RES-9098 Upholding Appeal No. 450RESOLUTION NO. 9098
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY
OF ORANGE OVERRULING THE DECISION OF THE
PLANNING COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF ORANGE
AND UPHOLDING APPEAL NO. 450, GRANTING A
CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO ALLOW THE ON-
SITE SALE AND CONSUMPTION OF BEER AND WINE
UPON PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1948 NORTH TUSTIN
STREET.
Appeal No, 450
Conditional Use Permit No. 2238-
98 Applicant and Appellant: Aroma Italiano Coffee
House
RECITALS:WHEREAS, on September 21, 1998, the Planning Commission of the City of
Orange conducted a public hearing as required by law to consider Conditional Use Permit No.
2238-
98;and WHEREAS, the proposed Conditional Use Permit was to allow the
on-site consumption of beer and wine for an existing restaurant upon property located at 1948
North
Tustin Street;and WHEREAS, the subject property is commonly known as 1948 North Tustin
Street and is more particularly described in Attachment "A", which is attached hereto
and incorporated herein by
this reference; and WHEREAS, by Resolution No. 69-98, the
Planning Commission denied Conditional Use Permit No. 2238-
98 with certain findings; and WHEREAS, Appeal No. 4S0 was timely filed
by the appellant, Riccardo Bosco,representing
Aroma Italiano Coffee House; and WHEREAS, the City Council heard the appeal of
appellant by conducting a public hearing
on November 10,1998; and WHEREAS, at said public hearing, the City Council heard
the testimony of members of the) public, considered documentary evidence presented and found
the facts more
particularly set forth as follows:1. The proposal is granted upon sound principles of land
use and in response to
2. The proposal will not cause deterioration of bordering land uses or create special
problems for the area in which it is located. Approval of this CUP will not cause an increase in
the clrime rate for that police reporting district, nor will there be any adverse effect from over
conclmtration of liquor licenses in that police reporting district.
3. The proposal has been considered in relationship to its effect on the cornmunity or
neighborhood plan for which the area in which it is located and will fit in well with the shopping
center.
4. The proposal is made subject to the following conditions necessary to preserve the
general welfare and not the individual welfare ofthe applicant:
1) Development shall be in substantial compliance with plans as approved by the Plarming
Commission, and which are on file with the Department of Community Development.
2) There shall be no coin-operated games or video machines maintained upon the premise at
any
time.3) There shall be no exterior advertising of any type, including advertising directed to
the exterior from within, promoting or indicating the availability of alcoholic beverages.
Interior displays of alcoholic beverages or signs which are clearly visible to the exterior
shall constitute a violation ofthis
condition.4) The quarterly gross sales of alcoholic beverages shall not exceed the gross sales of food
or other commodities during the same period. Licensee shall at all times maintain records
that re:flect separately the gross sales of food and gross sale of alcoholic beverages of the
licensed business. The records shall be kept no less frequently than on a quarterly basis and shall
be made available upon
request.S) Sales and service of alcoholic beverages shall cease at least one (1) hour prior to the close
of business each
day.6) One year after the cornmencement of the sales of alcoholic beverages begin, this
conditional use permit shall be reviewed to evaluate if excessive calls for police services and/or any
other re:lated problems have occurred that are associated with the sale of alcoholic
beverages.7) The applicant agrees to indemnify, hold harmless, and defend the City, its officers,
agents and employees from any and all liability or claims that may be brought against the
City rnising out of its approval of this permit, save and except that cause by City's
active nl~
gligence.8) The applicant shall comply with all federal, state, and local laws. Violation of any of
those laws in connection with the use will be cause for revocation of this
permit.Reso No. 9098
9)1 If not utilized within two (2) years of the date of approval, this conditional use permit shall
expire.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Orange
that Appeal No. 4S0 is upheld and Conditional Use Permit No. 2238-98 is approved for
the following
reasons:1. The foregoing recitals are true and
correct.2. The findings required by Orange Municipal Code Section 17.1 0.030.F are
met.Adopted the27'" day of April,
1999.
ATTEST:Cl4Uu~~Ctdw'AU:
r City Clerk of the ty of
Orange I hereby certify that the foregoing Resolution was duly and regularly adopted by the
City Council of the City of Orange at a regular meeting thereof held on the27'" day of April, 1999,
by th<: following
vote:AYES: COUNCIL MEMBERS: MURPHY, SLATER, ..COONTZ, SPURGEON,
ALVAREZ NOES: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NONE ABSENT: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NONE ABSTAIN: COUNCIL MEMBERS:
NONE A#A~~~
r City Clerk ofth ty of
Orange
MEB 3 Reso No.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION EXHIBIT A.
PAlCE!. I:
THE lIUIlJ)l1'Cj~, FLXi1.:W MO lloII'KOVIij.Ie....) l..OCAnJ) OS TIlE fOU,OWNC t)~..)CRln!;D
u..'IC
TlV.r ..,:i1mu:\ Of!.OT Ig OF nil! FU,TOl::A TRACT, .u pEJ, MAP llLCORPl'J) ll'IIIOO'; 1. PACI>
J OF MbCEU.A:-;1.0US lIJ!,CQP.OS IN nt~ OfFICr. OF nil:: COUNTYAl;COI\,;lEl OF Ul$ "''luEU.$CQ\;/.
Tr, CAUI'Oll.'lV., t)1;,)ClU.1lUl AS Pou.oW~:i:.
ClI\SIl'C...T Tm l:oo.TtllSEC'TIO~ OF iHt C!lNTWlUNE 01' T1.lSTIS ...VL..UIlAND Ttl: C!,'11liR Ul'
E 01' ~IJ:;.\TS AVE.'I.:!. P1:.R COUNTY S\,;RY1:rOk'S TIE bOO); no, PAOU lO. Tlu;.'CI: ....OXTH f!O:.
cIU:I,s )J' II' \l.'C.5i ~Uo Pu;rA1.0:oo011111 )AID CE.'1Tl;;lUNEOF nJ:..TINAVliNUL: T'~" P\l1l\"T os...
ClJll\'f. TH! IlADII.:SPOlSTOF SAIP C1.:RVl:: 1lE.\lU !oOVTH 0 Pi,;OREi'S~" '" ",:.1' 1200.(.('pur;
TIlt."CE W\:.:lTlllU.Y 2g:.06 f!:EI Al.O:OOOMID CUP.VIi. TllltOUOll A CL'IrMl........~l.! O~ a Di:
C;R21~ ~6' ';1' TOmE B&.INSI.'iC OF... cuav!;; COSCAVliNOIl.THt.lU.'I' AND HA\lINO... RAN1.:SOF
Doo.w FIiI."T, THt.'1CIi wt5 rEJU. r jjH~ Pii.t1' A!.ONOSAle C1.:Il.Vl::, ntll.OUOll ... :':i-."IIl.\1.A.'
iGU01' 6 OEOIl.E\:.:l ~9' W: niE.'\CB SO\.:TH17 llEGllJ;B~ '9' ),' \\ItST ~3<'l.O~ PI.:.T 1'II!.:o....1I o:.:
nl . Dl.Gk!:.UIJ' 20' iAST 113.,u FLJ.T 10 nJS TII.I,;E P'OI:-rr 01' iL:GISS1Nl.i. Tllf....C. SOH'T11 IY
D;;.u~f5 ,:. 0.' ~T ).4691 Ftlii TO TlI!; LA~T l.lll:li Of Sl,W LOT I~, '1Ir.."CIl10UTII 0 O,
GRl:.l..s .)" II' EAST 3JJ.\IO fU., TO 1, POL'ITNOKlll 0 U~GllEES ". II' W~l7j.t.l ~L ':' flW~1 THE
SOI';"TllE.AST CO;lNE.l< OF SAltJ!.OT19. iHESCko SOt,;1'11'~ DLliRI.ll.5 )~' c.' WUT :~, \091'F.f: r.THt.'
iCI; SOt:H, 0 OEGft!E,.) )3' II' !;.UT 49.16 PCl;:r 10 Tll!: Io;UIlTIlIi...H C'\)^'~ll (,' TllACT 00.
0 ~~J1. "S PF.j( M"P RI.COROED 1:" 1>001\ 10'. ~ACt~ 33 "SO'~ 01' l>11:.CtU.A~I.(')l': ~IA~S I.";l11E
OHICL GF 1 HE c.:Ot;:-;TY lu,CORDLK Of S...IU OkANC!: COl'STY: Tlll.NC't sot,," I .. . 'L.(,lll~:i l)' c,.;' '....
t..;.,. :J: 30 H.1.f AU"lNG ll1LNOllllll.l."l: \J~ SAID lK"Cr. 'lIal,l'~ NI"lltl11 v ~"lUJ..S 13' u,' '''''
WT )l.oOio fGrrTO 'Mil! nt.:t POISTO~ IIl:CilNNL"O PAIlCl;l. :
THAT ~O,,
7lUS OFLOT 19 Or THE. I'u:TClII:.RT1v,Cr. AS POI. SI.4J' lltl.:OIi.UWIN ljiAl.. J.
PAl1L.
Cf :":I:.
Cf.l.,-^-\EO:':S llC~R;)S1:-. Tlll: OHIC!: 0' nuC01.:N1)' Il!CORDU OJ' WS .,;GIol.l,,1 C"i.;~n, CAl..li-
UK.'.!A. D~lUB(.;l ....:. fOU'O.....S:I.Cl.'~OlSG J\
TTllL.INTF.iUEC'ilON OF 1115 Cl:S;l.R UNE I,)F TtiSTIN AVl!~l,r.A"U;Hl '. f.'olrl(l.l." OF M:..\;
S .\\l.'It,;i:. PER eOl'SiY ~\.'IlVL.YOin nc aOU); 1~6. ~AC.L. ,C. TlIl.S~:' '.vkTlI"L.(,j;";:~ 33' : I'
WwT ~).,S(; rliE; ALO:oo.C THE SAIDCE~TD. L.IS~ OF n)~1IS l,Vlt-.UL 1(1 ..1'OI1\TC.... AC:':il.\~.
1 ~~ K..~)II.:~ l'Ol>.;T Or S,l.ll.I CURVE IIE.\J<S ~O~1110 DE(iIlH~ U' , I" ~ \ i1:,.0,; VJ f[::. "Hl:.'CC WUTt.
K!.. y:n OG FLl:':" .....C!\I.J ~....:L) CI.:KY~. nl~OUull A (l..Ni KAt. AN'..f ul' ; l ll;'SS w.:\' TO ;
lllllEGlSSISO CF A TA)\OE..'r Cl..ll\ l.. CO,"'lA"E !'OURiH<-\'!.. \' A'r II" \'I.'C s OF l)w ~ r'
L~T. '!'HL.....C~ Wt..::dfK:"V ~') 0' ~l:l...TA~:\O ~.'\JL) ,-'UJ.\\ E. 111 ......Uull A 1. A'O;'1: 01' 0 =:
EG^l..[~ .,' i'J'. TIIC),C" ~OI,;IIII' fll."UE.:> W )7' WE.~: oj: (I r::'!CE. ~()t,;1li ~ D~::'KE.:.s :3' "~.
J.,.5; 1.) ~J FilL T T() 1 HF. 1;(t,;1. l'OI:oo.T Or uu.;l.' ,';1:." ,Hl'L~Oi' rn i> DI:C.P,::LS :l' (',
0' !~: ,..o9IpE.LT10 Till; LUT USS OF ~.\ItJ l.fJr 110. TIlL....C. ~l.'TII GiI.W;' ))' II' ~1 )iJ1 iIOFll.':'hl ^ tOIST1>>
OilTHU '-'bCKL.!:S )1'11' we~, '~e.:J :'l.1 rRu,,'71:~ ~:'l.'Tll!:.\H CGilSt,K Or s.....;;:, l..
C; I;, THL"CE .c>t.:'fH " Dl.CRt:.~'" (>.I' 'oW:::S I ::10 ,vl...E1.ilI~'CE SOUTIi 0Dv....:.~ ))' :1" EAST '916 l'
LE1 TO lHt. I\Ol<TI1LASr COR..'1:R Ufll<Al'T 0 ""37, ~ P!:.ll. ~IAP Rt.CORD~ IS bOOK
16', I'ACiES 33 AND,. O~ .1lSCE~NIoCI;~ j,IAl'j p,.;ThE OHICEOF THE COI.:1>>"TY kECORDW/. OF
SA10 ORN'ooO!i COUNTY; Tll4.'ICI: $OI.:TII 19 :ll"Ljltf;U 0.' ......UT ~3:.30Flli' ,,1.0,";0 Tm ,"
OllT1f ~'iE. 01' ~.\ID TMC1": nu;."cll /'<OXTII ~ :'COJu.U lJ' :0' W!:.:ii' ~.~ n:.~7 TO niX; n:.:
l.: PO~'1TOP lIWl1'''INO U:Cl:i'Tl,'\G T KE.l(t,
ROM, '71iA 7 l'CI<.T10,... n1lJI,=o~ Dl:.:lCklll~') J~ DUD TO Tl',; C'. ,y r. u J::.' ,(iL ,,~rr,..Dd) ~I A II.CrI 11,
197, L" ~OO" llQl,~, PAUE 1) 0' OI'~ICIAl. _!!.CUllt)) u, "..^~UU CO..~ I'Y. CAl.lh~k.'iA o U:
CL.?'TL"G TH~;tO.\I. THE
DUIUlL.'iGS. fD('f',.'au ....'10 lMPRO\l!.ME-'I1. lLJ.;AT\.Ll Th:.J;,,(I....PARCEL 3 E 'NORTH 1.0~
FOJTOF PARCE,-
I, AS
SHOWN ON A MAP FILED IN u~OK 29,D:"G~: 2S C~ ~":;,,,,,:" U:'P II..,; THE O::-F~
C:: 0;:- ;HE C8o\J:..,.T'r' RE.CCRJE.OJ ',..OR.....GECOUNTY, CAl..iFORI-.:':'