Loading...
11-06-19 118 W. Chapman Avenue - Rod's Liquor (DRC 4986-19 & MNSP 1987-19)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM NOVEMBER 6, 2019 Anna W}( I RECOMMENDED ACTION - PRELIMINARY REVIEW BACKGROUND INFORMATION gnwnU(OX5ZCwnU5(OMU5)xgl96SFmmdg,2SFcvrddriv­hru/arkirtySz9Fary,2PUBLIC NOTICE fijprt,29OunSjcqfp Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 2 of 12 ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards) PROJECT DESCRIPTION • Chapman A venue elevation and corner treatment. cadefl-kh(BC)ccwn• Covered patio. Thru/karbfl• Olive Street elevation. AwAtaaneks9grpEsspxxnin.Anewa Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 3 of 12 EXISTING SITE EXISTING AREA CONTEXT an,sstru,urrunxmmgrunflffiunurrungznigwnMU15-24..EVALUATION CRITERIA Mun(M)710070glgjg:jrnygrgnhseflcein thwi:ArhttrlFtureturflgn ty. fyturcrhigh jwi2Lnypzaljc'ellgLty qrut trixty Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page4 of 12 Signage. Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Issue 1: Revised Design rm-fleWhgnayrmanHPrvDSOwnSOI Standards. Issue 2: Historic Leaded Glass Window xagndcadhmvlwllHhany.Sllrtiono.,affanclCA1ppthewwrhartf 2019 12 ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION REQUIRED FINDINGS Design Review 0G.)frgraAxanurrrpturhieyrnly2.IyNlegHD,ppmplSfthe'SGul(M..G.2).DgnwnaryrmSIS.IwSSS,urhrifeturheExtuwleaIurftraInfwignwteca,m,gnl Design Review Committee Sta.ff Report November 6, 2019 Page 6 of 12 ()ioacmbwr,iclftvmwrvohxiM0G. )Minor Site Plan Review 1cscbwupmb2omtypmttyppbpgoppm3.ptfosfvcbt-ff-st./.CitycaabvpjtbynCelanqurtrpturnvyaxiurqrv Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 7 of 12 5. The project has been designed to fully mitigate or substantially minimize adverse environmental effects. CONDITIONS General Drmpsopthc,tholeoegpmmunDqannd/umsubmittedBtkgremnifyarmty,ifcr,agnhggtyari,xtdyty'actytal5Dgn6-P97-twfrgr,urtOM70066BrmaitrckquythOangemmuneartm'Bdg Frmt Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 8 of 12 Fire Prevention HriB,B3cgrfuankrurtw,ankCrime Prevention 4aruOM55(B)d:,g,ur Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 9 of 12 Right-of Way Subdivision Water gr01aiS,,41g,d/xygnriyanthyrvFartmv3rirm,yfi(Cty4umalumtwty­(2'arfrd/xtruCtySLUgrunUd25rid,ruumty f artmvSNW Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 10 of 12 phand/ahsgn3ttqmns''lansturrfmgfir/4ArtlanprittOGCNp5rtfurnindividual pressure regulators on new services where the incoming pressure exceeds -q Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 11 of 12 Water Quality ATTACHMENTS 4.RC1820195(amO30019) Design Review Committee Staff Report November 6, 2019 Page 12 of 12 cc: Eduardo Diaz Architects Orange 144 N. Orange Street Orange, CA 92866 <eduardod@architectsorange.com> Rick Fraser Rod Fraser Enterprises, Inc. 1320 N. Manzanita Orange, CA 92867 <rafraser2@yahoo.com> N:ICDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4986-19 Rods Liquor\StaffReport 2 - DRC 4986-19 - Rods.docx Vicinity Map 118 W. Chapman Avenue DRC No. 4986-19 N s City of Orange Community Development Department ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4986-19 & MNSP 0987-19; ROD'S LIQUOR CONVERSION VICINITY MAP November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting State otGalJfi,mli - ifie Rnourc:es,Agenoy DEPARiFMENiJ' GF !PARKS AND REGREA.TIGN PRIM.AR¥ REGE>RB 30-J.�867 f.lRl1'i 038049 Trnnornlal 01ll 8tiitui, Gode !LI!) Gther l:.lstlnga,: RmewGbde: Reviewer: #: B.M. ,it D d UTM ���������- nP.3)(Ltta)D D D D D (Vw,cessi#D D cby(Name.affiliation,andaddess)sumthttrhctur347enuBlvdShrmna,423*11.rtCta:(Curveyrprthso,'.")ngysssrRrd(0)hateAhu()HtoiRcsSuvyAIS(9)HsoBudIvyUpdHaguy,In.()OnHsSuvy*9.eday,5*10urvyTyp(Describe)Rnc*ttmD D D D D D D D ,jD illSD ockArtco*RqeiTTACHMENNO.2DRCNO4986-19 & MNSP0987-19; ROD'SLQUOR CONVERSIONHISORICRESOURCE URVEY FORMNovm6, 2019 RC Mtig BEPAR;rMENT ei; PARKS AND 8l:Jll . .:01NG, SifrRU�ilil!J�, ANp Q§JJ;CT RECGR_D 30-158677 0380J.3 lD #: ---------------------------------- � Historic O Prehistoric O Both O O -------------- ---------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------� ------------------------ AC ------------ egty:Ortuosat'sg2abps.811.AdditionalResourceAttributes:82eOangDays.Sbps(,,5).813.Remarks:Sthagsivy.*814.EvaaRbrhaEvai: September,20059 ------------------! DPR 5238 (1_/9_5_)���������������- *q�����������- Stitii 0F PrMKSvAND REC::REA'FION CON1ilNl!IAiJ1QN SP.l&ET 1P.i'lffiaey,W .B0.-1.S.ll.6.J.;J.. lifRI I! 0380413 ORA #: (Assigned by Recorder) __ .;... _ D edinNationalReger:-97----------81.mks(Cid.2)l # fts0.OTIX-5# ofBuildings:__i __ OTU-# ofStoresGliZLtAplBigSqft5486.ttHstry(ifr.2).Dipt(Cug.1)DPR 52L(11/98) *qiIm v: I- l.. u.. I- - I l.. 0:: �<t 0- '";" <, 0- 0- 0 N <, =It <X) dl 0 Q -, L' J z u 0 Cl z �C) ... ·� C) ?.:w C',J , . - CJ:;. .. c.o 0 (.'' m "' L•. ·'u -�UJ CD 0 �er ::, � .G.. <( c.( � ov, a. 0 ....= +-' V) 0 w > ..c ::::; 0 c, OJ +-' ·- Vl ....= V) w > ::::; 0 INrpnnkrp,,Im,xNMOTION CARRIED. ()gnN89-'LqqinurtriuingrizHritri.1WC,azHriDtriffari(71)77243@ty.garyHrv,rvpcninJarazaraj.Mr.Daz provirijgnCir tt pariFnk,rve cnmprry arcrivefrm he inATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4986-19 & MNSP 0987·19; ROD'S LIQUOR CONVERSION DRC MINUTES FROM 09/18/19 November 6, 2019 DRC Meeting • A ryInSODgnSTugbgivwn,trxturfimmjgrrythvvrnufacade.TvtuxtrurybdpTfrfacade;nyCrmarynkRECESS: 949:55