04-17-19 (DRC 4952-18) Catlin Culver ResidenceAGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM APRIL 17, 2019 Anna RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION ZfigamExiv:,33ryf2FeartyzAssA:,7FN//2
PUBLIC NOTICE Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 2 of 10 ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, PROJECT DESCRIPTION Fru,hm4inAnyhirtThpkztri
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 3 of 10 EXISTING SITE ppa2%ft krk8urrfrastt4thiThffhigrafrtyAgrfrOpuatt6rtywnrvsdnu8WkbOCCmpli,nppbgnCmmAr,.trTurrwnuurrskpd part f s EXISTING AREA CONTEXT jrtE.uvnSHarwECb6 zariamurrunniwithiasqH
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 4 of 10 EVALUATION CRITERIA Architectural Features. 2. Landscape. Signage. Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation TDsignvmmttwidtrummttthjfualrtunthfrfiR
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 5 of JO ramnovnfSartthkanfrtthinthhictriartDgnhiturvjcrdthiS#6"hif.Whvrityqgnqalgumary.yal.."BnfCea#6SOSwin•/um
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 6 of 10 1h, /DarrrtyECukirmDRcanrrDgnfufisACin
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 7 of 10 6th ary,',RjqfurtarifycThaCmm'mmo:A-3Ahmrtpfiunun-Ahm,andSanihi/thri
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page8 of 10 2007 27th ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS ,rtetwuwingk"utaummf)jtTam;akiuwhyiannakThBurfithaasrmrv
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page 9 of JO ftt'dgu(OM17170.2'Sfbili,WppvyRCpDSOISTa,oarpocadumaarptthegHDtr3hjgnuutyuhufgrgnifi,pgnqu.fig(M7G3knfrmprtPgnfOangMuniCwiwmanumvtrpttnfrp#SaryfI'ST,gnaryohibHDtri4FfiifityfgfignGuhtruu(hgufuuehxhd(C17174IlDgnGuhiOwnHD
Design Review Committee Staff Report April 17, 2019 Page JO of 10 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS ATTACHMENTS VnityM.pArtur(4/3/RffRrtMruary629M.R29rtgrFgr7Egr(7//8PRFE9.N42907PgrZL55E.(//9)ailWtuF:in@
Vicinity Map DRC No. 4952-18 Catlin Culver Residence 585 E. Culver Avenue - --�----------�------ . . . -o l() Lt) L() '· l() Lt) 0 LO 'O VER AVE �----�----------�--------------- �- ----------��---�----�-��-----� N • . W E . ORANGE= CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE YELLOW= NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE s CITY OF ORANGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC4952-18; CATLIN CULVER RESIDENCE VICINITY MAP April 17, 2019 DRC MTG.
AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM FEBRUARY 6, 2019 Anna RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION 33ryg2SFahar,7FNIA 1710gnN49,dmj107ATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC4952-18; CATLIN CULVER RESIDENCE DRC STAFF REPORT & MINUTES (2/6/19) April 17, 2019 DRC MTG.
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 2 o/9 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, PROJECT DESCRIPTION EXISTING SITE twiawianifrnpor,turhyg
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 3 o/9 ft EXISTING AREA CONTEXT EHarwSEvuTbyrt6zrtariamdhiqwnHEVALUATION CRITERIA OanMuni(M)Sn11rijT:rngnfl:1. Architectural Features. .turturfltyri
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 4 of9 2. Landscape. kigakgs.3.Signage. Aggpwi(),riin4Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. Tgtranrmsananiquipalann,wtumwirig()ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES SfffiwwckHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. I1:WwFtrTprxywwthrigwwwframwwAwwSA-1fartuWw2007nartthwkrrA,wwwurdriuttDgnRwnT-MAthrtpnywiwwwwirmwiSecretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation (ftSOIS)artkTeHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne (ftDgnS)tfrthrigwthriApartDgnSandSOIS,wturv,,fiur
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 5 of9 mff8hirimaminniurhifyritn.BkuparamHqwi,yurpSaffjwiDgStanarSffmmfjDgnCmmqrwCmmyfu-MCjrtyjy
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 6 o/9 TortyRru2asmmhr2urtfiTakgrtyrtumhiturGkhiOvrnrtangnqHtur
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 7 o/9 ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS ing"(mmf).amruj;akinmannmakrijBurthrirvgu:1. In the Old Towne Historic District, the proposed work conforms to the prescriptive standards and design criteria referenced and/or recommended by the DRC or other reviewing body for the project (OMC 17.10. 070. G.1).
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 8 of9 in in nterny,grgnppifip,pq.fiOM.G.HstorvDOTw4Ffivpm,pifiCtyOangefillResdenDgnn,()pt,massin,,vmvnhnxCG4.uarhiOTwntri
Design Review Committee Staff Report February 6, 2019 Page 9of9 RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS ATTACHMENTS Au.N-0gr9.ZwLsgg5Eulvusse14219)C:Tnn@x
wllwlasw.pualothnwdhyiricallyrrwknyjssAtr10yanyth,knwqfirrs,wlvlly$100,000ngnulywbupdtalaiba; lzsCmmJnk,wOdwn PrvAiaingrfljHldvij00d iwrn uividattvtwdtrry. FnkdgrdlthwncA try 5% ty urrf pummprtg ghhCmmlibmmqmmTmmianar wdivf ; wwRip'thrialtpriThatai007a'
frics.RsagrmyayrmtuktrigffcmAa4triarinv4trinrigrgkgmktripytaMAgryScryInritymwiSInriCmmki.Cmmaairmagrrnmacannkgriaktutgn tfirmflfrCgryqynjyingjie rwmmkkbthEnfrMRfftbrt Dgn kn'2017g rmirign IthiaNf lActruriknutktturpmmstyMwthac'Ptrtyrrmh
ttnnthqfijfrTunlthtrmTtrurmfrity;rtutakprve,tyfl,inyar;,wyfiryithgryygmmMffffirrmtffrrgnantiknygTutuyigunHntiRi, truturg,Hnry utuThf rr
tfyanvpertrirtvl;ugnvknwThvgrfiguuwgorpieveerietwwnAriertngbtrvriRCppv.MsClinmsrtyrpAgiwneakrtCttsssRifkinShSff xvbnd rtA mmttdrnnild a pmskn, iit innSafnoknnnig Swinxig , drftff ttifrapawawiSdrtry shwuy vryy mmrtSmmruswn antrikSlturfrnninrmy xvff nmmit
-8,lCRsipvoSEOND:AYES:NOES:ABET:Imx,Imboden,nn,rmttaSnMOTION CARRIED.
PLANNING DIVISION RECEIVED APR O 3 2019 CITY OF ORANGE gng7f:R--6z58L5L;: ):. 4 _:i or. <r: E. ·v1·- " ' .• · •· 1' - ,.,)j -:;1 ,{ J , ,·: '. . ' (J:Nf:1': · OwnrtjctpfttT.TwimtrwxctzgiwisMxactgiwfltpfalbepwiiqstrwipwiowsOy"tu,rtfy,wiplTwiywiMsA.TppswiwipyMAct.TxexctgnxcTttxfannedvisfsiognvigTgRviwftfr.ATTACHMENT N0.4 DRC4952-18; CATLIN CULVER RESIDENCE RESP. TO DRC COMMENTS (4/3/19) April 17, 2019 DRC MTG. .. ) !r";
tsgtmttvi.Pg8ti:Lne1etybesl.Pbrvfivfittctuv357L9L111CttyvyttAbttumtgyufrwiwwgruuthd(N)Pbjmgggffbtsgignq(N)
1 2 3 4 6 7. 8. 9. upgPvixcgzwitiwictupta.Nwtrwiusfiy"tuccpufrwigthuggsfigtafffrwiwicgffcs(alyc)ypyCxgvytuccfixtuadpctigialxtu,pjwnptuxtigtuWhffbthxtigtuccxtupavctixtustixggwihtiAgwih-tuchfutuapualpugjctduxgpyflcepcuhtacsguggpjctpRCuavi.Pgtathyggn'cDRCpp.
APPLICANT PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPHS • .,.. ::- .. • ATTACHMENT NO. 5 DRC4952-18; CATLIN CULVER RESIDENCE APPLICANT PROPERTY PHOTOS April 17, 2019 DRC MTG.
FRONT DOOR PHOTOGRAPH l
CODE ENFORCEMENT PHOTOGRAPHS(DATED 07 /30/2018) Pfl.C 'iCIScl-lR
PRIMARY RECORD ORA lD #: . � # -----� O ---=----- tn.tatios,z,seing,boris.CntineoP.3.}a a {Lltttrlcode}-== *P4.Ro�O O O O O *P11,prtiion:(Ctrveyrtatheu'no.")c.}Srv.*AttamntO O O O O n RAr.nrrl n 3(1/95)DPR FORM FOR 585 E CULVER AVENUE 5bptnoPhot:2 O O 5 (Viw,,accon#} *6Cgo�HO O *7wnA*S:cdby:(Nrn.fflaUon,nddde}D.,P.Lv,DMArchitecLure13417VBvdmOk,CA4*9M,*0urvyypDescribe)�B,,jectRerO illig0kAR*ReqInfor
r-- ------- -- BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD 30-158990 038356, 111596 lD RES O O No� Unknown ce:(.170-0)AppablCieriCregrity.CiuPg.4.)StructualIntegity:GoCdi-ppeggiuu.ItyOpprt11AAttb(Listtribuod)*12.RfgDe.813.Remks:(ContinuesonPg.3.)(SketchMapwith Nortarrowequed.)Stauscngesie1991uveye.*814. EvluobChal*Dof vluaionSpmb,2005(Thissperrvedrfficicmets)OR528 (1/95) ----- qInorm
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION CONTINUATION SHEET ORA O (Assigned by Recorder) 22-14Marc,200��--��� ..... ---�-- 2,19,207;..nR# fBlsZ:R-2-6# SLA0.UsPrplBqft:786.Cniry(Cfrg.2)81.ak(Cfro.2)P.Dsrp(P.1)DPR 523L (11/98) 1 1 1 Dsiptfhtoi 99i *qImin
(}.(· I DRC NO. 4249-07 APPLICATION PHOTOGRAPHS
. !)) ). /f t
ZILLOW LISTING PHOTOGRAPH OF 585 E. CULVER AVENUE (ACCESSED 01/14/2019) }