The URL can be used to link to this page

08-07-19 Calvy Residence - 231 E. Culver (DRC 4938-18)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM AUGUST 7, 2019 Anna rtySzAEyvyWh2ty2-6u/inFy--636F-ryamy,harinwian-ami(3Gtr)twhar,32FN2//2N Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 2 o/8 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. PROJECT DESCRIPTION gFlArR(F.)qir. Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page3 o/8 EXISTING SITE EXISTING AREA CONTEXT EVALUATION CRITERIA RCholduwinThi:jrnlygnthflnth:1. Architectural Features. turturflgntyanfyturehiqtyjthurty2. Landscape. ypzalj'vLtrutyqubtruanty Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 4 o/8 ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. •Gimryamtprin.ThGgViryty•fulzSaffJ8amiframwwiritruturainiBainppwn Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page5 of8 Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation qygkpfiaryThmmittjbugFurtmmigngnakifrizaurrg#:gnNImm,Ijrpgtyp"TwnThwigpp,wipwiaiwik'arg-bbankwirn Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 6 o/8 ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS ThpBarurthaprmaagnrv:rmf.AnthiaffpdgnrvpwiS6Syhr'SfRbThrvpbwithtriuinToHtriIn dinimghvtrrtyfrGtrE.CvrAveu Design Review Committee Staff Report 7, 2019 Page 7 o/8 mutyauurn,grgnmppifipl,pplcldgn,qufi(C7.HscPrvsgnfOT4FfivifityfOnfiRegnutru()dmb,ssg,,fugvprvxgb(OM1G. 4RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS goCty'gee.3trurmaiffuturtruCartm'BFaiuraiquiruithi Design Review Committee Staff Report August 7, 2019 Page 8 o/8 ATTACHMENTS ArhiturP(am/5/209)3DgnRwCmmttSaffRprtnDb984DRF23CvAv/394GanStrc:CaigWhaigbwh@lrrN:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4938-18 Calvy Residence Vicinity Map DRC No. 4938-18 Calvy Residence 231 E. Culver Avenue ------------..J L ---�----C!,J I 405 I 3-73 I I t-------4, l 383 I I lt------t I ! 3.91 I I I ', I ,--------· eo N 404 CX) 375., ,j 378 374 ! I .------+------� r 383 385 384 ! 38 7 389 piiii&liim...__-..__-1 I �r/2 �?1 � 394 i ,-----�---_._ .__-"'. I �-------------------�- / N • . W E . ORANGE= CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE YELLOW= NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE s CITY OF ORANGE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4938-18; CALVY RESIDENCE VICINITY MAP August 7, 2019 DRC Meeting AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM DECEMBER 19, 2018 Anna RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION AtADuENNIA ATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC NO. 4938-18; CALVY RESIDENCE DRC STAFF REPORT AND MINUTES FROM 12/19/19 August 7, 2019 DRC Meeting Design Review Committee Staff Report December 19, 2018 Page2 of7 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. PROJECT DESCRIPTION EXISTING SITE .urOwnHstricDistrict.ryftThmoshinglroof,afrhi/ubjnihi,4GrStrt,tw-O,grhigrityunwexteurrgrrtyarhmt4of thiaff anyhistoric grerty. Design Review Committee Staff Report December 19, 2018 Page 3 of7 EXISTING AREA CONTEXT EVALUATION CRITERIA 1. alty2LandThtyp,rirtthrj'ovalgnbLtruqbsximiLpdkiglrakupx3Sgnggn)gn,,o4SondryuntinndryFtuasta,oaganoainasanialphannhiri() Design Review Committee Staff Report December 19, 2018 Page 4 o/7 ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation. amtruturaleniBaiwnaflhinunfitppniHistoric Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne (ftgnrthcthihitriartDgnarSecretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation (hftSwhictu,tannfijt Design Review Committee Staff Report December 19, 2018 Page5 of7 Vigftheunidmmpthirnfltyanaxzp745kADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION hijyrySTAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS urtydcakzakfiakiy"akgdrawthr(yrtvnmeal)unprtchuprt Design Review Committee Staff Report December 19, 2018 Page 6 o/7 In ygu(MC77)ydadfoili,3pjgn,uuityuu,grgn,sifi,gn,squfig(M7073).HioricPvgn,xrty Design Review Committee Staff Report December 19, 2018 Page 7 o/7 70.4).RECOMMENDED CONDITIONS riATTACHMENTS VAr(am/8/LJfi4rtyPh5xrpfr9SrnInMfalrniGarthAriEA37FEA/94GrtrSanErimag@anm AGENDA ITEMS: Continued Items: None New Agenda Items p-famynwhthffrtThdmbthdtrudwthamungieSb,gipbwweew,whhdndkSgthrughfintunbeuwSmwbRibpinwdwdrwnthertwnkibtrucd,thingartbryfrJFankfwnrviniwrtS06. urjmry fInri'Sarffithwwnwadjrt,dn'zwqdnSeum,grrwxwtrutur,Owikthhdrimtthinfunti'rn humrvumHggpaghbwrvwThulqunohiribintur. uinindunt thwuwricturJScz,v,uarwthnrithti City of Orange - Design Review Committee Final Meeting Minutes for December 19, 2018 Page 4 of 7 mmrv;dtyamgf;ftun•CrkffvdrgthmmMfffigirtdn'w•Tdi;vrvyCorndn'Iaardrg1:12,oMSfldrNrdrrrflwnxhiftfgrrttth;trwuvd ThiflThart fidriorviHrizgwn ry typrv City of Orange - Design Review Committee Final Meeting Minutes for December 19, 2018 Page 5 of? cSryIn'qirtw,'TC'ryarifi:x,ghtruWfirrtarrrwnunyflmlm.rtibvryThtrig City of Orange - Design Review Committee Final Meeting Minutes for December 19, 2018 Page 6 of7 ananrtunityvisthlansasedthmmittee'mmentsanremmendatinsSECOND: AYES:NOES: ABSENT ABSTAIN:rmrpxINrmttMOTION CARRIED. P-nma(¥4' f.lRl'#i o� oile JiD Review <::ode: Bate: D Not for Publication � Unrestricted �---- ----· s. ---------- Building O Structure D Object O Site � Element of District D District D Other (Isolates, etc.) rvyreortandothrsorcesrntr"non.")11)BuyUp.Hn(8)y25(Viw,,cess#) � Historic O Prehistoric D Both RdyName,affilation,andaddres)DGP.vyDMso347VBSk4*9M,*10rvyTyp(Describe)*tthDPR 523A (1/95) D NONE O Archaeological Record O Artifact Record D Location Map � Continuation Sheet(s) D District Record O Linear Feature Record D Photograph Record O Other (List): � Building, Structure, and Object Record O Milling Station Record O Rock Art Record *qiniATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4938-18; CALVY RESIDENCE DPRFORM FOR 231 E. CULVER AVE./394 S. GRAND ST. August 7, 2019 DRC Meeting lilRI #,I "NRFIP Stafus G6cfe 30-158•972 0383(3•8 !l!,D #: Historic O Prehistoric O Both No O Yes O Unknown �------------ .---------------------------------� .-----------------------� Pg.4.)ppprthagestorgsruure.Ltttribuedco.--------------------------------------------------------- eDyNs.(ContinuesonPg.3.)(SketcMapwtthNortharrowrequired.)ushaese191uvey:.bCSpemb,25---------------------------------- l(Thlspcervedffiacomtsiodofgnificnc:lT:yem(.87-)DPR 5238 (1/95) qn D. Gest, P. Lavalley, D. Matsumoto Chattel Architecture 13417 Ventura Blvd. Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 1982, 1991, 2005 1997 LDR R-1-6 712 DPR 523L (11/98) 1 1 1 enmaey• 30-a,ss,9172 fll:U� 038�38 CULVER E 231 APN 390-402-11 corded:March, 2005 � Continuation O Update Dch19 91 *qn*sc(Assigned by Recorder) enmaeyf# l'IRI# 6tJituit' · ORA J,)E) aate: #: O Not for Publication � Unrestricted ,_# ---------- igboCtieg3.)LttribuncodBuilding .J Structure L Object O Site � Element of District O District O Other (Isolates, etc.) (Vw,dt,accesin#� Historic O Prehistoric O Both (Name,affiliation,andaddress)(Ctrvyportthc,nt"n")CAc(25)rRuvAEGIBgIrUp.C,I(8)gHivy.M,2(Describe)m:DPR 523A (1/95) D NONE D Location Map � Continuation Sheet(s) � Building, Structure, and Object Record D Archaeological Record D District Record D Linear Feature Record D Milling Station Record D Rock Art Record D Artifact Record D Photograph Record D Other (List): qIrm 1 lilRI\J '"NRFIF Status e�e D.IID #: ��--------�------------------------��--�- RES �--��- * � Historic O Prehistoric O Both No O Yes O Unknown �----------� �----------��----------� ��--��--��--��- ��--------�� _A_c _ .CtiuPg.4.Litttributesandcodes)��--�----------------------��--�------- .To:Ey(.7-)(CntiuPg.3.h1y:bh*DfEvaanSpmb,25�� {SkMawiNrthrrwreq)l(Thlspeervffficits.)lPPR 5238 (1/95) *qInfmi!��'--��---' Pnifiii¥1# 30-�59024 HRiil 03·8,390 eRA (Assigned by Recorder) GRAND_S_394�APN_390-402-ll D. Gest, P. Lavalley, D. Matsumoto Chattel Architecture 13417 Ventura Blvd. Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 1982, 1991, 2005 1997 LDR R-1-6 0.1698 712 DPR L(11/98) 1 2 1 DateRecorded:May, 2005 �� ontinutionO Updtpoh1991 *RqI