Loading...
08-21-19 278 N. Harwood Street- Ruppe Residence (DRC 4972-19)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM AUGUST 21, 2019 R RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION rviEurtnAmarrittyglArhi8arwtLtyal6u/lFami654Frygamiwi+/34F48F8//N Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 2 of8 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation Design, Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. PROJECT DESCRIPTION Conditions: in Wamai,;angarwiHrvgnarOwnOranMuniRecommendations: 1ununtp.Nary Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 3 o/8 EXISTING SITE rtyrigriyalrsfraymCurrngrahofthertyhirtTblocanyhirigrrtEXISTING AREA CONTEXT jrtyrthkthraonNHtrbtwEPalEMnalaryrtzhrtarpmariyamiyurrunthirtqdranof thOwnririEVALUATION CRITERIA MuniC(MC) 117gnral rRC should jThin: jrn, gn m, crflcd ih: 1. Architectural Features. turturflar tyri Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 4 of8 ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation w,rnersepcywignrgqirMOMC7090thifrararel60%fryardrikn­caxumaryar"HRB"sarsrvqfrfrmssg:"Ririnsrifturfi Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 5 o/8 30A5101x3hbnrpniunfiurrun,rignalrADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION jrySTAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS urt"F"conakakAak"akFin,"drawthrfy(,,rtnmenalum)unrtp,wingthalaki",t Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 6 o/8 G. l). 2nnyNaRgtr,pwcanguMC7.10.00.G.2).S'arfoh,3pjgnupuntyuguofnally,grsscdopeificpl,ppgna,nrqufing.070.G.3).isPagnawithpprty.4Fnfivp,apifintyaInfillRetGu,nstruu()rnablwthcl,massng, Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 7 o/8 orientation, and articulation of the surrounding development and will preserve or enhance existing neighborhood character (OMC 17.10. 070. G.4). RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS in EMS7086PannunPwi25rthnium3wwiflrth6Irrgultrturauasrifini7aftau8PriturnrfiWamo;wiriPrvgnSanOMun Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 80/8 ATTACHMENTS :arrittyarritty@gmailomourtnurtny@trufonmN :\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4972-19 Ruppe Residence \ I I I I I I I I I I I J I I I I I I Vicinity Map DRC No. 4972-19 Ruppe Residence 278 N. Harwood Street 261 N W�. E ORANGE= CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE � YELLOW= NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE s CITY OF ORANGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ATIACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4972-19; RUPPE RESIDENCE VICINITY MAP August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting � � -. . tll'-0- i14'-1° ARCHITECTURE 10540TalberlA-Sull175 Fou-V-,.-!1271l1 Tel (9491515-8600 -�-­ Coil,rlQht o 2011 ........ A--,.tn PUC ....__ ....., I�;!�l!I I :�11!ili Ii f11ilHIHH; 1, 1,1�11:11 I 0 n !1-- !l 11 �,,� 11iilll1· I ii�,�§�� en m •!:j! <; .. !l �; ; jd&i § =i i,·· !!: � � -·· !i ; s::: =r .... � : Cl B �� . 0 11�=��� §i 5�� m ;18� n • ! -< i:I § z r >=>Si m;.ijlj a i!! iii �; u� P =i J�1. i- � i!! I iii .,, 6 li!ll ill I e f4:t meif��i : i':1 11 i'lii 0 z � I 'I �� ";� :::0 z ii I . �11 s::: i ·1 � 0 � I I�� -I R 6 m I en !I n z I .. 278 N HARWOOD STREET ORANGE, CA 92888 RUPPE RESIDENCE RESIDENTIAL ADDITION ! 1l u ; l,>1,>l,>&,[,:,S, � ! ! u u � i'I � ';! Ill� ,: � "' a � � u i i q� I q � N � � t � ! !, H � �m 1:1 ;11 !I r u !f' I � I 11 "'I "' ::0 hi ; e! .i,;i f � � � 0 ,J ii ii!i ; � 0 Ii Si 1: i : 0 •• "Tl � � � "Tl )> en E o s m � ::0 5 � ::0 0 :;;,;; m 0 0 � I .. i I: i ·- !�I -� )> ' i ; I �� ,..::: s:: l!I a l!I e! en � I i I ii � m I .. II Si � 0) � ; I\J !:; "' ::0 fl I � I � a � � ij � Ci) : 0 ! m -e )> Ii CJJ q -I � z -I s: m 0 ::0 m 5 -I s ::0 r- 0 0 0 � I .. i I: �� � )> ' I I I :,:� s:: l!I l!I il en � I � I � a I .. II � (,.) "' ::0 � g •• "Tl .., )> q -I � m OD .i:,.. i � r�r i � ir 1u; 1 �i � I i11 .. ""C •sl ,11 i e! i .. ""C : 0 : 0 1: ijfl 6 )> ijfl e: I ii 6 )> i Iii . r- Iii hie Si . r- � � z z l 0 0 0 0 � :E � I r- � r- 0 m ::0 u ii �q q I iP at � �d I a a �:; �u l,>l,>l,>[:l>[:l>� I> p =, =, � � Ui al ili ::t < .. "r, m < RUPPE RESIDENCE RESIDENTIAL ADDITION 278 N HARWOOO STREET ORANGE, CA 92868 Ms!QiUlaD AR.CHITECTUR.E 10540T-A-,Sulle175 F...-Y*f,Cllb*ll270B Tel (949) 515-9600 -�-""" C.S,,.t.;,t O 2011 U......, A--1n PIJ.C LETTER OF EXPLANATION Approved Conditions for 278 N Harwood Street Orange, CA CONDITIONS: o a,b o O o O o ,qgg,yanee-ATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4972-19; RUPPE RESIDENCE LETTER OF EXPLANATION August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting 17 .14.160.A o O epmprtyliRe.b.ryuyuyiiidritririd,uhagg,okp,g,dcessryructurdrmittdxttpryrty(40) pcrqrrrdrAse,miRim1:1mfkiprxtdpydrrykrrudddpcdrpryuuryigcdrkdpuuf. ri,ikreq1:1reensferprinsp1:1ileing.o Wtcom{)p,capprtylcggsbbscover40%)Opjcpprty-scbutd4" bycodfpprtylrgim(o). Wcadperty p)Tggs1 O . fppce ta{. Toortsgxs. O ee6Nooeeedeit6Ndyg7,019.PGCBff,Nk"pMB,hbFNtaedcyd1#2 #9 *Newvbivlu#9 1Thispchh,pieCgyOodes/Tltle4,eheei AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM AUGUST 7, 2019 .TpprtytririurwithinOdTwnHRECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION SgnmmttvpdpjjtthfindggnvwandfdHrirvagnSddOTwn.BACKGROUND INFORMATION Own:urtnyanAmypOwn:arrArhi:ganArhiprtyL:278.HarwdStrG:Lwtyal-6u/ZniCfi:SgF1-6Egm:95SFrygfcwi+/3SFaprtySz::rvw:Em:,78SFNNIA ATIACHMENT NO. 5 DRC NO. 4972-19; RUPPE RESIDENCE DRC STAFF REPORT FROM 08/07/19 REGULAR MEETING August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 2 of8 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. PROJECT DESCRIPTION 6z,ludiFlrArRFA) Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 3 of8 EXISTING SITE EXISTING AREA CONTEXT EVALUATION CRITERIA fl:1. Architectural Features. hiturturfltyfyturqtyvhiurty2. Landscape. yp,pal'vpLtruvtyqbtrutripmity.Laku Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 4 o/8 ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation & :•trutururiqturoniri;•truturrtyriryyptriFurtoarthiturvvnfijur Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 5 o/8 0:"jsbunrtaksuhaannfurmgrisripprtnmwuniai"pniffsand90OI,s,angnbpprtyvsbflsm,thleoggtwgnrpphhhou.rvmmpprtsTwngPDgnsturg rvgnfi Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 6 of8 ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS ,asarrmaodsgnrv:G. l). pppjfrmwigqrthDwi#ft'StigwiannwirutumalgriturcatwvNHarwStr.wwi#910fanapofrmtyorivptrfrgrity . 2yNRgH,pppey'gue(C.0.G2). Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 7 of8 .G.3).HisoricPvDO4Ffivp,pifihCtyOidentiDgnG,tr(),sg,,fvrvhxhOMG. 4)RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS vqvwignReviC Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 8 o/8 ATTACHMENTS 1. prtygrp5WLWamS& AI8RF2NHarwStr:arrittyarritty@gmurtnyRurtn@mN:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4972-19 Ruppe Residence PRIMAR?f REGGRD ©Rl>i !!ID O ,_it hl*3a.scpi:.Ctio.3Materials:*P3b.ResourceAttributes:l(Lttribue*sPs:�BildgD SrutrD bjD S�rD D (Viwccesi#) riD rhD h:(Nme,affiitio,andadds)o. pi:Cisrvyportahuce"none.")R()Ce()SGI()BIUgI()v:(Describe)Rn:D D hlrD D hD sD D trrD thrBildg,SrujrD MllirD krt*eqrmATIACHMENT NO. 6 DRC NO. 4972-19; RUPPE RESIDENCE DPR FORM FOR 278 N. HARWOOD STREET August 21, 2019 DRC Meetine Of Bl:JIU)ING, $1iRl!JC'Fl!JRE, AND OBUEGT REC9Rl1> Ul #: No O Yes O Unknown ------- � Historic O Prehistoric O Both -------------� )AC------- xlii-Npggs.tionalResourceAttrbutes:82f:OragDlyws.813Rarks:with shsicSy:.*814lRbrhal����������������---! DateofEvaluaton:mbe,lcomme�n�ls�.)�==========��=�====�--1DPR 5238 (1/95) *qud I 1:>EPAR;r-MENT oi; PARKS �I:> RECREATION CONililNU�ilil0N SHEE1J" HRl!W:1. (Assigned by Recorder) D ������������� # BgZ#fSAc2#cpaBgSqftBG.CcHry(m.2)81.ak(Cfrmg.2)a.Dscp(Cm.1)DPR 523L (11/98) 1 1 DcpPh1991*qIm