09-05-19 166 N. Cambridge Street - Caesar Residence (DRC 4980-19)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM SEPTEMBER 5, 2019 U)hinxsgsingleamy.TpprtyribgurwihiOTwnHsriRECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION Swm(R)akfirmiothppj,bjthqfiggnppBACKGROUND INFORMATION Own:VArhi:SrrortyL:66.ambrigStrGPgna:Lty2-6u/Zgafiin:SgFamlylR--6Exgmn:22SFgl-famyPrtySz:6675SFApl:nPRv:NI PEm:
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 2 o/8 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, PROJECT DESCRIPTION kihihgaynfrtyEXISTING SITE rtyNOwnHristrhsryftBun92shinfasThpprtkiaryOartygrrity94imy4Sfaa992ttcintp7hyunknwn
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 3 of8 EXISTING AREA CONTEXT EVALUATION CRITERIA 1. Architectural Features. 2. Landscape. 'ovalgnLtruvtynhalbtruxLvkigoakux3Signage. gn(coSecondary Functional and Accessory Features. coirmaniqannhictuywi()
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 4 o/8 ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation in ity,alhitriADaryfuntyqrtwnaffqCwcotyoakjquirfi2FArRgngutr"PrtmmFArrturrunasw"nfiC2)00kNrtCamumamurwnHtrirykhm
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 5 o/8 lamLUminityfrtraninaryarytruturLtyfrtrxarunx88xihUaryhifunntyqrtwnqtyADUakpfidADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION ThirySTAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS urtfi""rialcmakzakfiaki"akFd"drawcnu, hruh ifyid (nm) unprt Ftwhng riaki"in"u( mmf) sams tru; akiuwannakth
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 6 o/8 utyg,grdpifipla,pbhq.fi1)4Ffid,cifityfnfillnDu,wtr(),ugnxstignghO1G. 4)RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS be alcodthDCppr1.ThippAkrmandaignfwipxhiAtthm2(amAgu22,2019)mythnanmmygnCtt.AnyfrompqvalbyDgnevCmmitt.2.Afty,aranytrutur,anymttCmmunitymDpprvICuntyDvmrmiosanmpwintfprovalanamfanpprvanuniyvmDmyvangpanwiqurigmg
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 7 o/8 ATTACHMENTS J4rtgrExrpHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne GA8897FArRRN:Rrrrrl@gmtru@gmv@a
Design Review Committee Staff Report September 5, 2019 Page 8 o/8 N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4980-19 Caesar Residence
Vicinity Map DRC No. 4980-19 Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge Street -----,---- - .... , (--------------- ] J I I 192 l I � l I ,--.....:V;.__""---� i-------.1 I ! 1 *"" 182 l I � t-----�11-JF---��----4-- .... 174 /oo I 175 r-::-=----...----.-!!!!!!!!!IIIUJli--*'-------+-� lc.9 l 1 o7 166 ,01 l ' t--------+- .... ,.... __ 1_6_0----11 ,� ! 1 57 : � r -----+- ... 150 '<Ci 149 r---���1(.)r---�---- 142 ! I 141 I I i------+- ......... i-------=-.,...,,/ ! 133 Ii-----� ! 125 l -r----_...j \ N • ' W E . s ORANGE = CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE YELLOW� NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE CITY OF ORANGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ATIACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDI VICINITY MAP September 4, 2019 DRC Meeti
T-1
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
Rolando Serrano
APPROVED
Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC
R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
T-31
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
APPROVED 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC
R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
2
LIVING AREA
ENTRYREF.BATH
KITCHEN
BEDROOM#1
BEDROOM#2
HALL
CL.
CL.
A-11
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
APPROVED 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC
R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
REF.REF.A-21
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
Rolando Serrano
APPROVED
Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC
R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
2
ROUGHOPN'G.ROUGH OPN'G.A-31
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
Rolando Serrano
APPROVED
Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC
R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
1
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
Rolando Serrano
APPROVED
Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC
R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
A-43579
2468
A-5
1
D
C
B
A
1 2 3 54
1 2 3 54
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision ByProject For:SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
Rolando Serrano
APPROVED
Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
4
2
3
BEDROOM #1 BEDROOM #2
LIVING ROOM HALL BEDROOM #2
KITCHENLIVING
ROOM
A-6
1
3
OWNER
REVIEW
PRELIMINARY
REVIEW
CONSTRUCTIONPERMIT
1
2
3
THIS DOCUMENT HAS
BEEN RELEASED FOR THE
FOLLOWING PURPOSE(S)
ON ________________
X
05-15-19
Revision By
SHEET
Copyright-2019
expressly reserves its common
law copyright and other
property rights in these plans.
these plans are not to be
reproduced, changed or copied
in any form or manner
whatsoever, nor are they to be
assigned to any third party,
without first obtaining the
written permission and consent
of Shucri Yaghi Consulting
Engineers.
112 E. Chapman Ave.
Suite#D
Orange Ca 92866
Tel. (714) 997-9120
Fax. (714) 774-3676
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SHUCRI (CHUCK) YAGHI
Rolando Serrano
APPROVED
Project Designer 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange CA. 92869Caesar ResidenceNew ADU DwellingDRC R.SCorrections
07-12-19
.
DRC
Corrections
08-21-19
R.S
2
4567
o\\f\S\ON p\..AN�tclNr.D \.\� � 1 '3 7.0\9 Letter of Explanation/Justification C\n' of oRANGE. 15, 2019 PROJECT LOCATION: EXISTING LAND USE: ryy(,214.)Butru123.up,frp,x"l,/uhulx4truwpprtygtrutu(e,ptrhruxpkppvpkgOepprtgry,gxExuprtupprtp-ryHDPROJECT DESCRIPTION: ppptru(33f)ryAryUltdheopprty,-lykxfrpjDgnturythxsgryinu,u•Gpfi•"px•/uylxu•FrytryppryDHDFAquSy,VOwnATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE LETTER OF JUSTIFICATION September 4, 2019 DRC Meeting
z w 0 (;) ci5 er. 2 - -o c::) � �UJ ('.I Cl> c,uJ ('I") 0 z o ('.I LL. -UJ i 0 Za:: z � :5 a. (.) Driveway -Street View Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869 ATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE PROPERTY PHOTOGRAPHS September 4, 2019 DRC Meeting
South Side Elevation -Street view North Side Elevation- Street View Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869
2: UJ 0 o ci5 S!:? z .$0 c:::, ;} -UJ � 0> CJ jjj ("') 0 2:U � u, -u.i >- 2a:: � 0 ;z � :5 a. e Area of Proposed ADU Dwelling- Rear view of property Driveway- Rear view of property Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869
z UJ 0 e �o CT) z - c::> c2 2!w c:"'-1 O> ('I") 0 c [j c:"'-1 u.. zu -w � 0 Zo::: z � � :s 0.. u Area of Proposed ADU Dwelling- Rear view of property Area of Proposed ADU Dwelling- Rear view of property Caesar Residence 166 N. Cambridge St. Orange, CA. 92869
Infill Construction bPctmFARofppnipFRyj.3RgiertDtyATTACHMENNO5DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCI EXCERPT FROM THE HISTORIC PRESERVATIC DESIGN STANDARDS FOR OLD TOWNE September 4, 2019 DRC Meeting
c, lmye,eatactuesolHDct8T,caIryryIry,iiletsukb.TrytcywBfrp9ISHcResidetialB-SSHCB-Sttg
FLOOR AREA RATIO IN THE HISTORIC DISTRICTS Ihe Floo- Anc,i (FAR) 's of strucuncs on area the: i ,i calculation of rntio development compared to of A lov. I 1\1( indicates that .u.rrounded plenty oi and dreds. 1\ li!gli F1\R me.ms that there s sp.« 1,mds<.df.l'" wlucl: to the ,md sense of pl,H;•; e's esidential histor srde11tc1!propertros nOd·kwm,, rc111<:1cfc,0.15 t0.):j 1/\1�. nfconsn L,ct011that k1:; a :;bsc11,l!yh19heI-Al< tt1cH' surounnproperties unlikelv be compatible tho 1inlil] project shoulr] r:AR that 110 the FAI� rH1 block. i 10rn,my inctors th.it ;iftectcrnnp.itibilitv :Yn!lconstruction.but FAR provide"nefr,1;.se:;sir19whether yourp:t".1j,··,t isintothe ch.rracter ofthe '.,1111ou11cl111Jne.qhborhooci. Floor Area Ratio (FAR) by Separate Floor Area Floor Area Ratio Example: I = & ft. oipe)Mumy= SceDkey= HbtaAeoeHeih& ttreDvyL0I ,= 3lArsanoAR.+ 3= .3RBlock Floor Area Ratio (FAR) D BO BO �rn B .22 .44 eR• 48
ATTACHMENT NO. 6 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE GOOGLE AERIAL IMAGE ACCESSED 08/28/1! September 4, 2019 DRC Meeting
brig76667Nrig677N.amg206603NCg8774Cbdg2,7Nambg06NCg0NIA 70FlARRang0o0Average9* Infrmnfromfincm,c8/8/0umrdppartoinudareaofchdcrytrucuruhgarg** SizimyffdGgEarthlmgry,d8//2ATIACHMENT NO. 7 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCE FLOOR AREA RATIO TABLE September 4, 2019 DRC Meeting
Stiita1 l?RIMM:V RECORD lilR11# ORA: #: D D�� T , - sr __ ._# ---------- bouries.CotiuesonPg.3.)Lttri4�D D D D D *rtCita:Crvyprthrsouresoreer'oe.')Spofhoto:View,,ce#6ucAgSoO D 7ArBy(Nme,ffiltioandress}v,.MmC47Vk,CA39Ap,0rvyTyp(Describe}iAttD D O D D O O O O O kAqIniATTACHMENT NO. 8 DRC NO. 4980-19; CAESAR RESIDENCI DPR FORM FOR 166 N. CAMBRIDGE STREE September 4, 2019 DRC Meeting
of DEPAR1TMEN11' OF eARKS AND 'RECREATION BUILl;>ING, SliRUC::'JiURE_. AND 9B�EGi1' RE€GRB lD #: RES RES --��-�--�--�-�----� � Historic D Prehistoric D Both No D Yes D Unknown ������- -���������������� ����������- ------- Pg4.).921-194)(Lttribedcodes------------------------------- Os.(ContinuesonPg.3.)(SketchMapwithNortharrowequired.)Scnese1991Sun.rRa*DafvluinSpmb,25--�-�------------------ l(Thlsrvforffialments.)�R 5238 (1/95) *qInrm
OF ANI:> GONiTilNUA't10N SHEET It. 0RA � Continuation O Update (Assigned by Recorder) pril,25--������������- 982,99,25:GeP:OR#BllgPigZ--sLAe.5#UtsPpBqft986.ConsHry(Ce.2)813.ks(CmPg.2)P3.Dsp(CfP.1)DPR 523L(11/98) 1 1 Dsph1991*qIm