The URL can be used to link to this page

11.01 Old Towne Historic District Boundary Adjustment G�°�°�� AGENDA ITEM � � �..� *: :* o� .� . �: �••. October 9, 2018 pA••.A��;�.�;.(' �b�.l.y C 4 Reviewed/Verified B • TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council City Manager Finance Directo THRU• Rick Otto To Be Presented By: Marissa Moshier, • Historic Preservation Planner City Manager Cons Calendar City Mgr Rpts FROM• Willlam CrouCh Council Reports Legal Affairs • Community Development Director Boards/Cmtes X Public Hrgs Admin Reports Plan/Environ 1. SUBJECT PUBLIC HEARING: Zone Change No. 1289-18 to expand an existing historic district overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia Street to the local Old Towne Historic District. With the overlay zone, the City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory will,be updated accordingly to reflect the status of these properties. T. 2. SUMMARY The City of Orange is proposing to expand the boundary of the local Old Towne Historic District (Historic District) to include 12 properties in the 100 and 200 block on the west side of South Batavia Street. The Historic District boundary is currently the centerline of Batavia Street. Under Orange Municipal Code Chapter 17.17,historic district designation is processed as an overlay zone with protections for histbric resources added to the base zoning. 3. RECOMMENDED ACTION Approve for first reading Ordinance No. 12-18: AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ORANGE APPROVING A ZONE CHANGE TO EXPAND AN EXISTING HISTORIC DISTRICT OVERLAY ZONE TO ADD 12 PROPERTIES ON SOUTH BATAVIA STREET TO THE LOCAL OLD TOWNE HISTORIC DISTRICT AND UPDATE THE CITY OF ORANGE HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY ITEM . ' 1 10/09/18 4. FISCAL IMPACT No impact. 5. STRATEGIC PLAN GOAL(S) 5. Recognize,promote, and preserve Orange's rich heritage. d) Expand and strengthen processes and practices related to protection and cultural resources. 6. GENERAL PLAN IMPLEMENTATION Cultural Resources Element Goal 1.0: Identify and preserve potential and listed historic resources, including buildings, structures, objects, sites, districts, and archaeological resources citywide. Policy 1.3: Provide long-term assurance that potential and listed historic resources will be used, maintained, and rehabilitated in conformance with SecretaYy of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties with Guidelines for Preserving, Rehabilitating, Restoring and Preserving Historic Buildings (SecretaYy's Standards). Goal 3.0: Provide incentives and expand education efforts for historic preservation. Policy 3.2: Provide incentives to encourage and support historic preservation. Implementation Pro�ram I-19 Program I-19 of the General Plan Implementation Plan calls for maintaining and periodically updating an inventory of historic resources in the city. 7. DISCUSSION and BACKGROUND Local Old Towne Historic District The local Old Towne Historic District was established to recognize and protect the cultural and architectural history of Orange's late 19th and early 24th century commercial downtown and surrounding residential neighborhood. The Historic District consists of historic (contributing) buildings dating from the 1880s through 1940. The boundaries of the local Historic District were established in Ordinance No. 38-88, adopted by City Council in 1988,as"Batavia Street on the west,Cambridge Street on the east,Walnut Avenue on the north, and La Veta Avenue on the south, including the Nutwood Tract on the south side of La Veta Avenue. The boundaries of the Old Towne Area shall run along the centerline of the designated streets and the borders of the Nutwood Tract." In the City's 1991 Historic Resources Inventory, several houses on the west side of South Batavia Street were identified as historic resources. However, these houses were not included within the Historic District boundary and are not protected by design standards for the Historic District. ITEM 2 10109/18 Historic District Expansion Following Council direction in March 2018, Historic Preservation staff surveyed the properties in the 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street. The survey found that these blocks of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of 12 properties dating from 1903 to 1940 and representing historical themes consistent with the existing Historic District. The houses first identified as historic resources in the 1991 Inventory retain their historic character and additional , houses not previously identified are also historic resources eligible for inclusion in the local Historic District. The two blocks have a high degree of historic integrity representing the same period of construction and architectural styles as properties within the Historic District. The properties to be added to the Historic District are: 134 S. Batavia Street 204 S. Batavia Street 140 S. Batavia Street 210 S. Batavia Street 152 S. Batavia Street 220 S. Batavia Street 158 S. Batavia Street 224 S. Batavia Street 164 S. Batavia Street 236 S. Batavia Street 176 S. Batavia Street 248 S. Batavia Street Of these 12 properties, 11 are contributing historic properties. The one non-contributing property (236 S. Batavia Street)�was constructed in 1963, outside of the period of significance for the Historic District (1888-1940). The non-contributing property was included within the proposed boundary expansion, because it occurs mid-block and is flanked by two historic properties that could be affected by major changes to the property. Maps in Attachment 1 —Exhibit B show the proposed new Historic District boundary. With expansion of the historic district overlay zone, the Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne will apply to these properties, consistent with all properties in the Historic District. Changes to the exterior of the properties will be reviewed by staff or the Design Review Committee for conformance with the Design Standards. Expanding the boundaries of the Historic District protects these historic resources and the Historic District as a whole from incompatible changes that alter the character of the historic neighborhood. Contributing historic properties within the Historic District may use the California Historical Building Code to address building code requirements in a way that does not affect the character of the historic property. Contributing properties also are eligible to apply for Mills Act Contracts. Environmental Impact Zone Change No. 1289-18 to expand the historic district overlay zone is related to the public welfare and is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines 15308 (Class 8 — Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment) and 15331 (Class 31 — Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation). The overlay zone is established for the protection of historic resources and makes no changes to the land uses permitted by the base zoning. The regulatory process for projects within the historic district overlay zone involves review to ensure conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, required for projects within the Historic District, are consistent with and incorporate the SOI Standards. Expansion of the overlay zone ensures that additional ITEM 3 10/09/18 historic resources and the Old Towne Historic District as a whole will be preserved and protected from changes that may affect the integrity of its historic character, design, materials, and features. No environmental public notice is required for a Categorical Exemption. Public Outreach and Noticin� Letters were mailed directly to potentially affected property owners inviting them to participate in an informational meeting about the proposed Historic District boundary change on June 27 with Planning staff at the Orange Civic Center. A second letter was mailed on July 3 inviting property' owners to an additional meeting on July 12. Six property owners representing five affected properties attended the meeting on July 12. Staff also had phone conversations with two additional property owners. The meeting allowed City staff to present information on how a historic district overlay zone could affect properties and get property owner feedback on the proposal. Property owners asked questions about the requirements of the Historic Preservation Design Standards, design review for projects in the Historic District, the effects of the overlay zone on existing base zoning, and the Mills Act Program. The majority of property owners expressed support for the boundary expansion. Some property owners were neutral but did not express opposition to the proposal.No additional responses were received at the time of publication of this staff report. Public notice of the City Council hearing on the proposed zone change was published in the Orange City News newspaper on August 9, 2018. A total of 278 notices were mailed to the owners and occupants of affected properties and owners and occupants within 300 feet of the affected properties.Notices were also posted at the subject blocks of South Batavia Street,the Civic Center, and Library posting locations. Planning Commission Hearin� The Planning Commission reviewed the subject proposal and considered the entire public record at the August 20, 2018 public hearing. There were no public speakers at the hearing. The Commission recommended approval of the Zone Change to the City Council by a vote of 5-0. A copy of the approved resolution is provided as Attachment 2. The Planning Commission minutes are provided as Attachment 4. Council Action Zone Change No. 1289-18 expands a historic district overlay zone to add 12 properties to the local Historic District. The action includes updating the City's Historic Resources Inventory to include survey forms identifying the 12 properties. The survey forms are provided in Attachment 1 — Exhibit C. 9. ATTACHMENTS Attachments to Report: 1. Draft Ordinance No. 12-18 Exhibit A: Existing Local Old Towne Historic District Boundary Map Exhibit B: Proposed Local Old Towne Historic District Boundary Maps ITEM 4 10/09/18 Exhibit C: Historic Resources Survey Forms for Properties on South Batavia Street 2. Planning Commission Resolution No. PC 26-18 3. Planning Commission Staff Report dated August 20, 2018 4. Planning Commission Minutes dated August 20, 2018 N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications�Zone Changes�ZC 1289-18 Old Towne Boundary Adjustment�ZC 1289-18 CC Staff RepoR 2018-10-09.docx ITEM 5 10/09/18 ORDINANCE N0. 12-18 � AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ORANGE APPROVING A ZONE CHANGE TO EXPAND AN EXISTING ffiSTORIC DISTRICT OVERLAY ZONE TO ADD 12 PROPERTIES ON SOUTA BATAVIA STREET TO THE LOCAL OLD TOWNE HISTORIC DISTRICT AND UPDATE THE CITY OF ORANGE HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY ZONE CHANGE NO. 1289-18 APPLICANT: CITY OF ORANGE WHEREAS,the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District were established by the City Council in Ordinance No. 38-88 as "Batavia Street on the west, Cambridge Street on the � east,Walnut Avenue on the north, and La Veta Avenue on the south,including the Nutwood Tract on the south side of La Veta Avenue. The boundaries of the Old Towne Area shall run along the centerline of the designated streets and the borders of the Nutwood Tract"; and WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 15-98 amended the local Old Towne Historic District boundaries at Walnut Avenue and Waverly Street to match the National Register of Historic Places Old Towne Historic District,designated in 1998.As established in Orange Municipal Code(OMC) 17.17.030,the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District are delineated on a map on file in the Planning Division of the City of Orange entitled"Old Towne Boundaries"as adopted under Ordinance No. 15-98; and WHEREAS, OMC Chapter 17.17 establishes that"application for a historic district shall comply with the zoning amendment procedure for a change in the zoning district classification upon designation approval by City Council as prescribed under OMC Section 17.10.020"; and WIiEREAS, a historic district overlay zone includes additional regulations over the base zoning of a particular area to encourage historic preservation and complementary new development. The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, incorporating the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties, apply to all properties within the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District; and WHEREAS, the City Council directed the Community Development Department Planning Division to proceed with expansion of the local Old Towne Historic District to include properties on the west side of South Batavia Street in March 2018; and WHEREA5, eight properties on the west side of South Batavia Street were identified as historic resources in the City's Historic Resources Survey completed in 1991; and ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRAFT ORDINANCE 12-18 ZONE CHANGE NO. 1289-18 OCTOBER 9,2018 CC MTG WIiEREAS, the City Council adopted the City of Orange 2010 Historic Resources Inventory Update,including the survey results from 1991,through Resolution No. 10426 in March 2010; and WHEREAS, in April 2018, Historic Preservation staff, meeting the Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualifications Standards for architectural history, surveyed the area and deternuned that the 100 and 200 blocks of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of intact historic properties constructed prior to 1940 that are eligible for inclusion in the local Old Towne Historic District; and WHEREAS, Historic Preservation staff conducted community information sessions for potentially affected property owners on June 27, 2018 and July 12,2018; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission, having considered Zone Change No. 1289-18 at a public hearing held on August 20, 2018, including review of the staff report and having invited public testimony on the item, has determined the proposed amendment is justified and recommends approval thereof; and WHEREAS, the City Council held a duly advertised public hearing on October 9, 2018 for the purpose of considering Zone Change No. 1289-18 as it pertains to the expansion of the local Old Towne Historic District as shown in the attached Exhibits"A", "B", and"C". NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ORANGE DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION I: The existing local Old Towne Historic District is depicted on the map attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by reference. The boundaries of the Old Towne Historic District are amended to include the 12 properties on South Batavia Street depicted on the map attached hereto as Exhibit"B" and incorporated herein by reference. The "Old Towne Boundaries"map adopted in OMC 17.17.030 is hereby amended to depict the change in the local Old Towne Historic District established by Zone Change No. 1289-18. The contributing and non-contributing properties within the expansion area are depicted on the map in Exhibit"B"and described in the historic resources survey forms attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and incorporated herein by reference. The City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory is hereby updated to include the historic resources survey forms attached hereto as Exhibit"C." SECTION II: The historic district overlay zone described in Section I is related to the public welfare and is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines 15308 (Class 8 —Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment) and 15331 (Class 31 —Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation). 2 The overlay zone is established for the protection of historic resources and makes no changes to the land uses permitted by the base zoning. The regulatory process for projects within the historic district overlay zone involves review to ensure conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne,required for projects within the Historic District, are consistent with and incorporate the SOI Standards. Expansion of the overlay zone ensures that additional historic resources and the Old Towne Historic District as a whole will be preserved and protected from changes that may affect the integrity of its historic character, design,materials, and features. SECTION III: General Plan Consistencv The project achieves goals of the General Plan Cultural Resources and Historic Preservation Element and the Implementation Program. The expansion of the Historic District's boundaries provides long-term assurance that additional historic properties will be used, maintained, and rehabilitated in conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards fo� the Treatment of � Historic Properties (SOI Standards). Projects in the local Historic District are reviewed for conformance with the Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne,which are consistent with and reference the SOI Standards. Inclusion in the local Historic District also provides access to incentives for preservation including the Mills Act Program and California Historical Building Code. Consistent with the General Plan Implementation Program for Historic, Cultural, and Archaeological Resources Surveys,the expansion of the Historic District's boundaries recognizes a small concentration of historic resources that reflects a unique sense of time and place and establishes a design review process for its protection. Historic District Criteria(OMC 17.17.050) An historic district may be established to preserve landmarks and areas exemplary of architectural, archaeological, cultural, economic, social, or historical value if the landmark or area meets the following criteria: A. The resource exemplifies or reflects special elements of the City's cultural, social, economic,political, aesthetic, engineering, architectural or natural history and possesses an integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship,feeling and association; and 1. It embodies distinctive characteristics of a style, type, period or method of const�uction, or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship; or 2. It contributes to the significance of an historic aYea, being a geographically definable area possessi�zg a concentration of historic or scenic properties o�� thematically related grouping ofproperties which contribute to each other and are unified aesthetically, by plan or physical development; or 3 3. It reflects significant geographical patterns, including those associated with different eras of settlement and growth, particular transportation modes, or distinctive examples of park or community planning; or 4. It embodies eletnents of architectural design, detail, materials, or craftsmanship that represent a significant structural or architectural achievement or innovation; or 5. It has a unique location or singular physical characteristic or is a view or vista representing an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood, community or the City of Orange. The local Old Towne Historic District embodies the cultural and architectural history of late 19�'and early 20th century Orange County.The Historic District represents the original residential community, central business district, and industrial area of Orange with historic buildings dating from the 1880s through 1940. The houses throughout the Historic District represent the popular residential architectural styles of the period,including Folk Victorian, Craftsman, Tudor Revival, and Spanish Colonial Revival. The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of residences representing the themes of early development and growth of the City of Orange, consistent with the existing Historic District. The houses are distinctive examples of the architectural styles prevalent in the Old Towne Historic District. These blocks, combined with the east side of South Batavia Street within the Old Towne Historic District, have a high degree of integrity of design,setting,materials,workmanship,feeling and association. Of the 12 properties proposed for inclusion in the Historic District, 11 are contributing historic properties. The one non-contributing properiy was constructed after 1940, outside of the period of significance for the Historic District. Including these properties within the boundaries of the Old Towne Historic District will protect these historic resources and the Historic District as a whole from incompatible changes that alter the chazacter of the historic neighborhood. B. It is one of the few remaining examples in the City, region, state, or nation possessing distinguishing characteristics of an aYchitectural or historical type, or specimen; oY The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street are characteristic of the historical development and architectural styles of the City of Orange from the late 19th and early 20th centuries. This area is contiguous with and represents the same distinguishing characteristics and themes as the Old Towne Historic District, which is one of the few remaining intact historic downtowns from this period in Orange County. C. It is identified with persons or events significant in local, state or national history; or The Old Towne Historic Disixict was originally designated as a representation of the broad patterns of development in the history of Orange, rather than for its association with a specific event or person. This criterion does not apply. D. It is representative of the work of a notable builder, designer or architect. The buildings throughout the Historic District are vernacular examples of late 19th and early 20th century architectural styles and are rarely identifiable as the work of a specific builder, designer, or architect. This criterion does not apply. 4 SECTION IV: A summary of this ordinance shall be published and a certified copy of the full text of this ordinance shall be posted in the Office of the City Clerk at least 5 days prior to the City Council meeting at which this ordinance is adopted. A summary of this ordinance shall also be published once within 15 days after the ordinance's passage in a newspaper of general circulation,published, and circulated in the City of Orange. The City Clerk shall post in the Office of the City Clerk a certified copy of the full text of such adopted ordinance along with the names of those City Councilmembers voting for and against the ordinance in accordance of Government Code Section 36933. This ordinance shall take effect 30 days from and after the date of its final passage. ADOPTED this day of , 2018. Teresa E. Smith, Mayor, City of Orange ATTEST: Mary E. Murphy, City Clerk, City of Orange STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF ORANGE ) I, MARY E. MLTRPHY, City Clerk of the City of Orange, California, do hereby certify that the foregoing Ordinance was introduced at the regular meeting of the City Council held on the day of , 2018, and thereafter at the regular meeting of said City Council duly held on the_day of , 2018,was duly passed and adopted by the following vote,to wit: AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS: NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS: Mary E.Murphy, City Clerk, City of Orange 5 EXHIBIT "A" [Beneath this sheet.] � �� i�i �— � �,;.... � � ��mn ��I ■ i�--- �� i 11111111` �IIIIIIIII 11111111111 =� � �� '� ., � � 11111�1111 /11111111 i �� ■ l,il � ' �IIIIIIIIA 1111111111: � 111111\III 111111111 �'a '��,�;; — ��i�u� iiii��_ : ��„n�� i �`��i� � _' � == : :��ii ��i�i ��'� � �� - r ■� i .. � 1111111�\\=1111�� ' � � � �� ■ �� ,� .,.,� ��; _ - : __ :_ �� _i� __ _ .... � ' — =_ == == - -- -� � � -- � � -- -- -- �. —� � ■ �� S_�� •,'' �. \ ' � .�j �� .�� ♦1 �� ' �� -- - — ` �� -- -- -- — 1� � -- —�� ■■■ . �� :o .= u Qc :�'�o ��w� ;:! � � � �� '_ == _= �� , �'lll� 81 == =r1:..� :.�w� - . - ...- I�� i� ��' . i� �� '�� =� � �� ■ � �l1n� �11 ,i: 01f�, /11 ` -� i� �� 19�� _ �``= =_' �� — � = �� "'uTii -� =�� :i= _: 1= , , � � _ � � � _ :�� ,o'to� iiin �n: ��i.■ �� . �. ':.: �� i , -- � ,. ... e� -- -- � � d11� �.. �� -- -- �� :: �� S::C ; I �� : � �. �� — G.�� C �� C �� e.� ;�� I , �' � � � �� i �` � �� 'w.� a S� � � � � �� G �� '� 0: C: � I�111 �' �.. � � �� s �� 1 1� � a�� 1� � �� ° 11{I I MIIIIIII � �� 7/ \� 1 1 uo e I 3 • � � � !� � m� _ ��+ ',�� =ii I ��1 �� uie�_ •�; �e 11111�1�. � �=-'i w�u= I � � � � .�., �- �C �� /�I�I�IIII �� i;� � � ��'< � ��, �� C �O �� 11�1��11 � :� I ' � — � � �� '�_'� C� 111111 ��' � ■ �� u�: ��1 �� 1 � ��1 1� � � C�� C 111111 � �� II� � � � �� 1 � �a� �� : �111: � — ■ � � ■ • � ��. . 1111�1 =�€ � � w II k � � �„,""'= �.� , �° � s �� .: : � �C �� r�lll'� p �� .�. ii � �� n �� i dl �� 111� ��I� �1i�? ■1 � .� �� ■m s � t��, �� _� o�� II � � �� , ■ �� _ .._ . � �@ .. � r ,. ■ — = ■ � �.. �. —� : I C 1i � '. �� :: d. � � � � � _, � � ■ � � ' � _= i�s ;;��11 � � II s li�� ■ tl 1 = � �m = �� 1►: �C%: �I�.� —�.� �� '� • —� .� _� �I : s .. �,-{ , i �� 11� �9� � ��i �� IIIIII�! �1�� I: �� 11 �:.�: ►� :� s: 'iI � C � �� : 1�1�1�� 111111�If� ■q�l:�'� �� :: �: �II � �� . � �= �—� �� 1�� I��III a � �� 1 � � ��1 11� !1� 119��1`_—IIIII�� ►�il _8 : � � �� r�� _� � � �� l1Q 119��n:IIIIIIIIIII�II � 1 _— �1•':�i i �IU� I�� Illiiiii� � � �. : uo��r,: �� : n n y mi�i mii`i.,= =L� 111111111111 ;.� �� .: 4 =�1U/�!� �,.�� i � II � � 11 e� ,�� •�_ �� !m� �o � �� e°' � � O 1p� C. �11:„1111111111 /r •�► �� esRae e�ra� �To III �� :� � �� 1��It�� :0 �i� 11 IIIIII�: ii � , � � �= ��e�lll � �� .. �, �, � ■■■■■■ �� _� . � �-II � �.. � �= � � ■ . ��I�� —=111 � r� � � ��u��n��r� . ;�III � = � �— �at 1 � '� �i,�� li �iii�i��i� � w � � q� . . � � ■ ��_ w 1 il �11111 11 1� 1� � � � �� ■ : ,,� �� ■ � �� . . -- � a �I�� ; 1 � J li� ��._� �� '��i"+r �� ,.�0��I. 1 � ��?i iL �� ■ i%�•��•� � I�,� � � � e� � . �,� �� `��i�n ■ � � �� '�9 �'� �� \s�� _. � ,.��" �j��,a� � _� • ��'i .. � � r�o� ' llll� , ��111 / �j,�� , � �— �i ,��. � I ��►� .r� � :�, ��;� `�; . � . . . — �� , � � N i -- .. � — i�_ �= ��.�� 1��1��1� ■ :�� r 111111111� �111111111 11111111111 � � �� `I��`\ i �� II � ��illlllll 1111111111: � 111111�111 11111111 � '�+��,/��il � t 11111111� 111111111� i 11111\llll 111111111 ' ��.�%' �� = �: p� � :1111�111 1111111/1 —��'� � �� r � � i � 1111111\\\ 1111�� ` � � _ -•— -- -�— � �� ,• ■�■� �II�� _ �� \�� T�` �' � �� C C �� ■ L �C C� CL� ��■� ��7— �1� —� �.. �� 11 �� 1� �� !� � \ � �w �� 1 ' �� S_�� C 1181�9 ��dll � �'� � � ■ • � �� ■�■ ��: �� 1� �r_ .._ _ 1- _ 1�1�`i ��e � �rlll�\�� = =� ` ;a� —•• � 1 — ': = C= ..� �� _16�� : =� == � t i � �_s -- _� .,... �� !�1 010 �O �II� � �� . =I ��= � li �= � � =� , '�� Illllllill �� ,`:� � ��"� :� � � i � =� �- 67- � .�� 111111111 11111 11�� 11111� u�� ... � s=... � .� �� rii f � ' � '�4:�7 � 1� n� a� � �� u a � �e� � � �s�o s�0 �� '�—� C� �■� ■ �� =nn t�, � �� .. �� '� �iQ�i �� _ ` � � .� � ` "� ' .�''I �'� � �� -�� S� �� n� i I ' � � � � �. �� =� �� G: C: � C�:11� i'��iii ` ,�� 1� '��' �6 � =��1��1 ■ I � F71W � �9 mb.. � �� ■� ■� w�.��i 11 1111 unllll I � � �� ''��"�� 1 �am� � � '-�a[�c� �� i��/ � =� 11111 � `�'=� � � � �� 'i' Ti� �� t ��111111� �.��. �e�i mnw=' I �� ` � � ��,' �� CC �� IIII��I �� .'�'j� � =a�a� �. � � ��-�— �. �:� � �� , ��'�• �C .�._ �� 11��1 �� i ;.^� � � � �-�—, ��. � �� w�� i �� I■ �� o ��i = �i� �� - e= � == = iiiiii == - �� =� � �I�� !�' "'= � �� , �� 1 �� _� :G ��I� = �� == � ��° � ile' � s �� ,1 � �� " ��: �� ' '�� = ■ — -- � � = � t� F�111� ii �p■ �s� o �� . . �� i � �� i'� ��'o ��e �II �o� �i �ilt � i� . i�� . �� ,� ■m �� e�� ■ :� �t �� !� g��i� s�■ ! �� t�� e � e :=_ _ � � � � ■ �� —� ■ � �_ = �1� ' .�� __ � = == ��i'�� i � �� .� � o� _ �� ; �� - =. �= i�■ ��1� �� I a � II �� '.' �— �� ` � �� i � � ��I� ��-- �� . �_,:(�1�+�11 �— � �� _ o. �� . � �� :��. � �. � —� �II�, �a� �i�Q��ll�� Illlil, ��Ia�B� ` �� 11 ..o � � � �� I ! ■ �.:� r �e IIIIIII II �_ �. � i �� ( � 8= i1� � �.�� " - �i _� �._ .. .e �� — � �� a� �_ �� aQOQ��i� tnmu�n� � m�:=1` ��__ �= == =: �' � �� :� �� ,� _ . �— --!``_',�m � := =� � � ..� _� �� ue� �.� �� n�►�� o I��a�� =€��un�� ►9 == =� -- �►- -- -...�� :� ��_ _�, ��o �,� ��o�� Q�n�� d�� o�� i�iii��iii�r�i'= � == =�� C�� Nn� �1�e� � Ii:i��: ! � =� � t�ou� I�la[I[1 �0��6 �� 1■ :'��. IIIIII IIIII`I��' '` � � _. ' � �� e� � . 1111111111111 :� c� � .: � � �► .- . . :� �� = �� = I j�i�� Q 1��e�l� �� = im lii�it' . � � � � sp � � � ■ �, ' ��a �e��e ��a� �n III �. � �� = �� t�Ifi �: 'i,i 11��1�111r= r�i � ■ �� i'i� �a�t � 1�� 1� ■■■■■■■ ��_� _ �s= ��r�ll � � _ _ �o ..a �► � � � . ■ ��■�■ I�� =� �iii = �` � �� =: �� r � ��1��. ' � ,,.� _� � t c� � � .. �� — P � � Yd !� �= �- ■ . �� nnu��i��i�� ii� ' � I�� .�� ■ � ��i �■ .� � , � � � : _ �� «. _ � � ��QE� �11 III 11 II� � � �� ' ' •� r,��, � � ii► i 1� � ,�lil �� dl�� .. .. �� .��- � � i 1� �c� ��'�'� \i�� +r��I3 � ' I� �� 1� i �i�� ' � � � � �� ,� s�� i� �� \�� II� �C �� s:� � x � � r ♦ Il��j�� ♦ � <�� ° ��' 1111 � ��''1 � �� . ,�.�`,h.; � 1� �� .. �w - ,��:,�, 1 111� �� I/ 1��►.A ``1\ � �� _ , I \�\ �� __ � ` � • • . • � �. . ,�. � � s N '�',; � — � — i i 131 130 � i - i , .; w;� i � ; � i i ° ;129x� ' ' 122 126 ; ; 133 122 i ; 125 . 128 122 i � 125�27 A 132 ._ , I I � . ..� j r --. � . I I _ . .. i I .. � ..' . , .. �' , s�� . i i-� -- � — --— �— j j �.. . � ' � � � . . .., . .' ... I � • pJ�� I 0---../� �� N�`��,.�` �.�.I �\ :. 0��0. � � ': � �� . . I� ;�.� � \,:. " � �0�9 � O� ,J � � �� n 4 .. ..-'—'------ .....-------- '-----�- ._ ------.._ _._._...------ ' ' .�.` ` , `' / . �' ._�\ i --------'— -------_ --- ------ —� � � / --- -- ♦ —'— � i-------- —'--------� �-- ---------- I I � � � I Rb,* � `a' .,.. 1 �""____ � N o 1 f �� 1 � �. ��. i i � p N j � � O. , i i °0 cV mo° i i O � p " � � N I I � N � � '�,i,Oz` : O� I � � � m �� I I � Q O j I �' .�,N �O I I `� O � � �-a'��: . i � � � ^ N I� � � `O �O i i � � I 2 i � 12�2 i � �- -n-,�,. . � � i 121123 124�2`2� ' �. __ �N�... _._. � ' -_ --- 30 i i 131 i i 'r�31�25�127. 126 ; i : 13r 1w32 � i 123 r 13p 126� i i �129 1'3 , , 1 131 i i tx� i i � „r 130 h I I ; � .135 137 ` � ' ` � ' 133 136 i I 1:37 139142 �3s-r g � µ 139 � � � 1fi34 � � 14�9P3 � 134 i �' 140 i�i �143` , ��' �0 i i 141 �1�40� i v�ji .',�� 4' �1�4�142��'. i i 1411'43`�1480� 6 i � 147 i i - _� i i 1451,47 , `'�1�4$�" i Yi 141�1�3 � � i i �� . 6 I � 157 ��; 151 ' ' �`"' 1S2 i i �'5 156 i g; 1491511.��'.w 150�^ i i 151 155 152 ,. � 148 , � , � , 156 , � -� � 153 155 , - � 4 i i 165 162 160 ;U i 159 15$ i i ` 165 1,62 i V, � _1�6�� . 160 . i i �." 164� 1 0 � , 157 � 2 ' ; 173 168 ; � 167 164 � � 3 168 16 � ' �6�5 �,68:x i i -�.6�� ,. 176 1 � --=-- --- -- � w � � � 181 176 i i 175 ��76, i i .. 181 � o, � i i 17+ � N�ri 1_� , i i 18 �.N o.-^- � i �$2 � I o�o� N � .,�:� j i �.p� C�l�� „ � � i ta I�Iw ~ I I '° �O �o `�. _ ; l 1033 1015101 ; �\o``�.�. Q. o.', oo, ; i w� cc� °°,� 000,J i r`�\' ;� � �� I I 195'�: N N o -----' ---- . . ,-------' � ..:, ; l .� � �o � .- -- -- __----------------- -------------------' `---------------- -------- LMOND ----- - -------- --- - ---- -------- -- � ----- , --- ,- - o � � N �o 0 0 o i i �_ 0 206`\i i �n q 208`\i i co;�oeo 0 0 0 0 0 0 0, 204 i i �_o"'o , � , .�. , � � i ,209 . N O . � � .. � .. � I I� � „ .._� � I . ;. �O�D `O�O. � .- '-. r cv � : i ; 215" ;'21 i i � i 219 ' Q o � � , � � , 4731 218 � � . � � � o o. , i i . � . � i � 223. o .a. o N o ;a.o�. �� i i 226 i WASHIN T-6N V�28 I i 229 ?w r � O � � G12� I � .: .. i � � _ / . 7�7 .. ,j I . � � � � i 233. 236 � i � � 238 ; � . 237 : 238 �,- x 2�24 � i 239 . i � � �. i i 2. � i � 24 246 ; ,A � o- 248. ; i 245 � , ; , � -� �F-; 246.. " ; � � � � �� 236 � i 249 25 i � � '1"' 256 ��i . 255 254 iv~i iQ , i � , 261, 264 � v 266 ;Yi 263 ; '262 I� t 248 � I � � -..� 733 �� . , 264 . ;� i ��' ,�, i i 271 .. 274 i MARIEi T�A E 276 i a� �2 7 1 . 2'7 2' i i 265 2 6 6 i i 2 6 5 i � , 281�28 2 8 i � \�'_� >� ' � $; , i� ' ' ' .--._._..._ � . � , 286 I ,281 � i i i i � �' � i , E,�� i � �282 i ; 273 274 i i 275 286 i i c�-o.• i i v > i i i i i i i � .� oNo. 29. J i .� ' �� . 296; i 291 2�0 � �, 284 � N 283 � 292 • � 283 � � ------------- --' �� ----------- ' ` --- = � � , --__ __�__ � _PALMYRA A i � i i 293 294 i � 293 i �—- -- --- --- '� i � � � 297 i � 96 1 � a`ro o�'o o�'o o�o N. 302 i i � c� �. ;. N `�' �� i i �;;. ..�'o � :� .� i 296 i I-r 297 i i °0 308 i i °� .� � n �'i i .`° �o `o `O � i 299 � � N � o o ; i 315 � 12' i i . � N '�;i i . � � 298 ; ; 299 0. o. o. o. i i _. °0 � � , r� a,�e i i � �._...--------------' � ' i 322 320 � � '335. � � PALMYRA AV�----- ----- ------` , 325 , � � � 322 � � 323 .. 23 Yz32 .....__ , , 3 0 0 0 0 0 � o I � ��7 24 ----- ---------------------------------, `r N °° o c� i � ' 33313342.330 ; i 339 328,4�F,; 33'q , 33 �' °� °` �` ' i . 3,44340. '� i H - 34��°�343' 33$`'i�i ,��°-9 �'4��.42 34� i i ,341� 343 354� ;� 345 34 340. i�' ,�47 34. •M'Signifranl'remurms(Buldng,Sile,or ObJecl) braled wiWn Ihe OIE T ne Orange PlanNngArea ere pF Op 0 Old Towne Orenge Lowl Hisloric District Boundary Fxpansion(2018) mnilCoreC b LeContrIDuting Ine NiabrieDb4lcL { R.�, Likewiw.ell'Nor�Si9�ifranPmsowcasvriMNOie `��+� c� OOIdTownaOrangeLoelHistaricDistrict(1991) eo�oaaryereNo�.co�ma�wymaH��to�nd. . Old Towne Orange � Railmad e yo Y ��.��'£ Bounda Ex ansion w�e� �4/MY�µ ry p � Significanl Historic Building(s)on Parcei(ConN'hutnrs) o a.OWs0.o75 0.03 a.095 etai � Non-Signifinnl Building(s)on Pamel(Non-Conlri6ulors) Mi�es State�,of.California TheResourcesAgency��` , -�#� � ' � P�lmary#; � 30-158701 � ��' ' . ;;DERAIt7'MENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION� '�� HRI# `� 038067 ��"� ��y � ' � PRIMARY RECORD' " "�� , �� Trinomiai� o� ��Rr�. �� ;�g�� NRHP Status Cotle�� 5n1�`�� '� �#��' , . � +m`a,g. x '� �' �, , . � s �' a�=�� Other Llstings � � ' � ' ��„� =e � � , .. �� , �.��. ,Review Co,'de� � -� _ �:Reviewer: ��' ��,� Date�� `�g�' � �� 3.- � �, . _.�. , � � . . .,. . �- ,_ . , • , ��.�w � Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATavrA s_134_APrr_091-042-18 (Assignad by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication 0 Unrestricted *a.County: orange and (p2b and P2c or P2d.Attach a lora9on map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T�; R� a 1/4 of � 1/4 of Sec � �B.M. c.Add�ess: 134 - S BATAVIA ST ,# City: OranQe Zip: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one far large and/or Ilnear resources)ZOfIB � � RIE/ � R1N e.Other Locational Data: *P3a.DeSC�lptlon: �Oescribe resource and Its ma)or elements.Include design,materials,candition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Materials: Frame - Wood sidin Rectangular plan with side gable roof, front-facing gable dormer, and lattice at gable end vents. Wide eave overhang with exposed rafter tails and decorative corbels. Raised concrete front porch spans full width of house supported by four piers. Pair of front picture windows with leaded glass transoms flanked by double-hung wood windows on either side of front door. Side elevation windows are one-over-one wood windows. Large "P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--sinqle familv propertv (Llst aftrfbutes and codes) "P4.Resources Present: ❑� Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) %''�� -, P5b.Description of Photo: 2018 / �ew,dale,accesslon#) i � " `�. "P6.Date Constructed/l�qe and Source: � ` "�-�s.�-' ,: � � _w ./ _'r.- -_ 1917 ' ,>• ,F;;,�«=„� �`�;�,~ ! ❑./ Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both �� *��''� *P7.Owner and Address: � (�' � � *, . a - ' � "'�' 0' � •P8:ROCOfdOd by: (Name,affiliation,and address) r �,�' I � , ;Y � ---== ` `pC .q, � ? Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuf£o � ''e+�'►3ii1 i��p A i�� i � 1 r � � �� , � � � i f �� ' ��i � o i � "'i f f { � � �� City of Orange CD Dept. ,��i �, r . ��, j �� (, ��k�� 300 E. Chapman Avenue � �i � .ti � � � :'�� Orange, CA 92666 I� I '; , i --. •��..��`'�:•`��x� �._i � i �� *P9.Date Recorded: �P11.Rep01'tCltat10I1: (Citesurveyreportandothersources,arenler"none.") � April 2018 � Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1982) Orange *p10.SurveyType: (Descrihe) Historic Survey. Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information - �x >P-_ � a�= i a� ,�r' °. �� , � � .� St�ate�,�California�TheResources.Agency �M,�� P,rlma.ry# 3o=1i587o1 _ , �s , � DEPARTMENT OF P,i4RKS i9ND�RECREATION �- �$��'�� HRI# 038067��; . � �, , � +�tu� ��3 ,BUILDING STRUCTURE,AND OBJECT RECORD *NRHPsstatus cocle, sD� k� �_; ��, ��. �, ��,:_� �.�, �, te,;��x,.. ,., � ,. r..:.. �,�.t, .:,�; � , Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_134 APN_041-042-18 (Asslgned by Recorder) B1.Hlstoric Name: Unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Architectural Style: Craftsman *B6.COnSt�UCtI0I1 HIStOry:(Constructlon date,atlerations,and date of altaralfons) Date of Construction: 1917 ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both *B7.Moved? ❑J No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *68.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: unknown "B10.Signiflcance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of orange PropettyType: Residence Period of Significance: Early settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss Importance In terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) Structural integrity: Good Condition - No apAarent chanqe to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities House does not appear on historic aerial photographs until 1997; however, the date of construction appears to be considerably older. The house may have been moved to this location from a different property in the late 1930s or early-mid 1990s. B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��ist atv�b�te5 and oodes� "B12.References: 873.Remarks: �consnues on P9.s.� (Sketch Map with North arrow�equi�ed.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change from 5S1 to 5D1. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of•local Old Towne Historic District. � � � • *B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 . (This space reserved for official wmments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information State of.,CaliforNa The Resources qgengy Primary# ��30`�158.701�:��.��:. •'$ , �� r�� DEPAR'iMENT QF PARKS AND RECREATION, � ' HRI#�` � 03806��„�*� � <�� :�� : .. , . ; . >' � ; �CONTINUATION�SHEET' . ` �� ?� mo` ��"''� .,., .. - . ino al� �oxi�`��'�� a� . . . ._..-.. r r<��-a ,. ��- �� ` �.. �. � Page 3 Of 3 `Resource Name o�#: BATAVIA_S_134 APN_041-042-18 (Assigned by Racordar) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City oP Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 1982, 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Llsted In National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 1 Planning Zone: R-2-6 #of Stories: 1 x µ a�� ` ; , r' ' � x x"'>"s Lot Acre: � #of Units: 1 � ' ;�;� ,�� ' � � �� Principal Building Sqft: � `� .' r�; , z �+,� •� B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): j��`a ^1`�z • c � r,. _ __ =�..v„�`��_�_�� . r �� . ,- � ;r B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): _ '�r"'.r " _._ .�, ._ — - _... _ . _ .. ; ' � _ � � � � } 1 T ��b . .s�� at � ,r � v �. �.�Y� �i�Yf`{ �l � ��I� P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): rear accessory building with shed roof dormer and board and batten siding at rear. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information t State of,Cal�for��a The+Resources Agency � ' � sPrimary# � UEPARTMENT OF PARKS�AND RECREATION ` r HRI# ; ; k � � _ PRIMARY RECORD " t Tri�omial o�i � � �� N�tHP St�tus Code* .5D1� �� w�. OtFier Listings � "'� � -ReviewCode Reviewe� . � �;' �Date Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvza s_140 APN_o41-042-28 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication ❑� Unrestricted *a.COUnty: Orange and (pzb and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T�; R ; ,� 1/4 of mm 1/4 of Sec � B.M. C.Addl'ess: 140 - S BATAVIA ST ,# Clty: Orancxe Zlp: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one tor large andlor linear resources)Zolle ' mEl mN e.Other Locational Data: *P3a.DeSC�iption: �Describe resource and its major elements.Include design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) MBteI'1815: Frame — Stucco or Plaster One and a half story residence with L—shaped gable roof with rolled eaves and louvered gable vents. Sand finish plaster cladding. Wood double hung windows on front elevation. Vinyl windows on side elevations. Side entry with curved front porch wall. Two story rear accessory building. *P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP3)--Multiple familv propertv (List attributes and codes) ' *P4.Resources Present: � Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) P5b.Description of Photo: 2018 (Viaw,date,accession#) `�, *P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: �, a 1927 a � ❑./ Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both � � *P7.Owner and Address: II� � , �I �,.,,; � � 4� ��,��s��. .�V� ,f A � � ` a w��6 .q `�/.a, . . . `.�,u� +x i..�• *P8:ROco�d2d by: (Name,affiliation.and address) °r �� Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo F—� � ¢�� _�� k '.�.. s x`."+r�r�'•�� ,' ,�., � � � .�� ; �<d:. �� 1 , City of Orange CD DepC. < �< c �'� � �� ' �� "�'y 300 E. Chapman Avenue "z.""`"-".w.^^`�" """"� ,�y.,'N.� �^�s x v�; �. „� ,,,,,:,�„� �,�=E�� Orange, CA 92866 �- � Ia{a��'tt"� a*.�:1a r, A�"�F �� ^"�*n+.:.rm,r ��+w x"`"' - *P9.Date Recorded: *P11.Repoft Cltatlol7: (Cite survey report and other sources,or enter"none."') ' Apiil 2 018 � � Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. *P10.SurveyType: (pescribe) Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) '�Required Information �--' � -` ` ��`"� �c 3a�' . =i`y `� �°�' � y� ,rc�< ,� � � ;_� �.. '�, a�a r,. a _��. ,> �, ,< �t State of Galifornia The�R�ources Agency � �� z Pnmary# ' �� k� �' �� :�,�� ` � � �� . � � �yDEPARTMENT�OF P�KS�AND�,RE�EATION " ' �� 'HRI# � � ��' �� ., < BUILD.ING;5TRUCT:IJRE;�i4ND�OB:IEC�T REf�ORD��NRHP Sta4us Codey sDi�"`�y� ��,�� ' ;� ; �, � �� ...�.�� . Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_14o APN_041-042-28 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: 1tEs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.ArChlteCtu�al Style: Provincial Revival *B6.ConStfuCtlon History:�Construction date,atierations,and date of a�terations) Date of Construction: 1927 ❑�/ HISto�IC ❑ PfehlStofiC ❑ Both *B7.Moved7 0 No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: "B9.Architect or Builder: Unknown "`B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Signi£cance: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme,perfod,and geographic scope.Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) StruCtul'al Integ�lty: Good Condition — Some original windows replaced with vinVl. Slte Integrlty: Large two story detached building in rear used as second residential unit. Opportunities B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��isc anrinute5 ana codes� *B12.References: B13.ReRla�ks' �Cantinues on Pg.3.) (Skelch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change £rom SS1 to SD1. - Outside 2005 Survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne .Historic District. . . , "B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribu£fo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for oNcial camments.) DPR 5238(1/95) �Required Information .�State.of�California TheRes.ourcesAgency � ' � . +Prima'ry# ` x�� - ,,� DEPARTIIIIENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION � = � � :IiRI# ' ` '�� ;��..,..� : GONTINUATION�SHEET . �� Tr,tnomial= �oizta�: � :��`� =� , , . , _- �� . � �, � . � „ , , ...,_..:_ . ,..,., ,�.x a ,., . - .-��,: � . Page 3 of 3 `Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s_14o APN_091-042-28 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Reco�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 2 _ _ �� :.. � � ,�� Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: 1�5 4 ti �''� � ,.�" G "'r'' € �}A, Lot Acre: #of Units: 2 _ , � °-< � 1 � t t ;'� Principal Building Sqft: :��„��`�� ' � ��' � ,� �: , z 5�''�,'�� '�1 4, o r; n*PkAz"�'r„+`� B6.Construction History(Contlnued from Pg.2): ;, ` k� �-� :� � y;��; �. ± a.,.-' k_�`°�-. _.� r, ' B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): � , j 3 . :_. �_, _�,��.:_ — ,_�.,.. P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information Pnma # ` ' "State of California �'he Resources Agency ry- ,�.�,„�„ iDEPARTMEPIT OF PARKS qND RECREATION � ,H1tl# �' � '' 4��v � � Tr�nomial caR�i � � aPRIMARI�RE.CORD ; H - NRHP Status.Code 5Dl � y � r Other Listings `� �_ � Review Code " µReviewer `` ,Date ' ��:�. Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_152 APN_o41-092-16 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication � Unrestricted *a.County: Oranqe and (ppb and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T ; R ; � 1/4 of � 1/4 of Sec � B.M. c.Address: 152 - s BATAVIA ST ,# Clty: Oranae Zlp: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or tinear resources)ZOIIe ' mE/ m N e.Other Locational Data: `P3a.DOSCI'IPtlOfl: (Describe resource and its major elements.Inciude design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Mate�ials: Frame - Stucco or plaster One story single family residence with L-shaped gable roof with composition shingles. Sand finish plaster with wood shiplap siding in gable ends. Small eave overhang with exposed rafter tails. Front porch with concrete slab and square post. Wood front door and front £ixed picture window with multi-light sidelights. Metal awnings over windows. Front windows are wood one-over one windows. Side windows are metal one-over- one wi *P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--sin le family property (List attributes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: ❑� Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) �'� p��,��v�a��,�'`�"� �*�r�!��;� �� .w �� '�� 3��'"��` ��'��s� �� 4�� P5b.Description of Photo: 2018 °�x,�'��'��r "�� '"�� ` ""�� (View,date,accession#) � � � � 4s �� 9� '� ��y3m�� o '��z `�� r� ��.,,�,,,�,' u � a�� I� � ��,�� s� ,� � � ��r � � *P6.Date Constructedl Age and Source: S ��f�` � � � +� , � �� d ';�� ,,�' �..�"-..-�.,,4 �, �'* �a. 1938 s r �-�-��'"'ts,��,�� .,a ;�, " � ' �� -��'�~"'"- ❑�I Historic � � y � .--. ..�,�_ ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both f • �� *P7.Owner and Address: � T _ Xd �) 1 Y • �+. k. �� "P8:ROCO�ded by: (Name,affiliation,and address) =',�' Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo ` , . � City of Orange CD Dept. ,� - "�� 300 E. Chapman Avenue �V�. :��TMv Orange, CA 92866 - y� � �F �,. �;u�i�- � -' �� "'�""" ' ---- *P9.Date Recorded: *P11.RepoltCltatio�l: (Citesurvey'repartandothersources,orenter"none.") ' Apiil 2018 ' Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018) . 'P10.Survey Type: (oescribe) Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Infarmation State of California-The Resources Agency �"�� ' Prima.ry# � �F ��a �D PE�ARTMENT O�K�S�RECREATION �' � G HRI°# '�� "�,H M��I'��' ' 3.�: �� w *NRHP S fr�;�� , ^,,:BUILDING;�STRUCTURE,AND10,_,BJECT�ECORD �� tatus�Code 5D� { ' � ., .� - •��i. �� .� x. � ,�. � Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvrA s_152 APN o41-092-16 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Hlstoric Name: B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: 1t�s "B5.AI'chltectu�al Style: Minimal Traditional "B6.CO(IstfUCtlOn HlstOry:(Construction date,atierations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 1938 ❑�I HlStofiC ❑ P�ehlStoflC ❑ BOfh Side elevation windows replaced with metal double hung windows. "67.Moved7 ❑d No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *BS.Related Features: *89.Architect or Builder: unknown *B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Significance: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criteria: AC (Disc�ss Importance in terms of histarical or architectural conteM as defined by theme,period,and gaographic scopa.Also address integrity. Continues an Pg.4.) Stl'UCtUfallnteg�lty: Excellent Condition — Minor changes to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities 811.Additional Resource Attributes: ��;St an�b�tes ana codes) "B12.References: B13.RCrt18�k5' (Continues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map wilh North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. • *B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo "Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This spaca reserved for official camments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information ; i= " . � ' a°' r•�X:,:v?� u ' �... � � .. .,.� �„ .:ly �4 � k� �� 'S:. 'State of Cai�fornia The Resources Agency � `� �^ ��:Primary# a x;� '�,fr�a� ��_ � 6jS"�`'i5 '�. �. �4M.8�� _ �rt�- �� , h :€ ,y-, F"4 +��DEPAR7'MENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION � ; � � HRI# '-�` '� F�, � � � �� .„�,�p"� ; .. ;��y�:� x aa �x€a j * T��""�' �3` e "CONTINUATION SHEET � � � �=� �-� ��y,�' �'�� r nomia�� o� � �;�� `�`� � ��_,� :�.�"�' �,`.� �`:., '>'kt`"kr a��a-.�;" ,�a � �* Page 3 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_152 APN_o41-092-16 (Assfgned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCofded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 a. chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 2018 Description of Photo: Listed in National Register: General Pian: LM�R #of Buildings: 3 Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: � Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 Princlpal Building Sqft: � B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): ndows. Plaster chimney on south elevation. Two detached accessory structures at rear: a two-car garage and a shed. DPR 523L(11/98) "Required Information Pr�mary'# 30�'168703,�. State ofaCahfornia The,Resources Agency � pEPARTMENT'OF PARKS�AND RECREATION .,,.' ' HRI# 038069 PRIMARY RECORD � �' ; Trmomial o� , NRHP Status Code 5Dli Ather L�stings � _` Review Code �sReviewe� � "'Date „ � �- �� : � . . � • _ , n .s , - _..�, � .�: _��,,. . -�< � �' ' Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#• sATAVIA s_158 APrr_041-042-15 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: "P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication 0 Unrestricted *a.County: Orange and (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T�; R � 1/4 of � 1/4 of Sec B.M. c.Add�e55: 158 - S BATAVIA ST ,# Clty: OranQe Zlp: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than ane for large and/or linear resources)Z0�8 ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "P3a.DOSC�IPtI0I1: (Describe resource and its major eiements.Inciude design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Mate�lals: Frame - Wood sidinq Rectangular plan with side gable roof with composition shingles. Front porch with square posts, front gable roof, and wood slats in gable end, centered on front elevation. Narrow wood lap siding with corner boards. Wood windows with wood screens. Detached two car garage at rear o£ property. *P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--sin le family property (List attributes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: ❑d Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) ,, -�--��, ,..��,�,�,� �, � �, 7' , ry ��i �� ' o c � �r �d �i� � �w� �, �' � � � � � �� , y�„� �� P5b.Description of Photo: 2018 ,, � � a '�� ' �� `" ky� �,a�" � �`� ,;, � ' (View,date,accassion#) , ' a ��,��«. �"� �; �r ��r � ��`� ' �� '� `` ��% *P6.Date Constructedl Age and Source: ��e�, � � + N^ A ,��5°,. 1924 �,�,� �,rr... �,,� . . y�'� � �,, � � � ��:; �,� � �� ❑.I Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both 4��'�. C� ��"' � � �� I - ,. y : f `�`�'� � '� : �+'� ` *P7.Owner and Address: - } � � ;'�� . , d_.K._.-... ., �.l a i��``i�;�� + *P8:RBGO�dBd by: (Name,affiliation,and address) ;' , .<_., . • . � __ �-a,.." . _ ' Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo � . _., , � _�. . _ , _ . s-;� m-�� City of Orange CD Dept. ✓ =�""°' `' 300 E. Chapman Avenue r �,� Orange, CA 92866 � ��w M * s �'�.a. � '��.•^^,-""-...... �,. I � _.^7iwauct.'�=' c:`�'��5� . . �-----�-�-_ -- --�----- -- - � *P9.Date Recorded: "P11.RepOft Clt3tlOn: (Cite survey report and other sources,ar enter"rtone.") " April 201 S Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1982) Orange *p10.SUNeyType: (Describe) Historic Survey. Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information . . �i �" �-'�:�, .��'�' � ' °� � � `� � StateofCal�fornia The.Resourcesqgency � � #�� , Rrimary# 3o i58703�*��3, ��.�� a� - ��.. ��x�� ,- �� : � �DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND F2ECI2EATlON ' �'��`� �HRI# '� 038:069 "'' :.� � �� ` � �� s . �� ,�,�� ` � ��*��,��"� m' � x .a- « ��'s' ��".� � � �;BUILDING,STRUCTURE,AND�OBJECT,RECORD NRHP Status C�ode ,�sDlHI'��. .�� _ � { , Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_lse APN_041-042-15 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs 84.Present Use: xEs *65.Architectural Style: craftsman "B6.ConSt�UCtlon Hlstory:(Construction date,atlerations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 1924 ❑�I HlstOfic ❑ PfehlStoflC ❑ Both "'B7.Moved7 ❑./ No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features:� "B9.Architect or Builder: unknown "B10.S'Igni£ICanCe: Theme: Architecture Ai'ea: City of Orange P1'opettyType: Residence Period of Significance: znterwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss Importance In terms of historical or architectural conte#as defined by theme,perlod,and geographlc scope.Also address Integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) Structurallntegrlty: Good Condition - No apparent chanqe to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities 611.Additional Resource Attributes: ��ist atNeutes and codes� "612.References: B13.Rema�ks' �Continues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with North anow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change from SS1 to SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. . *B14.EvalUato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information �.; State of'California �The Resou�ces Agency Brimary# �30 T587o3- " DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION � ,:IiRI# ��038069 �� 4s'` ��=� �� Y F �ti.t x - ,�� CONTINUATION SHEET `. � Trinomiai :oi��4 Page 3 of 3 "Resource Name or#: sATAvza s_158 APN_o41-042-15 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCofded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue 0 Conti�Uatlon ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 1982, 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDR #of Buildings: 1 � _„�_ ��,�,�,,,�,�„�� , � ,� Planning Zone: 1t-2-6 #of Stories: 1 � ` � � � ��' ';� F � x e= � , ��x Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 �� . � r �� •� �, '- r Principal Building Sqft: 1000 � ! � - 6a,�s,� ! � s��.�. :t =�s� , 'i , .��- B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): ,�, � ,,� , � -; c � �:' r � B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): ry �, m` `! ,.., �t;i �-� ;;�..a,�,'�"l � s- a �.''a '�5 y �'�"—"�'y� �.iy ��,_._.._' _.__ _-�. . _ �:.,_�.s.r_��'�._....�_ . P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information '- State;of,California :TheResourcesqgency, + r`.Pnmary# 30*-1-58.�7.09 � � � � �� :, a ° DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION �` � a�� HRI# ' 038070 u, �z� s av�''� a�� PRIMARY RECORD . � _� , ; � � � Trinomial't ot�: � �-� �� . ` � � '� ,NRHP Status Code �i A' ��,,� �- �Other Listings. �:��.��+.�.��'��' ,�:� � � ��, s� �� '� � � � 'ReWew Code y ' �u��Reviewe� ° � ��''Date�` ' . . , . , , . . _ . � �. :�. , _ q� �_ , . �. . . ,., >.� � _•��:s. :* .. � �� . �� „ u� ,�_ ��.: __ � . . _.. �� ,;. Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA S_164_APN_091-042-19 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication ❑� Unrestricted `a.COUtlty: Oranqe and (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a loratfon map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T�m; R�; � 1/4 of � 1l4 of Sec �; B.M. c.Address: 164 - s BATAVIA ST ,# City: Oranae Zip: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one far large end/or Ilnear resources)Zone ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "P3a.DeSCI'IPtlO�: (Describe resource and its major elements.Include design,materiais,condition,atterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) M8te1'lals: Frame - Wood sidin Two story single family residence with steeply pitched cross gable roof. Entry is through main porch which spans the full width of the house. Masonry porch columns with beaded mortar joints. Wide eave overhang with decorative corbels. Narrow wood lap siding. Fixed picture window with decorative transom on front. Paired double-hung wood windows in frontmost gable and on side elevations. Additional decorative wood work in fron *P3b.Resource Attributes: (HP2)--sinqle family propertv (List attributes and codes) � *P4.Resources Present: ❑� Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) ,-' PSb.Description of Photo: 2018 j- (View,date,accassion#) / / � �-_ \ � _ *P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: ,` , \ , i 1903 � f S �i _ - � `� ��. � s'�. � ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both Y ;* � ;��11� � =r��` i *P7.Owner and Address: '�1 :� `_ ��'s�� t � j� . �, 1 z�. { P � � "kt��"h�i� ��C�� t �� i'�� f�C��,� (,{� �{�d �±� ! i�' - �. � � *P8:Recorded b ( ) � j ,4' y� Name,affilfation,and address ��!-ftf ��t��r �� p� ',�0 �'��'l��ti �i j(; �� -��,s � ,� � �� Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo _ . .S : A.fI � . ��.' .� " .\ ��1.., y. - I .+� �. _��. . � � . � � i .3 ... , � �: — �� ,� 4� :�. .� a e 1� � :�= � � ; i k s�' � s .Y ��—a�---.._. .�':� s � � � y � i;��i I �-� rt C k � �-„ � r � -,f,� � ! .', � R City of Orange CD Dept. �C ` � 4 °�� i i � ,� � � � � f. _ � i �� 300 E. Chapman Avenue *� a�� : . ( , t �: � , �i �; ; ;. Orange, CA 92866 t � �� "'''� �``' �' �� ' '�P9.Date Recorded: � *P11.RepoltCltatlon: (Citesurveyreportandothersources,arenter"none.") ' April 2018 ' Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1982) Orange •p10.SurveyType' (Describe) Historic Survey. Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map � Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) "Required Information ;� �� ' ' '=- `�� "`"'`��3 ' �q_ � r r�.�,� .:�,� � b ,,�'�� „��' � s �,�' ,�� StateofCal�fomia TfieR`e�sources�qe�ncy�,�-�� , .�:� �� P�mary#' 34 15s704 �� :��-�� ° �DEPARTMENT OF PARKS�AND RECREATION � � '� ��" °�"��'��`'��RI# � 038070�_ �� ' ` '� � �:�� - :: ��#=v' �� `� . - '.�� r,� '` � �. , �zs'� z.�_ � '.�� - ,.s �'L-e. BUILDING, STR�1CTl�RE�AND OBJECT RECORD *N1�HP�Stat�is Code: 5p1` � �� , .._.��x�._... . _, _ ��>r<��rz-.-_:.. �.�,.r. - .,.r� �_�,...� � ��:t-�`��_-r.;,E_ :y ..-''�r,"��,�.,. � a..,'Lek,�F_. .�r� -..x Page 2 of 3 'Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s_164 APtv_o41-042-14 (Assigned by Recarder) B1.Historic Name: unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: �s B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Architectural Style: Folk Victorian *B6.ConStfuCtlon Hlstory:�Construction date,atlerations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 1903 ❑�I HiStoflC ❑ PfehlstofiC ❑ Both *B7.Moved7 � No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: unknown *B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Significance: Early settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Dfscuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope.Also address Integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) Structurallntegrity: Excellent Condition — Minor chanqes to oriqinal structure. Site Integ�ity: Large accessory structure at rear of property. Opportunities 611.Additional Resource Attributes: ��isc attrinuces ana oode5� *B12.References: 813.RCR18fk5' (Contlnues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change £rom 551 to 5D1. Outside 2005 survey area. Style previously noted in 1991 Survey as . Vernacular. 2018 City Council—directed survey for potential • � boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. "B14.Evaluato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for o�cial comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information State of�California The Resources qgency �: },' . : , Primary..# -30-158704 • DEPARTMENtOF PAItKS AND�RECREATION t , HRI# �:03'8070 � 'CONTINUATION SHEET ' '' � ' �Trinomial o�� . r�� v� '� �. < �. ,�.��.. . � _ ��5, Page 3 of 3 *Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s_169 APN 041-042-14 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 1982, 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 2 � y�� °��.r �---�-- ��"-''�'��`-�-s it� Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: 2 ,r �� , �'t°� `` ` 'f , �o��>. � '� -. � �. � %:i ��"' x . Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 • �.§: t�*'°��'�'� X �r : `1 � ,. d '� /. ... . t r .t s�p t�`�S`�14yM F'y. � �.. � Principal Bu�lding Sqft: 1235 . �,- � �`''�� `' � 66.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): ~' �,\� � j j � i -eteotrf 2:� .� � � _ ,��613.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): �; ' - ;, � k `.:r _,. . ..�� ' �Y,-�.•,..-r�+- _".__ P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): t gable end. Large two story accessory structure at rear visible from driveway. DPR 523L(11/98) "Required Information State of California The Resources Agency ' Prima.ry# 30-158707; '� ��rs+o-°�� .a t a'w: +n � � � :. �. x v , DEPARTMEN�OF PARKS AND RECREATION e � HRI# 038073 '�'`�4 , �>T' n `' �.�� a PRIMARY RECORD�'�� - � �F Trinomial o�f� ,Y��,� k j �t� � �` ��,� � ' '�'" � NRHP Stafus Coiie 5D1: �� "�� ''' , � � ' �.��" � �s� OtFie�List�ngs at :� .�.��^,°`� »k� r .a��' ; �` i,#��s �� ,Review C,ode " Rev�ewe� ,� b' � ��,`'',' � Date > . . : � � a,_ .- �� . x�, - � �- � � , , ,. . � ..s,:. . ., .. _� .:. _ ,. Page 1 of 3 "Resou�ce Name o�#: BATAVIA S_176 APN_041-042-13 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifer: "P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication � Unrestricted "a.County: Orange and (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) 'b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T�; R ; � 114 of � 114 of Sec �; �B.M. c.Address: 176 - s BATAVIA ST ,# City: Oran4e Zlp: 92868 d.UTM: (Giva more than one for Iarge end/or Ilnear resources)Zane � � � mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "P38.DOSC�IPt10I1: (Describe resource and its major elements.Include design,materials,wndilion,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Matet'lals: Frame - Wood sidinq A one and one-half story single family residence with side gable roof and front-facing gable dormer. Main gable roof overhang forms front porch spanning full width of the house. Porch has half wall supporting elephantine piers. Red brick foundation with brick steps at front porch. Wood lap siding. Symmetrical fa�ade with centered front door flanked by pair of tripartite wood windows. Front dormer has arched window with decor *P3b.ResoufCe Att�ibutes: (HP2)--Single family property (Llst attributes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: ❑d Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) ;; �q� `��r�: , i �,��,,�� PSb.Description of Photo: 2018 � i I � ,. �8� �, i � �,,,�"T� �-='""'ro� � , (View,date,accession#) i� - - # � n � ,w \^ *P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: �. - � �� fi� ,��- 1911 ❑.� Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both *P7.Owner and Address: � �6 ; .. . ._- � ,;� — ��'.. � `` � �� Y „� � �- Q{ ��,.�..:�. I �hl� ',t P r '. � � �j�.'�I s Y��:' _ x� � *P8:ReCOfded by: (Name,aKliation,and address) �}' ' I,�+' ; �� , , � Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo 4 l �. �� ,' j � �'i� �,�`� Cit y of Oran ge CD De pt. � , � t� � ,s,'x'�b , �� 300 E. Chapman Avenue � � � s:,"� � � � � � �� r�„� '�`� Orange, CA 92866 � �.�..�,,,� fi� �' . . �3 ��€ � �� g . � ! �; ' . ��, ?'� ^,� �:i,� t...{.''"i+t�q , ,,..,�;. - _ �_.._m�..�_ _ .�_ . �` *P9.Date Recorded: � *P11.Report Cltatlol7: (Cite survey report and other sources,or enter"none.") Apiil 2 018 � Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1982) Orange *p10.SuNeyType: (Describe) Historic Survey. Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information ��State ofr'alifornia�The Resources�Agency"`�� Pr�mary;#�30 158707= � �,�� ,��`.�� `DEP�A�R�TMENT�PARKS AND�RECREATIO�IV'�` ��; � � HRI# '�03,8073 �� ;�' �ffBUILDING,STR�UCTURE,AND�OB�JECT ECORD� �NRHP�Status Code �#�5tii`�� ` ` � �� . �` �.,, ....�....atac-.�,� . -�.;-�,w.�.�,5�.'-<. x,_ _�.;�' �=�-� ,r.�,�'� ,.r�#�`,... Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_176 APN o41-09z-13 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: william J. and Marie Richardson House (1911) B2.Common Name: 63.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Architectural Style: Craftsman *B6.ConSt�uCtlon History:(Construction date,atlerations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 1911 ❑�I HiSto�ic ❑ P�ehlSto�C ❑ Both *B7.Moved7 ❑.I No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: onknown "B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of orange Property Type: Residence Period of Significance: Early settlement (c. 1s7o - 1920) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss importance In terms of historical or architectural conteM as defined by thame,period,and gaographic scope.Also address fntagrity. Continues on Pg.4.) StRlCturallntegl'Ity: Good Condition - Minor changes to oriqinal structure: brick front porch steps and founda Site Integrity: Opportunities William J. and Marie Richardson were early owners of the property. Mr. Richardson was the city water superintendent. B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��ist anritutes and�odes) *B12.References: B13.Remarks: �Continues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with Norlh arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change £rom SS1 to SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for . potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District.. . , "B14.EvalUato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: _april 2018 (This space reserved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information State of Cal�fornia The Resources qgency � '` Pr�rr�ary#"� 3o i5a7o7 4 � �,� , � 'DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND REGREATION ` � ��'�~ HRI�# 038_07=3 r:� : � �- , � CONTINUATION,SHEET Trtnomial oi�h '' v , , , .� �-> � � �� - ��. _ _�� . 3 =1 � Page 3 of 3 "'Resou�ce Name of#: BATAVIA S_176_APN_041-042-13 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo DBte ReCofded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 1982, 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: General Plan: LrtDR #of Buildings: 2 ,�� ;�, _� „�,� ��„ $ �,��, �� 't w� " � :q � > x � P�817f11I1g 2000: R-2-6 #Of 5't01'I@S: 1.5 �";s `� .�`' �''� "'"+ ��,.� ? '�e,� � .�, r:'§ ' �� ti t a " Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 � � �..' ''�� '�°a,*r�,� � �« � ��` .�� " '�`"�,.�t `w�� Principal Building Sqft: 1673 �.� � ,� 3�i� B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): �`� � -� �-�- �"��`"� i �'-�.'"�-.�`3 s ,�' �� z� >�k`' �.: � B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): r ,�� ,� ��a� s� r� - �'^°sx;��, ��t'h«�. , .,m ' . � .� ��-.�.�."�. .�.. P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): ative corbels. Wide eave overhang on roof. Detached garage at rear. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information State of.Cahfomia The'Resou�ees enc � Pr�mary# 30.'15870`8� =r _ A9 Y 'DEPAR7MENT OF PARKS AND-RECREATION = HRI# _�, 038Q74 2 = � � �� _� :� �`�PRIMARY RECORD�� ` ,�' Trinomial o�i � � � �� r �'� � � '� NRHP Status Code � 5�1/3s �` ,� � 4 OtherListings _ � �'� ��``�,�� : � Review Code �" �Rev�ewer �. � 'Date �"� ` � ' � , , a � , _ , t� _, .� �� Page 1 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s 204 APN 091-064-17 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication � Unrestricted *a.Cou�ty: Oranqe and (pZb and P2c or P2d.Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T ; R ; � 1/4 of � 1/4 of Sec �; B.M. c.Add�ess: 204 - S BATAVIA ST ,# City:_ Oranqe Zip: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources)Zo�e ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "P3a.DeSCi'Iptlon: �Describe resource and its maJor elements.Include design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Matel'ials: Frame - Wood and wood shake sidiny Large two and one-half story single family residence with hip roof and gable dormers with shaped exposed rafter tails and decorative corbels. Square plan with covered porch with large arched openings wrapping northeast corner of house. Variety of wood window types including bay windows, diamond-shaped windows, multi-light double hung windows, and leaded glass windows. Cast stone porch piers and foundation walls. Narrow wood *P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--sinqle familv proPertv (List aflributes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: 0 Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) w��y �' � �� i�� '��`�"-`��,��r''��r� v%��5��`,�r��. � � �; F��,,a l<" � `�x � �,�/�, "`r��u.+`"��r��i P5b.DQSCfiptio0 Of PhOtO: 2018 ��,� �c�ka��''�t�„�"�3`� � � � ��v " "� �`E�-0�?� �, a��'��m�✓,�"� � "`s� �� r ��%�� (View,date,accession#) �� a ✓?� .�„ .•-�'� �� ,r�, �e��.�^�� -��'%� + , n /s x � � ��' � �-�s �` �"'„`��s��' � � �� .�` . � °� � �� x� �' ��"�` x�� "P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: �$ �� t;J''�� ` "°` > .�- � „�� F q�:,: ..� - 1905 . �� , �� ❑./ Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both �, �� . , � rrr►ttnnnw______°•n -,_--� � i ��i �` 4 LL �=: -.,x ;1�I�m�� '�`��_� *P7.Owner and Address: �� -�� '�. _ �� : ,�°.'' �1�+�} -« ��. �PB:Recorded by: �Name,aKliation,and address) � . r:,. ^: a�..• �T" ;:_�:^; Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo <*a -� ::,�a� ,M,..�. City of Orange CD Dept. �'"' ��> � 300 E. Chapman Avenue a Orange, CA 92866 j < ".?��• '4$„ ' �f� .. t . *P9.Date Recorded: � *P11.ReportCltatloll: (Citesurveyreportandothersources,orenter"none.") ' April 2018 ' Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1982) Orange *p10.SurveyType: (pescribe) Historic Survey. Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑d Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information �State of Califor�ma�The Resources Agency � § �W�{ Pnmary�# 3o,�i587o8° � ` � 4 DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ,��M�� LiRI,#� 038:0'74� : � � � '�;u�::BUILDING STRUCTURE AND OBJECT RECORD`��*NRHP Status,Code �sD��%3' < =� ��. w,.,ti.v,ez�� .�r:,,�vzz•�,. =�> > ��-a� _v v��u�t: ._�'^.�."!.v-'�. Page 2 of 4 `Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_209 APN_041-064-17 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: James M. and Emily D. Marsh xouse B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xES B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Architectu�al Style: Folk Victorian *B6.COnSt�uCtlOn HlstOry:(Construction date,atleralions,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 190 5 ❑d Histoflc ❑ Prehlsto�ic ❑ Both *B7.Moved7 ❑�I No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "B8.Related Features: *69.Architect or Builder: unknown *B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: city of orange PropertyType: xesidence Period of Significance: Eariy Settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss ImpoRance in terms of historical or architecturat conteM as defined by theme,period,and geogrephic scope. Aiso address integrity. Continues an Pg.4.) Structurallntegrity: �ood condition - Minor changes to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities The house is an excellent example of its architectural style. Appears individually eligible for National Register of Historic Places. History of Ownership: James M. and Emily D. Marsh, citrus ranchers, lived at the property from 1919 to 1922. Neil H. and Viva Edgar lived here in 1923. Mr. Edgar was part owner in Edgar and Hays Company in Santa Ana. In early 1924, they sold the house to Frank E. and Nellie Miles, and moved to 2302 Spurgeon in Santa Ana. Mr. Miles was a pioneer in the grocery business, and had operated grocery stores in Goldfield, Nevada and Pomona, California before coming to Santa Ana in 1913. He opened a new store there and soon had outlets in Orange, Anaheim, Fullerton and Garden Grove. He sold that firm after a few years, then started a new chain with stores in Orange, Anaheim and Fullerton and a bakery in Tustin. Around 1919, he sold out to Acme chain. Mr: and Mrs. Miles had a son, Frank E. Jr., listed as a student, clerk and later, in 1930, as an operator in B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��;st attr�b�tes a�a oodes� - *B12.References: Orange Daily News. "A Place Called Aome," Brigandi, Phil and Wilson Tunbull, Karen (1990, p.40) . City Directories, L.A. County (1883-1884) and City of Orange Section (1901, 1907 - of the age 15 years and over and Classified Business) . Orange Householder's Guide (1919, 1922-1930, 1932) . City Directory by Streets (1919, 1922-1930, 1932) . Classified Business (1919, 1922-1930, 1930) . B13.Remarks' �Continues on Pg.3.) (Skelch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Added SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. Style previously noted in 1991 Survey as . Classic Box. 2018 City Council-directed survey £or potential . . . boundary adjustment o£ local Old Towne Historic District. *B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for o�cial comments.) DPR 5236(1/95) �Required Information State of'California The Resources Agency Primary# , 30=158708'{ °::�DEPARTMENT QF'PARKS AND RECREATION �HRI# > =sa38074 ,,.z:;; " .`C,,ONTIf�UATION SHEET "7rinomfai ,oiiA _ Page 3 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s 204 APN 041-064-17 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue 0 Contlnuatlon ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 1982, 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 2 Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: 2.5 � Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 � ��; ��f x �� S �"�r� , �. � �� .��.z��,� ; Principal Building Sqft: 2796 �� °�,�� `s�' �''� �� W.�. �:T; � ,��, i .'_�'#F lr.tt.,i.,y��n� M� � B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): � :�.�3� r r , ��'r �.. '"3' :.�;'_ ��-��.�,` x�a s,...._ � � � �_ ° B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): �' �� `M' ��,.. �. �A `"� � � af x� ` a� .m.w,. "_eS �., -�&a a+,�ana�.. � 1: _ . .�, , �.oa . ;� ,,.- a? � -, Y» _ _ .�,�Y^,="'�.. �. , :., ro .�„� �,, . P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): lap siding on ground floor. Wood shakes on upper floor. Large corner property with two mature Canary Island Date Palms in Batavia side parkway, flanking concrete front walkway. Double-height carriage house on northeast side of property. Carriage house has steeply pitched front gable roof with exposed rafter tails and a shed roof side extension. Small cupola with louvered vents centered on ridge. Wood lap siding with wood shakes matching the house in front gable end. Sliding wood carriage house door on east elevation. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information ., ie"�1�._'¢��,''`�"'�,'�,.�"-�. �� , a.�r �:�. �'. 1:a;�"a�� . ;�' �, � .,< ��State of California The Resources Agency � �Primary# O�lse7os' � �� ; ��':: ` a��'D PA�RTMENT�OF PARKS AND RECREATION �� F� «;� HRI# �038:074 '� � �� CONTINUATION=SHEET �n�' ��'� �� ¢ �� °�� : � , . .� � ,Trinomial �oRA k �� __s,.,gw.i,. .,.3-e, _>... � ^;�:, !i. ��,.�, -,. �c`-'�x'".'�,r. „�. ...tY.r','�. , de-�".4'€'%�-':,��; �"m Page 4 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAvrA s_204 APN 041-064-17 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: April 2018 City o£ Orange CD Dept. 30o s. chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 810.Signiflcance(Continued from Pg.2): the Community Service Station, 224 E. Chapman. In 1932, another Miles, Glenn R. was also listed as a resident. He was an operator with Standard Stations, Inc. The Miles family lived here until 1933 when the financial pains of the Great Depression cost them the home. Mr. Miles retained his ranch in Lemon Heights, where he died in 1950 at the age of 73. In September of 1937, the house was purchased by Edwin Gould for $5,500. Gould had moved from Wisconsin and become the manager of the Anaconda Wire & Cable Company, Orange's first successful large-scale industrial plant. He was active in many social and fraternal organizations and also served on the Orange High School Board of Trustees. He lived in the house until he died at 67 in January 1963. His widow, Alma, continued to live here a£ter that. His son, Richard, was the proprietor of Orange Camera and Photo in the Plaza. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information Stafe of Cal�forma The�Resources Agency ` P._nmary,�# ' ,`;DEPARTMENT OF PAF3KS AND RECREATION � „ � HRI# � �PRIMARY RECORD` � t Trmomiai o� *i �� :, , : : x � : b .. � _NRHP Stafus Code ,5a1' " x � Other L�stings '' _� - �� Re�iew Code =;Re�iewe� . �tlDate �' Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s 210 APN o41-064-16 (Assigned by Racorder) P1.Other ldentifier: "P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication 0 Unrestricted "a.CoUllty: Orange and (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a loration map as necessary.) "b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T ; R ,� 1l4 of � 1/4 of Sec � B.M. c.Address: 210 - S BATAVIA ST ,# Clty: Oranae Zip: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources)Z�t10 ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: '"P3d.DOSC�IptlOfl: (Describe resource and its major elements.Include design,materials,condition,al[erations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Mate�lals: Frame - wood siding One and a half story single family residence with steeply pitched side gable roof. Front elevation has two gable roof dormers with wood double hung windows. OPf-center £ront entry with pedimented surround with engaged £luted pilasters. Decorative wood front door screen with £an-shaped detail. Curved front driveway. Brick chimney on south elevation. Wide wood lap siding with mitered corners. Two-over-two wood double hunq wind "P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--single familv propertv (List attributes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: ❑� Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) �' a+.r °° �'.wNp� ✓F r ; '%��,� � .�''�-'z' � � � ,.1' +$x i �,✓'� '$ a 7� ��i,��u��"A�n � � ,�e .�;�., � �^ ¢y�� '��"� �k� �%�� ' PSb.Description of Photo: 2018 � � �",�- 5�� '"��'��fi��n'^��'�i� "'��z�,z� ��y��o�'�.�� `�}�� q� �"�'d �r /�r � � u �� lew,date,accession# s{�'` ,. � �, H �r� �-�z� �;�� " d;�� Cv"�s�� (� ) : � � a�f Y G'�`�'` 1�,� y�^�.,��" ,za v, ��" z E��e'x� ' "� „ ��ry��Y �rP(:� � t.99�,„, . ! �� +�,�,�A�, . ��"`'� .� ��a�� "� �! °�� g� *P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: �= �_ �' ''�v ;4 cs � �� r ��'� 1990 � �e � it�� ; ��, ' .%rt '° � �_- � �� ",. , _�� ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both _. � �,h _- f ,. et��e.. �;� , �; *P7.Owner and Address: � . a �� ', _._ '1 d: � i - *PS:Rewrded b : y : y (Name,affiliation,and address) �� " Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo r�<' �«� . �� -' �.. �; ..s .:,.,.�. � ,� -+�'.��5�, r . � �� " City of Orange CD Dept. .�,. � ^!��. <x.rt, " 300 E. Chapman Avenue �� Orange, CA 92866 .� � /'' ,`��k«�. " ......_.�^��.:_. �.___.u_.. . � _��,..�._ __�__._s.___.,__ . __T __.. . «P9.Date Recorded: • *P11.Repolt CltatlOn: (Cite survey report and other sources,or enter"none.") April 2 O 18 ' Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018) . *P10.Survey Type: (Describe) Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information .,s�,� �. ,. �, � #,>` ��" S� :��, � � ��..� � �� „�. � r n` ��,. , State,ofGal�forora � e FtesourcesAgency� ' �� ry# ��g'�� '� �, . � �,�~ � �� ,�Th � � Prima � �� aEPARTMENT OF..PARKS AND�RECREAT(ON � � HRf# -:��. -�� '"� `y�� ' ' `�� *NRHP StaEus+Code � �5D1�' � -� �' �'� BUILDING,STRUCT,URE,AND OBJECT�,RECORD . � 4�,*,� __ ,�-� � .,� _ �W� � r _�.� �� z._ r��,��-�,��, � Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#• sATAvzA s_210 APN_041-064-16 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name:. B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: REs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.ArchlteCtural Style: Colonial Revival *B6.Constl'UCtlon Hlstory:�Construction date,atlerations,and date of aiteralions) Date of ConStfuCtlon: 194 0 ❑d Hlstoflc ❑ Pfehlsto�iC ❑ Both *B7.Moved7 ❑d No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: onknown 'B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Significance: znterwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criteria: Ac ": `=(Disciiss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) ... ., . _ ,rc,;,._ St�uCtufallnteg�lty: Good Condition — No apparent change to oriqinal structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��is�anrib�te5 ana�ode5� *B12.References: B13.Remarks: �cor,u�ue5 0�P9.a.) (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment . of local Old Towne Historic District. . . • � *B14.Evaluato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: april 2018 (This space reserved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) •Required Information "State of Califomia The Resources�qency � ' �� Prlrt�ary# �� t� ��- i�� DEPARI'MENI'OF P/IRKS AND RECREATION � ��`"� �� WRI# � ��.��`�� `:�'� �� ' ��"�,x.x x � � = � � �,CONTINUATION SHEET �``` �' � Trinomiai�,�o��' ��' � � � . . ,. . .� �._�." ��; .. ; . _ .;y � , _. ..> _ ry . . � � _ �. . r . . � �,. ,� ,. , 4�.N� . � � a-� _ � ..�, _ _, � _. � � .�� Page 3 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_210 APtv_o41-064-16 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 2018 Description of Photo: Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 2 Planning Zone: 1t-2-6 #of Stories: 1.5 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 Principal Building Sqft: B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): ows. Detached two car garage at rear. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information ,�; Primary# ' ; ' State of Cal�forma The Resources Agency� �.� '.DEPARTMENT QF PARKSFAND RECREATfON � HRI# ,�ii' � � ` � PRIMARY RECORD Tri�omial ox�i � � NRHP Stafus Code �DF - OtBer List�ngs � � - �'= Revie�nr Code Rev�ewer ` ` �„� �Date Page 1 of 4 *Re50u�C0 NHRIl O�#: BATAVIA S_220_APN_091-064-48 (Assigned by Recordar) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication ❑� Unrestricted *a.County: Orange and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a Iocation map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T�; R � 1l4 of � 1/4 of Sec � B.M. c.Address: 220 - s BATAVIA ST ,# Cltyl: Oran e�Zlp: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources)Z0�0 ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "'P38.D@SC�IPtI0I1: (Describe resource and its major elements.Inciuda design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Mate�lal5: Frame - Wood sidinq Two story single family residence with side gable roof. Wide exposure wood lap siding. Large multi-light bay window on front elevation. 3 gable roof dormers with multi-light double hung windows on front elevaton. Wood paneled front door in recessed, off-center entrance. Decorative dentil trim at entry and roof eaves. Very narrow eave overhang. Curved driveway in front yard. Detached two car garage at rear. *P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--sinale familv propertv (Llst attributes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: ❑d Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) ;�� ;ry,�'E�'��y;�t��c�� . .rx� , �° x,��,� �N� �� r�' � � P5b.Descri tion of Photo: ��i��w`'��..�r��.�`", ��-, � ,�y� �, � y P � � � �. �,�� (View,date,accessfon#) ��!�t4��';�` "'a''��' �' aP � °��`,�� x�� *P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: � � .�v. G �/µi�� pd r " � .� �rd a/ ... ,f` ,, _ �� ✓�'��. �.9 4� � �� y 1 x �� -'-� -- :^ ,�,�� '��, ^�"'� � Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both ---�-�, e��, .� - �F��, � �' `P7.Owner and Address: z7� � — .. ...�... . ?... . -- ., _,....,�. ' a�`-.: -... �� `:` � - -�_,�.,- _ � .� °�� ,-„ ��,�,�w� r a��'" �`��-� �� ;��• "P8:ReCo�ded by: (Name,aKliation,and address) '*'"-�, .y :� � ,,._.;, Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo '� �� t� �:�� " � ''"` � � City o£ Orange CD Dept. �l�.c°"� f - p,� 300 E. Chapman Avenue � Orange, CA 92866 � - *P9.Date Recorded: *P11.R0pO�kCltatlOnE (Citesurveyreportandothersources,orenter"none.") ' April 2018 ' � Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018) . 'P10.Survey Type: (Describe) Reconnaissance "Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information -� � - �a"�'n, "`.tr'�#'y,c+ ,.t - c � a&'�`�' ��f �.: t : .�� C'� .yt � , ... � ,;State of Cal�fornta The Resources qgency � � �� `�" a �� Primary# �'' `�' � � ��`� � �� '� `,�.s -�,-. '�'�..�,�d-�,t�;€�� - �. Y , . ,� , ' � . 7 �;DEPARTMENT OF PARKS NVD RECREATION .� ��HRI# �-�.�'�.� �� `�� `�� BUILDING,�ST'RUCTURE,AND�OBJECT ECORD� *�RHP�status code ��5n�i�� '�`�� -�`.; x�,.c�_ .�a ,.s�..�. r4;�-, ,:as"� �a�.�.�� e...:��., ,.;3,-� �r- � �Q Page 2 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s 22o APN o41-064-98 (Assigned by Recarder) B1.Historic Name: B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: �s *B5.Architectural Style: Colonial Revival *B6.ConSt�uCtion Hlstory:(Construction date,atlerations,and date ot aiterations) Date of Construction: 199 0 ❑d HiStoriC ❑ P�ehlStoric ❑ Both "B7.Moved? d❑ No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: vnknown "B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Significance: rnterwar Develo ment (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss importance fn terms of historical or architectural conteM as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope.Also address fntegrity. Conlinues on Pg.4.) Structurallntegrity: Good Condition - Minor changes to oriqinal structure Site Integrity: Opportunities The house was constructed in 1940 by Roy R. Russell a prominent contractor and real estate entrepreneur, who built and sold houses throughout the Santa Ana and Orange areas. In 1941, Vera Wettlin purchased the house as her sole and separate property, where she lived with her husband David Wettlin and their children until 1954. From 1935 to 1954, Vera Wettlin served as the City of Orange Postmaster, a federally appointed position, and was the primary income earner for her family. She served as Postmaster during the dedication of the new Post Office at 308 W. Chapman Avenue in 1935. She was Postmaster when the Orange Post Office received first class office status, the highest class rating in the Postal Service, and was present at the first airmail drop in the City in the summer of 1946. Her tenure ended in 1954, having completed 20 years o£ service t 611.Additional Resource Attributes: ��isc anrituces ana�odes� "B12.References: B13.ReR18�ks: (Contlnues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment . of local Old Towne Historic District. . . . , "B14.Evaluato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuf£o *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for o�ciai comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information State of Cahfomia TF�e Resources qgency� ��'� }'_; � �`� s P�imary# � ` ��_�� '�'� '� �``� "° � yDEPARTIIAENT�OF'PARKSAND RECREATION�� .��` �H�tI# �� : � �� '�� CONTI.NUATION�SHEET #��,�� `� T.r7nomial � ox� � .��, '`�` Page 3 of 4 *Resource Name or#: BA'rAvzA s_220 APN_041-064-48 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: April 2018 City o£ Orange CD Dept. 30o E. Chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 . --� .....:_ Years Surveyed: 2018 Description of Photo: Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 2 � Planning Zone: R-2-6 #of Stories: 2 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 Principal Building Sqft: B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information � _.� �` "' . ;t -��- - .� � i'i+, � .� '�+k; # �� £ :r State of Cahfornia The Resourc'es Agency , ,�'� �a�` Brimary# �� `�� .�r n � i. �.- � � ' ' i3 � t� � DEPARTMENT OF P�ARKS AND:RECR AT ON F � �' ��,''�"# �� ' �� `�� ;��t .� .�<'"� '+�� "� t��"�� :CONTINUATION SHEET� -�;� �� ° � �;��' a �T Inomial�` �o� ` _ r ? � �� ti � Page 4 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATavIA s_22o APN o41-064-48 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCol'ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 B10.Slgnificance(Continued from Pg.2): o the community. Wettlin's position as Postmaster, her pro£essional and civic life, and her homeownership reflect the slowly increasing number of women in the workforce during the mid-twentieth century and the reality of women's roles as income earners and heads of households from the Great Depression through the 1950s. Wettlin was a member of a number of important Orange community organizations, including the Toastmasters and the Woman's Club, where she held the presidency for several terms. She was also an active member of the Orange Business and Professional Women's Club, where she served as Public Relations Chair in 1941. As a prominent member of the community, her home served as an important meeting place for these community institutions. The house retains the majority of its features from its construction in 1940 and through Vera Wettlin's ownership of the house, which ended when she sold the house the same year as her retirement in 1954. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information ^State of Cal�forma The Resource's Agency � �� :� 1 P,rim�ry# �.30 1587 09 ��r �DEPARTMENTOF PARKS�AND RECREATIO`N � � -� � IiRI# '_"038075`*��'� '� ,' �` ��' 7'rmomtal;- � oRa� '�PRIMARY RECORD � � � 3 � NRHP Status Cotle �5n113s �� Ofher,L�stings � _ ��_ �� `` � ReYiew�Code � ~ �'Reviewer ��'� �' `Date + ., , ., , , , . � , .,,. � � . ,„_, r n,.. _ � _ .; � „ ,..� , tx-. t. Page 1 of 4 *Resource Name or#• BATAvzA s_224 APN_091-064-50 (Assigned by Recordar) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication � Unrestricted *a.County: Orange and (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) 'b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T ; R�; � 1/4 of � 1/4 of Sec �; �B.M. c.Address: 224 - s BATAVIA ST ,# City: OranQe Zip: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources)Z0110 ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "P38.DOSC�IPtI0I1: (Describe resource and its major elements.Include design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Mate1'lals: Frame - Wood siding A two story Craftsman house with a series of front gable roofs. Frontmost gable is supported by Japanese influenced piers at £ront porch and incorporates slatting in the uppermost portion of the qable. Two large picture windows with transoms are located on either side of main entry door. Gable eaves are wide and have exposed rafters. A brick chimney is located in the rear. Large accessory building at rear of property. Curved *P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP2)--sincrle family propertv (List atVibutes and codes) *P4.Resources Present: ❑d Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) z �a� �1�A' �" y,;�ef�'� ��:� ��' :�"� 'h�`�r��"+� t�"��^ � � �� ,,,�� n��r��,�st�� ,�� '��,� P5b.Description of Photo: 2018 �n � `��x,� `� ��,�r� �` �'a t�,� i�� "�'� „� � � r� , � - �.�ir a . �� r�"� � y F ° View,date,accession# �' �� s.� ��.�> � � x v,a�,�� ,�'' �v y G u �r m ( ) �u�'� �� i��r�i�xr r, �f� �'�`y.� �°'r��'�'� k1� .� � � ?,��9 ;2� �,,�'�"�. � ; 3 5' � a', r� a ��' ��,��'�'�'� ��u �° `�.� � r „,,' *P6.Date ConstructedlAge and Source: � � � �` N/� 7�,,�,X � � �� 1915 w r` � �t � @ „.. �I �� ''�� ❑�/ Historic .,�, � � �� , �. �� ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both �:�: �;,, *P7.Owner and Address: � �'� , �: ..�. ='. �� -- � _£5� �'� ' '� ,. �,, u.,j. � �� wiw^'��- .9�...� ��_°, s«,.,�„�.�,-,, .. ., _.. � ,� *P8:R@CO�dOd b)/: (Name,a�Iiation,and address) �+ ,��" Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo � aj�'��"� , '�'�- � o �LL�,,� � . ,. , " u �: .... �r �E3e� ��"u ,Ce .. x '�"�€� � �, � * ��-� ��"'� ' •�E City of Orange CD Dept. t ��t� � } �u�"��1� �� "�� :=�4 " , � � �.�:� ; 300 E. Chapman Avenue �� a`�',�ti r�n*��'�� ' ' � Orange, CA 92866 � �.� �.,�z J �,.�4 �'�"° � �"�� "pg,Date Recorded: � *P11.ReportClt8t1U�1: (Citesurveyreportandothersources,orenter"none.") ' April 2018 Orange County Assessor Records (2010 and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1962) Orange *p10.SurveyType: (pescribe) Historic Survey. Reconnaissance "Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information �'"��€. .�`�^' ; : � �.:. � �s`-�'�.�s *z .,»„�� d�, < #s-:6.�� , �. ,µ � �� :�� _� ...�� State of Gal�forma The Resources�4gency,�� P.ri ary# 3o i5s709 �� ,_ �. � :� �DEPAR MENT OF PARKS�D ECREATION �'�'�..r HRI#��`�` 3 038075 ` �:� 3�° `�`�� t��. �> = <:��, ' �"��`��'� �� " "� � � ` � a y � ?- .�� r� `� �- � BUILDING,STRUCTURE;AND�OBJECT RECORD "NRHIP Sta,t�us�Code�, °5�iY3� ;�- � r= �� : .,-�= .:�...=� ..��.�, ,sw:a., �.��.�r>n,; r � ��'�t"�.�.. .s Page 2 of 4 *Resource Name or#: BATAviA s_224 APtv_o41-064-50 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Histo�lc Name: John and Gail Younq House B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Architectural Style: Craftsman *B6.COnSt�uCtlon HlstOry:(Construction date,atlerations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 19'15 � HISto�IC ❑ P�ehlSto�IC ❑ Both Wood windows replaced with vinyl in the original openings on the side elevations. One window has been converted to a bay window with vinyl sashes. *B7.Moved7 � No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: Unknown *B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of 5ignificance: Early settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Applicable Criteria: Ac (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural conteM as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) Structurallntegrity: Excellent Condition - Minor chanqes to original structure. Sltelnteg�lty: Substantial grade change in front yard has caused the original raised front porch to be level with the curved driveway. Large accessory structure added at rear. Opportunitles Appears individually eliqible for National Register. In October 1918, John W. and Gail C. Young purchased four acres of land at 224 S. Batavia. At that time, Batavia Street marked the western edge of the City limits, putting this property just over into county territory. South Batavia was then considered an upscale neighborhood, populated by gentlemen citrus farmers. In 1919, he built this house on his property and lived and ranched here for the next ten years. In 1929, the house and land was aquired by John J. and Ida M. Collins, another local citrus rancher. Born in Missouri, Mr. Collins had settled in Northern California in 1887 and in 1916 moved here. Collins continued to live in this house until he retired from ranching in the late 1940s. His son, Ray Collins, took over the groves at that time and movecl into the house. John Collins died in April of 1950 at the age o£ 83. Ray Collins held onto th 811.Additional Resource Attributes: ��i5tanrib�tes ana�oaes� *B12.References: Orange Daily News. "A Place Called Home," Brigandi, Phil and Wilson Turnbull, Karen (1990, p.33) . Orange Householder's Guide (1919, 1922-1930, 1922) . City Directory by Streets (1919, 1922-1930, 1932) . B13.ReR1a�k5: (Contlnues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with Norih arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Added SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for . potential boundary adjustment of local.Old Towne Historic District. . "`B14.EValuato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information 'State of Cal�forn�a The`�Resources Agency P�imary#; 3o=i58709` eDEPARTMENT QF PAFtKS;AND RECREATIQN� ;' HRI# 03'8075 ,» CONTINUATIONSHEET `�' �.'- �A � ' _ Trinomial oxT�: ,.. �_ . �_... �� .-�� ,: � _;�.: . . n. : k E . , � .,� x Page 3 of 4 "ReSOu�Ce NeRIB Of#: BATAVIA S_224_APN_091-064-50 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Reco�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 19s2, 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in Nationai Register: General Plan: LMDR #of Buildings: 1 Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: 2 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 � � Principal Building Sqft: 1516 � �� ; � �� .�..s-.»�,�"��` 2��,�' B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): `£� „x � ��u�w � y r= �+ D? '�P�� • M . B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): „ Y � �a �� .�� `�,��r �; .��.� °�„�`� � � e: �:,�°�`� , ��n'� �� y k'3 Y. ,� �r j � * 'S A��.R+G �v_ •ap+wia+,�;�y �' ,*.'�r'�'�`< ..u.�`,"�.�.�.�.='`'s s.�a��x.,P ,i�X�"��x <.:��.� *.�;.�'� P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): front driveway. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information StateofGal�forma TheResourcesAgency� Pr�mary�# 3o i5s709 �� ,� � ;5 � ` -� -� �� .:.c,�,`" .�,� � - �., �- DEPARTMENT OF PARKS�1ND REGREATION �� HRI# Os8075 '� � �tt�� -� �-, CONTINI`JATION SHEET��"� k # Trtnomtal` o1�A� � �� * � ' _ Page 4 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_224 APN 041-064-50 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo DBte ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Oranqe, CA 92866 B10.Significance(Continued from Pg.2): e property until he sold the house to C.O. Dale in the mid-1950s. This house is an outstanding example of architectural style. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information Pnmary..# ..State ofxGalifornia The Resources Agency a" � - `' ' .� DEPARTIfAENT OF PARKS A�IVD RECREATION HRI# ; - � � � " ` �PRIN�ARY RECORD ` Trinoml�l ox�i s �� t � � �NRHP 5tafus'Code :6z� � Other List�ngs �,.-; Review Code �sRewewe� `YDate Page 1 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_236 APN_041-064-47 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication ❑� Unrestricted *a.Coullty: Orange and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T ; R�; � 1/4 of � 1l4 of Sec � �B.M. C.AddreSs: 236 - S BATAVIA ST ,# Clty: OranQe Zlp: 92868 d.UTM: (Give more than one for large and/or linear resources)Zone ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: "P3a.DeSCI'IPtlOfl: (Describe resource and its major elemenfs.Inciude design,materials,condition,alterations,size,setting,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Mate1'lals: Frame - Stucco or plaster and wood sidinq One story multi-family residential property. Cross qable roof with composition shingles and wide eave overhangs with fascia. Combination of board and batten and plaster siding. Vinyl multi-light windows. Brick chimney on front elevation. Detached six car garage with metal roll-up doors at rear. `'P3b.Resource Attributes: (xP3)--Multiple famil�propertv (Lfst ariributes and codes) "P4.Resources Present: ❑d Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) "".�"" ",� � }��;� ",�--�.�."�N"��,' �� '` � p- P5b.Description of Photo: 2o1s � '� 6 9 d � �: � , ��, � � $ � (View,date,accession#) � r �b � '`P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: e6 k. �� d: � i" R� �� J � rr � � �; `�" r�' �� - 1963 � , �� ,.� � `�� `� ❑ Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both ^'� �,� .,�. - �'" �x '� „r -��;, *P7.Owner and Address: � � � , ..,i` -.�r.„;� .t .�Pr P { . .,�, ".� *P8:ROCO�ded by: (Name,afGliation,and address) � � , �` �•� Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuf£o ... -;t _ .. ,� _ 1 City of Orange CD Dept. ��: o- "� � ' ��' � �. ` ... ' �,._, -.-•-�....,,,�; � 300 E. Chapman Avenue ,,�' Orange, CA 92866 `� 1fr✓� - *P9.Date Recorded: *P11.Repolt Cltatlon: (Cite survey report and other sources,or enter"none.") April 2018 � Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018) . *P10.Survey Type: (oescribe) Reconnaissance *Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) � Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information � '+ �k'�� "�- ' � �t ' '�da. � a',� � � `"� *` ��sf ;t � � �` ��`� �` �'�� c� � State.ofCal�forn`ia 7he Resources Agenby� r�� ' � � Pr�mary# � - �"`�� ,� ��;_ � ° � � *� � � ��; � . DEPARTMEN OF PARKS AND RECREATION ¢ �� x� a� li�l##� ° `':� �`��.�� ,� �� , � � °� � �' � � �'��'� � *NRHP=Sfatus Code; ¢'�6z ` ` �^ � �` � �� BUILDIN�G;STRUG'�TURE,AND�OBJECT��ECORD� .��m u, � � .�, - � �� e.� ,� . _ ��,. .._ .��-��, � � �� Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA S_236 Aprr 041-064-47 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: B2.Common Name: 63.Original Use: REs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Architectural Style: Ranch *66.ConSt�uCtlo�Hlstory:�Construction date,atierations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 19 63 ❑ HlstOflC ❑ P�ehlStoflC ❑ Both Original windows replaced with vinyl. *B7.Moved7 ❑�/ No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: unknown *610.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: city of orange PropertyType: xesidence Period of Significance: None Applicable Criteria: N/A (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural conteM as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope.Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) St�UCtU�811�t0g�i�/: Good Condition — Minor chanqes to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities 611.Additional Resource Attributes: ��i5c attrib�ces ana�de5� *812.References: B13.Rema�ks: �Contlnues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment • of local Old Towne Historic District. . . . "614.Evaluatol': Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for oKcial comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information State of Cal�forn�a The Resources Agency �#� �� Primary# � �' - � : � DEPARTMENTrOF PARKS AND RECREATION . � `�� _� ��HRI# =� '�" ' a s ; `�, CONTIIdUATION SHEET �� "� � � � � � , -�. - ,. - � � ,.. ��. �Trinomial o1zA '� �,��, , .:: , . r .�� ..�_ , . x .�..m ,� . ,�.>., , � �t � .s- E . , ._ .. ,_ ,�,. :,', . . �' ,. `�. :, . . 5,.,; Page 3 of 3 *Resource Name or#: sATAviA s_236_APN_o41-064-47 (Assigned by Rewrder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo1'ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 s. chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 2018 Description of Photo: Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 2 Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: 1 Lot Acre: #of Units: 8 Principal Building Sqft: B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): 813.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information ` State of Cal�fori�ia The Resources qpency ' � Primary# 30-158710, 30 162093 a(Garage); 30 DEPARTMENT OF PARK$AND RECREATION � MRI#� 038076� `o638S0, .08385i1" � ` � �PRIMARY RECORD, - = Trinomia� o� ' � � .�� NRHP Stafus Cocle ls%SDl Ofh@[LiStIrlgS `,�NHU Pla�ue #N1:8.70 .(Re.f .#.94b00818)`= ,t :r.', Review Code �� :Reviewet ,��;:' `=Date ,;�, �_ Page 7 of 4 "RBSOU�C@ NeR1@ O�#: BATAVIA S_248_APN_041-064-12 (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: *P2.Location: ❑ Not for Publication ❑� Unrestricted *8.CoU�ty: Orange and (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: Date: T ; R ; 1/4 of 1l4 of Sec B.M. c.AddfeSs: 248 - S BATAVIA ST ,# City: Oran4e Zlp: 92868 d.UTflA: (Give more than one far large and/or linear resources)ZOIIe ' mE/ mN e.Other Locational Data: *PSB.D@SCI'IPtI0I1: (Describe resource and its major elemenis.Include design,materials,condition,alterations,size,settin9,and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.) Materials: Frame - stucco or plaster Large two-story estate home with box plan and sand finish plaster cladding. Flat roof with clay tile hip roof at parapet. Wood windows are placed regularly around the facade; some are sash windows; some are fixed pane, picture windows with decorative transoms. Main entry is via a stoop beneath a small porch centered on the facade. Main door is wide with fixed pane windows and side lights on either side. A variety of mature 'P3b.ResOu�Ce Attflbutes: (HP2), (HP4)--Single family property with caretaker's house and garage (List attributes and codes) � *P4.Resources Present: ❑d Building ❑ Structure ❑ Object ❑ Site ❑ Element of District ❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) � �r��,� � � .�� ,� � -�-- � � � � � �x , � , PSb.Description of Photo: 2018 a 1 �i� � (View,date,accession#) 4 �� '�� ,��..�a"�r+a��"."_`�j"f"�1"��'t��=-" ` \ k ��.�.��,�.y,..a,,`Kx.,;�ry.•r__.._i, ir�^t . * z.� ,� ��` �,x 3��s`#. � P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: ��ti r�^�� ,� ^�ya �" �� 1917 �'C `�� : �, �,°n �` � `��"' �. ��'�+� ��' ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both �`,$ .,,�„;�'-�:�.�"�. � . �r,<, �,� �:: �: �,��'j�� '"` �, *P7.Owner and Address: , > �8S''� � �� ` c; � '`1, `~ a�� ,, . � , �., � ;� � x �; t � ��: ;� '` � �� .�w4. "'��. > '��. Y�•r. �' *P8:R@COfded by' (Name,affilialion,and address) , w .._. ,..<.�.,.._. .. � ""'°° . ry Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo � � �. ' < k , - - City o£ Orange CD Dept. _ . 300 E. Chapman Avenue � ' Orange, CA 92866 *P9.Date Recorded: � *P11.RepO�Cl�tlOn: (Citesurveyreportandothersaurces,orenter"none.") ' Apiil 20'18 " Office of Historic Preservation (2011) Historic Properties Directory. Orange County Assessor Records (2010) . AEGIS (1991) Historic Building *p10.SurveyType' �oescribe) Inventory Update. Heritage Orange County, Inc. (1982) Orange Historic Survey. Reconnaissance "Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map ❑� Continuation Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Structure,and Object Record ❑ Archaeological Record ❑ District Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record ❑ Artifact Record ❑ Photograph Record ❑ Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) *Required Information .},� . � ��Y��.. .a+u( �~ �� '�S.1`�� ; 3 4 � v.....� . , .., �'+ �StateofCalifornia The°ResourcesAgency fi �� Primary# 30 ;15s710 �30 162093f (Garage).; 3o , -.�'.z��a��c�r� � '�i� �s � � k - ��u*�. ,;a=z'�., . �a�z x .e. � � DEPARTMENT OF PARKS/�ND RECREATION� � `�� HRI# � 038076, 083850 083851�1 � �BUILDING STRUCTURE,AND�OBJECT RECORD� *NRt�P Status ode �,ls/:sn`�� ' `� '�� ,�� -� �«� , ��,__�� >� _�� .�.. � ��r_�4, �. ��,- Page 2 of 4 "Resource Name or#• BATAvzA s_248 APN 041-064-12 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: Porter-French xouse B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: x�s B4.Present Use: �S *B5.ArChltectul'al Style: Mediterranean Revival "B6.ConSt�uCtlon HlStory:�Construction date,atlerations,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: 1917 ❑d HISto�IC ❑ P�ehlSto�IC ❑ Both "B7.Moved7 d❑ No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: unknown *B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: city of orange PropertyType: xesidence Period ofSignifcance: Earlv Settlement (c. 1s7o - 1920) Applicable Criteria: Asc (Discuss importance in terms of hislorical or architactural contaM as defined by theme,period,and geographic scope.Also address fntegrity. Continues on Pg.4.) StruCtu�allntegrity: Excellent Condition - Minor and reversible or appropriate changes to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities Original owners appear to have been John and Ora Lee Porter. Mr. Porter was a cashier with the National Bank of Orange. About 1940, the home was acquired by Judge French. David French became a resident of Orange in 1937 and served as City Attorney from 1946 until he was appointed to the Santa Ana/Orange Municipal Court bench in 1957 by Gov. Goodwin Knight. He was named to the Superior Court bench in August of 1966 and retired in November o£ that same year but seemed to serve an occasional assignment on the state judicial council. Among his other accomplishments was a term serving as trustee of the Orange Unified School District, secretary of the Orange County Municipal Water District and chairman of the Orange Red Cro'ss. Full history is contained in property's National Register designation form. B11.Additional Resource Attributes: �u5c an�b�ce5 ar,d oodes� *612.References: B73.Remarks: �co�a�ue5 on ay.3.� (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Added SD1. Separately listed in National Register. 2018 City Council-directed survey for.potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne • Historic District. "B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: Anril 2018 (This space reserved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) *Required Information -�StateofCalifornia TheResourcesAge�cy Pr�mary# 30158,730; 3o i62093 ;(carage}' ,30 ';DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREAT(ON HR�#' . 03&'0`76, 083850,'0838511 X CONTINUATION SHEET ' a Trinomial o� Page 3 of 4 "Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s_248 APN_041-064-12 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Oranqe, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 198� 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: 1993, 1994 General Plan: LMDx #of Buildings: 3 ��, � �-�,� � � �� Planning Zone: R-2-6 #of Stories: 2 � � �y + ,y � ��y T � � � ,� � �t �� Lot Acre: o.93 #of Units: 2 x �t �° )� ��a � *�`�S' ^ ��'� ��r Y�� r : �, �Y Principal Buiiding Sqft: 3318 �� $�� '�' � � - � �� '� � �.� � �, �� r s" `3 B6.Construction History(Continued from Pg.2): � p , ? � � . R � � L� � �\i �"; ..:. " h •,, .. � . ��(.., �� , B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): � �� '�' '" { y ;: �+.Ky��{��.eca'�,� d�.""r.fi�� f s'� a. �r, q x3 i$x��`� ��,�� M�""e�.�y$„.r.r.��ci�r�y,w�,..�'".r�r�,_�.�-, x'�� '�''-.�i. at"�� - *^�,.:- ,i�t• "„� � �`Y�L. P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): trees are located in the front and rear yards. Property also contains a historic Caretaker's House and Garage. See National Register designation Porm for more information. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information _ � :State of California�The Resou�ces Agency, < � �Pnmary�# 30;158710� 30 16'2093 (Garage>; 3D �DEPARTMENT OF PARKS 14ND RECREATfON ' f �IiRI#��. 036076, 083850 =08385�.7. .`:CONT,INUATION S�HEET, °` � Trmom(a�l � .oiz:a; � �� Page 4 of 4 "Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_248 APN_041-064-12 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 B10.Signiflcance(Continued from Pg.2): DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Information ZONE CHANGE NO. 1289-18 RESOLUTION NO. PC 26-18 A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSIOIlT RECOlVV�NIENDING CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF ZONE CHANGE NO. 1289-18 AND ADOPTION OF AN ORDINANCE TO EXPAND AN EXISTING HISTORIC DISTRICT OVERLAY ZONE TO ADD 12 PROPERTIES ON SOUTH BATAVIA STREET TO THE LOCAL OLD TOWNE HISTORIC DISTRICT AND UPDATE THE CITY OF ORANGE HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY APPLICANT: CITY OF ORANGE Moved by Commissioner Correa and seconded by Commissioner Gladson that the following resolution be adopted: WHEREAS, the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District were estaUlished by the City Council in Ordinance No. 38-88 as `Batavia Street on the west, Cambridge Street on the east,Walnut Avenue on the north, and La Veta Avenue on the south, including the Nutwood Tract on the south side of La Veta Avenue. The boundaries of the Old Towne Area shall run along the centerline of the designated streets and the borders of the Nutwood Tract"; and WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 15-98 ainended the local Old Towne Historic District boundaries at Walnut Avemie and Waverly Street to inatcl�the National Register of Historic Places Old Towne Historic Dist�-ict,designated in 1997.As established in OMC 17.17.030,the boundaries of the local Old Towne I-�istoric District are delineated on a map on file in the Planning Division of the City of Orange entitled "Old Towne Boundaries" as adopted under Ordinance 15-98; and WHEREAS, Orange Municipal Code (OMC) Chapter 17.17 establishes tl�at "application for a historic district shall comply with the zoning amendment procedure for a chaube in the zoning district classification upon designation approval by City Council as prescribed under OMC Section 17.10.020"; and WHEREAS, a historic district overlay zone includes additional regulations over the base zoning of a particular area to encourage historic preservation and complementary new development. The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne apply to all properties within the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District; and WHEREAS,the City Council directed the Cominunity Developinent Department Planning Division to proceed with expansion of the local Old Towne Historic District to include propei-ties on the west side of South Batavia Street in March 2018; and WHEREAS, eight properties on the west side of South Batavia Street were identified as historic resources in the City of Orange Historic Building Inventory completed in 1992; and ATTACHMENT NO. 2 PLANNING COMMISSION RESO. NO.PC 26-18 ZONE CHANGE N0. 1289-18 OCTOBER 9,2018 CC MTG Resolution No. PC 26-18 Page 2 of 5 WHEREAS, the City Council adopted the City of Orange 2010 Historic Resources Inventory Update,including the survey results from 1992,through Resolution No. 10426 in March 2010; and WHEREAS, in April 2018, Historic Preservation staff, meeting the SecYetan� of tlae Interiof-'s Pf-ofessiofial Qualifications Standards for architectural histoiy, suiveyed the area and determined that the 100 and 200 blocks of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of intact historic properties constructed prior to 1940 that ai•e eligible for inclusion in the local Old Towne Historic District; and WHEREAS, Historic Preseivation staff conducted community infoi-mation sessions for potentially affected property owners on June 27, 2018 and July 12, 2018; and WHEREAS, under OMC Section 17.10.020, the PlannYng Commission shall hold at least one public hearing on a Zoning Ordinance Ainendment and shall make a recommendation to the City Council on the request; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission, having considered the proposed Ordinance and Zone Change at a public hearing held on August 20,2018, including review of the staff report and having received public testimony on the item,has detennined the proposed amendment is justified and recommends approval thereof. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Planning Commission recommends the City Council approve the subject Ordinance and Zone Change, as depicted on inaps and historic resource survey fonns included in Attachment A to this Resolution based on the following findings: SECTYON 1- FINDINGS General ]Plan The project achieves goals of the General Plan Cultural Resources and Historic Preservation Element and the Implementation Program. The expansion of the Historic District's boundaries � provides long-tenn assurance that additional historic properties will be used, maintained, and rehabilitated in confonnance with the Sec�-etary of the InterioY's Staszdard.s foN the TYeatment of Historic PYoperties (SOI Standaf-ds). Projects in the local Historic District are reviewed for conformance with the Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne,which are consistent with and reference the SOI Standczrds. Projects found in conforniaiice with the Historic Preservation Design Standards are generally in confonnance with the SOI Sta�zdards. Inclusion in the local Historic District also provides access to incentives for preservation including the Mills Act Progratn and California Historical Building Code. Consistent with the General Plan Implementation Program for Historic, Cultural, and Archaeological Resources Surveys, the expansion of the Historic District's boundaries recognizes a sinall concentration of historic resources that reflects a unique sense of tiine and place and establishes a design review process for its protection. Resolution No. PC 26-18 Page 3 of 5 Historic District Criteria for Establishment(OMC 17.17.050) An histoyic �listYict rrzay be establislted to �f�eserve lan.drnarks aiid af•eas exenzplaYy of architectural, arclzaeolooical, c�tltu��al, eco��ornic, sociczl, or historical value if�the lanclrnaYk or af•ea rneets tlze follotivi�ig CYZ1G'YZCI: A. The r•esozsr•ce ea:erra�lifies of� r�eflects special element.s of the City's czcltural, social, ecorion2ic,political, aesthetic, engineef�i�tg, CIYCllltG'Ctlfi'QI 03')1CltllYCll j2ISt01 y C112L��70SSBSSeS arr irategYity of locatioya, design, setting, nzczteyials, woykrraa�zslzip,feeli�zg �rad association; arrd 1. It etnbodies distinctive char•acte��istics of a style, type, pe�•iod o7� method of C012SLYLIC/1011, or is a valuable e.xa»zple of tlae use of i�zdigenous rncztef•ials oy crcrftsnzansltip; or� 2. It contribzrtes to the Slol?lficai2ce of czn historic a��ea, bei�Zg a geogrcz�hically defi�aable c�rea possessirzg a conce��.trcztio�z of histof-ic or• scenic pT•operties o� tl7ernatically r•elated girouping of proper•ties tivJ�ich coritribicte to eaclt otl7e�•a�zd at-e u�zified aestl�etically, by plan or pl�ysical developmeizt; o�� 3. It f•eflects sigrtificant geograpliical patte��ris, ifzclicding those associated wit1� differe»t eras of settlenzent aiid growth, particular tYanspoy�tatioi2 rnodes, or distiizctive exa�nples of pa��Ic or conirnz.cnit}�planning; or 4. It er�ibodies eleri�.efits of architectic��al design, detail, naaterials, o�� craftsynanslzip that represe�zt a sig�zificant structzcral oJ�architecticral achievernent or inizovation; OY �. It has cz i.��aiqzre locatioh o�" SI71gZ[IpY 1JI1)�SlCQI CT'IQYCICtG'YZStlC OY lS Cl VZ2i1� oY vista j•epresentin� a.ri establishecl a�zd farat.iliar- visical featt.cre of a �ieighbot-hood, cor�imunity oj� the City of O�ange. The local Old Towne Historic District embodies the cultural and architectural history of late 19`l'and early 20t"ccntury Orange County.The Historic District represents the original residential cominunity, central business district, and industria] area of Orange with historic buildings dating from the 1880s through 1940. The primarily gridded street pattern, oriented to the cardinal directions, has been maintained with two lane streets, parkways with street trees, and consistent front yards. The hot�ses throughout the Historic District represent the popular residential architectural styles of the period,inchiding Folk Victorian, Craftsinan, Tudor Revival, and Spanish Colonial Revival. The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of residences representiiig the themes of early development and growth of the City of Orange, consistent with the existing Historic District. The houses are distinetive examples of the architectural styles prevalent in the Old Towne Historic District. These blocks, combined with the east side of South Batavia Street within the Old Towne Historic District, have a high degree of integrity of design,setting,materials,workma�ship,feeling and association. Of the 12 properties proposed for inclusion in the Historic District, 11 are contributing historic properties. The one non-contributing property was constructed after 1940, outside Resolution No. PC 26-18 Page 4 of 5 of the period of significance for the Historic District. Including these properties within the boundaries of the Old Towne Historic District will protect these historic resources and the Historic District as a whole froin incoinpatible chan�es that alter the character of the historic neighborhood. B. It is one of the few reynaini�zg examples i» the City, 1'LalOyl, state, or• ization. posse,SSl110 distir�.gz[ishi�zg chaf-czcteristics of a�z czr�chitectuYal or laistorical type, or�specirneti; oY The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street are characteristic of the historical development and architectural styles of the City of Orange froiil the late 19th and early 20t�' cent�iries. This area is contiguous with and represents the same distinguishing characteristics and themes as the Old Towne Historic District, which is one of the few remaining intact historic downtowns from this period in Orange County. C. It is identi�ed with.pe�so�zs oy-events sigriificant in local, state or�i�atioTzal history; or The Old Towne Historic District was originally designated as a representation of the broad pattenis of development in the history of Orange, rather than for its association with a specific event or person. This criterion does not apply. D. It is rep��esentative of t7�e wo��1c of a rTotable builder•, desigJier or•at�chitect. The buildings throughout the Historic District are vernacular e�:ainples of late 19`�' and early 20`�' century architect�u•al styles and are rarely identifiable as the work of a specific builder, designer, or architect. This criterion does not apply. SECTION 2-ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW The historic district overlay zone is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines 15308 (Class 8 — Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment) and 15331 (Class 31 — Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation). The overlay zone is established for the protection of historic resources and nlakes no changes to the land uses pennitted by the base zoning. The regulatory process for projects within the historic district overlay zone involves review to ensure conforniance with the Secretary of th.e Iflterio��'s Sta�zdaYds_foi- the Treatment of Historic PropeYties (SOI Stafzdards). The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, required for projects within the Historic District, are consistent with and incorporate the SOI Stafzdards. Expansion of the overlay zone ensures that additional historic resources and the Old Towne Historic District as a whole will be preserved and protected froin changes that may affect the integrity of its historic character, design, materials, and features. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Planning Commission recommends that the City's "Old Towne Boundaries"map adopted in OMC 17.17.030 be ainended to depict the change in the local Old Towne Historic District boundaries established by Zone Change No 1289-18 as shown on maps in Attachment A and that the City's Historic Resources Inventory be updated to include the historic resources survey foniis in Attachment A. I hereby certify that the Planning Coinmission of the City of Orange adopted the foregoing resolution on August 20, 2018 by the following vote: Resolution No. PC 26-18 Page 5 of 5 AYES: Commissioners Glasgow, Simpson, Correa, Gladson, and Willits NOES: None ABSTAIN: None ABSENT: None � � � � . �,�-�/ ;'�� ;' 'est . Glasgow, Planning Commission Chair � ?Gj _. ZOi � Date A':\CDD\PI.NG\Applications�Zone ChangesVC 1289-18 Old Towne Boundnry Adjustment\PC Reso.docx G,��°,��Q� Planning Commission *: :* °� �` Agenda Item ��5 c�� August 20, 2018 TO: Chair Glasgow and Members of the Planning Commission THRU: Anna Pehoushek� Assistant Community Development Director FROM: Marissa Moshier� Historic Preservahon Planner SUBJECT PUBLIC HEARING: �Zone Change No. 1289-18 to expand an existing historic distxict overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia Street to the local Old Towne Historic District. In conjunction with the overlay zone, the City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory wili be updated to reflect the inclusion of these properties. SUMMARY The City of Orange is proposing to expand the boundary of the local Old Towne Historic District (Historic District)to include 12 properties in the 100 and 200 block on the west side of S. Batavia Street. The Historic District boundary is currently the centerline of Batavia Street. Under Orange Municipal Code Chapter 17.17, historic district designation is processed as an overlay zone with protections for lustoric resources added to the base zoning. The following properties are proposed to be added to the Historic District: 134 S. Batavia Street 204 S. Batavia Street 140 S. Batavia Street 210 S. Batavia Street 1S2 S. Batavia Street 220 S.Batavia Street 158 S. Batavia Street 224 S. Batavia Street 164 S. Batavia Street 236 S. Batavia Street 176 S, Batavia Street 248 S. Batavia Street RECOMMENDED ACTION 1) Adopt Planning Commission Resolution No. PC 26-18 entitled: A RESOLUTION OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDING CITY COUNCIL APPROVAL OF ZONE_____ ____ ____ -_-- ATTACHMENT NO. 3 PLANNING COIVIIVIISSION STAFF REPOIZT DATED 8/20/18 ZONE CHANGE N0. 1289-18 � OCTOBER 9,2018 CC MTG Planning Commission Staff Report August 20,2018 Page 2 CHANGE NO. 1289-18 AND ADOPTION OF AN ORDINANCE TO EXPAND AN EXISTING IiISTORIC DISTRICT OVERLAY ZONE TO ADD 12 PROPERTIES ON SOUTH SATAVIA STREET TO THE LOCAL OLD TOWNE HISTORIC DISTRICT AND UPDATE THE �CITY OF ORANGE HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY AUTHORIZATION/GUIDELINES Orange Municipal Code(OMC}Section 17.10.020 requires City Council approval of arnendments to the Zoning Map and establishes procedures by which the Planning Commission reviews such amendments and makes recommendations to the City Council.OMC Section 17.17.050 establishes the procedure and criteria for designation of locail historic districts. � PY.IBLIC NOTICE � On June 19, 2018, letters were mailed directly to property owners inviting them to participate in an informational meeting about the proposed Historic District boundary change on June 27 with Planning staff at the Orange Civic Center. A second letter was mailed on July 3 inviting property owners to an additional meeting on July 12. Six property owners representing five afi'ected properties attended the meeting on July 12. Staff has had phone conversations with two additional property owners. Public notice of the Planning Commission hearing on the proposed zone change was published in the Orange City News newspaper on August 9, 2018. A total of 278 notices were mailed to the owners and occupants of affected properties and owners and occupants of properties within 300 feet of the affected properties. Notices were also posted at the subject blocks of South Batavia Street,the Civic Center,and Library posting locations. ENVIItONMENTAL REVIEW The historic district overlay zone is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines 15308 (Class 8 — Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment) and 15331 (Class 31 — Historical Resource Restoration/Itehabilitation).The overlay zone is established for the protection of historic resources and makes no changes to the land uses permitted by the base zoning. The regulatory process for projects within the historic district overlay zone involves review to ensure conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, required for projects within the Historic District, are consistent with and incorporate the SOI Standards. Expansion of the overlay zone ensures that additional historic resources and the Old Towne Historic District as a whole will be preserved and protected from changes that may affect the integrity of its historic chazacter, design,materials,and features. Planning Commission Staff Report August 20,2018 Page 3 PROJECT BACKGROUND The local Old Towne Historic District(Historic District)was established to recognize and protect the unique buildings, features, and character of Orange's historic commercial downtown and surrounding residential neighborhood. The boundaries of the local Historic District were established in Ordinance No. 38-88, adopted by City Council in 1988, as "Batavia Street on the west,Cambridge Street on the east,Walnut Avenue on the north,and La Veta Avenue on the south, including the Nutwood Tract on the south side of La Veta Avenue. The boundaries of the Old Towne Area shall run along the centerline of the designated streets and the borders of the Nutwood Tract."In 1998,the boundary of the Historic District was revised on Walnut Avenue and Waverly Street to match the National Register of Historic Places Old Towne Historic District designated in 1997. The initial boundary was drawn to encompass roughly a square mile azound the Plaza, plus the Nutwood Tract. The centerline of Batavia Street is the western boundary of the Historic District. In the City's 1991 Historic Resources Inventory, several houses on the west side of South Batavia Street were identified as historic resources. However, these houses were not included within the Historic District boundary and aze not protected by design standards for the Historic District. Following Council direction in March 2018, Historic Preservation staff investigated the potential of expanding the Historic District to include the west side of South Batavia Street. In Apri12018, staff surveyed the properties in the 100 and 200 blocks of South Batavia Street.The survey found that the houses identified as historic resources in the 1991 Inventory retained their historic chazacter and that additional houses not previously identified could be considered historic resources eligible for inclusion in the local Historic District. Staff also surveyed properties in the 900 block of West Almond Avenue and the 100 block of South Citrus Street. However, there was not a sufficient concentration of historic properties in these blocks to justify including them in the Historic District. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The west side of South Batavia Street contains a concentration of historic properties representing the historical themes of eazly development and growth of the City of Orange, consistent with the existing local Old Towne Historic District. The City of Orange is proposing to expand the local Old Towne Historic District boundary to add 12 properties in the 100 and 200 blocks of South Batavia Street. Eleven of the properties are historic contributing properties. One property is non- contributing because it was constructed after the Historic District's period of significance (1888- 1940). Maps in Attachment 1 —Exhibit B show the proposed new Historic District boundary. Zone Change No. 1289-18 consists of a historic district overlay zone added to these properties to include them in the Historic District. The action includes updating the City's Historic Resources Planning Commission Staff Report August 20,201 S Page 4 Inventory to include survey forms identifying the 12 properties. These survey forms are included in Attachment 1 —Exhibit C. APPLICATION(S)REQUESTED/REQUIRED FINDINGS Zone Change/Ordinance Amendment.Zone Change No. 1289-18 will expand the local Historic District boundary to include 12 properties on the west side of South Batavia Street. The historic district designation is a zone overlay added to the properties' base zoning. Required Findings: There are no required findings for an Ordinance Amendment or Zone Change since it is considered a legislative action. However, OMC Section I7.10.020 requires that when the Planning Commission makes a recommendation to the City Council, the Planning Commission include in its decision: 1) the reasons for the recommendation; 2)the relationship of the proposed amendment to the General Plan and applicable Specific Plans; and 3) the environmental deternnination. These three items are addressed in the Planning Commission Resolution. By adopting the Resolution, the Planning Commission will have complied with this Code provision. Historic District Designation (OMC 17.17.050). An historic district may be established to preserve landmarks and areas exemplary of architectural, archaeological, cultural, economic, social, or historical value if the landmark or area meets the following criteria: A. The resource exempli�es or reflects special elements of the City's cultural, social, economic,political, aesthetic, engineering, architectural or natural history and possesses an integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship,feeling and association; and 1. It embodies distinctive characteristics of a style, type, period or method of construction, or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship; or 2. It contributes to the significance of an historic area, being a geographically defirrable area possessing a concentration of'lhistoric or scenic properties or thematically related grouping of properties which contribute to each other and are unified aesthetically, by plan or physical development; or 3. It reflects significant geographical patterns, including those associated with different eras of settlement and growth, particular transportation modes, or distinctive examples of park or community planning; or 4. It embodies elements of architectural desigrr, detail, materials, or craftsmanship that represent a significant structural or architectural achievement or innovation; or 5. It has a unique location or singular physical characteristic or is a view or vista representing an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood, communiry or the City of Orartge. Planning Commission Staff Report August 20,2018 Page 5 B. It is one of the few remaining examples in the City, region, state, or nation possessing distinguishing characferistics of an architectz+ral or historical rype, or specimen; or C. It is identified with persons or events significant in local, state or national history; or D. It is representative of the work of a notable builder, designer or architect. ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Issue 1: Historic District Desisnation The local 41d Towne Historic District embodies the cultural and azchitectural history of late 19�' and eazly 20�' century .Orange County. The Historic District represents the original residential community,central business district, and industrial azea of Orange with historic buildings dating from the 1880s through 1940. The primarily gridded street pattem, oriented to the cardinal directions, has been maintained with two Iane streets, parkways with street trees, and consistent front yazds. The houses throughout the Historic District represent the populaz residential azchitectural styles of the period,including Folk Victorian,Craftsman,Tudor Revival,and Spanish Colonial Revival. It is one of the few remaining intact historic downtowns from this period in Orange County. The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street aze characteristic of the historical development and azchitectural styles of the City of Orange from the late 19�' and early 20�' centuries.This area is contiguous with and represents the same distinguishing characteristics and themes as the Old Town.e Historic District.The houses are distinctive examples of the azchitectural styles prevalent in the Old Towne Historic Dishict. These blocks, combined with the east side of South Batavia Street within the 41d Towne Historic District, have a high degree of integrity of design, setting,materials,workmanship,feeling and association. Of the 12 properties proposed for inclusion in the Historic District, 11 are contributing historic properties. The one non-contributing property was constructed after 1940,outside of the period of significance for the Historic District. The non-contributing property was included within the proposed boundary expansion, because it occurs mid-block and is flanked by two historic . properties that could be affected by major changes to the property. With expansion of the historic district overlay zorie,the Historic Preservation Design Standazds for Old Towne will apply to these properties,consistent with all properties in the Historic District. Changes to the exterior of the properties will be reviewed by staff or the Design Review Committee for conformance with the Design Standards. Expanding the boundaries of the Historic District protects these historic resources and the Historic District as a whole from incompatible changes that alter the chazacter of the historic neighborhood. Changes to interiors are not regulated by the Design Standards. The Design Standazds only apply when a property owner.is proposing a change to their home. They do not apply retroactively and do not require property ovmers to proactively make changes to their properties. Contributing historic properties within the Historic District may use the California Historical Building Code to address building code requirements in a way that does not affect the chazacter of Planning Commission Staff Report August 20,2018 Page 6 the historic property. Contributing properties also are eligible to apply for Mills Act Contracts, which provides a property tax reduction in exchange for an agreement to rehabilitate and preserve a historic property Issue 2: Public Commeut StafFheld two property owner information sessions and mailed notices to property owners prior.to sending out regular notification of the Planning Commission public hearing, as described in the "Public Notice"section of this report. The meetings were intended to allow City stafFto present information on how a change in zoning. could affect a property and get property owner feedback on the proposal. No property owners attended the meeting on June 27. Five property owners attended the meeting on July 12. Staff also received phone calls from two additional property owners.Property owners asked questions about the requirements of the Historic Preservation Design Standazds, design review for projects in the Historic District, the effects of the overlay zone on existing base zoning, and the Mills Act Program. The majority of property owners expressed support for the boundary expansion. Some property owners were neutral but did not express opposition to the proposal.No additional responses were received at the time of publication of this staff report. ADVISORY BOA,RD RECOMMENDATIO�T The proposed Zone Change does not involve a specific development project,so it was not reviewed by other staff departments or the Design Review Comtnittee. ATTACHMENTS/EXHIBITS Attachments to Report: 1. Planning Commission Resolution No. PC 26-18 1-A. Draft Ordinance Exhibit A: Existing Local Old Towne Historic District Bour�dary Map Exhibit B: Proposed Local Old Towne Historic District Boundary Maps Exhibit C: Historic Resources Survey Fornns for Properties on South Batavia Street N:1CDD�PLNG�ApplicationslZone Changes�ZC 1269-18 Old Towne Boundnry Adjustmenl�PC StaFf Report_2015-08-20.docx Planning Commission August 20,2018 3. NEW HEARING: 3.1 OLD TOWNE HISTORIC DISTRICT BOUNDARY ADJUSTMENT The City of Orange is proposing to expand the boundary of the local 0[d Towne Historic District (Historic District) to include 12 properties in the 100 and 200 block of south Batavia Street. The Historic District boundary is currently the centerline of Batavia Street.Under Orange Municipal Code Chapter 17.17,Historic District designation is processed as an overlay zone with protections for historic resources added to the base zoning.The following properties are proposed to be added to the Historic District. � LOCATION: 134 S_Batayia Street 20�S.Batavia Street 140 S_Batavia Street 210 S_Batati�ia Street 152 S_Batavia Street 220 S.BataVia Street 158 S_Bata�ia Street 224 S_Batayia Street 164 S_Batayia Street 236 S.BataVia Street 176 S_BataVia Street � 248 S_Batavia Street NOTE: The Historic District overlay zone is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines 15308 (Class 8 — Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment) and 15331 (Class 31 —Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation).The overlay zone is established for the protection of historic resources and makes no changes to the land uses permitted by the base zoning. The regulatory process for projects within the Historic District overlay zone involves review to ensure conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, required for projects within the Historic District, are consistent with and incorporate the SOI Standards. Expansion of the overlay zone ensures that additional historic resources and the Old Towne Historic District as a whole will be preserved and protected from changes that may affect the integrity of its historic character, design, materials, and features. RECOMMENDED ACTION: Adopt Planning Commission Resolution PC No. 26-18. Approval of Zone Change No. 1289-18 and adoption of an ordinance to expand an existing Historic District overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia Street to the local Old Towne Historic District and update the Ciiy of Orange historic resources inventory.. Marissa Moshier, Historic Preservation Plartner provided an overview of the boundary expansion consistent with the staff report. Commissioner Simpson asked staff to explain the Council's initial direction on this matter of being in the Historic District and the Mills Act designations are to property owners. Ms. Moshier responded that Council directed staff to specifically look at the 100 and 200 blocks of Batavia due to the concentration of noteworthy historic residences and to bring forward a proposal for the expansion of the Historic District. ATTACHMENT NO. 4 2 PLANNING COMMISSION MINiJTES DATED 8/20/18 ZONE CHANGE N0. 1289-18 OCTOBER 9,2018 CC MTG . Planning Commission August 20, 2018 She described the City's Mills Act program and the potential reduction in property taxes it offers. She also noted that in the Historic District the properties are allowed to use the California Historical Building Code which provides relief from the State's standard energy code and allows flexibility to preserve historic features that might otherwise be affected by the Standard Building Code. Commissioner Simpson asked why those particular properties were not originally included in the designation. Ms.Moshier responded that there is nothing specific in the record as to why the boundary was drawn at the centerline of Batavia. Her impression from reviewing the original Council resolution was that the City simply wanted to recognize a square mile around the Plaza.. She stated there are also a handful of historic resources around the edges of the local Historic District boundary that could also be considered for an expansion; however staff received specific direction from the Council to move forwazd with this particular boundary change at this time. Commissioner Correa asked why those particular homes were left out of the City's 1991 survey and registration. Ms. Moshier responded there are homes that are scattered throughout the City that are recognized as being historic resources and are included in the list of City's inventory. The homes on the west side of Batavia were part of that inventory; she's not sure why they were not included in the Historic District at the time that the boundary was created. Commissioner Correa asked what criteria are used to determine that a home is historic. Ms. Moshier responded that the Orange Municipal Code has a section related to Historic Districts which lays out specific criteria. Generally, they are properties that are related to history, an event, a person or is an important architectural style. In the Old Towne Historic District,the criteria are related to the early development of Orange as a town;and commercial downtown and the residential area�hat was developed in the 20th century. It is also related to the architectural styles that were prevaIent in the late 19th century and early 20th century. Commissioner Conea asked how Mills Act contracts are monitored,if there is a specific timeframe for the property owner to make renovations, and what the City does if the owner fails to meet his contractual obligations. Ms. Moshier responded that there is an exhibit attached to the Mills Act contract that sets a timeline for a specific set of repairs;at the beginning of the year a reporting form is mailed to the owners to ask them what has been done in the prior year; and State law requires staff to do an inspection once every five years. If a person fails to keep up with the agreement,staff works closely with the owner to bring them into compliance. If compliance is not met,the City Council has the authority to cancel the coniract and there is a 12'/z%penalty of the fair market value of the property if canceled;staff has never gotten to that point with any of the owners. Commissioner Willits asked what the historic building survey process consisted of. 3 , Planning Commission August 20,201 S Ms. Moshier responded it was a survey taEcen in the public right-of-way from the sidewalk, exterior building photographs and a written architectural description. A survey code is also assigned indicating . whether or not it is e(igible to be a contributor to the Historic Disfict. Commissioner Gladson confirmed that this is just a step to acknowledge that they are in the Historic District of Old Towne. Ms.Moshier stated there is one property that is separately listed in the National Register. Chair Glasgow added that as a non-contributor the owner of 236 S.Batavia St.needs to be made aware that he needs to follow the standards and realize what they can and cannot do. Chair Glasgow opened the public comment portion of the meeting;seeing no one approached he closed the public comment period. All of the Commissioners agreed this has been a long time coming and thanked staff for tying up the loose ends as these are alI beautiful homes and should have been included from the beginning. A motion was made to Adopt Planning Commission Resolution 26-18.Approval of Zone Change No. 1289-18 and adoption of an ordinance to expand an existing Historic District overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia Street to the local Old Towne Historic District and update the City of Orange historic resources inventory. MOTION: Commissioner Correa SECOND: Commissioner Gladson AYES: Commissioners Glasgow, Gladson Simpson, Willits and Correa NOES: None ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None MOTYON CARRIED. 3.2 ZONE ORDINANCE LAND USE MATRIX AND USE STANDARD CONSOLIDATION(CITYWIDE) The City of Orange is proposing to consolidate multiple existing land use matrices, special use standazds, conditional use standards, prohibited uses, and standards for unlisted uses for all land use . sections of Title 17.(the Zoning Code). This proposed ordinance establishes a single Master Land Use Matrix, reorganizes existing Code content and serves to promote ease of use and elimination of redundancy. Limited new supplemental text is incorporated to clarify City policy regarding table content and incorporates supplemental text to clarify City policy regarding table content. LOCATION: CITYWIDE NOTE: The proposed Ordinance is not a project under the Califomia Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) pursuant to the definition of a project provided in Section 15378(b)(5) of State CEQA Guidelines because the activity undertaken is consolidation and clarification of existing land use tables and use standards text. The activity will not result in direct or indirect physical changes in the environment. No public review is required. 4 CITY COUNCIL MINUTES OCTOBER 9, 2018 11 PUBLIC HEARINGS 11.1 Old Towne Historic District Boundary Adjustment Zone Change No. 1289-18. (Z1500.0) Time set for a public hearing to consider Zone Change No. 1289-18 to expand an existing historic district overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia Street to the local Old Towne Historic District. With the overlay zone, the City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory will be updated accordingly to reflect the status of these properties. Historic Planner Marissa Moshier provided the staff report. She noted that the majority of the property owners are in support of the boundary adjustment. The Mayor opened the Public Hearing; there being no speakers, the Mayor closed the Public Hearing. Ordinance No. 12-18 (First Reading) An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Orange approving a Zone Change to expand an existing historic district overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia Street to the local Old Towne Historic District and update the City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory. MOTION —Smith SECOND —Alvarez AYES —Alvarez, Whitaker, Smith, Murphy,Nichols � Moved to approve Ordinance No. 12-18 for First Reading and same was set for Seconding Reading by the proceeding vote. 11.2 Nutwood Tract Zone Change No. 1288-18. (Continued from September 11, 2018) (Z1500.0) Time set for a public hearing to consider Zone Change No. 1288-18 to rezone select properties in the Nutwood Tract to Single Family Residential (R-1-6) and Office Professional (OP) to establish consistency with the Low Density Residential and Neighborhood Office Professional General Plan land use designations in accordance with state law. The subject Zone Change addresses certain properties presently developed with single-family residences on the 500-block of S. Orange Street and S. Grand Street between E. La Veta Avenue and E. River Avenue and a professional office at 503 S. Glassell Street. Associate Planner Kelly Ribuffo presented the staff report and answered Council's questions regarding the property at 225 E.River. If left out of the zone change,there would be an inconsistency between the General Plan and zoning. CommuniTy Development Assistant Director Anna Pehoushek explained that if the property was to be removed from the proposed zone change, Council could make a General Plan Amendment in the future in order to resolve the inconsistency. There are other approaches staff could also take to make the General Plan and zoning consistent. PAGE 11