvwyrubnlyoadydgwlvmilyalakarlyaiTsaleotrualaidFrtanzADUaidrnggDanrvdvld,jwvgyrtyalNamdFARRnrnsdARdnruq(A6 Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 5 of9 An 5UaxpeMmy:•rrqqartjalbbrmrrkig•LUlanytru•Lveml.ppDynyqb Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 6 of9 Privacy Between Dwellings ddedhehxgjutonofheiADUgDriveway Gate mmihgkigjosruedqzxgdrivewygearkigrtAlternative Building Placement partk,xwddhpprtyggtrtd/xgaooADUhprteexsg:•kaipart;•rualygg962rrgqUbrtower;and•,fiygg,ob2nddedwhenheicswvrtADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION hi Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 7 of9 STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS (mmf)j.Tj;akiyakethggarjBwarpparrmiwj:jhrusqurwvebaararhmiarrirarhiai.afaihARiwithinangxhi100-kNCambStr.2. IyNiRiiiii,hppliitaryfhi'guiliC..G2.ppjwSar#910ryi'fRiliiakarhicualyfairzADUarblarfbardwihvemiarvbyTfuxitanADUwvtyai3.pjiguuityiugusanintrnallyi,iiiiipifipla,ppliiirequiredfindingsO7.0.070.G.3). Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 8 of9 lpcexiiigbr(OM17.10070G)RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS qvDnmmiqyDimmicuymimmyDIDDmianvvanCmmDDviqugigmnymlCgaiumixyCy'4fivrumiBD5rurmialruqiOgmmDDart'BDFailaitqrmimi Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 9 of9 If hesd/yfidy(9)ymmgjgIanfigq,anyarrdggG2ATTACHMENTS Vy.OS(hT3)am//93.RArhi(9/3/29)4SRDt5095ygErpHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne 7AIm/8/9FlArR9DRFNmdg:Ranrranseanoacll@gmiomikMbymttt@gmimVn@vnN:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4980-19 Caesar Residence 1 2 3 4 5 AGENDA ITEMS: 6 7 Continued Items: 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 • 33 • f 34 • 35 srirtsek36 anunlkrt37 • yanzH38 sq7mnimum;manr39 gk40 • Thttannakqfigrt;41 twman42 • arytquaiui43 ;v44 • fianttrn.Th45 aratwturanhcturged46 geun 1 • 2 lal.eluwulrv9addition3frmhitruturr.4 5 Mr.ymmialaspacnth6 pprtyangrinumdr'rn.7 8 mFxmgnv.4980-9-Casar9 nmu.10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 z LI.J 0 (9 �Cl en z - C> � �w C'.I O> o GJ ("I") 0 z o "' IJ.. -w >- 0 Zo::: <C z ::r: � :5 0. o Driveway -Street View Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869 ATTACHMENT NO, 5 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPHS November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting Area of Proposed ADU Dwelling- Rear view of property Driveway- Rear view of property Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869 z ui 0 <.!) �Q C") z - c::, � �I.JJ ('J O> ("t") 0 (.')W N I.!.. zo -w � 0 Zo::: � z :2: ::5 0.. u Area of Proposed ADU Dwelling- Rear view of property Area of Proposed ADU Dwelling- Rear view of property Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869 South Side Elevation -Street view North Side Elevation- Street View Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869 Infill Construction oasseCryitypryldbuildingtsxtst1Tryryruty2.NulIPruFARofrrptSFARyj.3TaRrtDmzstyrtiATTACHMENT NO, 6 DRC NO, 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE EXCERPT FROM THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION DESIGN STANDARDS FOR OLD TOWNE November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting ptspk..eaehmarybildinwtypwevmBp9SHRdB-SSCB-Sttg. FLOOR AREA RATIO IN THE HISTORIC DISTRICTS pei;pi.lceandlanapeaeaonepert,bwhbecharacter,mclsensefplaeOTlfc,l bbssgeeproecfithecharacteresurroundinqeb/ Floor Area Ratio (FAR) by Separate Floor Area n Floor Area Ratio Example: = ft. lr25ytticAaveeetInHgt8TtaFlra81se(WithOpnPorces)1,120rages& ccessrytrucs42Totas1,540Block Floor Area Ratio (FAR) D BO [D I Number of Stories First Acor FAR .15 .19 .27 .20 fincluding garages) Second Floor FAR .03 .03 .04 .03 Total FAR .18 .22 .31 .23 FAR Range .18 to .47 FAR Average FAR .29 FAR o& ttDeyte85/6200=.13TtFisSeono.5+.13= 38 R!� [D B j I I I I I I I j 1-1/2 2 .25 .22 .36 .32 .33 .19 .28 .03 .03 .08 .03 .14 .03 .03 .28 .25 .44 .35 .47 .22 .32 ATTACHMENT NO. 7 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE GOOGLE AERIAL IMAGE ACCESSED 08/28/19 November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting Address Building Size Accesso:cy Lot Size (S� 1,FAA (SF)* Bilildmg I SizeT(SF;) �� - NIA F.AlRRange Avefiil!e * 8//umrnppartluareaoftcherytruturuhagarag** SzimbyffGgEarthalmgry//ATTACHMENT NO. 8 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE FLOOR AREA RATIO TABLE November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting by ::J --�-----� 2LtLil:*3.sipiting.bori.Cnti.3.)Materials:Frame-WodsidiAsinglestoybunglowwithwidelidmltiosdeontwotlteoiyistoemorrioeoe:iirprLttribcodsU O L ie[J i:Ciesurvyreportanhsourcesorntr"on.')eouotlitsostiiliteittti:(Vw,t#)t:O O (Name,affiliation,adss)lMmoAit47VetldhrmOk423*9til20*0rvyType(Describe)Roin*Attacmnts0 OEO LnMp�onh)blJ B,,nOjRO AaolaRC RD LFeRoO MllingRodO okrt RO ArtifoO ograpD Oh(Li):R23A9) *qinfrmATfACHMENT NO. 9 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE DPR FORM FOR 166 N. CAMBRIDGE STREET November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting RES #: by RES O C O O �----------- -------------------------------- ecrArCityfOragePropertyType:Resdece����������- AppiableCitia:_A_c_by rahscope.Alsoiegrity.CotiuPg.4.)StructuralIrCditiidrierrratecestrtrcre(Litttribuscos���������--��--������----���� ais(ConUnuesonPg.3.)(SketchMapwithNortharrowrequired.)ttceireeeadereetrtCtEvaluaion:.s_e..;p;..t_e_mb_e_r_,_2_0_0_s_l(Thsprvfffiicommets.R5238 (1/95) *RqInfrm (Assigned by Recorder) CAMBRIDGE N 166�APN_386-074-16 D. Gest, P. Lavalley, D. Matsumoto Chattel Architecture 13417 Ventura Blvd. Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 � Continuation O Update April, 2005 --������������ 1982, 1991, 2005 1997 LOR R-1-6 0.1561 1092 .1DPR 5L(11/98) 1 1 1 Dph1991 *qIa