The URL can be used to link to this page

SR - ORD-12-18 - SECOND READING .. . .. .. . .. .... . ..... . . . .. _ . _ .. . . _ _.. . . _ . .. �'- _�� _ . . �� O A *: . :* . . . . . ��.,�� . . . . . � . � SECOND READING November 13, 2018 .. . : .:: . 1... . .. UBJ�ECT . . . Secorid Reading and adoption of an Ordinaiiice of the City Couricil of the City of Orange approving a Zone Cl�ange:to expand an exi:sting historic :district.overlay zorie to add 12 properties on.South . ... . Batavia Street to.the local Old 'i'owne Historic District and.update tlie City of.Orange Historic - . : :. Resources Inventory. : : 2. SUMMARY : . .... . � � The intr.oduction and First:Readirig of the above-erititled Ordinance was approved:at a Regular Gouncil Meeting on Oetober 9, 2018. � The Ordinarice is now presented:for Second Reading:by title only; arid adoption. . .. . . .. . .. Vote at First Readirig: :: AYES:: .: Alvarez,Whitaker;.Smith, Murphy,:Nichols ... NOE3: None : . A . BSENT: None �. �: _ 3. .. RECOMMENDATION. � _ : Adopt Ordiriance No. 12-1$: ... :. : . 4. ATT:A.CHMENTS.. :: : Ordinance No. 12=18: ::.. ITEM 9.1 _ 1 . _ 11/13/18 � ORDINANCE NO. 12-18 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ORANGE APPROVING A ZONE CHANGE TO EXPAND AN EXISTING HISTORIC DISTRICT OVERLAY ZONE TO AI)D 12 PROPERTIES ON SOUTH BATAVIA STREET TO THE LOCAL OLD TOWNE HISTORIC DISTRICT AND UPDATE THE CITY OF ORANGE HISTORIC RESOURCES INVENTORY ZONE CHANGE NO. 1289-18 APPLICANT: CITY OF ORANGE WHEREAS,the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District were established by the City Council in Ordinance No. 38-88 as "Batavia Street on the west, Cambridge Street on the east, Walnut Avenue on the north, and La Veta Avenue on the south, including the Nutwood Tract on the south side of La Veta Avenue. The boundaries of the Old Towne Area shall run along the centerline of the designated streets and the borders of the Nutwood Tract"; and WHEREAS, Ordinance No. 15-98 amended the local Old Towne Historic District boundaries at Walnut Avenue and Waverly Street to match the National Register of Historic Places Old Towne Historic District,designated in 1998.As established in Orange Municipal Code(OMC) 17.17.030,the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District are delineated on a map on file in the Planning Division of the City of Orange entitled"Old Towne Boundaries" as adopted under Ordinance No. 15-98; and WHEREAS, OMC Chapter 17.17 establishes that "application for a historic district shall comply with the zoning amendment procedure for a change in the zoning district classification upon designation approval by City Council as prescribed under OMC Section 17.10.020"; and WHEREAS, a historic district overlay zone includes additional regulations over the base zoning of a particular area to encourage historic preservation and complementary new development. The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, incorporating the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties, apply to all properties within the boundaries of the local Old Towne Historic District; and WHEREAS, the City Council directed the Community Development Department Planning Division to proceed with expansion of the local Old Towne Historic District to include properties on the west side of South Batavia Street in March 2018; and WHEREAS, eight properties on the west side of South Batavia Street were identified as historic resources in the City's Historic Resources Survey completed in 1991; and WHEREAS, the City Council adopted the City of Orange 2010 Historic Resources Inventory Update,including the survey results from 1991,through Resolution No. 10426 in March 2010; and WHEREAS, in April 2018, Historic Preservation staff, meeting the Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualifications Standards for architectural history, surveyed the area and determined that the 100 and 200 blocks of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of intact historic properties constructed prior to 1940 that are eligible for inclusion in the local Old Towne Historic District; and WHEREAS, Historic Preservation staff conducted community information sessions for potentially affected property owners on June 27, 2018 and July 12, 2018; and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission, having considered Zone Change No. 1289-18 at a public hearing held on August 20, 2018, including review of the staff report and having invited public testimony on the item, has determined the proposed amendment is justified and recommends approval thereof; and WHEREAS, the City Council held a duly advertised public hearing on October 9, 2018 for the purpose of considering Zone Change No. 1289-18 as it pertains to the expansion of the local Old Towne Historic District as shown in the attached Exhibits "A", "B", and "C". NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ORANGE DOES ORDAIN AS FOLLOWS: SECTION I: The existing local Old Towne Historic District is depicted on the map attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by reference. The boundaries of the Old Towne Historic District are amended to include the 12 properties on South Batavia Street depicted on the map attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and incorporated herein by reference. The "Old Towne Boundaries" map adopted in OMC 17.17.030 is hereby amended to depict the change in the local Old Towne Historic District established by Zone Change No. 1289-18. The contributing and non-contributing properties within the expansion area are depicted on the - map in E�ibit"B"and described in the historic resources survey forms attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and incorporated herein by reference. The City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory is hereby updated to include the historic resources survey forms attached hereto as Exhibit"C." SECTION II: ' The historic district overlay zone described in Section I is related to the public welfare and is categorically exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) per State CEQA Guidelines 15308 (Class 8 —Actions by Regulatory Agencies for Protection of the Environment) and 15331 (Class 31 —Historical Resource Restoration/Rehabilitation). 2 The overlay zone is established for the protection of historic resources and makes no changes to the land uses permitted by the base zoning. The regulatory process for projects within the historic district overlay zone involves review to ensure conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). The Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne, required for projects within the Historic District, are consistent with and incorporate the SOI Standards. Expansion of the overlay zone ensures that additional historic resources and the Old Towne Historic District as a whole will be preserved and protected from changes that may affect the integrity of its historic character, design, materials, and features. SECTION III: General Plan Consistency The project achieves goals of the General Plan Cultural Resources and Historic Preservation Element and the Implementation Program. The expansion of the Historic District's boundaries provides long-term assurance that additional historic properties will be used, maintained, and rehabilitated in conformance with the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards). Projects in the local Historic District are reviewed for conformance with the Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne,which are consistent with and reference the SOI Standards. Inclusion in the local Historic District also provides access to incentives for preservation including the Mills Act Program and California Historical Building Code. Consistent with the General Plan Implementation Program for Historic, Cultural, and Archaeological Resources Surveys, the expansion of the Historic District's boundaries recognizes a small concentration of historic resources that reflects a unique sense of time and place and establishes a design review process for its protection. Historic District Criteria (OMC 17.17.050) An historic district may be established to preserve landmarks and areas exemplary of architectural, archaeological, cultural, economic, social, or historical value if the landmark or area meets the following criteria: A. The resource exemplifies or reflects special elements of the City's cultural, social, economic,political, aesthetic, engineering, architectural or natural history and possesses an integrity of location, design, setting, materials, workmanship,feeling and association; and 1. It embodies distinctive characteristics of a style, type, period or method of construction, or is a valuable example of the use of indigenous materials or craftsmanship; or 2. It contributes to the significance of an historic area, being a geographically definable area possessing a concentration of historic or scenic properties or thematically related grouping of properties which contribute to each other and are unified aesthetically, by plan or physical development; or 3 3. It reflects significant geographical patterns, including those associated with different eras of settlement and growth, particular transportation modes, or distinctive examples of park or community planning; or 4. It embodies elements of architectuYal design, detail, materials, or craftsmanship that represent a significant structural or architectural achievement or innovation; or S. It has a unique location or singular physical characteristic or is a view or vista representing an established and familiar visual feature of a neighborhood, community o� the City of Orange. The local Old Towne Historic District embodies the cultural and architectural history of late 19t"and early 20th century Orange County.The Historic District represents the original residential community, central business district, and industrial area of Orange with historic buildings dating from the 1880s through 1940. The houses throughout the Historic District represent the popular residential architectural styles of the period,including Folk Victorian, Craftsman, Tudor Revival, and Spanish Colonial Revival. The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street contain a concentration of residences representing the themes of early development and growth of the City of Orange, consistent with the existing Historic District. The houses are distinctive examples of the architectural styles prevalent in the Old Towne Historic District. These blocks, combined with the east side of South Batavia Street within the Old Towne Historic District, have a high degree of integrity of design,setting,materials,workmanship,feeling and association. Of the 12 properties proposed for inclusion in the Historic District, 11 are contributing historic properties. The one non-contributing property was constructed after 1940, outside of the period of significance for the Historic District. Including these properties within the boundaries of the Old Towne Historic District will protect these historic resources and the Historic District as a whole from incompatible changes that alter the character of the historic neighborhood. B. It is one of the few remaining examples in the City, region, state, or nation possessing distinguishing characteristics of an architectural or historical type, or specimen; or The 100 and 200 blocks of the west side of South Batavia Street are characteristic of the historical development and architectural styles of the City of Orange from the late 19t�'and early 20t�' centuries. This area is contiguous with and represents the same distinguishing characteristics and themes as the Old Towne Historic District, which is one of the few remaining intact historic downtowns from this period in Orange County. C. It is identified with persons or events significant in local, state or national history; or The Old Towne Historic District was originally designated as a representation of the broad patterns of development in the history of Orange, rather than for its association with a specific event or person. This criterion does not apply. D. It is representative of the work of a notable builder, designer or architect. The buildings throughout the Historic District are vernacular examples of late 19th and early 20��' century architectural styles and are rarely identifiable as the work of a specific builder, designer, or architect. This criterion does not apply. 4 SECTION IV: A summary of this ordinance shall be published and a certified copy of the full text of this ordinance shall be posted in the Office of the City Clerk at least 5 days prior to the City Council meeting at which this ordinance is adopted. A summary of this ordinance shall also be published once within 15 days after the ordinance's passage in a newspaper of general circulation,published, and circulated in the City of Orange. The City Clerk shall post in the Office of the City Clerk a certified copy of the full text of such adopted ordinance along with the names of those City Councilmembers voting for and against the ordinance in accordance of Governnient Code Section 36933. This ordinance shall take effect 30 days from and after the date of its final passage. ADOPTED this day of , 2018. Teresa E. Smith, Mayor, City of Orange ATTEST: Mary E. Murphy, City Clerk, City of Orange STATE OF CALIFORNIA ) COUNTY OF ORANGE ) CITY OF ORANGE ) I, MARY E. MURPHY, City Clerk of the City of Orange, California, do hereby certify that the foregoing Ordinance was introduced at the regular meeting of the City Council held on the day of , 2018, and thereafter at the regular meeting of said City Council duly held on the_day of , 2018, was duly passed and adopted by the following vote, to wit: AYES: COUNCILMEMBERS: NOES: COUNCILMEMBERS: � ABSENT: COUNCILMEMBERS: ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBERS: Mary E. Murphy, City Clerk, City of Orange 5 EXHIBIT "A" [Beneath this sheet.] � �� jll— �� ------ - -------�■� = � ��I�I� ��l��I ��■ ��■ IIIIIIiI1L �IIIIIIIII 1111111��Ee — � �� 111111es :��,��i � ��siii�n� omoiiiii: ' : i�ovio�o � i�� i v� �j�� 1 ��i,1i11111 111111111� � �IIIi11I1 1 t111111 � ��.�r� �i � � �: :� � .�111�\II I�A11111 � �:�'� � � �� . i � 111l1 �\\�Illli� ��r ��+� �; � � �' = -�� •=�•'a =� �� .� li °S� �� o��■ �, , � �� -- --� - �i=� �.. m •• ��■� ��■= d� _■ � � � �= �a �� -� �� 111 e� �� C l��,� � � O: ::. S: �� '�� s� �i�� I Ii .� �p 11�13C i!'.�1� C`I�I I , ' •• � — r � �es v ,,�� w � �� i�� ' II'I� '�� .��.�. � � �� +�O�Ai`��'� !I� rrt� II , •.., .�� _ �, � � � �,. 7� � � ' �.� �� I � �� .��° �` :: � �� I� �vi .� � � "- � I� �Id�� 111 i�� e�. at. .. _... E 1� a- � �- �i b �� [ af a. ` ��I 1.��.!" ��p �, C �� n■e �1 Yi � � : . � °1�i iliY :.Aw � �w�� tJ� � � � ! �Ui7 �� .° ce I s �,�'" x� ... "'�PI.� �5� cQ° aaa°�a� � �e�+ � � w#� iAY� -� � �� • +I��qdy�� y� ��°w� � � �'"'t�' �'" m � - ,. _ Y p � � ��, .. ;�i � �t :' re?��t s 'e�{�r �; C 1 1� �I --�' ' _su ,__:.,� ::4 ,Y. _� ■ �/ ( p 1 1 ili111 �. � i � ! �It' ■ � � i � nn _ I , � �� `��a L�� s� � � �iu .�,v �� ses ■�l�1�� am : . 6 �..�r, , • �i = � ,'. i ��■ m o� � 111�1111�' �, i � nm— I �� `�-��i'' .�� `�„ ��', �� ,� T' � � =e Ce� �� n � ` I �",� �� ° � �� C =� I I�N�� I �� ' � 4� �!■ :r�V 11I� � a' ��..� _�1:� ! ^� `� '��.'J'4 � .. 11111 "`� ■r- � u � � �-`; �. � �t ■ � � � � BII� �v �� '� �. I�.; ; _ — � � �.� �! �o �.�1 = z C .111.■ � I I I � II°� ■ ..� S� ,� « ..�� ,'.� � � �A'.� � � 11=� �� r� �, i� ;� i P°a � � � ; ' `��o i:�� 1 � ial� � _ ■ � II � � �� :� t ,� � �, l� -'e, tJr�ff ! ;�I� � 4 1� �`� f�� II e •e� K..:� � 1 �1'[]' � II ~ �'��'^.I LILI�-. r� � .I�, ��'� �,� f lJ � � (! °�� f:� 1 � 9• � �� II � �� ;' �Z � a �� i! ��R � O� � � +�}� � = �� -.� � �� I� �� r'� �, ±.� .n�� l�HI7 r�� s�� ..- � _ � rq � II � 0� � � �� p � � : • �C �// ' �� IJ�� Y !�!! � _.,'::l �ie� l�� p� _°:u�� i� f� �� I, r: � �� '• • � � ��p � C.Y� r0e ......,,�� L9 lilll�l I � �� .�i,�� o — �1�� ■� �� w�°� �� Qa ��n��w■ ��ia �_� � �i ..- e� : �: �i��d � s �� m .� � f� �e� 1 11�11 �e�ee o 1� ��, �� _, �,�., � � �� ,�o ,� � �` � �EI f1G�fl�� [l :il��i ��IoAi�et ►► == _� -� d� .. _��.�I. � r. �ir ��n�� r_i� M� �I�l� �� •�iQ�� .JO�� (� 3� 17��I�n�s� IIIeB�iOiil�i � SI �� olll 1� 1111� I � �s� U�� (i� � "'� � �� S r d � �� Ill�a. �i � � � e � 111 I III`I�. �` �e�e te�� . = iii � � � �_ c �' �.�a �� . . .. z.L; �� es a�e � z� � ,t � � e - - � � ,. � �`� � �� .� � �� d :� �� s. G '�!Q Z� �� 111 r �1�1�� .� --�--. � �ear�m ��n�.'i �u III ��^ F�� :� �� It�i��I�A4�� a �iT 11�1�111,� �� e�■ �� 1�11 �' a°a�n°S` �� v. �r� � K � � . �� op �� ;� � � � �C�� . ■....�,�. ��! � {�0.n� II �� A'� �� "...1 �_'7 � d�N�,1, 1, !I� � oA! ` ��-�,; o �'�� -� �_. rll� �i A 1 � � � r�t1 r ' < .�, I.� !1 �roi�i � - . �� 1 11l1 1111 �� 1 , 1�� ."'. p�5 �"Ca�l�l� , �'�^ m^nK�°o �^:::� � � " �� t , �' �� ,/ �� . ' 0 � �I� (° 4 �. � �. �j ' � � �`��l��I• � e = � >°'.r !u: ,: � +e' � ii . � �� v�;�� 3 :�� A 1 �P� ■ . a; �� ✓Q� � II :C��,`�� , ... II� �Q :, <;µ ,�.�� ae� ■ � ♦ � � o il�r1 • � ` 6�a� ' �� I ,� F4p Y?L�p � 111 , , ,', � . �4`v.�„ 1'�� ,�, '�laa� .�`� � 1 111 �I�� r�.,�,�� ` �B , � �'�� • . . • . — .� ,N. � - � — EXHIBIT "B" [Beneath this sheet.] �� I'� '�� --- -- �Gir •• ,� � l��1�1� ��l��I e � �;I r IIIi11Yi11� IIIIIIIII !11l11 !i! � � 11 1111111 11 111! � ■ �°° �li :1111111� 111 11��1: � IIii11\i 1 �11111 � ' �,, � �v� ��il � � lillllr 111111 " i 1111i111 ! 1111111 � ��.�.�r� Ii � �: �� 'illl��tl �Alillll � �.�.�� _�1� �� 1�1�111�\��II�II�i s m �� e i � � �� C� �� 11 �� m� , \'� � �� s� $e�i � ��y rl= �a�� _ �♦1 �� A o$ =� � � �� r�� i� �� i� n�i� : T =i �;� � �� 1- a= �'� �= 1� __ _ __ '�w �� :8 =r�� .� � �S := � ��' � �� • _ � ., .. , ... ,1,� �, � ; �� ;� � � � �� li 11 1 1� � u��v� � � � i � � ��! � ! Ili i, � � �..� i �: CC �� _� i � 1�1 � � �� e � '��. 'y': :s w �o ra i ""' �� see �� : � i�s� _ —�� ' � � */, ' is 8! Iil I � � �m � � I� .■��1 � � �� IIII�: � � � �i � � „ _� �� = 1 ♦♦n�♦1 � � �� i � � � � � �� 1� 1/ � � � �� i� � � � � � � � �Y1�� r� � � � . � � � m � �e�� _ f _ u ■ � p� � � .� . -�u� . �� i� � = � � � ��1= ' � �— �� _ _�� , �� a r= � �� ■ �� o ; � E � a �i� � ■ � � !I �� ' � !' ��11�� a �es t �� a t s i� �' ,�� = _� �� °� � = ■ li s::4 �1� �_ �� itl�� ,, � �. �� ,� � � � � a• � . ..� � �� . C c �hr'�� 9� e � � �° � � 1 1 � � �� ,� I� �� a� � �� 11 � �B �N�1 i 1�� 1l1i9� ��1��1�I� � 11 �� ' ;�3i. �� ,� � yy 1 ■ �'�� a� �: �i� � �� 6 � �� N 1� 11�111 11 ��eel� C I�PYY■ � � �� o . ,I � 1 �� 1 �� 6k � II� s '�IIiA 9! ►� �� :�,� � � :� :'r.ali! ��i �� ,� �°'�� I�I�i IIIIBIIIi Ilfl�� 1 �5 �o�i � , �� o � � iii ■■■ � � ��a �� ' �y��i�; e . oe�i�e��e� � � � II� �e �_ � �� ► � to �� `��+: :� � � �� . . � �� ■ � � d� a t. ��r� � r� • � �a�� III � � 1 � � �� ie��si�j j Ii� � � �� I� '��C �o. � �� 33: � � � 0•1��1��11��111� � �i�� le � 1 1� ; ' s i�'� �i � IAYllllllo � � � �il� � � � � � � � � � �i�i�� .r.��: � i� p � �,� �� i�i �::_�� p�� pl � : ■ �� '� i o o e:�`'�� ' � ��Ii � � �� , • � p 1 111 � �� 1�I 1 ,. .�- �i�-�— I �\� , � `\ �`� - � - k • . . • . — - �' ,N _ _ _ .... ... . .. . .. . . . . . . . .. . . . ... . . . . _ .. . .. _ . . . _. . .. . .. . .. ... .. . . . . .... .. . . . . . . � �� .131 130. ; ;� -- --- '�. I I 1`�29��mw � . .. .,: � . . . . I ' � i :.. . 125 . . ]28 122. � ' 1�32 r. . .. 122126 , ; 133 122 ; � I 125 ��. ' :. .' :' .. .. . i i �}� � r i ,, _ � .... .. .. :. , r 7 A . . . .. p�• �„� - .� � � ' �o."'�' � j � �. k � �' .' �k,'. .. . .. .. . . . . . . � � .. ... . .. .. M .. . � . �. ,.Q i � � ^ �� I �,.. �� 3 . ' : :... � .. �. :1 a foN.o.�.O �. . ; ;, , M ' a00 � I'c�\ ^ ^''.� uj,. i � g . . . ..... . � .\ :.,., O�..0� Q0: � � � �O� . .. . -----...._ . . __,,,, . . �� _ � za � --- -..._..__.-,-,_�.. ' :" O� � ; ^ � . � :.. .. .. . .. . . . . :.. . ' :. . :--� � ;---'.. . . ;.:- -�-----' :'-�--�.-�...,.�-'__----'-� :•._....--'-:-r...___._.___� . . . .. . . . .. .. . '.. .. . .. .. . . .. . .. .. . .. .. . . ... .. . . ... .. . . ... .. . . ... .. . . ... .. . . ... .. . . ... .. - -. ,- - ---_-:�� _..._. - -- - - --- : � :: APMAN . . �_..,. :�: , � . . . � . . GH , � � _..._ . �--:.:------- --. i-------- - � , o o � .i oz ' � , , � . i. i: � p N j � � � O ^ i' � � N °�°o i...� p -? � I: j (V 'rOt. . � � � ,_ N � � ' a ' O� � i � 00 °N° �.� . � M Q O I � �. - N ¢�OE . .. ' �' ��r-.. � - �� '�.j � � ro.-� �� ... �...�.y� � �� i � � � :.�0 t . O I j ]�� i ., : *�,. ' 2 I I 123. .. I ; � T ' . � ; 121123�124�122� ; � � . , ` ` .. I � . . . , .� 125 127 � 126 ' ( a �� , �� , � � �W26 � � � R , �. � , i1;2�9 1�3 30 � .�. 131 � � . _, , ; 1"�3i1��t �3�„1�32 F � 1,23��13�.�, I I s , 13o Y�� i i: ... i t �'� � i . � �'�� '� i i � 4 i i 1361 � �. . ,. r 135 137 � � 1�33 J36 � 13�7139�a2 .� $ � F: 139.. . .. . , r , 13�4 I 1�E14 ��B�"4 �: i � „ 13 y �4� ��'i , a�; i a s ,$t k�""��'��o ~i 8�.��43 i i ��x v 144140�1 ' I � ... !cn 143 � ��,��40 � ' k�a� � �' �l�"431 �'�� 44�42" 14 143' �� .�:.� _ � , � 145147 ��48 , Y � �14�a�� a � � ; ;� , 1�48 6 � 147: : 148 ;v�l � � s�: � � ��E�� , � - i � 157 ----- ��i. 1.51 . : .�� J 52� ; i `�` � t.�'� i.�i '�149#1�5�1'1�53i��1�50 'F I j•5� �.152��" 6 � : . 156 ;��: �� , � 153 155 1 S 156 I:g;�� ; �. � 155 .`r��1{ � �f-�: : �� i � � � � . 4 ; ; 1.62 168 U� T 59 158 � ; '16k5� 0 :i.V l °7�' I 6'�1 160 i , �1� , 165 � i . �,�t' .�� i i "��m�a.w 162 �a i i �5�`'�:a -t-.� i � 1 fi4, i i � ' 167 ,� '�1�6�4 i i �173�' 16 � I °1'65�s3 � �� 1;68� i � 1:�7 �'��T �� , � 6 .�> �'t��'7a6,��1 2 , , 173: : � � � �,�� 168 i , �. � . a� �.. _i i � 176 ; I '.175 '�'��1�76 I � �1$1 I ' �� , �. � �-� _.. 0 i : i :1.81 � i:i\" ° ,� . - i :i . "a'� �` ��`a� ' i �7 �°'� �� i i �`8 ' Nw°� � � • � ..� . . 182 .;..�.. ,. ^ � .. r . , � �� a i ��'�, � .o �o `o� � � �� , �.�o�� n� u�.,�, :.� � c�� _ � -�y!�� „��.M..�lV p I � �c�7 �pp°.� w0� � � <,•) l�!'�r Nz� � � i. 4 � � p�a� � ' � i 1033' 1015101 � � o.o., o. o. - o. i i �. r� � � aof� � n s��, M�i; i �:195-� c� cv o:; :' . . .� _.,� �_.'__ \ � .00 00 v ,,.,�0 .�'� � ._.i:` .. . I I.. .. "---'--�--�—./ � S . g '.:'� �O �O �O, � . .... �_ .._.---.— ..."'-----� � .... �-�i i_ / l' �. , .. :: . . . _......._.....—=-----._.__.._.._.__ _::--- �. : .. .'. . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . .-,-,—.-.-..'--.._.....----� ti.�_._..:_._ . . . .. . . . .. . . . . . . .. . . .. ��._�-�- ----- ---- .. LMOND ------ ----- -- N ^ . . ��* __ ��. .� -- -- �� i_...._ _ _ p.� 'N � �O O O� �r�j. ^c ��' � � �p.p � r. � i r- o o cv ;� � � � :. r�wr� 206 � i. u� q 208 ;i � 209 00 �oco : ^ r o 0 0 0 � 204" � '21._�.,_,_ 21 � � v '.. '� :` � i -�-=- `o�o � 4 I � � � - .. . �. , '�� I c� � o v ��+ 1 � � _ . : : . : : . � r- Q, ,¢ ,. .. i i 21:9 ' :. : . a �.. � � �� p ! � , 3. . 226 ;. WRSHIN; 731 218, � . :: v o� i � i v^ N v a � N 0 0. .o o � �$:i.. � 229• r'v�w �' o . ^ ^ •- . . : � � �` ,p� ; ::i 2 36 � f� __� 73. 238 ; � ::237 ?38 � ,, �2�,� , 33 ,2. � �: � , ' . � � � � � � �� , .,� � , . �� 224 I 239�` �I ::, � � � . . ��.� ' , �.�.�� .; , 24 � '�2,4b; o- `�� 248,.,:`,; "245 '� � : . , � ., " . � �F-.� 246.. 1 .. . � I � ; ;�n , 23b. ., � . 249 1`�� ; 25 �� ::: . 254 � .. .. . � . 25 � 256 �� 5 :. : . � � � � > I ; 2 , _ ;Y; : 6 26� �� . : .. : : � f�� '� ��2� � � 271:. 64 � U`�� `,.�\ . 733 2 . 'a� ? 3 26 j 2 66 : - . : �w�� °� r�,'��e�=�.i �� , 274 i. � MARIEi �. E 27,6� ; i � ` � ,�.. �; � , , �. , , � � 271 ' 272 ,. � � � .. � :� , �.. �` - � - , ,. 265:: , 281 28 28 � �: � i , 266 � 265. . . . .. . � I � � : � 286 � � .281 : � : `� I ; ,_ �82 I ' � ' ------- -- ' ' � . � 273 I I : :...286 I r�-o• i I � > � i i .. � 274 i 275 . i r�. 29 i � � •. . .� 296' i 290 . � � , � . a.. � , ; . i °0_°�°-.._.._----._.; ..i 8 i. �. .i 291. 2 �. . . {. 283 : 284 ; �! 283. :. : ; :. : - '... :_ ------........__- ----- �_._........_. . . 2 � u __....._._ r . i � i ::::. : : :. -- _..._�_.�,; ; 293 ; � 293 � :�� . , -- _ P�4LMYRA A ---._.............._............. � , 294. � � � � � ovi�oo�: � � � � �< ( � � � � � �� v c�r�c�. �302 I i �ao ' � � ��'�' �'��;;� , r��;; v •o��r� � 297 . 96 � � co 00 00 0o N. . � � � M N' Ot � � ,o u� � � 296 f H 297 i ' - a 8 i i ^ :'� . ^ n n�i i `�F� �o �o� `o � . -- 315 . � 2" � � � � �+ 299 i V I� I� o. , ; r i � � y»�i t ��s �f?`iyt� t . ;\ 298 � ; 299 oN. o. o�. o�. i �; _. i ;i ° r� i �^a.g �, : ' ._---�.,._--=-_--, � —=� ;:3� 322320 �:. � 335 �P?� � PALMYRA AVE- �- --�- -- 5 � � �3 322 � � 323 23 32 ----� � 3 Yz . _._....._...-----_:. ..__..--.-- ---- -�_-..._ � 24 �� i i r, 3 . �. c� N °° o o �... - � � .o � I i 33 � 332 33 , �> � �`��328��Hi �33'� ��3 � ; ; 339 N o ,. , 334: � .� 341 �'��t�� I�' �°. 341° � -�'`v 0 0 0 0 0 0. o. o. � �,�, :� �. ^ .- r. � ; : o• o• ; 344�� ..I� .. . ..343 �=�338�i.�i 339.�,��,42�,�34 . . . .. . ; 1:.341 343 I 345 34 r w , � �- . - - ' ._ .. .. . . , , .. 354 �� 340 �� 3�,47 � �34 . . . .. ,. . .. yW �;�..�.�'. .. . . . .. . .... .. . .... .. . .... . .. . . . ..... . . ..... . . ..... .. . ... . . ..... . . ..... , _ _ , •RII51gNflunPnmiumt(BuOBig, Ilo;arOG tl , .. . . ' ,. . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . bated MWn 9ia Oltl T Or�^Oe PI�nNnp Arca ere •• . . .• .. . .. . F p .. . . .. . :.. .. .. . .. .. . . .. . . .0 Old Towne Orenge Local Hlstoiic Oiehict Boimdery Expenelan(201BJ : �+mol.a.ro bo co�treump m e x�ntmm oi•mct... . . tr� {o R,�M .. . .. .. . . �u�xi�o.nn•rlonsqnmcenr�auwn rnmM ma .. � ti d°"�'� � ''' '' "Q Old Towne Orange Local Histodc Dishict(1991) hmindiry am NonContrmuWg ta a NbbAc OieUct �. � �: Old Towne Orange -,-..��ed . . .. .. . .. ��w,.d..,5� Bounda Ex ansion : � w e�r �� . rY ,P � Slgnificent Hisfdic BWlding(s)on Percel(ConGibutars) . . ..... : . : ": e .; . . .. . . . . : .. . . . �8�1� .: .-.�- :.- -. � NmSign�mnt8uiltling(s)on Percel(Nan-ConlnbNors).�� :. . a.�Ni4. .. . . ' .. . .. . .. . . .. . .... 0 0.00750.01fi O.R1.. ' EXHIBIT "C" [Beneath this sheet.] _ .. . . . . .. . . . _ . - �State of CaltforMa The Resources�qency ' * � � `,�PNmary#; 30 �].58701.�• ' � � DEPAFtTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION �� HRI# 038067 s � �� "��" PRIMARY itECORD.� �t t ''� � $ �'� ��,Trinom�al` oxt�� " ° ,� �`�� - , . ,, _ � �� , hN P St �il 1�� ' � �,� 3 , , � RH at s Code 5n �' . � � $w � f � �-� ' Other Listl�gs ��'"�,, � ��., �� . �� ,�,� P . r", x >'�: �� `� �a'�=x��" � ' � � - " Revlew Code ' � 'Revlewer '' �x �-Date � � , . � - - .,o a ..,._ ; � _ .� , _� _ _, .. �� , �; -�;, u ��. �� .� �� s, �.�� . �, , _. , M,. , �h h � ,� . � ,, , . . ,. •. � Page:1::of 3 "Resource Name or#:::::. BATAVIA_S_134_APN o41-042-18 (Assigned by RecardeY) =.' '. " ' ' P1.Other ldentifier: ::.. *P2:Location: � Not for Publication � Unrestricted *B..COUIItJ/: Orange:::. 8n(1' (p2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a loralion map as necessary.) •b:USGS 7.5'Quad: . . .. . . Date:. . T. .. .. .R. . ; . 1/4 of . 9/4 of Sec :�;. .,��B.M... C.Add�eSS: . :134 : - S BATAVIA: : : ST ,#. : .. Clty: Oran e . ZIP: ': 92868 d.UtM: (Give more than ane for large arid/ar linear resources)ZonB ' RIE!.. mN e.Other Locational Data:: . � *.P3a.DeSC�lptlOn::(Describe resource and its ma)or elemenfs.Inblude design,matedals,condition;alterations,size,setting,arid boudnaries. Continues on Pg:3.) . _ , Mete�Id15: : Frame - Wood sidin " " " , . . . Rectangular..plan. with side gable.roof, front-facing..gable.dqrmery and lattice.at gable end vents...Wide eave overhang with exposed rafter tai;ls; and decorative.,corbels. Raised concrete; front porch; spans,full width of house supported by four pier's;:; Pair of frorit:piat;ure windows with leaded glass transoms flanked by double-hung wood windows-on ei'ther side of front"door:'Side elevatiori "windows are one-over-one'wood " ' : windows. liarge - -. ._ _ "P3b:Resource Attributes:. (HP2)= sinqle. family pro e�rty� (Llat attdbutes and codes) "P4.Resources Presen4: = ❑d Building �] Structure ❑ Object �.Site: ❑ Element of Dis4rict: ❑ District ❑ Other.(Isolates,etc.) � �.�-�.�,��.�.��..�� ,� � �r'„�"��' �.� r . �� , ,� a :��a��'� '�� fl A'e,: ' �t � , F ,� v �' �� r ,s,r �� _ `��" • � �� r ��' ' P5b.Descrlption of�Photo: 2018 �, r �' �. w4 I �" � � �, � � � � � ,�„ � �� "� i �I Mew,date,accesslon#) , p � � � � , i� ` � � "P6.Date Constructedl.Age and Source: � � � :_ . " � � ,..,.�� ..� � -� °:; z �. �' �� r 1917 =' � �� ' . .. . . a ��. �4 . .. .. .. .. . . �� . _ . +��,,� � . '. ❑�/ Mistoric ❑ Prehistoric : ,� Both , � � 2�,� � �q ��; '?�°' *P7.Owner and Address: _ :?." j I . � .. . . . . ' '„vi w� '�`. ��. . . . . .. . . .. . . .. . . � I��L, . . ' � � _" . . .. . � �U:�� 'I, ��b'� .. .�.� .�� . . . . . . .. . .. '' � t�. . . . . � : . n �i .. i` :,. ' . �.. ..y'.: .� .. . �� ' � �' ' � ` I��I ��, � J�� 'P8:Recorded�by:;:�Name,affiliatian,and address) k I i �q �j tt�� .,�� r �� '�: Marissa Moshier &'Kelly: Ribuffo �.'� � ...��: ". � •' �' �� ; .��. , � �-�" � � � '�� City of�Orange CD Dept. �::,� i. ,. . ." r . . . . �.a ' � ". ,�� . 300 E. Chapmah'Avenue �� ' �� `' � ' Orange', CA 92866 4� t', s '� � ��I{�� ,, '" ;�;:;;�...c u.i � i. . "P9.Date Recorded: :.. �P11.RepOrtCltet(O�: (Citesurvey.reportandothersources,orenter'none.'): Apx'il 2018 Orange County'As'sessor Records (2010 :anii 2018) . AEGIS"(1991)_ Historic " ' Building Inventory. Update. Heritage Oran e Count , Tnc.: (1.982) Oran e Historic Surv.ey: :.. . 4 Y 4 "P70.$urveyType: �oescr;ee� Reconria;issance. . 'Attachments: ...❑ NONE� ❑.Location Map Q.Continuation Sheet(s). 0.Building;Structure,and Object Recorci " � Archaeological Recofd 0 District Recard ❑ Linear Feature Record:;0 Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record � Artifact.Record. , 0 Pfiotagraph Record 0 Otlie�(List):.. . . .. DPR 523A(1795) ; "Required Information. : _ . . . _.. _ , b� 4 .. a�. rex �YW��.''+s�� r=.+�� ,-��" x4 �..: '_...�i., �^ ,. � �'. t '�-'�'�" {; '�g'S,�'r,�� aE -� r �State of'Cailfo�nla �The.Resources Agency t°�� PNmary# 30 �iz58701��"��a� �-��'�.��^�'�� 4�,��:;.�� - '. �3✓n�� a� <n�*rc��^a�^�� ""�""�':�'�' DEPARTMENT,�OF�PARKS,IWD=RECREi4TION' �� °� � ,� HRI#�`�,� �>�03�8067��p;� �� ;�s��,�':"Y ��`^�'`�3��.��"'"'� : " n . BUILDING,ST�,RUCTURE;�AND"OBJEC�T<S�REC,�ONRD *NRHP�,Statu�sCode a�dsnl� � ° '� �r�,�x* �'r` ;; ' Page 2 of 3 'Resource Name or#: HATAviA s_i34 APN_041-042-18 (Asslgned by Recorder) B1.Historlc Name: Unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Orlginal Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs "B5.Archltectural Style: Craftsman "B6.COI1St�uCtlon HlStory:(Construction date,atlerations,and date of alteratlons) Date of Construction: 1917 ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both "B7.Moved? ❑d No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Origlnal Locatlon: •B8.Related Features: "B9.Architect or Builder: vnknown "870.Slgnlflcence: Theme: Architecture l4rea: City of Orange P�opertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgnlflcance: Early settiement (c. 1870 - 1920) Applicable Crlterla: Ac (Oiscuss importence In terms of historical or archftectural cantext as defined by theme,period,end geogrephic scope. Also address integrity. Conlinues on Pg.4.) Structural Integrity: Good Condition — No apparent chancTe to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunitles House does not appear on historic aerial photographs until 1947; however, the date of construction appears to be considerably older. The house may have been moved to this location from a different property in the late 1930s or early-mid 1940s. B11.Addltional Resource Attrlbutes: �us�am;b„ces and oade5) 'B12.References: B13.Remarks: �continues on Pe.s.) (Sketch Map with Norlh ertaw required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change from SS1 to SD1. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. 'B14.Evaluato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo *Date of Evaluation: Agril 2018 (This space reserved for oKcial wmments.) DPR 523B(1/95) `Required Information . . ... . . . . . .. .. .. . . . .. .... . ..... . . . . r��4�, +�g�.ag�r'a#&�ci;.. ., 3�e�*",�.�a��. � . . , r7 � ��`- a a'�+v.�.��,�r.3a�,. . g.'�. . ��'��a��'� . S�e�o�f�C�alifornla-The�Resources;Agency ��'��`,"� �� ;�� ,w<Primary:#� 30�,=15,87A1��` �� t,„DEPARTMENT•F.P KS AND=RECREATION ��$ , � sHRI#� �03,&067 � Pi �C,ONTINUATION SHEETi '�r�K��'� � T - "� � � �w �-�s ��.� ��. � ;�°��;..� ., �,`,,��-�&�� ' rinomlal ox� � , x m .��a�s�� : _ .. . . � Page 3 OT:3 *ReSOUfCe N3rtle o�#: ,BATAVIA_S_134_APN 04T-042=18 " ' " ' ' (Asslgned by Recorder) " " " . .. . . . . . . Recorded by:. . :. ' Marissa,IvIoshier & Ke11y:Ribuffo .. ' DateReCo[ded: April 2018 ... _. . Ciby' of 'Orange.,CD Dept'.. .. . .. 3 0 o E. Chapman Avenue ❑�/ COI1t1�Uet100 Q.UpdetB .... .. . . . . . .. . . . Or.a.nge., CA 928'66�' ' . . .. .. . . . Years:Surveyed: 19.82;: 1991, 2018 : : : Description:ofPtioto: 1991 Listed In Natlonal Regfster: : General Plan: L�nx #of Buildings: 1 • � Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories:. 1. ��'��'� ��'� �,�� : �, �,�� s� � � � � ,, ,x w� �_ Lot Acre: #of Units:_ 1 $.��`'�'`;r��F ,,,,yP�s�" ="�,� �;"��,,,+;r�,„��'��.��'�-� � ' S .. .... z "�,� �, � a --"ti �l r � � r-�� Y Principal Bullding$qft: . � � , h � �`:� `, ` "t F�,r�,�'� � � _ :. � ... . � . y-"a, : �'�y+'' ' ��x �'t �'f�v a`i1 t v B6.Construction History(Continued.from Pg.2): ' �s '�` � �` � � �' � . . ,�, � f. r �� , ;. :�,��'�,�. -��-"",�''�sr�. � ��=�`°x.� w, . w� :. : B13.Remarks(Contlnued.from Pg.2): .. � - — _ . . . _._ __�.. _ _ _.. r';;1T r � } r �, b I . _ . . . . .. . ^ ; . . . . ... � .. .' .. .. 1$ � � ' � '.� � .. . �� T : . � � .' �� ..':l � ��:.. : ... .. P3a.Descrlptlon(Continued from Pg.1): ' . . . .. . .. rear accessory building with .shed roo£ dormer and.board and batten:siding at rear. ; DPR 523L:(11/98) i. : "Required Information. : _. _ .. _ _. � . . w.... . Prima # ,. , �. . �State of California-The Resources'Agency - ,• ry;, " ' • �� _ 1 ��-� . .;- � �.N .�,Y: , .,. . ��,�,. DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATfON i :, �HRI# '; � �- � � ��PRIMARY RECORD � ' � �� Trinomiai 'o�; r� s � .- � � � � ;� �� = R1RHP Status Code 5D1 '_ ' �� , a �. � ' " "Other Listings: � � � �' � � �, �` � � �...�r :� �' = t�. .� � �.�.,,.�.,� , . ' Review Code: �' Reviewer. ' ' ` Date: � . . . .. . - • . . . ..., . , .,,�.� ; � , .�� Page:7::of 3 "ReSou�CeNartleOf#:::;: BATAVIA_S`140_APN 041-042-28. (Asslgnad by Recorder): — - ::.. P1.Other ldentifier: `P2.Locatlon: 0 Not for Publication Unrestricted :. : *a.,County: orange:::. and (p2b and:P2c ar P2d.Attach a location map as necessary.) " "" *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: . Date: T ; R ; 14 of . 1/4 of Sec. ; .M. � 1 B c.Address:; i.40: :- s BATAVIA : : ST ,.# : . : : :City: Ora�nqe Zip:: : :92868 �...�.. . .. d.�17�IV�:'(Give mare than one for lerge and/oc linear resaurces)Z0�8 � R1E/,. �I1N e.Oth'er Locational Data: '"PSB.DBSC�IptI011::(Describe resaurce and its majoYelements.:lnclude design,materials,condition,"alterations,size,setling,and baudnaries. Continues an Pg.3.) - Mate1'lals: : Frame - Stucco..or piaster One and 'a half, story 'residerice with L-shaped gakil'e roof.with 'rolled'eaves,and. louverei3 cjable_ yents.,_San3 finish plaster cladding. Wood double-hung windows dn front elevation. Vinyl. ivindows on side elevations. Side entry with curved front porch wa]:1_. Two story reaY accessory building: *P3b:Resource Attributes: (Hp3j=�Niultiple family property. .. .. (Llet ettrlbOtes end codes) � � "P4.Resources.Present: : ❑d Building �.Sfructure ❑ Object :� Site ❑ Element of District: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isolates,etc.) f PSb.Desc�iptlon of Photo: 2018: ;. \ (Vlew,'date,eccesslon#): ' __ "P6.date Constructed/�qe and Source: .. : ,, � C i9z� :.. � ' ❑d:Historic ❑ PreFiistoric::..❑ Both � w•:� ::','' *P7.Owner.and:Address: _ r --- . * . . r �.fi r�� . `� - 1 . .. . . =r . �1 .'... � . ... v . . .. .. . . ' �� -'�¢x#tMtiSN.�Y°�+'Ai ' . Q • ' _. . . . . ' . .. .. Y�•' ^ �' ' . . . ; _ �� '�7� �-�j'� 8:ReCOfded by: (Name,a(filiation,and address) ... f ' •P � ;,'� .,.� �� !'Y! � Marissa Moshier &..Ke1Sy Ribuffo . .� f � , 1�fl � . �;�- ;�?-� :�.. . � ��,�' . .. � ` � ' �� City of Orange CD Dept. , 4.i: . . / � �� .� '��'�i� ,�„�� ''�" r � " �a; � 300 E. �Chapman Avenue � . _ . .,�,�,-.-� w..�a � „ , . . . . . �,,,,,. � `°� �,,,�`�'"`° ` � i Orange, CA 92866 " ; � .. � "v.�?°� a a;, ,� � i ,�^�' � a�' w � ..,•.�-� . , .i �� , s a - "P9.Date Recorded: 'P11.Repo�t.Citatl0�: (Citesurveyrepoifandathersources,orenter'none:•) April 2018.. ; Orange County Assessor Records .(2030,and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic . � " ' . :, Building Inventory_Update. •P10.SurveyType' (Descdbe) Reconnaissance. , •Attachmenfs: ❑ NONE ❑ Location Map:. 0 Continua4ian Sheet(s) � Building,Strucfure,.and Object Record 0 Archaeological Record 0 District Record 0.Lineac Feature Record 0 Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record _ __ � Artifact Record � Rhotograph Record �.Other(List): DPR 523A(t/95) � `Required Infomiation ,�^"� ?��k'i '�' ��.�Z'��r+a ��:�_; '.'t.,s�.�'U�"e y� %s �+ �+ �axYCw 4', '"..t :�4i4��§.�� t�,�,'�"�,� si"� {z" . '�`: -�y ,��"�"" � �'-c'. h�kState of California The.Resources Agency �Y r�'� :�., � Primary;# <Y �. ,,, ��,:; 5aP5.�'u�Y' � tl��t��'`�.��.C.�h, •mre�s .` �Fk`�^�"x, '� :. . :4�. � � �.�, i; �DEP�ARTMENT•OF PARK3�,A�ND RE�C�TION �� - HRI#' „ �,� _.. ,�� ,��'��,; �BUILOING STRUC�TURE�AND:�OBJECT`RECORD= "NRHP°Status coae sD� �,�;� , �``�� ,��.� ..;'�.�wti.^ear�. � 4nn trz.. ! ��fo+,�.aa..�.�° •,�a.w.,.rci�a�fr�.&��3.� �r'. ��'h��. ..x.��r��,m...,.,tta�_ ,t ,�.: ,erW$ae.s`�..��,'�+. Page 2 of 3 `Resource Name or#: BATAVIA S_140 APN 041-042-28 (Assfgned by Recarder) 81.Hlstorlc Name: unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs 84.Present Use: xEs "B5.Architectural Style: Provincial Revival `B6.Constructlon History:��nswcaon date,atleretions,end date of alterations) Date of Construction: 1927 ❑.I Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both "B7.MovedT �/❑ No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "B8.Related Features: "B9.Architect or Builder: vnknown 'B10.Signiflcance: Theme: Architecture l4rea: city of orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Slgnlflcance: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criterla: Ac (Dlscuss importanca in terms of hlatarlcal or architectural context as deflnad by theme,perlod,and geagraphic scope.Also addresa Integrity. Conllnues on Pg.4.) StnlCtu�al I�tegfity: Good Condition — Some original windows replaced with vinyl. Site lntegl'Ity: Large two story detached building in rear used as second residential unit. Opportunitles B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��isc attrinuces and codes� •812.References: B73.Remarks: (conunuas o�Py.a.) (sk@tcn MeP wiW Norui errow reyu�rea.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change from 551 to 5D1. Outside 2005 Survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. "B14.Evaluatol': Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo 'Date of Evaluation: a�ril 2018 (Thls space reserved for official cammants.) DPR 5238(1/95) "Required Informatlon _ . . _. .. . _. .. . . .... . . . .. .. .. . . .... r .;::os `^a'�,"',�`r�.Yr,� ,.a.f �a t�}�; �._,$ ��. ""� '` �,, ,` �i�,r y �, .� r.,x°r,¢fi" ;��z.�z'�fid;�"�;",��' t �>�t':: 'RYF ��,'� 7„{�'�}7F �� .. . x�;State of Calffomia The Resources Agency,, _ � , ��r` . Prima # s �, �5s�� ,��x �� e��M�iR°'�F`��^=-s �e�«s�4�''.a�,`v�ua:dt �� `�� ,�i��p'�,,� ^ �.r�,�-� " r�eg ��. a, �� ;r�;DEPARTMENT OF,.PARKS AND RECREATtON �"3�`��"�� ' HRI#_' s'+ '�r' �:�� i a��"` 'w �� '� �� , �� '8�b�4u��d�+��; � `�S �. t rip`��,�� s� �� ' ^,� � �gr ��` � . r ��CONTINUATION SHEET � � ,� °�� . � �"�-�`�� -�Trinomial� ox�i �t�� ,� �.�;,� �� r�� tt<i r.� *lu:r�+rad.aqarctt;�aaS..:� a,� ,sa<��. rk' �,�-� oi `�"� a,l;+-� . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . .. . . .. . . . . . Page 3 Of:3 "Re�SOU�CB N0R1e 0�#: BATAVIA S_140_APN 041-042-28 (A9slgned by Recorder) - ... . . . 8C0�. Q y:. Marissa_Moshier & Ke11y;Ri:buffo �• ;:,. D8t0 ReCO�ded: April 2018, City' of 'Orange,.CD ,Dept 300 E. Chapman Avenue :: � Continuation � Update . " ' ' ' Orange., CA 928'66' ' Years:Surveyed: 199i;: 2018 i : : Description of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: : General Plan: LMDR #of Bulldings: 2 �: �. , ,,:� '�� s:.. d,:f rr. ,. Planning Zone: tt-2:6 . : #of StoNes: 1.:5 �� a�� -. � .,-. , - Lot Acre: '#of.Units: 2 • � :� � � . � , { � �� Princlpal Building 5qf4: ` � � .� f ` � -� . B6:Consfr�iction History(Continued:from Pg.2): ,,� ,� w ��, ' ,..� �� .��'', �� . �" b"y'.;�� 5. � .. �.� �...' . . . .. .. . .. � .. .. . .. . .. . . . . . 813.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): � � . - - .-..�„ P3a.Description(Continued from Pg.1): : . . DPR 523L(11/98) `Required Informatian .. . , , . ,. . ;b, � � � �Resources qgency , .. .' .;', °Fw t,.Primary# .. � ,,r �:. : State of California The , v, . : ;NRf# - " , . , DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION �PRIMARY RECORD� ° ; ',Trinomial o� � � � k � &��`� '� � NRHP 3tafus Cod`e, �5��1� ' ' �� " � , �� .,� ,„' �� . �Other Listings = � ' k� , � . _�. ' = �� -Review Code -. "`° . :.'' Reviewerc ,-Date: '` - _ ' Page:l::of 3 . "Resource Name or#:::::: BATAvzA s 152 APN o41-o4z-16 (Asslgnad by Recorder):. . - - —.. _ P1.Other ldentifier: : ..� :. .. . . . •P2.Location: � Not for Publication ❑�_Unrestricted " : *a..County: Orange:::. and (p2b and:F2c ar P2d. Allach a loqtlon map as necessary.) . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . "b.USGS 7.5'Quad: . Date: T�; R ; /4 of , 1/4 of Sec. ; . � 1 B.M. - c.Address:: i52: :- �� S BATAVIA: . : ST ,.# : . : : :Clty: Oranae Zip:: : :92868 _ . d.UTM:'(Give more than one far large and/oc linear resources)ZOI18 � RIE/,. RIN - e.Other'Locational Data: . . *PSO.DBSC�IptI011::(Dascribe resource and its majot elementa:lnclude design,materials,candill"an,'8lteretions,size,seriing,and bautlnArles. Continues an Pg.3.) .. : MateNal§: : Frame - Stucco..oi piaster . . ' One story single. family resid'ence.with L=shaped'g'able.roof with'cbmposition .shingles: Sand finish, plaster " with wood shiplap. s;iding in gable ends: Small eave overhang; with exposed rafte'r•tails. Frorit porch :with "' concrete sl'ab.and square post. YVood front door and 'front:Eixed picture window with multi-light sidelights. " Metal.awnings over windows.. Front windows are..wood one-over one..windows. Side' windows..are.metal one=o�er-.. . .. : one wi:. : :. "P3b:Resou�ce Attributes:. (HP2j--5ingle. family property . .. .. . (Llat attributes and codes). . .. . 'P4.Resources:Present: : � Building O.Sfructure ❑ Objeot :� Site ❑ Element of Distriot: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isalates,etc.) � � : � `��°" ' �- �� P �+" �� `� � ' � P5b.Description of Photo: 2018 � � r�� `✓�r�'��'�'� �" „°�� k�,� � j I �r %,�....� I � (Vlew;dete,accesslon�1) � �-� .v, , • � . �.�.. '� '{# � t{�`' . % "P6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: .. � z`\i�� f� , _. � � �- , � � � ��w�''�^'��,��`- �� ,�'�� '"s� 193 8 � i . s��,�,�� ,,,... �. ,�<_ � _, � , �--�_—..:�--,�,_s� � -- � �:Hi§taric ❑ PreFiistoric ..❑ Both � - ;. , �-~'"' � . *P7.Owner and:Address: . .... ' l . . . �� R M' �. . . , . . � . . � . � .. "� ' "P8:Recorded b y�:: (Name,affiliation,and address) "' � �`- - Marissa Moshier &,Kelly Ribuffo � : .. , " City of Orange CD Dept. _ - 300 E. Chapman Avenue i,. . .- �:': �`. ' '-� - Orange, CA 92866 : � .""�`��..��-' �JA `� •P9.Date Recorded: `P11.ReportCltatfon: (Citesurveyreporfandathersources,ar:enter•nane'); , April 2018., : Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018) . . ;P10 . (oescdbe): :: _.. .:Survey Type• Reconnaissance.. "Attachments: ❑ NONE . ❑ Location Map:. � Continua4ion.Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Strucfure,.and Object Record :. : �.Archaeological Record � District Record ❑ Linear Feature RecorcJ ❑ Milling Station Record❑.Rocli Art Record � Artifact Record � Rhotograph Record � Other(List): DPR 523A(1195) *Required Informetion _�.�:s.*,��a:h,s� �g� �f�,�"�k �4�� fl, �,�, a,��w.v�e�� -a _ & _ y�h}�� DEPARTMENT OF PARKSBAND RECREATION' � ��'�'�'��'�"'�� `HrRI�#ry"#{ �„ �' � .,�3�+ . � � '�,BUILDING;ST�RUCTURE ANDfiOBJEC7'RECORD *NRHP�.s�aeus coae� sD� - '` ��; �an��ce u.,�7nm1`mu��. �� -�rt+�w,�.i-cs, .:.aec„a��;.v�^�;�Ncs�s "�.. �•� y:aa, Page 2 of 3 "Resource Name or#: BATAVIA S_152 APN o41-042-16 (Assigned by Recorder) B7.Historic Name: B2.Common Name: B3.Origlnal Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs "B5.Archltectu�al Style: Minimal Traditional *B6.Constructlon History:(ConsWction date,atlerations,and date of altera0ons) Date of Constructlon: i 93 S ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both Side elevation windows replaced with metal double hung windows. *B7.Moved7 ❑d No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *88.Related Features: "B9.Archltect or Builder: unknown *B10.Signiflcance: Theme: Architecture Area: city of orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Signlflcance: znterwar neveloPment (c. 1921 - 1941) Appllcable Crlterla: Ac (Dlscuss Importance In terms of hlalarical or archltecturel cantext as deflned by theme,perlod,and geagrephlc scope.Alsa address Integrlty. Continuea on Pg.4.) StfuCtu�allnt0grity: Excellent Condition - Minor changes to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities B11.Additional Resource Attributes: �usc anrib��e5 a�a�ode5� 'B12.References: B13.Remarks: �conanues on P9.a.� (Skatch Map with Narth arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. � 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. •B14.Evaluator: rtarissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo 'Date of Evaluatton: A�pril 2018 (Thls space resarved for ofticial comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) "Requlred Information `State of Californfa The Resources Agency Primary# r ' . •;DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION ;HRI# �� ^�' :i ' ' CONT,I `� � ��..��, � p� , � '�-�� " ��NUATION SHEETr,��-�`"� ' .Trinomiai� o� ��:�� i � : .. . . „ .. „ . ,.,..,..� �H ,„ ��.� . _� �. . �, .��.� . .,:�. _ . . �;�-_�u�� ._ Page 3 Of 3 *Resource Name or#: BATAVIA S_152 APN 041-042-16 (Psaigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue d❑ Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 2ola Descrlptlon of Photo: Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDR #of Bulldings: 3 Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Stories: 1 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 Principal Bullding Sqft: 66.Construction Hlstory(Continued from Pg.2): B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Descrlptlon(Continued from Pg.1): ndows. Plaster chimney on south elevation. Two detached accessory structures at rear: a two-car garage and a shed. DPR 523L(11/98) "Required Information , : �� .�.q.: � � b State of CaliforNa�'Ttia'R se ou�ces Agency } � `�� - � F'� �'n �Primary# �,30 158703" * 4 ,x�'.�'9v� `��k��°�AE�6� �'t�, n sv nx n . b , ' 'a�t. i ��€.�",�+�HRI��`P�„�`r��it038;069�w1. � ;, � DEPARTMENT;OF-PARKS AND RECREATION � � t kr��;`�w�«a'x�t`wJ', ,� ' r ��. sr'a�� "r f� c� �ri��.��ai� as a . . �. � � y $ ��.��.Trinomial��*°'oii�;'�� PRIMARY RECORD,� � � , ,,, � F ��a�<&,��r �' ��;k��m^� A�:r'�l�+rde2+', R ��a � p: ad`�wi+ *.p: .;� ¢�`�'�-�,NRHP 5t8�US COd@`�a's��JD�?�..�� yk��'~;� � W� h�14h r} �. �, �vr'� NX .�?u3m� .��^+''t� I � ' 4c Q '�� `�q��' ��r'�.3L� . �Fp, a ' t �t� i� .a'zi � . .. �:^ �.�, �� F�� Olfier Llstings ��: a .,,;• � � � � �� .. , � � �` a:� „�� . r.� , � ��..;t��„ �` v ��cr� �r��,� : t : � , . � �. R Review Code .:Rewewer . -Y� .... ; . Date. ;: ,,__ ; ,�� ,.. . . .. , � - . � ,� . Page 1;:of 3 " sATAvia s 15'8_APN_041-042-15 ....Resource Name or#:::::: (Assigned by Recarder):. . P1.Other ldentifier: ::.. .. .. . . . . . .. . . "P2.Locatlon: � Not for Publication ❑�.Unrestricted ' "a..County: oraiige:::: and (ppb and:P2c ar P2d.Attach a locatlon map as necessary.) ' . .. . . . . . . . . . "b.USGS 7.5'Quad: . . Date: � T ; R�; 714 of . 7/4 of Sec. ; B.M. . .. . �• • C.Address:. 158: :- S BATAVIA: ; : ST ,.# City Orancre Zip: 92868 �.a. . . . d.UTM: (Give more than ane far large and/oc Ilnear resources)ZOIIe � rt1E/.. RIN ... e.Othe�Locatlonal Data: . . : ' ' "P38.DeSCI'lptl0�::(Descri6e resource end its majoi elements.:lnclude design,maledal§,conditi'on,'alteratfons,size,setting,and boutlnAdes. Continues an Pg.3.) .. .. . .. .. . .. .. . .. Mate�lals: : Frame - Wood siding ..... . • ._Rectangular p1an. with' side�gable. roof,with ooinpos'ition, shin.gles'. Fiont porch witH squafe 'posts,,,,front " � ' gable roof,: and wood slats in gable_end_, centered 6n front"elevation. Narrow wood lap sidirig with oorner boards. Wood windows with wood 'screens: Detached two car:garage at rear:of'property. . .. . .. . . . `P3b:Resource Attributes: (xP2)=�single. family property .� .. (List ettrlbutea and cbdes) • � � � • `P4.Resources:Presen4: : ❑d Bullding �.Sfructure ❑ Object :� Site ❑ Element 6f District: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isolates,etc.) . ,- � � � � � � �d� b y : ,- �� °P'�`� �,�� P5b.Desc�iption of�Photo: , � 20Y8 �; " } � �x�� n s�i , 9 �^ , +�,_. Mew,dare,access on#) , �� . . � . � � . �� , � �;•� � �: � � � . . � • ;,� •P6:Date Constructed/Age and Source:. . . • r�, ^�. �. ��i, f 1924 _ .• -� ' ; _ �� l _ , - � • • ;.� oric oth .�J. ❑d Hi§t ' ❑ Preliistoric: . ❑ B ��: - - '� .. . "P7.Owner and:Address: �� , _ . � . � ia _�,. ..... ., .;- . `. 'P8:ReCo�ded by::::�Name,afiliation,and aAdress) :; . .:. „. ' Maris.sa Moshier &.Kelly Ftibuffo � _ _ . _. -._. .:r'.M�"� �, ; � City of: Orange .CD Dept. . ... � ;_.�� 300 . Chapman Avenue �+ � • ' . . .. � i Orange, CA 92866 � . . .. Pr c.. _ ,,,z. �� .. . � . . � . � . . � � . . ' .. : � ----- -�-- -- - - •P9.Date Recorded: • ... :. : :. : `P11.Repolt Cltatio�: (Cite surveyrepoif end othersources,or;enter'nope'); : : : April 2018.. : � Orange County Assessor Records ,(2030.and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic , :. Building Inventory,Update. Heri:tage Oraiige County, :Inc; (:1962) Orange ;.•p10.:SurveyType' (Descdbe) • : . . Historic Su.ivey; ;,. ., • � ..... . . .. . .. 'Reconnaissance . . . .. . ... "Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location.Map:. ❑� Cantinuation.Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Strucfure;.and Object Record. �. . 0.Archaeolagical Record � District Record ❑.Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑.Rock Art Record . . � Artifact Record � Fhotagraph Record �.Other(List): . DP.R 523A(1/95) .. •Requlred Information .. �;s i�,,mt,«1rr a.�F��;t��`'�k� ' ..��'.� a� 5�s, 2 r 4N.�7rt3�ar"� #�xa`�°Ftd�v.eF`�� `q�F�"s t=C ��Stateof�Caltfomta The`:'Resourcesqgency� �� r , „Primary":# 39��.158703, .��'.' � �"� ��DEPA�RTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION `��,j�HRI�#� 0380�69 '� BUILDING STRUCTURE p►ND"OBJECT�RECORD "NRHPesiaius coae �SDi� � ,. . ��.a�,�..��w�e� !uz�.,,^ff�,�z;.. �� n�.. �.�.� xn*��k �v?tx.�,e�a�. Page 2 of 3 "Resource Name or#: BATAVIA S_158 APN o41-042-15 (Assigned by Recorder) 81.Hlstorlc Name: unknown 82.Common Name: 83.Origfnal Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs '85.Archltectural Style: Craftsman 'B6.Construction Hfstory:(�nsWctian date,atleretions,end date of elterations) Date of Constructlon: 1924 ❑Q Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both "B7.Moved7 .I❑ No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: onknown '810.SlgnlfiCanCe: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgnlflcance: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Appllcable Crlterla: Ac (Dlscusa importance In terms of hlstorlcal or architectural context es deflned by theme,periad,and geagraphlc acape.Also eddresa Integrity. Contlnues on Pg.4.) Structurallntegrity: Good Condition - No apparent change to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportuntties B17.Addltlonal Resource Attributes: �ust attribuces and�odes� •B12.References: B13.Rema�ks: �Contlnues an Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change from SS1 to SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. "B14.EValuato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo 'Date of Evaluation: Apri1 2018 (This spece reserved for oflicial comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) "Required Informatlon _. ' K tir �•L�'cF �� fi'�.A{.�N�#K€,�.�SX'�k s& . ;. ... .�.y, e,rtyz«3�`,ab x �,', r � �, 3 .RP� � SState of,Caltfomia The`Resources,Agency � �- , , y Primary#��3o,�158703 £�� z��;��:� '�c�,�� .a�r��:� ,��, �� , � � �, �� FDEPARTMENT F PARKS AND RECREATION�,� - NRI# �^ " 038069''� '„�- �:}�� '. ..��..� '�'�i�"t��a'��` ' "� :� � �, r E � x a� � s'tr. �S�ar� � �sa� ,� s. � �wCONTINUATION SHEET w"�� ;,� � � � �� 'Trinomlal ��ox�� ,, 3 � � � � �� .�. ,��„� r•Y_ ��x...��% .�...,+ z��-��:,. .�,.�`�� . . . " Page 3 of.3 'Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s_158 APN_041=042-15 " " "' " ' :. (Assigned by Rewrder) Recorded by:. - ' Marissa Moshier 6 Kelly;Ri.buffo DBte ReCOfded: April 2018 City of 'Orange.CD ,Dept. .. .. 300 E. chapman Avenue �❑ Continuation O.Update Oran9e.� ,CA 928'66. . Years:Surveyed: 1982y: 1991, 2018 Description of Pf�oto: 1991 Listed in National Register: General Plan; LM�R. #of Buildings: L � ��„��,,,,,�,�,�,,��. Planning Zone: x-2-G #of Stories: i ��,�`�'� ;� � ,;;' . . .. . 4 � . . . Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 , ' y •�. j a � , M_ PrincipaLBuliding Sqft: 1000 � ' � k��„, ` , �; ��k"�=`�` �-� k -, : 66.Const�uction Hlstory(Continued:from Pg.2): � ��,-;.�_,_�� ' . r �,;� , � .. B13.Remarks(Contlnued from Pg.2): . . . �� a . . .. � x�y�� _3 .rA . . . . . . . . � . . . � .�. . , .�y'y�',`�7,(.5 ¢ i+ � . . .. �. . . . ' � .�; �r�^.7i;n', � �,y-^�h.,�fi�' F Ur^�..�*,.X �.7f.,M �`"""}ts.� �i�� . �.,n a �� 'i ;� _.�.-�,�.�_�..: + . .» :. ' '.. :. : '._ :. : '.. :. " .,.a .,...r__..-.1..�,. .. .��... .z.-,.-.�P�.�.i...:��.� � . ..0 :. _ � ... .. . . ... .. . P3a.Descri tion Continued from P 1 : : P �. .. . . 9• ) . . .. DPR 529L(11/98) Required In * formation . _ _ _ _ .. _. _.. _. � � State of'California The Resou�ces Agency � � ' Primary# 30�,-158704; ` � � �°rr' -�k ' " � �"`r''a'.��s�v�,�' � � HRI# � 03807D r' �DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION � ,Nz�i.��'1iM'eYx 5 X`t��"jiru.;dl��"Z� �� s ,�" , y }� zt r0�,u k' N � � ..� c..�. p �, 'r.a' , x�PRIMARY RECORD � � � � � , � � �Trinomial � r 3�� + � �� a € e a^hs 4�7.�"�0 �' . � '�aaa .� -� . a^ �' 4��F' '� K�TM�'" �, "'�� i � :r - � � L � '"sp.,� �`�c.�a k>'�� s� �- aly �; � �� , o � a� �' ��.�a �«1�� b ; j s< r�NRHP 5tatus Code,,� 5D1 > �-�,,� � `-� ��a � _,��-�'r�.�S` E ',r �, 7^ 'Y`.'y� 3 y � r a.-; �w.! z�ia� r'yv`'� r u n�,� �v�t .�� . �. r ;"" ��` a�S s. t��r�,.�v xbSs� �� h� � , �� + �yk�e w� r� 1 . ,;t'*,�re4�a�+t �» t. � � `, � � , � �, ,,�Ot er Listings ��, : � �� _ r R�evlew-Code :��;`Reviewer. "�'��;�yDate•' �� . , .. .... _, , _, . :: , .. , - , ., ., .. . . �.,..�.�., 9 " " BATAVIA S 164 APN 041-042-14 P.a e;1,:of 3 "Resource Name or#:::::: _ : - - — (Asslgnad by Recorderj :. P1.Other ldentifier: ::.. `P2.iocatlon: 0 Not for Publication ❑�.Unrestricted : *a..County: orange:::. and (pZb and'P2c ar P2d.Attach a locadah map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: . Date: T ; R ; � 1/4 of . 1/4 of Sec. ; . B.M. _ .. . c.Address:: i64: :- s SATAVIA: : : : ST ,.# : �. : :�:City:, Oranue Zip:: ; :92868 d.UTM: (Give mare than one for large end/ac Iinear resources)Za�e � RIE/.. RIN _.. e.Other Locatlonal Data: . �`P30.De3C�lptloh::�Describe resaurce and its majat elements.:include design,materials,condiUon,'alteradons,size,setting,end baudnaries. CanUnues an Pg.3.) . . . . . .. Mate1'lals: : Frame - Wood siding .... Two story' single. family resid'ence.with steeply pitched. cross 'gable roof.. Entry is thibugH main porch'which spans the full width of the house. Masbnry porch columns with beaded mdrtar joints. Wide eave overhang with decorative corbels. Narrow:wood']:ap siding. Fixed picture window with decorative transom on front. Paired double-hung wood.windows in' frontmost gable and on' side. elevations. Additional..decorative wood work . .. : in fron. :. *P3b:Resource Attributes: (xP2j=-Single family Pio�perty . .. .. . . � � (Llat alVlbtites end codes) .. . . .. .. . `P4.Resources.Present: : ❑d Building �.Sfructure ❑ Object :� Site ❑ Element of Distriot:�:❑ District ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) /', P5b.Description of Photo: 20I8: :. : : : / •c'' (View;dete,accesslon#) : , •. ,p �' > ' —�-r� �� V��a. �" ,kt � . . : .. . �., � °�t' `" `.� "P6.Date Constructed/�qe and Source:. .. . • � , � � ' 1903 � .. ' `' .i�t: .a �� ; , , ' ; ' ' . :.: `�. ". ;Y � ,e '' ;,� ❑�I.Historic ❑ PreHistoric :..❑ Both : ' �'�f ,. , i U .,:_,� " •�;�, : ' : ' • -' : ,.i ` : � *P7.Owner and:Address: �� 1 � .. . �� >-� "* . . � �: � ,.,vs� � �� . ,a : 1,i � ��, ? � �; � I' � � �; � (� �'• � �� , ,�� , ��;� � � ' � ,� �Pa:RECO�dBd b�l:� (Name,affiliation,end address � iii i � 1 � ��,��'; ��j ► I� E � � ��'�� ._�, ,� �� !� �`,� � ' Marissa Moshier &.Kelly Ribuffo t � � ,. � � ;;�: , � . - �.:� `�i �.. .:''^,��,. �`.,�,�;M1�l',i f i �� E � ,�f .� ..� '`�s{; � , f I j S�y� j � � . "�''7 � {�'r .. �... � �;t�� . : s � . ` City of Orange CD Dept. �. i��! � �� , 1 j . � � �j � � 300 E. Chapman Avenue . .. �d!�`' �7:.� ' � �j� '� ��- :'. � , Orange, CA 92866 . . � „�°' � s�� . � . .. . . : . . ; . .. . "tL� . .. . .. �P, �; �..� . : : P9.Date Recorded: .. •P11.Re ort Citation: _ p (Citesurveyreporfendothersources,or_enter•none:'): April 2018.. :' '' Orange County Assessor Records .(2010.and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic . • �Building In:ventory.Update. Heritage Oraiige County, ) Orange :.*p10.'SurveyType' (oescribe) ' Inc; (1982 Historic Survey: :;=' . � . .. .. . .. Reconnaissance.. 'Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location.Map . ❑� Continuation.Sheet(s) 0 Building,Strucfure,.and Object Record. . ❑ Archaeological Recard 0 District Record �-Linear Feature Recard ❑ Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record _... _ . � Artifect Record � Fhotograph Record 0.Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) "Required Informaticn ,�� ..�- �.: - ��,w` �'�'aFw r.t}�,,r�,�A+S$^Y;�astiN'��:�''a£'�,t'# ;ay ffi r'+',�.a�,.��k�. , �,�`.� .. 't�A R.�a'�z:"�'t 4 '�� $ : ,�.+��S� ,�"."�',�,�`n''.. f, State of�Caltfornia �The Resources Ag�ency� .� �, �-��-�Prnnary��# 3A�:�15e7o��.�_ .�. t ��-��;.�,�`;` N DEPARTMENt'OF PARKS AND RECREA7'ION��'�� HRI#°� OS:807,0�`�^�-�� 4� �� -� �� - ��<�.�� ,. � . a�� . . �� , � �ti ', &�UILDfNG STRUCTURE AND��L'OBJECT`RECORD 'NRHPStaitusCode- 5D1 «�4 � �. �� ; � '9rt9A�fi`.. �t�..w�14�-.y.�'e4+ SW, x�I��,W.f di� m...3�'� .�l.kf-5�tw4'>.,. ..�)'iA..a�"'*'i��'. �� Page 2 of 3 "Resource Name or#: saTAvza s_164 APN 041-042-14 (Assfgned by Recarder) B1.Hlstorlc Name: Unknown B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: x�s "B5.Archltectural Style: Folk Victorian *B6.Constructlon Hlstory:��nstru�uon detB,aner��o�s,and date of elteraUons) Date of Constructlon: 19 03 ❑�/ Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both "B7.Moved7 d❑ No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *68.Related Features: "B9.Architect or Builder: vnknown "B10.SIgniflcance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of orange PropeltyType: Residence Perlod of Slgniflcance: Early settlement (c. 1670 - 1920) Appllcable Crlteria: Ac (Dlscuss Importance in terms of hlstarical ar architectural canteM es deflned by theme,parlod,end geographlc scope.Also eddress Integrlty. Contlnues on Pg.4.) StruCtunl Integ►Ity: Excellent Condition - Minor changes to ori4inal structure. Slte Integ�ity: Large accessory structure at rear of property. Opportunities B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��ist attrieutes and codes� •B12.Refe►ences: 813.R01I18�kS: (�ntlnues an Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change £rom 5S1 to 5D1. Outside 2005 survey area. Style previously noted in 1991 Survey as Vernacular. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. 'B14.EVelueto�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo •Date of Evaluatlon: a.�i1 2018 (Thfs space reaerved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) 'RequPred Informatian State of Californla The Resources Agency ' Pnmary`# so-159704 ' 'DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREi4TION , r�HRI# �038070 � � � ';r�- � + i '� � "* t �,� 4' �" .,�.A.,., �CONTINUATION.SHEET � ' 7{ fi,� �°^ C�rinomial o��; ;' .. .. Page 3 Of 3 "R¢SOUfCB NaR1@ O�#: ; BATAVIA_S_164 APN 041=0.42=14 (Assigned by RecoMer) . . — - ... Recorded by:. . .� Marissa_Moshier & Ke11y:Ribuffo Date ReQO�ded: April 2018, ; City of 'Orange_.CD ,Dept'. � ' 300 E. Chapman Avenue ❑�/ Continuatlon Q Update _.. Orange,, CA 92866. . _ , _ .. . Years:Sunieyed: 1982;: 1991, 2018 : Descriptlon of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: . General Plan: ' LMDx. #of Buildings: 2 F r-�, ��r 2�� ,�, � Planning Zone: R-2-6 #of Stories: ' 2 r '� h� ��a { � ;. a j,�, � . LotAcre: #of.Units: 1 '� t-.'�' -ti� ��Y;�'� s ,:'� ;; �.o`�' . �� _ �r?��' "„��i��'?x � �'s•'s i :. , Princlpal.Building Sqft: 1235 . .. . _~�� ` ;'�'` :. . �,, �' p .,� . � : �: B6:Construction History(Continued:from Pg.2): � ' . � � � , b .IIR' 1 ��•�� . . . . . . M, . .. . . .. . . .. , . .. - . .. . . . . .. . . .. . . . �.�-� ..d � . .. " . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . .. . . .. . . . . .. . . �� . .. . 813.Remarks(Contlnued from Pg.2): � ` � ?- •i 1��, � � w_' -- _ _ - � - P3a.Description(Confinued from Pg.1): : . � ^ � t:gable:erid. Large two. story accessory structuie at rear visible fiom:driveway. DPR 523L.(11%98) � "Required Information ... .. : . .. . :... .... .... ,��# ��.� �r � �'}�'� � � �- Primary# 30 ;158707;>?� � �` � -�,.>., �xx� : a r'� 5xs�r�:�,�.'��+�^':� ,µ:�; �a � n a 4��6... c � � k� � . State of:Caiifomia The Resources Agency ,�� , �� , `�� : >a aa�. ��..as, bk��+� � �r�a��< ^��+,�.��€r�t'r . � � ,� y c ,�., x t � HRI# 038073 �, ��, Y �� *DEPARTMENT F PARKS AND RECREATION '�� ,��,� ,, � � , � ° x��r,�� . �A�� ,, � a �' Trinomial oRa."�"`'��,y �-:� , `�` �.,�� , ��^; PRIMARY RECORD�� F -� , � �, � �:- � � � 4 �+''�.t��u��i��'M��' `��`�,�" . . NRHP Status'Code �$5D1��,��"�% ��5�� r� �,x.x . � � a_a �s r,,a� .�.. �� ' ,s�'� r7 � r�+. ,tr� ,�.� ��'�k'�- t�� : �I�� ri+�- r. '� <��`k,.F�''�� 181'�.�8�17�8 a�a . t�' ;" S�. .�; i" -�r�v"` ; , ��"��,� . �� . '��.. ..'mc'� �. J ,� t 3' �, �t . .. .. ,a= . . � �t � r"`� . . . . �. �. 2 �'�`�-+n.sF.� rA..r'�a�,3�o-,�5«�in'�k��rR :, '} "��&.tra z^�.� + �-�'�� .. ; Revlew Code .,,� . �.�< eviewer �� Date = . .. �_. � �. ,�_ .�� , ..,. .r . ,z�a��..��x,a� . w.3,. , � :,r, .,.,.�,. ;. �. , .� �5 �' ^ � f P.age:1::of 3 : . ' ::::".Resource Name or#:::::. BATAVIA_S`176_APN 041-042-13 _ :. (Asslgned by Rewrder):. - P1.Other ldentifier: ::..: : �: . •P2.Location: � Not for Publication' ' �.Unrestricted : .. :. : :. : 'a..County: , oranqe:::. and (pZb and:R2c or P2d. Attach a locadon map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'auad: , . Date: '� T ; R ; mm /4 of . 1/4 of Sec. ,�; ,� 1 B.M. . .. . - c.Address:: i76: = s BATAYIA: : : ST ,.# : .. : : :Ci : Oranae� ZI 92868 tY P�: .. . .. _ _ . d.UTM: (Give more then ane for large end/oc linear resources)Z0�8 ' RIE/.. rtIN .... ..... . . e.0ther Locatlonal Data: . � "P3a.Descrlptlon::(DeaCrib'e resource and its majoY eiement8.:lnclude design,materials,condiUon,'Alterations,size,seding,end boudn2des. ConGnues on Pg.3.) . : Mate�lalg: : Frame - Wood sidinq : ..... A oae'arid' one-half story� 'single family residenee iaith,side ,gable'roof and front.-fac3ng gable, dorm.er. Main gable roof overhang: forms £ront porch. spanning fu11-widtfi. of the house: Porch. has half wall supporting elephantine piers:: Red brick foundation with brick 'steps:at front porch: Wood lap siding. Symmetr:ical " faqade. with centered front doar flanked'by. pair. of tripartite wood windows. Front dormer .has'arch'ed'window . .. with..decor :. :. . ., . . . ... "P3b:Resource AttNbutes: (HP2 j--Single family pro�erty � � (Llat atVlbutea and code"s) �- � . .. .. . :`P4.Resources Presentd : ❑d Building �.Sfructure ❑ Object :� Site ❑ Element of District: :❑ District ❑:Other(Is6lates,etc.) . .. .. . .. .. . .. .. . . � , d.,;, , :. _ ... .. , ,,� , PSb.Desc�iption of Photo: 20I8. . ,i, ,� �' (Vlew�date,eccesalan#); � ,i' '' � 'P6.Date Constructed//�qe and Source: . �i�' �� +' �_ :1911 � . ❑d:Historic ❑ PreFiistoric::..� Both 'P7.Owner.and Address: . �6� " . . ' .. . ' . . � .. . . . . �: � �� - � � ,, � . �� ! . , : � •Pe ,� ,,�� , :Recorded byC .(Name,etfiliation,and address) . - �� ' �' '� �.~., �,., ' �g,'S�� y .^ � '�,; Maris.sa Moshier &_ICellp Ribuffo . . .. ,� :. ':' ...' :. . �4 a" '.,'�l� . . . . . . . . ... � - b:w � 7,�.(� .. ....� . . .. . .� " "� . . q � . .. _ _ � F t_ � • � #�' ` � ��i� C City of Orange�CD Dept. I ` `� - � , . . 300 . hapmari A . . � � ; �� . E C venue � �: . _ . ' Orange, CA 92866 : . � � ..� � �`�^ ,1^ . :-. '�� #'J'�.�'S't3+�.:� '�`s.+,".ICreH..,.� .��' e� "'@' ..�at'�1 ''.�PµRy� • . . . . ' � . • . .. . . . .. . . ..�.'. . . . '. • : � ... ` �• . , .w� _,._.._.__ <;r, , �� .. "P9.Date Recorded: .. :. 'P11.R@pOrtCltHtlon: (CitesurveyrepbiEendathersaurces,or'enter°none'); April 2018.. :' Orange County Assessor Records .(2010.and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic � Building Inventor.y:Update. Heri:tage Orarige County, :Inc; (:1982) Orange :.*p70.:SurveyTypB: (Descdbe)- - Historic SurveY• .� �. _ . : . Reconnaissance . . •Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location.Map:. � Continua4ion.Sheet(s) ❑� Building,Strucfure,.and Object Recard. �.Archaeological Record [] District Record �.Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑.Rack Art Record Artifact Record Photo ra h Record Other List �. � .. .. 9. P � � � )�.. . DPR 529A(1/95) . 'Requlred Infonnatfon .. .r S;Y:on�`+� ��%�k�:r;�x_ " �a§�� s � �"�?x�a�f�" ,s��.1, *��a� :` `" o��„, 'Y �;aState.of Caiifornia The>Resources qgency �� r ; �; �Primary-#�� 30,:�1587 0,?= ��.;�� '��'��t� + DEPA�RTMENT OF PARKS�I4ND RECREATION ��' �� , � �w�, � ,H '. 0 ;� � �� « � z� RI�# 380,73 ,� �'BUILDING STRUCyTURE�YAND OBJECT,�RECORD�y RHP�St�atu�s�de�sna, '� �� ;'.' �t�r,.. �. r. ,� r �..a�r.e. �.k.��a�a��.n.:a,a�,�r Page 2 of 3 "Resource Name or#: BATAvzA s_176 APrr_o41-042-13 (Assigned by Recorder) B1.Historic Name: William J. and Marie Richardson House (1911) B2.Common Name: B3.Orlglnal Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs 'B5.Archltectural Style: Craftsman "B6.Construction History:�consw�uon de►e,atleratians,and date af alteretlons) Date of Construction: 1911 ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both "B7.Moved7 ❑d No ❑ Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Origlnal Location: "68.Related Features: 'B9.Architect or Builder: unknown "B10.S(gn(ficance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Period of Slgnlflcance: Early settlement (c. le7o - 1920) Applicable Crlteria: Ac (Dlacuea Importance In terma of histarical or archltectural context as deflned by theme,periad,and geogrephlc scope.Also address Integrlty. Contlnuea an Pg.4.) St�uCtu�allnteg�ity: Good Condition - Minor changes to original structure: brick front porch steps and founda Stte Integrlty: Opportunittes William J. and Marie Richardson were early owners of the property. Mr. Richardson was the city water superintendent. B11.Additional Resource Attributes: �usc attributes ana codes� •B72.References: � 813.Remarks: �conunues on Pe.a.� (Skatch Map with Nnrth arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Change from SS1 to SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for ' potential boundary adjustment of local' Old Towne Historic District. 'B14.EValuatOf: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo "Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for official camments.) DPR 5238(1/95) "Required Information .. . . ... . . . _ . . . . . . .. .. . . ..... .. . . . � ` State=of�Caltfornfa:-The Resources�Agency�"�� ;�� , '�.Primary`# 3.o�i*5:8,7,0��. �'� � � ��^��`� ��r�s� . � �� DEPAR!iMENT OF PARKS/WD RECREATION� � ��`�k HRI�# 03:8037r3 �'��ra��rn- � � � � �� '� CONTINUA►TION SHEET'� �� Y«��' Trinomial, oxa � ��,� k� � � � � .,, �� x m �� . . � � � w � ��. �.x � �a��. s ,�.. �� _ ..� �� ..� .,.b_�r,. �A .. . .. .. . . . . Page3 of:3 *Resouree'Nameor#: BATAVIA_S_176 APN_041=092-13 :. (Agsigned by Rewrder) . . . . ..... . . . . Recorded by:. Marissa.Nioshier & Kelly:Ribuffo DBte ReCOfded: April 2018 ::., ' ..... City of Orange_.CD Dept'. . 300 E. Chapman Avenue ❑�I COntinuatlon Q Update Orange, CA 92866,. . .. . .. . . . Years:Suriieyed: 1482y: 1991, 2018 Description of Photo: 1991 . _ :. Listed in National Register: :. . . General Plan: LMox #of Bulldings: 2 - �, 1 1 L '""7^*�Y { .. ��'Y.t . .. �` �� : Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Storles: �i�5 ,� , � �,_ �t , �; r � y �,.;' � � ��,� �.'� ; , Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 '; ��=%�'' � '�.,,�,4 J `'Z "' � Princlpal.Building Sqft: ' 1673 . . . �� _ ��:� �,'�z, : B6:�Consfniction Hlstory(Continued:from Pg.2): • . �� -�� F ��-�,_ :n. . . . - �':�v�:_•,�;�� :;-- �=z B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): � . . . � � . . . . . . � . . .. . �h.�'p,4 Ty�-� .�..�NaY.�. ' . .. .��3:��.`�' : .. . ::::P3a.Description(Conflnued from Pg.1): : : � . . :: at'ive corbels. Wide eaye overhang on roof; D'etached garage at:rear:: . . DPR 523L-(11/98) 'Required Informatlon _. _ . _... _... _ � � 'Stateof�Califomfa TheResourcesAgency �� ir �Primary# � 3o�i587oa�. ' ' � =� s� `�.s�'�w«��'�'�c��r - r ��+ � 'e a � � i , �DEPARTMENT�QF PARKS AND RECREATfON c HRI# 038074 � , �� ^n`n��`A+�R��,,� � 3 ''� � ��TI'IDOIIlIBIr �`ORA `z �� - � PRIMARY RECORD Rr ar,ce r ` :, � �.r .t w,�,+ � v�S.��, �,a�N '�� x9 t z'�N . , G "°� ,��s � ��t �� ; ° ,NRHP Status Cotle;�� 5ni/3s 4 :�' � ,s� „b �nT ��t�` r � �r` �r u � �� e.% �a�'� �� " � � � � " ' " �:Other Listings :��;�,r �'� � � , . � � �Review�Code 4'Reviewer �' Date. �� . , .. . _ ., , _ � 4,',.,., . . , ,.<x- P.8j8:1::Of 4 ".ReSOU�Ce NeRI@ O�#:::::. BATAVIA_S`209 APN 041-064-17. —.. _ (Assigned by Rewrder) :. P1.Other ldentifier: i:. _ *P2.Location: � Not for Publication ❑�.Unrestricted : : *a..Gounty: orange:::. and (p2b and:F2c or P2d. Atfach a IocaUon map as necessary.) "b.USGS 7.5'Quad: . Datec i' ; R ; 14 of . 114 of Sec. ; .M. � 1 B .. . .. . C.Address:, 204: :- S BATAYIA: : : ST ,.# : .. : : : ity:,,,�Oranqe i 92868 .�.. _ .. P�: d.UTM:'(Give more than one for large and/oc Ifnear resources)Zo�e ,�H�g ' mE/:: mN . .... e.Other Locatlonal Data: . ".P38.DeSC�lptlOh::(Describe resource and its majot elements.:lnclude design,materials,canditian,"alterations,size,seriing,and baudnaries. Cantinues on Pg.3.) .. : Mate�lals: : Frame - Wood and:.wood shake siding.. :. : ' L'arge'tvio' and.one-hal'f story 'single.,famil'y =e'sidence. with hip roof and gable dormer's witli shaped exposed ' rafter tail:s and:decorative corbels. ;Square plan with oovered porch with large':arched openings_.wrapping northeast cbrner of house. Variety of wood window types including bay windows; diamond-shaped windows, multi-light double hung.windows, 'and'leaded.glass.windows. Cas.t.stone.porch piers and.foundation walls... .. Narrow:wood � _.. "P3b:Resource Attributes: (xP2j=-si�c�le famii�p�r�erty . .. .. .. (Liat alVlbtites end codes) . • • _ : :'P4.Resources:Present: : ' 0 Building �.Sfructure ❑ Object :❑ Site ❑ Element of Distriot: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isolates,etc.) . :� :� r� ,� �,��. �� . �� ' � �� - �yl � P5b.Description of�Photo: 20I8 � � � � .. . . .. r. K i ��K+�� .. �� ei i A � . . ' . . . .. . ;� s� X. „�'� ��r " "��'.r�i�'��,`�-�� F��,sa`�' Mew�date�eccesslon#)- � � �,�#'r. r �� ... � . '.'. �: . ' .'.. ," �s ( �_ � � Y �� P6.Date s g and So . f � � ?� " Con tructed/A e urce• ,<,+ m"' � - ., �v..�,,,, .��-� � ,#„ : , , s _ w . �,, -' ,::M �,'�.� r �.�`�,, , a . ,�: 1905 . �, ❑./:Historic ❑ PreFiistoric::..❑ Both ` imnmintr.�r r .�;� � , , � � 3_�,��"� "t� . "P7.Owner and:Address: � � -- - - µ x - - _-.;,_r., --- - - . _ . . . - .. . . . . � � � -- - � .� � 4. . . _� � . , :. .... . � - , nsa�.��-- •P8:Recorded by: :�Neme,affiliation,and atldress) : , �._.. . �"' ��,;-i; -----"' Maris.sa Moshier &.Kelly Ribuffo � . .. �'' 1?!.� � w'��'.�. . . ' . ' . . ' .. �i , ', ' ;. ,.:. City of Orange .CD Dept. '� � 300 E. Chapman Avenue , .p:, �, � . . -�.- � -` 4 , �. �# x : � Orange, CA 92866 i .... , �, , , � �.. ^ s;, . � � �� , ��,�. . . _: .��"� , � - ` .. , "P9.Date Recorded: . 'P11.Repolt.CftatlOn: (Cite.surveyrepoitandothersources,orenter'none') April 2018.. : - . . . Orange County Assessor Records .(2030,and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic . :: Building Inventory.Update. Heritage�Qraiige County, :Inc; :(19a2) Orange :.*p1.0.�SurveyType: (Descrfhe) ' � Historic Survey: ; - _ .... Reconnaissance.. ... _ `Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location.Map:. � Continuation.Sheet(s) � Building,Structure,.and Object Record. ❑ Archaeological Record � District Record ❑ Linesr Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑-Rock Art Record 0 Artifact Record � Photograph Record 0.Other(List): DPR 523A(1/95) 'Required Informetion �� i''.{yt�+.-r �'� � �) a ..; 4 ;.t.d'-t� "' _.: ;cY.. �$tl':j�•��"°:s.�„,- � . .�.y Yt'..t G State of Califomia The Resources Agency v �� ,:_ � � Pnmary'# � 30-1587oe � �. + �° ��- ` ,� : �iBl�:e7a'�ffiS'�.`�Jd��'`��.' �:a`a�R h� �'�i�wr ��.vi'�:e� '�#g'`I Fl��rt�„ �,`.:�'� � �. °� DEP,ART�ME�NxT�OF PARK�S�D RE��R�l4T-I�ON�� t,��t�.=��ar' HRI# �s� 038074 �+� Q �X'�-§ ��'��--a��s' qti , � ��`�BUILDING,#STRUC7URE,ANDAOBJECT�,RECORD ',�"NRHP.Status Code .- 5D1/3 G,,��.�; � �$ ��``��r�p�,�°,�ri a„4.,�,.o��_ a Fsaa, rs�m-n ��.t�aa.r. `��?J' � ��'�-.a.� � .wN�� .�.�t,.�.�: ,�A,. �-6'�� Page 2 of 4 "Resource Name or#: sATAviA s_2o4 APN 041-064-17 (Agsigned hy Recarder) 81.Hlstol'IC Name: James M. and Emily D. Marsh House B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.ArChiteCtural Style: Folk Victorian "B6.Constructlon Hlstory:�co�sw�o�dete,atleratians,and date af alteratians) Date of Construction: 1905 ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both •B7.Moved7 .I❑ No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "88.Related Features: "B9.Architect or Builder: unknown "B10.Significance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of orange PropertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgnlflcance: Early Settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Appllcable Criterla: Ac (Diacuse Importance In terms of hlstorlcal or erchltedural conlext as deflned by theme,perlod,end geagraphlc scope.Also address Intagrity. ConUnues on Pg.4.) St�uCtu�allnteg�lty: Good Condition - Minor changes to original structure. Slte Integrlty: Opportunitle3 The house is an excellent example of its architectural style. Appears individually eligible for National Register of Historic Places. History of Ownership: James M. and Emily D. Marsh, citrus ranchers, lived at the property from 1919 to 1922. Neil H. and Viva Edgar lived here in 1923. Mr. Edgar was part owner in Edgar and Hays Company in Santa Ana. In early 1924, they sold the house to Frank E. and Nellie Miles, and moved to 2302 Spurgeon in Santa Ana. Mr. Miles was a pioneer in the grocery business, and had operated grocery stores in Goldfield, Nevada and Pomona, California before coming to Santa Ana in 1913. He opened a new store there and soon had outlets in Orange, Anaheim, Fullerton and Garden Grove. He sold that firm after a few years, then started a new chain with stores in Orange, Anaheim and Fullerton and a bakery in Tustin. Around 1919, he sold out to Acme chain. Mr. and Mrs. Miles had a son, Frank E. Jr., listed as a student, clerk and later, in 1930, as an operator in B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��st anribuces and cades� •B72.References: Orange Daily News. "A Place Called Home," Brigandi, Phil and Wilson Tunbull, Karen (1990, p.40) . City Directories, L.A. County (1883-1884) and City of Orange Section (1901, 1907 - of the age 15 years and over and Classified Business) . Orange Householder's Guide (1919, 1922-1930, 1932) . City Directory by Streets (1919, 1922-1930, 1932) . Classified Business (1919, 1922-1930, 1930) . 813.RemerkS: (Continues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map wilh North errow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Added SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. Style previously noted in 1991 Survey as Classic Box. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. "B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribu£fo •Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This spece reserved for official comments.) DPR 523B(1/95) 'Required Informatlon ... . . .. . .. . . . . .... �� '� �,`b.c` �� x�.a'��h�ti,�?�7'�'J .. r ` 'E s�.�` w�r�%3 ; r ' �s.XB+kH w& '`�3 � �State of'California The ResourcesAgency „ u �: Prima'ry`#��30,°isa7oa�; a � �,�� ,° r�,r� � � x x�,�#'"�� r� x� �, i � a�a . � x -' +�� . � , DEP�E�OF�P�K�S 14WD�RECREATION � ��' HRI#, � ,�038074 �� , � � � �CONTINUATION SHEET �� k � � �` � �� " TNnomial oxa {�� .� b�,�� .,�ixYv^��r�msr�� -Aom.,h�,•.�.sm�r.�s`.t�?�,fl`��.,� ��:-a �.�rv"YS� �""°'°"�" . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . .. . . . .. . . . .. . Page 3 of:4 *Resource Name or#: BATAvia_s_204 APN- 041=064-17 " (Assigned by Recarder) — _ .. .. Recorded by:. ' . . .. Marissa •Moshier & Kelly:Ri_buffo DateReCofded: April 2018 ' „ City of 'Orange..CD .Dept'. . . . 300 E. Chapman Avenue ❑�/ CofltlflUatlon Q UpdBte Orange,. ,CA 92866' ' Years:Surveyed: 1982;: 1991, 2018 Descrlption of Ph�oto: 1991 . . Listed in National Register: . . . :. General Plan: LrtDx. . #of Bulldings: - 2 . . Planning Zone: x 2=6 : : #of Stories: 2.:5 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 : j`''3„ ��t �'��,� � a Principal.Bulldfng Sqft: 2796 . .. ��,�,��k�,��,,, .�,' '` j .. B6.Constnictlon History(Contlnued:from Pg.2): �� _ ;, �., . � -• , - �.�. _��. � g f`=� :� - - B13.Remarks(Contlnued from Pg.2): ' --;; : ..�:�, . ��iM� .� �� <� ��,^ .�.. _ _ .. .. . ._., . P3a.Descrlption(Confinued from Pg.1): : _ _ ,. lap siding_on ground floor::Wood shakes on. upper floor. Large;corner property with. tvro mature Canary :. ' Islarid' Date Palms in Batavia;side parkway;; fl'anking concrete front walkway. Double-heigkit;carriage house' ' .. .. ' on northeast side of,property: Carriage house has steeply pitched 'front gable.roof with eicposed rafter ' " " ' tails and a:shed roo£ side extension.: Small cupola with louvered vents centered.on ridge. Wood lap 'siding with wood shakes matching the house in:front gable end. Sliding wood carriage::house door on :east .e]:evation. - . DPR 523L(11/98) - - 'Required lnformatlon r.�P�Y ro�+,. � 2r'' y �r�R`aA�xh ,� ` : f �� 4 � t-r `"�r'K�t,.r� a ':� ,eY�'� � .s. ��. :,,: „ - �State of�Californfa �TheiResources/lgency , ' 3 °�,° ,� ��Primary# , �3o F�158708; � �, s � v�r��h�a��-�� ,.�� s� {� . 4,� ,� �� c��s � � 038074 , � r �� OF'Pi4RKS AND RECREATION � � ,�R,„ ��'� a��HRI#� '`��;a a. �'�c��' � �+� �DEPARtME T ��, N•� N � � g � ,�a�' r �� ,'-CONTINUATION�SHEET�� r ; '.c ',� �' y�' � ��,.� Trinomial{.��.�ox� �,`�" ��,�..,�. � �.�m��+a.�:.sn�u,a�S.ima^:,x..�,�a+.a,v�. � a��,..s*. ..-a ,� , ,. ��, r, �n'b t,.n9�,r mh`�.n,atta3t�;;t�"��nf;�.�u�t. na"4" Page 4 of 4 "Resource Name or#: BATAVIA s_2o4 APN 041-064-17 (Assigned by Recarder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date RecO�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue 0 ContlnUatlon ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 B10.Signlficance(Continued from Pg.2): the Community Service Station, 224 E. Chapman. In 1932, another Miles, Glenn R. was also listed as a resident. He was an operator with Standard Stations, Inc. The Miles family lived here until 1933 when the financial pains of the Great Depression cost them the home. Mr. Miles retained his ranch in Lemon Heights, where he died in 1950 at the age of 73. In September of 1937, the house was purchased by Edwin Gould for $5,500. Gould had moved from Wisconsin and become the manager of the Anaconda Wire & Cable Company, Orange's first successful large-scale industrial plant. He was active in many social and fraternal organizations and also served on the Orange High School Board of Trustees. He lived in the house until he died at 67 in January 1963. His widow, Alma, continued to live here after that. His son, Richard, was the proprietor of Orange Camera and Photo in the Plaza. DPR 523L(11/98) "Requlred Informatlon _ .. � �� `State of California The.Resourcesi4gency �� ' �,; Pnmary# ' � �� ` r�DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION� , �i�fl�� <� _ -�� HRI#� ?� ` " �,�� ` `` � � �PRIMARY,RECORD- �� ` � w � ' �' �Trinoml,�ai��o� , "` ' � � ' �, �� h ��t� �,`�� i:'�d� `�% k m :. ` '"��'�� "NRHP StetUS COd6 x��to 5D1 � � i a a � � a. . ay� « : , t ,.,Other Listings `.. �"�� y";��_ ' s R ^ a � 3 �{�Re`vlew Code M` ��':'+ " ' 'Reviewer `: "` °` ', Date ` � � • '.= v 5 � , , ,. . . , . . , , _ ... ,. . ...,. ��.��.�.` . .. Pageil.:of 3 "Resource Nartie or#:::..: BATAviA S 210_APN 041-064-16 (Assigned by Rewrder):. � P1.Other ldentifier: ::. _ . . . "P2.Locat(on: � Not for Publication� ❑�.Unrest[icted *,e.,COunty: Oranqe:::. ancl (p2b and:P2c or P2d. Attach a locadon map as necessary.) *b'.USGS 7.5'Quad: . Date: T�; R , /4 of . 1/4 of Sec. ; .M. �� 1 B . . c.Address:. 210: :- s BATAVIA: : : : ST ,.# : .. : : :City: Orancie Zip: : :92868 �. d.�17�M:'(Give more than one for large and/oc linear resaurces)Z0�8 � RIE/., RIN e.Othe�Locatfonal Data: . . '"PSB.DeSC�IPtIO�:.�Descri6e resaurce and its majorelements.:lnclude design,materials,canditlon,'ailerallons,size,setting,and houdnaries. Continues on Pg.3,) . .. Materlals: : Frame - Wood siding :. : . „One and a half. story single 'family. residence with steeply, pitched' side gable roof. R'rbnt elevation has tcvo ' ' „ gable roof clormers with wood double liurtg windows. Off-center front entry with. pedimented surround, with .. . engaged fluted pil:asters. Decorative=wood front door screen with fan-shaped detail. Curved'front 'driveway. . . . . " Brick.chimney on south.elevation: Wide wood.lap. siding with'mitered. corners. Two-ouer.:two.wood double hung . .. wind... :. :. .. . "P3b:Resource Attributes: (HP2j--Single. family property . .. .. � (Llst atVibOtes and c6des) � _ . "P4.Resources.Present: : ❑d Building O.Structure ❑ Object :� Site ❑ Element of Distriot: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isolates,etc.) : ri J; ' . „ ��.��,,�,� � � " �� `�� P5b.Desc�iption of�Photo: �o��e � v y : � (Vlew;date,accesslon#) em� � .. . .. . . . j� ��"�� * �a�G� .. � .. .. . . . �. . . .. ...Y- .. Yc s . . . � ' : ; ; � - ` ;,,._:� . �'':' •P6.Dete Constructed/Age and Source:. .. . .. � �`•„ � --_ ° r� i� 1940 : �, �,.,.�:� � • -'�'' i -' ., �- ` •" " � � � Historic ❑ Prefiistoric � Both ��F r t , „ -,.: � , � •P7.Owner.and Address: : _ .. . .. -�� - �,� ' . . . � , � . . _ �. — ' 1. 4 - .. � : f 4; ,,, ,�, �PB:Recorded by: :�Name,afiliation,and address) :; ��' Marissa Moshier &.Kelly Ftibuffo " - � - . ,- t.,..- • ,_� ,,.- _..,. . . . . v� �- ..- . - � .r ,.,_,.,-.,�,�.ny.:..;' -' ",� . . . ., . . .. . .. -' _-_ . .. . . . .. . . . _ .,. ....� ... a.... _.,. . . .... n. . . . "'.. r - - ,, r ;��:� City of Orange CD Dept. ,: . �,r � .0 ; 300 E. hapman A � � F � C venue � _ � � ` �. Orange, CA 92866 . . . ' `- � ' • , : . .� . t . .. �� . .. f � t�.. ' : �.': _,..::.:� i . . �__..__� . ••.. �.�.._.�....; .__,�.,. _ . �,_ , : . _ .P9.Date Recorded: . 'P11.RepO1t CitetlOO: (Cite;survey repoA end other sources,or:enter•none•); April 2018,. . Orange Couny Assessor Records (.2018) -: ::.. •P1 . D.:SUN@)/T�@' (DescdbeJ' :',::, Reconnaissance. " _ _ _. 'Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location.Map:. ❑� Continuation-Sheet(s) � Building,Strucfure;.and Object Record. �.Archaeological Record 0 District Record ❑.Linear Feature Record 0 Milling Station Record❑.Rock Art Record _ _. 0 Artifact Record [] Rhotograph Record 0.Other(List): DPR 523A(t/95) *Required Information .. �''e� �Dx�:�'4�cr�t.ba,�'n\'X�- _ .� -. :. . ,. .. ,,:.-, _ . ., .. �d-�'�.�"."F�'`+,2� h��;��a��f+��x�k�".---'„� . . ; 4'� State of California=The�Resources�Agency , Prlmary# �,,,�;��,�.`��„��.� .� DEPARTMENT'OF-PARKS ANDyREGREATION ' HRI�#= ��' :: � , a� "`�-- ,. .. • BUILDING iSTRUCTURE i4ND�OBJEC�T�RECORD "NRHP status cotle; sD1��k -° :R� , x�a.,-��.6� � ��.a��.�+1�.". _�:�ms�..�.�..k�.a.�-.� �"r,�w�.t�. � Page 2 of 3 `Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_zio APN 041-069-16 (Assigned hy Recorder) B1.Historic Name: B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: �s 84.Present Use: xEs "B5.Archltectul'al Style: Colonial Revival *B6.Constructlon History:�oonswctian date,atlerations,and date of alteratians) Date of Constructlon: 194 0 ❑.I Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both "B7.Moved7 ./❑ No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Archltect or Builder: vnknown "B10.SigniflCance: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange P►opertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgnlflcance: Interwar Development (c. 1921 - 1941) Applicable Criterla: AC (Dlscusa Importance In tertna af hletarical ar architectural context as deflned by theme,perlod,and geagrephlc scape.Also address Integrlty. Continues on Pg.4.) Structurallntegrity: Good Condition - No apparent change to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunities 811.Additional Resource Attributes: �u�c anr;b�tas a�d fode5� "B12.References: B13.Remarks: �coour,�as o�Ps.a.) (skecon MeP w�u,Nortn errow rey��rea.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously suryeyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. "B14.EValuato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo 'Date of Evaluatlon: ,�il 2018 (This space reserved for officfal comments.) DPR 523B(1/95j 'Required Information ��,��b� � � ..Stateof:Califomia TheResourcesAgency ` L�� „�;;�F�E � ;� �Primary# ,= ��d , : � �,�',� " +�a'`7w°'�sbi�'a `t#«�z k,z� � �a 4�.�i'4��`'�` ,x: ' - �� ¢ � ", x+, L �1EPARTMENT50F PARK�S�AND�RECREATION�,x �,��`��.�� HRI# ; g � a �:��t"�„� > � �,�� '�r°� '`�.,, , ,,CONTINUATION SHEET��`�,F ?#; � �,��`�n�� f Trinomial o�ia `�� _ �� ,;� �� .�. ;� � ��; � Page 3 of 3 •Resource Name or#: BATAVIA s_210 APN oai-o64-16 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: 2018 Descriptlon of Photo: Llsted in National Register: General Plan: LMDx #of Bulldings: 2 Planning Zone: x-2-6 #of Storles: 1.5 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 Principal Bullding Sqft: B6.Constructlon History(Continued from Pg.2): B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Descrlption(Continued from Pg.1): ows. Detached two car garage at rear. DPR 523L(11/98) *Required Infarmatlon __ __. _ . .... _. . _ ... .. _ �� y �� ri � t ; .� � � �� '5tate of�Caltfomla The Resourc�es �enc ' Prima `' � ` F � ' �' � ' F n rRr tAa��S�t.� � �&r ��.r� -u`e'�k��a� �,� ��,� � `DEPARTMENT OF�PARKS AND RECREATION.�', HRI# : *�,�;�� g �`m�'�"r�trrk�'�h£'�'a�R�.�xe.tM�ta�'7r: � �A�45F � �� "§ > ,�t h- ar t x F' av4 a �� . .a 5 � � �, � �a , T T�inomial ��o�;�,. °�, r� ��,� PRIMARY RECORD ' ,�, �� , � � x '4�'3 Y7 =.'un> .r a� , ,�� -n �+�'e � tt�M c t -r . .� �h c r"��`,�r,'�� s �Z : ��+� P � � , a,� k � " t ,�w�J<u,�` s�h n4 ��, � �, , �� , . 4 , y NRHP Status Code � 5nI � � � A � � „��,,4 , , � �^y aaa� �,t�4 d�r �� s� xf -,� k a � �� a+ ; � :rf �i'�' r ��. � r s � . .. r t L�`+t�' �'*.�'ve� a"nh-r ,� �s# a t � � m+.,ar+.� {��i� �rs��r:a�a��'��'.8V'a €:" � . . . � f� � �� i'�� Othe�LiStlllgs �, �:t. 3 r ;7:� �;� �'`�„'a � a� r �� a� 1� or. �,�.t�'`ar`4�'�✓�4S;a-5i` � " �,,.a .,. , Rev(ewCode "' 'FReviewer � �'�` r� �`Date '` � � � , . : , ; , : . _ ,. ,; : �: . . - . , . ,.� ,. . �, ,- ;ri, ,.�. �:....� ::� ., n� �.. • , w�-:,_ , . _ ; . . . . z Page:1::of 4 .' ' ::::"ResourceNarrieor#:; ;: BATAVIA S 220 APN 041-064-98 : — — — _ (Assigned by Recorder) P1.Other ldentifier: ::.. *P2.Location: 0 Not for Publication ❑�.Unrestricted : _. :. . "a..County: oranqe:::. and (p2b and:F2c or P2d.Attach a locatlan map as necessary.) . .. *b.USGS 7.5'Quadc . Date:� 'F�; R�; � 14 of . 114 of Sec. ; .�� .M. 1 B c.Address:. : 220: :- S BATAVIA: : ; ST ,.# : .. : : :City: Oranae Zip:: : :92868 _ d.�ITAfl: (Give more than one for lerge and/oc linear resaurces)Z0�8 � RIE/.. IIII� . _ e.Other Locatlonal Data: � "P38.DBSC�IptlO�::(Descrihe resaurce and its majar elements.lnclude desfgn,malerials,condition,alterations,aize,setting,and boutln8ries. Continues an Pg.3.) .. Mate�lals: : Frame - Wood siding � ..... . . ' Two sf.ory' single_ family'residence,wi,th side'gabSe' roof.,Wide 'expo'sure wood lap .sidin'g'. Large. multi-light bay window 'on front elevation. 3 gable'.roof dormers with multi-light double hung windows on front ' elevaton. Wood paneled front door in recessed, off=center entrance. Decorative__dentil trim'at entry and .. . . roof. eaves. Very narrow.eave overhang'. Curued..driueway in front..yard...Detached two. car garage 'at rear.. .. .. "P3b:Resource Attributes: (xP2j-�sinale familv Propertv (Llat eltrlbutes end code's),��'" . � � *P4.Resources:Presentc : ❑d Building 0.Sfructure ❑ ObJect :0 Site ❑ Element of Districti :❑ DisVict ❑:bther(Isolates,etc.) � x�'0 P5b.Desc�iption of Photo: �''`� �� ; � (Vlew;date,accesslon#) �� '�q"� : . � • �• �� "PB.Date�Constructed/i�qe�and Source: . � � �� . �`i _ :, '��wawn . _— r,., ,, 1940 N , P - ; <t �. '_� �'�r��:a _ _ . .� �.� ;�;:''r� ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ..� Both - _ ,� � 7� �' -____ "P7.Ownec and.Address: � � ' _�:y.- ___ „, --- , - _ - ,-�,x��.+�^=t- +� '� 4�" i � `P8:Recorded by: �Nama,affiliation,and eddress) + w'"yx' i � q� Maris.sa Moshier &.Kelly Ribuffo , :�;t8 @jq ' __�_ —�. . .«, t� �„ " �..� " . :. � . . . .. ' " i City of. Orange CD Dept. �� ._ i:�3. .. . 300 E. Chapman Avenue Orange, CA 92866 " ��.�. ..,. . . ..,i._9.. ' .. •P9.Date Recorded: :. 'P11.R@pOlt Cltation: (Cite survey repoit and athar sources,or;enter'none°): April 2018., Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018) . . .. :. : .P10 .... �: . .Survey Type: �oescdte�: : Reconnaissance . . ... . •Attachments: ❑ NONE �. ❑ Location.Map: 0 Continuation.Sheet(s) � Building,Strucfure,.and Object Record. 0.Archaeolagical Record 0 District Rewrd ❑.Linear Feature Record �.Milling Station Record❑ Rock Art Record � Aitifect Record 0 Rhotograph Recard 0.Other(List): . DPR 523A(t%95) .. "Required Inforrnation . f�,�,, ,,.�x,<.� �t�:��`��'r�t�.�;:,:�, $ ;, �, , e;,Y�•'��y�� ..� s �; �S � �a�€�Y: �State of.�Califomia The!Re"sources Agency £x �,��,�-�� - Pr�mary,#, �� ` � Pr ` � dy�',Ttl�...' i�1 ro�F-�'�� K .�!�' p 5�_thTi�'s��;�.^ J , e"�'�.a'�y .c .� � . _ b .. �. DEPARTMENT OF PARKS APVD.RECREATION�; ��, ti� ,�, :�� HRI# `"�� ., �; > , � r '�+��k �:�a 3 n,� �n'�r,* � ��» � ��'�^'"`� :: �BUILDING,rST,�RUCTU�R,E,:AND�XOBJECT RECORDK��,�!�P>status�C�ode��h�s�� ,��"�� "'��_� � ,� � Page 2 of 4 `Resource Name or#: BATAVIA s_22o APr7 041-069-48 (Ansigned by Recarder) 61.Historlc Name: B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: RES B4.Present Use: xEs *85.Architectu�al Style: Colonial Revival *B6.Constructfon Hlstory:(Canstruction date,atleraUons,and date of alterations) Date of Construction: i 94 0 ❑d Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Bath •B7.Moved7 d❑ No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "B8.Related Features: "B9.Architect or Builder: onknown "B10.SIgn1£ICanCe: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange PropertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgniflcance: Interwar Develo�ment (c. 19z1 - 1541) Appllcable Crlterla: Ac (Dlscues Importance In terms of hlatorlcal or architedural conteM as deflned by lheme,perlod,anil geographic scape.Also addreas Integrity. ConUnuea on Pg.4.) StruCtufal Integ�lty: Good Condition - Minor changes to original structure � Site Integrity: Opportunitles The house was constructed in 1940 by Roy R. Russell a prominent contractor and real estate entrepreneur, who built and sold houses throughout the Santa Ana and Orange areas. In 1941, Vera Wettlin purchased the house as her sole and separate property, where she lived with her husband David Wettlin and their children until 1954. From 1935 to 1954, Vera Wettlin served as the City of Orange Postmaster, a federally appointed position, and was the primary income earner for her family. She served as Postmaster during the dedication of the new Post Office at 308 W. Chapman Avenue in 1935. She was Postmaster when the Orange Post Office received first class of£ice status, the highest class rating in the Postal Service, and was present at the first airmail drop in the City in the summer of 1946. Her tenure ended in 1959, having completed 20 years of service t B11.Additional Resource Attributes: �usc anrin�ces and�ode5) •812.References: 813.Remarks: �co�unues o�Pg.a.� (Sketch Mep with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. 'B14.EValuato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribu£fo 'Date of Evaluatlon: April 2018 (Thfs space reserved for of(iclal camments.) DPR 5238(1/95) "Required Information ;State of'Caltfo�nia The Resources Agency }�r� Primary# � 7 � vk��,e��dr��a�` � � � �� t: zz . q��,�'s�,� y.��y��a-��n�� ;. DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION - � ��r��p��r� � � � � �� `.��tr� x",�r HRI�#"�"�'��h^� - �,CONTINUATIOf�SHEET " - �� b;�° aYTr`Inomia��.o�,�' >�,r. .�; " �; aA„a.,ixi��reae�+n 3 `.^„ �� r�'.: 8 .'s. `&$ ,��'�v. '1; Page 3 of 4 "Resource Name or#: sATAvia s_22o APN oal-o64-98 (Psaigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. chapman Avenue ❑�/ Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: zole Descriptlon of Photo: Listed in National Register: General Plan: LMDR #of Bulldings: 2 Planning Zone: R-z-6 #of Storles: 2 Lot Acre: #of Units: 1 Principal Bullding Sqft: B6.Constructlon Htstory(Contlnued from Pg.2): B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Descrlptlon(Continued fram Pg.1): DPR 523L(11/98) `Requlred Information xit� �r�.;�-� :. ic ._ ..:..� e�s ii:s�,:g'�,y, ��,�a� �� ra A�'4--'S�k"3 .a�,� ,�, ` ' '��-�, Y �fi art �, ;��State of�Cal(fomia The Resources Agency ;�°� �>� z ,§� ��7'� �Primary# � 7 , , ��, *� � �' ,,�.�u�t;:�� .�a �,��,�� a�r ,� �, �,��, . � ; 'DEPARTMENT OF�'PARKS AND RECREATION �- � � ��£7�� '' HRI# : ` ��f�; �� z�� > �r ��Q��a��°��f ��t�� , �,� �z � s k � �. � �� . �CONTINUATION°'SHEET '��r � °� ; ,�,r� �A� �Trinomial, o�u � � �. ,� ��s�. � � ray»„a.�nn�� a.. v»�,d .»? .r.hi�k- �^�r+;aF t�;r-t� Page 4 of 4 *Resource Name or#: BATAVIA s_22o APN o41-064-98 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: Apri1 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 30o E. Chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 B10.Stgnlflcance(Continued from Pg.2): o the community. Wettlin's position as Postmaster, her professional and civic life, and her homeownership reflect the slowly increasing number of women in the workforce during the mid-twentieth century and the reality of women's roles as income earners and heads of households from the Great Depression through the 1950s. Wettlin was a member of a number of important Orange community organizations, including the Toastmasters and the Woman's Club, where she held the presidency for several terms. She was also an active member of the Orange Business and Professional Women's Club, where she served as Public Relations Chair in 1941. As a prominent member of the community, her home served as an important meeting place for these community institutions. The house retains the majority of its features from its construction in 1940 and through Vera Wettlin's ownership of the house, which ended when she sold the house the same year as her retirement in 1954. DPR 523L(11/98) 'Required Information .. . . _. _. _ . . . �" ""'" `�"�`' " Pnmary# 30>158709. '� `" K � �'State of California Th�e Resources Agericy �,x � �� 'na ,r t a �.. �•` sxa�'n.$�",�ati,`"x rt�n�w�« S *3s. t3 '�"hY`c'� f� r }y � � `�t!t `^""� f'�, o ;'� �� e��i* ,�.,.. � �, 7� 's, ��, k� �r h HRI# "> �038075 � �' t « a ��s� � DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION� �� ,�,,�� , , . :..F .� �4 a �'+`�'�sT'�� n r-� � 4 a� p� � "��Li Fi > �� fr.r<+� - . . . -PRIMARY RECORD ��` �a ��`�'�'��` � jF t�� "` �` ��' t x Trinomlal o� �' ��;� � z ; �'� ,a• r � r�<" �� "�`�hi�,r'�T'�`c��a��`�", y,� a'r��3�� ` ' w ' 'r x a �;��'fi��"`�'Y r;� ' `,,�3 na �; � u ; L � z�, �� ' � � N�P stei�$coae 5D1/3S � � � � .<.a t, r �fi � �E�#`�r�u;'�'�tbi§a�,`'�t'�.� D�r��t��`�`u� r �'kr '�'��E��'§��.'.�qti i � x�� i � �F x�€d r'Y a�'�-�7 �' �� ; 5 Y � a : Other Listings �� . ., F ' � �, N , i s =Review Code r `' �� `�' :'Reviewer ' ;,;�;` '�'�"��,'Date ' r'`�`k '� ,, , , , , �, , , ��. ., �, -:. „„ <,��. �:�.M., . , ,�... , ,... , _,.. ,.,. . y„4 Page:1:;of 4 "Resource Name or#:::::: BATAVIA_S`22'9 APN 041-064-50. (Asslgned by Rewrder):. — — P1.Other ldentifier: "P2.Locatlon: � Not for Publication �.Unrestricted : ".a..County: Orange::;, and (p2b and:P2c or P2d. Atlach a lacation map as necessary.) "b.USGS 7.5'Quad: , Date:� 'T��; R�; � 1/4 of 1/4 of Sec ; . . BM . .. . c.Address: 224. :- s BATAVIA: : : ST ,# Ci : OranQe Zi 92868 ty p:: d.UTM: (Give more than ane far large and/oc linaer resouroes)Zofle �� ' mE/ mN _. e,Other Locational Data: ".P3a.DeSC�1ptI0I1::(Describe resource and its maja�elements:Include design,materiai's,candition,'alterations,size,aetting,and boutlnaries. Continues an Pg.3.) . Mate1'lals: : Frame - Wood siding ..... A two story Craftsman house 'w:ith, a. series of'front gable roofs.'Fioritmost„gable.,is supported by„Japariese' influenced piers:at: front porch: and_incorporates sl:atting_ i:n the uppermost. portion of the gabl,e..;Two large picture windows with transoms are Yocated on either side=oE main entry door. Gable eaves are wide and have exposed. rafters. A brick. chimne is located.in the rear. Lar e. accessor buildin at rear.of' ro ert " Y ' 4 y Y P P Y.. .. .. Curved: *P3b:Resource Attributes: (HP2j--Single family pioperty (Llat etVlbules and codes) "P4.Resources Present: : 0 Building �.Sfructure ❑ Objeot :� Site ❑ Element of District: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isolates,etc.) ;� �, � �y��+ � , , � ;� PSb.Description of Photo: 2018 ,� �' � �'��r� �� x ��s�� R� � . s��a��a��rq 8 �,,� p��.�'.c �� "�` �✓F 1�" �x , (View�dete,accesalon#). , . tt;. �,� . . . . ,. . . ,� , . .� . . . w 4 �aa.� :. ,� , � . . ., :' :' : ' : . . .... . .. . . . ..... . ..... . . . , � ,. �6>„ - . " . . .. �., � ° ° � � y "P6.Date Constructed/i�qe and Source:. .. � , >1 � ,�- 19.15 r: • i, „ �. u. ��,, .. �� , ., . ~�R''� oric oth -� r � \ ❑�I Hist ' ❑ Prehistoric: . ❑ B � -,� _ _ -a. . _ r.�. Y r 1.. , °�� •P7.Owner and:Address: � � � � ,� ��,.;� � �� - � � , t � _ � �:, . . __ y��y , . � '' f '� � �...y_,...�`.�,. � . .:,. r �"�, --� �� , . _ , �_. ....., •. , ' M"'�`� - ' `PS•Recorded by�� N r�r ti d aa • • ame,a ia'on,an a ress) ' • � �;'�—..� Mazissa Moshier &.Kelly Ribuffo :,��gr�'�>.w "'��.�°^,,....«.,. ' � ' : � � _ . . "�.;,�.. ��" '� a�_`"b'«•� ,a.-� t�. ' . . '. . . . . . . . .. . . . .. " �,%� City of: Or.ange CD Dept. , : _ . . . ; ;''°i • 300 E. Chapman Avenue . .. i `'± r ' � Orange, CA 92866 i ' � � � �� ,., � :� � � '. � ' : �.. *P9.Date Recorded: .. . : - "P11.R8portCltation: (Cite:surveyreporEendothersources,ar:enter•nane'): April 2018;. : Orange County Assessor Records .(2030.and 2018) . AEGIS (1991) Historic . ; ::.. Building Inventory,Update. Heri:tage Orange County, ;Inc; (:1982) Orange *p�:O.:SUrveyType: (Dascdbe) Historic Surqey: :' ' . Reconnaissance.. ... .. . .. "Attachments: ❑ NONE ❑ Location.Map:. � Continuation Sheet(s) � Building,Structure,-and Object Record. 0.Archaeological Record � Diatrict Record ❑ Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑.Rock Art Record � Artifact Record 0 Rhotograph Recard �.Other(List): .- DPR 523A(1/95) - "Required Information ��State of Caltfornia�The`Re ou�ces�ency r `�� x� �i�" �'�"� ��M� y � � � � � �' ' PPIR18ry#��`�30=158709 � r �*-��""�w3�.s3`e�* �'�u �°��`�k s� ...�r+�r a z i 4- -s ��.£�,n ��k��`'xiy��'N��e. � �� , t r ��.�� ;DEPART:MENTaOF PARKS AND RECREATION� �� " j�., {, "HRI# .,"" ��038075��;�`� �,$. � °° � ��, .?; �' �"�� - ��,�a`}�.?a� a�,s R.-` e r�,�.�,� c_'a�'+r�.pr��`u'.��-�p'�" ��',: � �. � '£ �BUILDING,�STR�UC,TURE,AN,D OBJECT�RE�CORD ��NRHP�Stat�u�s�Code��,sDi/3�`� �',��}� � ' ' ' � ,_ Page 2 Of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAvzA s_229 APN 041-064-50 (Assignad hy Recorder) B1.Historic Name: John and Gail Young House B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: xEs *B5.Archltectural Style: Craftsman *B6.COnSt�uCtlon HistOry:(Constructian date,atlerations,and date af alterations) Date of Construction: 1915 ❑d HlStofiC ❑ P�ehiSto�C ❑ Both Wood windows replaced with vinyl in the original openings on the side elevations. One window has been converted to a bay window with vinyl sashes. *B7.Moved7 ❑d No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: unknown "B10.SlgnifiCanCe: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange P�ope1'tyType: Residence Perlod of Slgnlflcance: Early settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Appllcable Crlteria: Ac (Dlscuss Importence In terms of hlstorical or architectural context as defined by theme,per(od,and geographic scape.Also addresa Intagrity. Continues on Pg.4.) StRlCtu�ellnteg�ity: Excellent Condition - Minor chan�c�es to ori ig nal structure. Sitelntegrity: Substantial grade change in front yard has caused the oriqinal raised front.porch to be level with the curved driveway. Large accessory structure added at rear. Opportunities Appears individually eligible for National Register. In October 1918, John W. and Gail C. Ybung purchased four acres of land at 224 S. Batavia. At that time, Batavia Street marked the western edge of the City limits, putting this property just over into county territory. South Batavia was then con9idered an upscale neighborhood, populated by gentlemen citrus farmers. In 1919, he built this house on his property and lived and ranched here for the next ten years. In 1929, the house and land was aquired by John J. and Ida M. Collins, another local citrus rancher. Born in Missouri, Mr. Collins had settled in Northern California in 1887 and in 1916 moved here. Collins continued to live in this house until he retired from ranching in the late 1940s. His son, Ray Collins, took over the groves at that time and moved into the house. John Collins died in April of 1950 at the age of 83. Ray Collins held onto th B11.Additional Resource Attributes: ��ist anributes and codes� 'B12.References: Orange Daily News. "A Place Called Home," Brigandi, Phil and Wilson Turnbull, Karen (1990, p.33) . Orange Householder's Guide (1919, 1922-1930, 1922) . City Directory by Streets (1919, 1922-1930, 1932) . B13.Remarks: �conu��as o�Pg.3.� (Skatch Map with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Added SD1. Outside 2005 survey area. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. "B14.Evaluator: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo •Date of Evaluation: APril 2018 (This space reserved for official commants.) DPR 523B(1/95) "Required Information . . . . ... .. . . .. . .. . . .. .. . . . .. . .. .. .. .. .. . .... . ... ... ... . ... . . . . . . State of C f n a�T�e Resou�c s Aq�ency � '�� Primary;#� �3�15a7o9�� '��, ` `, uDEPARTMEN�QF�PAi�KS A�ND� ECREA.Tt� � r��: �i; � •HRI# � ,�0,38Q75��,�'�r ,,��' '�' � � � CONTINUIe►T10N=SHEET�- �� 'Trinomlai oxa �� ' ��?t-��;�Y�,�s��::� �, �; _ . Page 3 of:4 *Resource Name or#: BATAVIA S_224 APN 041=0.64-50 " ' ' : (Assigned by Recorder) . __ :. Recor.de.d by:. . . Marissa.Moshier & Kelly;Ri;buffo Date Reoo�ded: April 2018 :• ' C�t" of Oran e..CD .De t Y 5 P.,. . ;:__ " 300 E. Chapman-Avenue ❑�/ Conti(1U8t10� �.Update . . . Orange., CA 92866. . .. : . :. : ... :. : Years;S.urvejled: 1982;: 1991, 2018 Descrlption of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register: : i. : • General Plan: . LMnx. . #of Bulldings: 1 . :.• . Planning Zone: 'a-2=6 : : #of Storles:: :2 Lot Acre: #of.Units: 1 : .~� ,�?+ ' Princl al.Bulldln S fE: : � 15.1.6 . � � p y� y � .,�,, �., �:� : B6.Constructlon Hlstory(Continued from Pg.2): �"'�� i . . P . � � ,: r , ��,,,,,,w. , .: .. .. _ - >,. � I�( � B13.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): � � ''�W ^ � . . � � ' � � "� � ,�� : . : ': : ... :. : .. �� . . ��.��'� `��:.�' �"� �,�_::R.�- �°;�, :. :. :P3a.Descri tlon Continued from P 1 : : � , :. . . . P 1. .. . . . 9• ) ,. ,. . . . . . frorit'driveway. . , .. DPR 523L:(11%98) . . :. � . . :. .. "Required Information .. ,TMStateof,Californfa TheResourcesAgency 3-; � � P'rimary# '. 30-15870,9� � �� ,'bEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND REC�TION ' . � �. k"�:� HRI# ;. 036075 � , aCONTINUATION SHEET �� 1 � �.Trinomia� �,ox� ?,-E;�?� �n •a� ,��, �;��.� Page 4 of 4 *Resource Name or#: sATAviA s_224 APN 041-064-50 (Assigned by Recarder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 B10.Slgniflcance(Contlnued from Pg.2): e property until he sold the house to C.O. Dale in the mid-1950s. This house is an outstanding example of architectural style. DPR 523L(11/98) •Required Information _ . . . _.. . . �.State of�'Caltfornia The Resources qgency �r � Pnmary# '� � �s u��:��r-.,„ ,� k ,„ ��a.� � � HRI# °'t ..� � � � , t � � ; , , � �`DEPARTMEN'f OF PARKS AND�RECREATION ,�¢,��a��f�_ � ` + i ' Fh�fC+r�y�` �F Y.'�[��13fi ' � lt Y-. . . .. ��PRtMARY RECORD�`�' � ' ' s�4 �',��,, .Trinomlal o�; # � �� , � �� , . " 'e ; ��z � �Y w �;� �t `�� j� }� E ��NRHP$tB�US�.'Of�@ 6Z: � �,� '� � �`� d „4�b�� 3�' .. . . , - > _ M , � �� sOtherLlstings ��`z�'� ' "",b" ' � . � , � , : �� : , , '." � ,+, y, � � R9Y'IBW C.Ot�A h s�f�'r�" y'R6Y�AWef �, +�}� n ,� .��<:; �e Date + �'� .. , , m. ..� t .� ,. �.,� -.a, ;�� ,s,F..,�: .:+..v�a,ww.+�,m�.,!,'.�� s,{vwie�� P.age:1::of 3 �::"ResourceNameor'#:.:::: BATAvzA S 23'6 APN 041-064-47_ : — — — ' — . (Assignad by RewMer):. .. P1.Other ldentifler: ::,. . . *P2.Location: 0 Not for Publication 0.Unrestricted : : *.a..County: Oranqe:::. and (p2b and:F2c ar P2d. Attach a locatlon map as nacessary.) " "" � "b.USGS 7.5'4uad: . Date:� T ; R ; l4 of . 1I4 of Sec. •r .M. � 1 B . . C.Add�ess:. 236: = S BATAVIA: : : ST ,.# : .. : : :Ci . Oranae Zi 92868 tY' P'..... �. . .. d.UTM: (Give more then ane far large and/oc linear resources)Z��B � RIE/.. IIIN : .. e.Oth'e�Locational Data: . ".P3d.D83C1'IPtlO�::(Deacrib'e resource and Its majaY elements.:lnclude deslgn,materials,cbnditian,alteratians,size,seriing,and baUtlnaries. Continuea on Pg.3.) .. . . . .. . .. Mate�lals: : Frame - Stucco.oi plaster and wood..siding One'story' multi-famil'y 'residential. property: 'C'ros's gable roof wiEh composition ,sHingles'and wide ea.ve overhangs with,_fascia. Combination,.of.board and batten_and'plaster siding.,_Vinyl multi-light windoivs. Brick chimney on front elevation. Det�ched six car garage with metal roll-up dbors at rear. "P3b:Resource Attributes: (HP3)==Multiple familY propertv. _ (Llet attribtites and codes) "P4.Resources:Present: ❑d Building �.Sfrircture ❑ Object 0 Site ❑ Element of District: :❑ DisVict ❑ Other(Isolates,etc.) � _� .� . . T., i � �. � . ..,r "� . : . 3 : �u \ � '. � ' .Descriptlon of Phot . , �, ;, : � �, �� (Vlew , ccesalon�#). . .. , ` � �. ' . -A, � 9 � ° , ; . P5 0' ;date a .., � � � : . V�: P6.Date s r and So .. . * Con t ucted/l�qe urce• :� � � , .i �v � ��>� . +• f y . .�. � i. � ' � .�,� �� , +;j 4� �? 963 . .. . - �r.��, _ . , " , 1 f �- s _ . �.Gr. ❑ Hi§toric ❑ Prehistoric: .0 Both r _��.�;�,��.. .. . .. . i w�-- _.z�..LC.` . . .. . . .. . . . . .. . . .. . . . . .. - ` .� 'P7.Ownerand:Address: - ; � _ ' ` � � ::..� ,� , �� ,-._,_._,-.._.:� � � � , � _ _ � _ . , . •, „ ., : � . � , ..�r, : � �. �:. � ;� tPB:ReCo�ded by: ':(Name,affiliation,and eddress) = r"'"`-`i�``,"'---�, , , � r,,�.�, �.,;,. x � .:� i Moshier uffo Marissa ' &,Kelly Rib .. ._. 'r r`"� - - ; City�of Or.ange .CD Dept. a��' �a .--•�, � • ' . � *, ,, x ; . ,;4 -� .� *� ��a � � 300 E. Chapman Avenue ,,.�� _ . , .. ;: '; � i Orange, CA 92866 ��r' f . . ' � � • r - �.. •P9.Date Recorded: .. `P11.R8portCltation: (Cite'surveyrepoiEendathersaurces,or:enter•nane?): April 2016.. :' Orange Couny Assessor Records (2018). . � •P1 . _ :. 0.Survey Type• �oescdbe} Reconnaissance.. 'Attechments: ❑ NONE ❑ Lacation.Map:. ❑� Continua4ion.Sheet(s) � Building,Struc4ure,.and Object Record. _. 0.Archaeological Record � District Record ❑.Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑.Rock Art Record � Artifact Record � Photagraph Record 0.Other(List): .. DPR 523A(1/95) "Required Information .. �;�"�e '4�k ��'^ ..�.� -�� - �.� � ,�.�€x � � r 1� �� ..� +�" � �,s��i: r �,,� � � �5tate.of California 'ifie;Resources.Agency �'; .� �-, � ��,,� ,� `�`Primary:# "'��`� " g`�.�� ' � ��'r�� •,�5��;��'�� • � � ;. <'DEPARTMENI'�'OF PARKS,AND RECREATION �� ' ` ` "s?��i �' �t��., e F; �HRI.# „ t1��h , ,��BUILDING,:ST,,RUC�TURE,�AND°OBJECT=RECORD��*��P 5tatus�coae 6z � �� ,, ' ��..,,�«r f��y��.,��.�''�>��*��.�.�� ..�n.�,:�.�� _ , . Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or#: $ATAvia s_236 APN 091-064-97 (Pssigned by Recarder) B1.Historic Name: B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: xEs B4.Present Use: x�s "85.Architecturai Style: Ranch •B6.Constructlon Hlstory:��nswcuon date,atlerations,end date otalterations) Date of Construction: 1963 ❑ HIStO�IC ❑ PfehlSto�C ❑ Both Original windows replaced with vinyl. "B7.Moved7 0 No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: "B8.Related Features: "89.Architect or Builder: Unknown "B10.SlgnlficanCe: Theme: Architecture Area: City of Orange P►opertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgnlflcance: rlone Appllcable Criterla: rr/a (Dlacues Importence In terms of hlatarlcal or archltectural cantext ea deflned by theme,perlod,and geagraphlc acape.Aiso addreas integrlty. Continuas on Pg.4.) StRlcturallnteg�ity: Good Condition — Minor changes to original structure. Site Integrity: Opportunitles B11.Additional Resource Attributes: �usc anr;b�ces and codes� '812.References: 813.R8R18�k5: (Continues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Map with Narth arrow raqulred.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. 'B74.EValuato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo •Date of Evaluation: Aprii 2018 (Thls spece raserved for ofticial camments.) DPR 523B(1/95) "Required Information `-�,;±�"+''$� �"��.s w�.rrk:'�kki'"' 8y'4"e�t��E�r,`�are;. �' : r't r �r� 'i� � ,�' at � �::1�.*w� �� ir Stateof;Caltfomia The�ResourcesAgency � �£��-�,��Primary# t�5�, � t� �rz^±�a�,�+w�� us �; w � � 4 �`��i�ar ''^r��a�. DEPARTMENT.�OF PARKS AND�'RECREATION ",�> �� "��'HRI#��'`�� "��'�' ` ,` ��,'�£'1F� r`. �,' � G x } ��'$ '� ��'�,t �s��:T�t �'�' �� t =CONTINUATION SHEET�£�� ' �,;,�,�'��kh`� rinomial oziia ��-�� ' �, ,K,,. ��+Na .nu,s� ,�t._zsk.`�:R_ 'e., .^��3 .��r Page 3 of 3 "Resource Name or#: HATAviA s_236 APN o41-064-97 (Assigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date Recorded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue 0 Continuation ❑ Updete Orange, CA 92866 Years Surveyed: zole Descriptlon of Photo: Listed In National Register: General Plan: LMDR #of Buildings: 2 Planning Zone: tt-z-6 #of Storles: 1 Lot Acre: #of Units: S Princlpal Bullding Sqft: B6.Construction History(Contlnued from Pg.2): 813.Remarks(Continued from Pg.2): P3a.Descrlption(Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L(11/98) 'Requlred Infortnation : . .; ... ,. . � State of California The Resources Agency ',• � ` ; ..' ; ;Primary# 30=1`58710�,�20'93 (Garage), 30 � �DEPARTMENT,OF PARKS AND RECREATION; ;x ,�;�', ' , tiHRI# ,� t`�`038076;-, 08385Q; �0838511 � ` °� �� 'Trinomlal o� �PRIMARY RECORD � �n � �_ � �� ,� �a � a� { ';��' �'� "'� �� :',� �� ''�{' NRHP Status Code��,�`1s%5�1 � � �;�lY? ^. ,. 'y'Yy�'SC= F . , j � Oth91'LiStiIlgS NHL.Pla ue,��N1,8.70, ('Ref. .#94000�81�'�� . , , Review Code ��~-Revfew"er r�' ' ".' �� Date � < <. , , . _ , , . , ,, . ,,� , ....,. �.,�... Page:1::of 4 *Resource Name or#:::::: BATAVIA_S`24'8_APN 041-064-12 (Assigned by Recorder):. — P1.Other ldentifter: ::.. *P2.Location: � Not for Publication ❑�.Unrestricted *a..County: Orange:::. and (P2b and:P2c or P2d.Attach a location map as necessary.) *b.USGS 7.5'Quad: . Date: � T ; R' ; � /4 of 1l4 of Sec. ; . .M. � 1 B • c.Address:: 248: :- s BATAVIA: : : ST ,.# : .. : : :Clty:, Oranae ZIP:: : :92868 ,.E,. d.UTM:'(Give more than one for large and/ac linear resaurces)ZOnB � RIEI. RIN . .. e.Other Locat(onal Data: . . *P38.DCSC�I(JtI0I1::�Desbribe resource and its mejo�element9.:lnclude design,materials,condition,"alteratlons,size,setting,and boutlnaries. ConUnues an Pg.3.) .. MateNal§: : Frame - Stucco..or plaster • ... . Large two=story,estat'e home with, box pla[i and sand finish, plaster' cladding..,Flat roof with clay.,tile 'hip' roof at par'apet. :Wood windows are placed reqularly :around the facade; some a"re";sash windows; some, are . fixed pane,' picture windows with decozative transoms..Main entry is via=a_stoop beneath a small p'orch � centered on the facade... Main..door' is' wide. with. f.ixed pana windows and side lights. on..either side'. A . .. .. variety.of mature ..... "P3b:Resource Att�ibutes: (HP2); (HP9)--5in�le family property with caretaker's..house.and qarage . .. .. . .. (Llet altrlbutae and codes) "P4.Resources Present: : ❑d Building �.Stnicture ❑ Objeot :� Site ❑ Element of Distribt: :❑ District ❑:Other(Isolates,etc.) ,� r � - - —-- : `�, � 1 � r� !`,� � , P5b.Desc�ipkion of Photo: 2018 ' .:.. , ,. . .f� � , �7f ��aY/ .; � : ; ,� (VIeu4�date,eccesslon#). :,;-�- � : .. : ' � . >�.� _ +a�j r .r�,�X,v.,x�r : . . . \\ �..� ;.' .x� . ��.�"s.xy=t�;4�,F,,.,.� lr+"wj.�4:#�+..�,��i�°7.� ' sa .:*P ". . �: . '. .. . , ?.� � • � - , � ,j�,,F�A_, 6.Date Constructed/Age and Source: . ,,t _ ' �`�[�l1 �i 91� _ a �ir � y _ •� � ..` �.= x; I. �� . � � ' ��' ,,K'�K�. �3'�` �.�� z; �.Historic ❑ Prefiistoric � Both _ ��:n;_� =,,;-��,.� .,,� ,� -� � . . ?,,,� . '�'. �'�' .��.. ..t : . .. �. . . . .. . . a N . }/�+. .� .. f�...�.�... *P7 . . ( " � .Owner and Address: . '� �. � }r 7..�.r 1 �e ,` . . . ' . , . ��.I +� _; . . . . .. . . . . ' ' . . 'I , :.:� ��: ' . . "�-� 4 1� . . . .. . . . ' . _. �� . .-: �� # . L �'�� .:-��•awqn-�sv �, : „ -. . ._ � �t,„� '''a-: '��pup ,-. �' *P8:RBCO�ded by::' (Name,afiliation,andaddress) ' .� _�.,. ... �� '"' • . �, ` , Marissa Moshier &_Kelly Ribuffo __� � � �:' ,K; _ ' - City of: Orange CD Dept. � 300 E. Chapman Avenue .. .. . .. . . .. � � � >,�. Orange, CA 92666 : : . _ ; ; "P9.Date Recorded: -. �P11.ReportCitation: (Citesurveyrephitendathersources,or:enler'none'): April 2018 Office of Historic,Preservation (2011) .Historic Properties.Directory. ;; : ::., Orange County Assessor Records :(2010):...AEGIS (1991)::HiStoric Building :.*p10.Surv8yType' (Descdbe) ' � �' " Inventory Update: Heritage Orange Gourity, Inc. (1982), Orarige Historic � _ Survey,. . Reconnaissance 'Attachments: ❑ NONE • :. ❑ Location.Map:. � Continuatian.Sheet(s) � Building,Structure,.and Object Record 0 Archaeological Record � bistrict Record ❑.Linear Feature Record ❑ Milling Station Record❑.Rock Art Record � Artifact Record � Fhotagraph Record 0.Other(List): DPR 523A(1195) "Required Information . State of Calif mta�The;Resources�Agency Prlmary#p�3`o�i�58710;;'�30-.�-3`�,6'�20�93} ¢Garage`),,< � � DEPARTMENT'OF PARK3�AND;RECREATION HRI# ,� � 038076,�a0:e3.85o, 0838511 a . BUILDING;.ST�RUCpTURE;�1ND OBJECT RECORD *NR�'+i�StatusAcoae i ��s�sn. ' ` ' . < ��,��. .,. . . , ��. � Page 2 of 4 *Resource Name or#: BATAVIA s_248 APN o41-064-12 (Assigned 6y Recarder) B1.HISto�IC Name: Porter-French House B2.Common Name: B3.Original Use: RES B4.Present Use: xEs "B5.Ar'chltectu�al Style: Mediterranean Revival "B6.Constructlon History:��nsWction date,anerations,and date of altere0ons) Date of Constructlon: 1917 ❑./ Historic ❑ Prehistoric ❑ Both *B7.Moved? ./❑ No ❑Yes ❑ Unknown Date: Original Location: *B8.Related Features: *B9.Architect or Builder: unknown "B10.SIgniflcance: Theme: Architecture Area: city of orange PropertyType: Residence Perlod of Slgniflcance: Earlv settlement (c. 1870 - 1920) Applicable Criteria: asc (Dlacuss Importance In terma oi hlatorlcal ar erchltecturel cantext ea deflned by theme,perlod,and geagraphlc acope.Alsa eddresa Integrity. Cantlnuea on Pg.4.) St�uCturallnteg�lty: Excellent Condition - Minor and reversible or appropriate changes to original structure. Slte Integrtty: Opportunftles Original owners appear'to have been John and Ora Lee Porter. Mr. Porter was a cashier with the National Bank of Orange. About 1940, the home was acquired by Judge French. David French became a resident of Orange in 1937 and served as City Attorney £rom 1946 until he was appointed to the Santa Ana/Orange Municipal Court bench in 1957 by Gov. Goodwin Knight. He was named to the Superior Court bench in August of 1966 and retired in November of that same year but seemed to serve an occasional assignment on the state judicial council. Among his other accomplishments was a term serving as trustee of the Orange Unified School District, secretary of the Orange County Municipal Water District and chairman of the Orange Red Cross. Full history is contained in property's National Register designation form. B11.Addlttonal Resource Attributes: ��i5�anrie�rtes and�odes� "B72.References: B73.RBRIH�kS: (Contlnues on Pg.3.) (Sketch Mep with North arrow required.) Status change since 1991 Survey: Added 5D1. Separately listed in National Register. 2018 City Council-directed survey for potential boundary adjustment of local Old Towne Historic District. 'B14.Evaluato�: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo •Date of Evaluation: April 2018 (This space reserved for oHicial wmments.) DPR 523B(1/95) "Requlred Information _ .. . . . . . .. .. .... .. , ..: �� '�,'s6;&;� a`.�:� : s,a� . . ,-t ar., , f= . ..: �E i t ti�r ' State of Califomia The Resources qgency, , � ;Primary'# 30=158710; 30 162093 (Garage); 30 r ` a.,o-`Y��,ff.�iY�."�4s�R�.�S�&,�Aa�t+, P.: x � �,�f}�{� h tii� � w ,� .�p y � � DEPARTMENTOF PARKS AND RECREATION � �- � HRI# �038076 ,oe3850 "0838511#x�, �� y ' �:o- -�;...��, r,.�+,,.�i3P,��mt'�'�'r�-`,��e �r�r`�r tzx�* ��i�. �t��»`'�$�'�` ` ,,. °� '� u� a . � � h ��. � a�y ' . . . CONTINUATION SHEET�"` � $ h �� Trinomlal oii� s �,�, � P�, ,;. � ��- . _., . s��;r,r .�,,,�>-, ,.�,z .,,<.,�.,F.� n��:'��,",�. , ..��.. Page 3 of:4 ' .. "Resouree Name or#: sATAvia_s_248 APN_041=064-12 " ' (Avsigned by Recarder) Recorded by:. Marissa.Moshier & Kelly;Ribuffo DateReco�ded: April 2018, :�.,' -- ' „ 'City of 'Orange„CD Dept. - 300 E. Chapman Avenue Q ContinuatlOn Q Update Orange,, CA 928'66 _ . Years:Surveyed: 1982y 3991� 2018 ' : . : : : Descriptton of Photo: 1991 Listed in National Register. 1993, 19:94 _. :. General Plan: LMDx. . #of Buildings: 3 , �. °' �.-.- .-�,�* -�r� Plannfng Zone: x-2-5 #of Stories: 2 t- x � � t ; � r}.�?� a �Lot Acre: � � 0.93 #of Units: 2 : �_; � `� ��`� �`�� ' �fi`. �� ` �� Principal Building Sqft: 3318 . �� ` .� � ""� �, :r�; ' ' � , �>. B6.Construction History(Contfriued:from Pg.2): � �. � � � �,V I � � I . , i . �,� � �°a � . . N , ,,: � d B13.Remarks(Contlnued from Pg.2): �?�'�� " � ' �F� � �.s�G � , C' �. �" i �v"6�� . 1��.�-g� � ' . "��:f.�"'�' Y�^"T# Y.r� ,�Su�y d y '.. .,4 yh �.� �' . .. .. . . � - �� ' . .. .. . .. � .'' ' ' . .. . . . . . ' _' —_ _ '�-�� — ' . .. . �-,��e�W.Jd�`@ T y � � -q,,.��&6�G,i,S.. .,..�.i�� . .��1�� . . . . . . . �t4r�' .; '- _. . . .. . .. . ... .. .. .. P3a.Descriptlon(Continued from Pg.1): : . . trees 'are :located in tHe front:and rear yards. Property also contairis:a historic CareEa:ker's Aouse and ' Garacj'e'.;:See National Register;;designation form :for more information;: :; DPR 523L(11/98) : "Required Infarmation .. . ''State of Califorrifa,The Resources Agency ° � . r'� ' �Pr�mary";# 3o--15s7i0;=30=1620'93�,(caraqej.,, 30.' �,' DEPARTMENT OF„PARKS AND RECRFATION :. HRI#• .' .'•�,038076, '083850,�`0838512: .`' ' >�'CONTINUATION.SHEET ; � } � Trinomia► oxa ° ; _ry z�, , �,.n, Page4 of 4 "ResourceNameor#: saTAvza s_2ae APN 041-064-12 (/lvsigned by Recorder) Recorded by: Marissa Moshier & Kelly Ribuffo Date ReCo�ded: April 2018 City of Orange CD Dept. 300 E. Chapman Avenue � Continuation ❑ Update Orange, CA 92866 B10.Signlflcance(Contlnued from Pg.2): DPR 523L(11/98) "Requlred Information CITY COUNCIL MINUTES NOVEMBER 13, 2018 9. LEGAL AFFAIRS 9.1 An Ordinance approving Zone Change No. 1289-18 adjusting the Old Towne Historic District Boundary. Ordinance No. 12-18 (Second Reading). (A2500.0) An Ordinance of the City Council of the City of Orange approving a Zone Change to expand an existing historic district overlay zone to add 12 properties on South Batavia '�Street to the local Old Towne Historic District and update the City of Orange Historic Resources Inventory. Public Speaker: Tony Trabucco—spoke in support of adopting Ordinance No. 12-18. MOTION —Smith SECOND —Whitaker AYES —Alvarez, Whitaker, Smith,Murphy,Nichols Moved that Ordinance No. 12-18 be read by title only and same was approved and adopted by the preceding vote. 10. ITEMS RELATING TO THE SUCCESSOR AGENCY OF THE ORANGE REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY—None 11 PUBLIC HEARINGS 11.1 Conduit financing for the Lutheran High School Association of Orange County Project. (53500.A) Time set to conduct a public hearing under the requirements of the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act of 1982 (TEFRA) and the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended to approve a resolution authorizing of the issuance of the Obligations by the California Enterprise Development Authority. THE MAYOR OPENED THE PUBLIC HEARING. Public Speaker: Justin Steward — spoke in support of approving the resolution, and was available for questions. THE MAYOR CLOSED THE PUBLIC HEARING. Resolution No. 11119 A Resolution of the City Council of the City of Orange approving the issuance by California Enterprise Development Authority of not to exceed $17,000,000 aggregate principal amount of the issuer's revenue obligations for the purpose of financing and refmancing the cost of acquisition, construction, renovation, installation, equipping and furnishing of facilities for the benefit of Lutheran High School Association of Orange County providing the terms and conditions for such obligations and other matters relating thereto herein specified. PAGE 12