10-16-19 154 S. Shaffer Street - St. John's Courtyard (DRC 4981-19)AGENDA DA TE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM OCTOBER 16, 2019 Anna Marissa Moshier, Historic Preservation Planner#- ' SUMMARY RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION n(-1()ExistigGthityc,,wijurtyarar'Lcam,um,ffiPprtyz63qarfurty8,
Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 2 of6 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Secretary of the Interior's Standards/or the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards) fagcalExptPROJECT DESCRIPTION TheCmmttajtwihwig:•ThfrhmndfrmaunalgturnDffiaparioanogrm•Allnfisnrmsxwg•Tdwinaarntanytruanytrmt• Refreshment Counter. undhanptdunwgo• Information Counter. nrmunwaandywioyndsgonnwanhurppyEXISTING SITE rjrtydwtJhn'MuConrvry(rmyuaagRtyriug
Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page3 of6 FamR(R6)VLURIRun(10070taraRwijwi:rnragnflth:1rhitturalFaturThturturflgntysfyaahhtyturaltyLatypzpjeralgnLptrutyqalbtrutrity ak p aranarx3Signggwi(gn, aSeodry Futialary Faturpta, ralainrmannh ralwi()
ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION REQUIRED FINDINGS idngrigthgpbtwaaanlthbthranalcsgprtkla"F"arnulmouwhchusbra(mmof)jt.ThsamhdrufdgprtmodgpprllFspFojsgnrafencdd/nbyhDRCrriwgboyfohpoje(OMC7.0.070.G.I).ptdcpralirpdrisrhtthalostltlspa.2InyNationalRgerHtoD,hpplihtheScrearyofhI'SandadGul(OMCI7. I0.07.G. 2).barlaSOIS.oddfSOIStandads,osuidbtsaanldthhsarothhitricbulgTprprmSOISana.
Design Review Committee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 5 o/6 G. .CtyfOfiRCONDITIONS rmiunAtruinfrmustanainfrmAtt3ffrt(tam8,09)nugmqu,asyDgnRCtt2Afteyaasgggtrutur,ymttCunDICmmuntymrmtuamthCuntymmqrigu3ThfingruumuttngBung4mnfyarm,Cty,ffigtsyfrmtyaimmuggaiCtyariorm,xcyCty'5CtrurmfuturukasquCtyrang,CmmunityDartm'BFurobtaithquuirmurm
Design Review Cammi/lee Staff Report October 16, 2019 Page 6 o/6 ATTACHMENTS sRurSurvFrm3Pans(damb8,9)c:SJhn'LCr154SShaffSOg,A92866STrr13661WhTt,A928<sani@rraig>N:ICDDIPLNG\Applications\Dcsign Rcvicw\DRC 4981-19 St John's Courtyard\DRCIStafT Rcpon 2 - DRC 4981-19 - St Johns Courtyard.docx
Vicinity Map 185 S. Center Street DRC No. 4981-19 N w s City of Orange Community Development Department ATTACHMENT N0, 1 DRC NO. 4981·19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARD VICINITY MAP October 16, 2019 DRC Meeting
l(RHP Stiitus Cado lS CRHR and NHL Plaque fN1740 (Ref. 191001520) RevJew11r: - of C 'Ar«fli • Tno Rosoarcoa Agoilc:;y Dl!PAlfflllliNT Ol!'E'ARKS·�D RECREATION PRIMARY1REGORD Otfior,Wstlngs: Review Cade: HR!# ON: Paga 1 of 4 *Resource Name or#: (Assigned by Recorder) CENTER_S_l85�APN 390-384-08 1/4 of Sec S CENTER Orange :J and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map a1 necessary.) T __ R __ , _ 1/4 of c. Address: ST , t City: Orange Zip: -,..--1o,-,.,..--"""-,-,-11,-,-.,-.....,--""-,-1Z_a_n_e-------::::::::-m-E/--:::::::::mN ----- a. Other Locational Data: Same APN as: 184 S. Shaffer. •a. County: •b. USGS 7.5' -------- P1, Other Identifier: *P2. Location: *P3a. Description: (Oescnbe resource and its major elements. lndude design, materials, condlbon, allerauons, size, setting, and boudnanes. Continues on Pg.3.) Materials: Masonry - Brick. ppA g--CuwidgawwD D 194c CA417VeBvrOkA205{View, date, acceHion #) (Descnbe) R•pa: (Name, afflllaUon, and addreu) D. P. LaVall�y,D. aop20•p7. D D D ::J O .,� (Cite survey repo,1 and other sources, or enter -none:) OgCyAR(20)tccu(2)HistorRvyAEI(199)BugIveUpgOrgyI(1982)Ovy(List attnbules and codes) Attachments:D NNED LMp�ee()�g,trure,njctecordD ArchogRcordD rd::J LFrerdD MlligtatiecrdD kArtcordD ArtifaRD hogracord;::]h(L):53A (195)•Required IrmATIACHMENT NO. 2 DRC NO. 4981·19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARD HISTORIC RESOURCE SURVEY FORM October 16, 2019 DRC Meeting
BUii.DiNG S'TRU&'TURE AND OBJEC'T· RECORD• • -� -• . r .,. - l!rl�-· HR11t 'NRHP.;Status C.§'di 30-158935 038301 15 CENTER_S_185�APN_390-3B4-08 Page 2 of 4 (Assigned b,' B1. Historic Name: St. John's German Evangelistical Luthern Church 82.CommonName: _s_•_me------------------------------------------------------------------------------� SOC/RELG SOC/RE LG •es. Gothic Reviv�l ��......;....;;...;.;;...������� O D O O •ea. Related Features: Stained gla.ss windows, Gothic Altar with central figure of Christ, and two manual pipe •e9.ArchltectorBulfder: Fred H. Eley (Architect) and Duke, Miller and Loescher (Builder) de[-ned scope. ty.ContiuesonPg)fian:•e10. gficc:Them:Area: PropertyTyp:...;.;.;.�������- AppIIcbIeriri:AC------ SIngrity:Opprtuti:theifmiisbuiliicacfAldOiv,wOTkilday,rmoddlus.Aagwut9,1914wepstoauisaggfdyaupwvs811.AdditionalResourceAttributes:(Lisattnbui.tandcodfls)-----------------------------------------------------*812.ferec:ilOiofUW.NBeautifulOHomesN(12c.p3)Oange& MgaySMp(95,90,22,5)813.mark:(ContiuesonPg.3)(SketchMapwithNCll'thanow reqired.ISugc991SueyNe.Syls-, *814.Evlua:R*DatoEvltin:Semb,2005(Thsapacereservedfaofficial comments.)DPR5238(1/95)*RqiredIrmai
'i'lit,o of Cillfomlii .:rfie RNoun:M·Agenq, D�AffTI!!BNT OF P,ARKS•AND RECREATION 60N'FINUA''lilON .SFl&E'li Paga 3 of 4 Recorded by: Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 Years Surveyed: 1982, 1991, 2005 Listed In National Register: 1997 General Plan: PFI # 1 Planning Zone: P·I # of Stories: 1 Lot Acre: 0.91 # 1 Sqft: l!ifmmy1J, 'l'ilnomt.l ORA CENTERS 185�APN_390-384-08 Date Recorded: April, 2005 �������������- O Description of Photo: 1991 •Required Information •Resource Name or#: (Assigned by Recorder) .)lofqiysiAi(i)iiviissiigEsg.
- cif,callfanila -� Rnouri:is'�--"""' DE�IJl!'��jj Rl!!e�TION CONillN!,!.A'llO!\IISl'IEEr Page 4 of 4 Recorded by: Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 P.rlm�t-· 30-158935 HRlf, 038,0'1. -iTrinom&al ORA CENTER_S_l85�APN 390-384-08 Date Recorded: April, 2005 -'----'��������- � ConUnuallon O Updale *Resource Name or#: (Assigned by Rea>fder) 810. Significance (Continued from Pg.2): eSysiweboEl.lscsxcecodiadaoaetag.EaessgficonibutinoecmmutyaimeslTcbii,tendlgocudlsttnoywlsddl.gsssppdGyooippdefWWII.DPR 523L (11/98) •Required Information