09-16-20 439 E. Chapman Avenue - Sinchai Eye Center Monument Sign (DRC 5015-20)AGENDA ITEM
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
September 16, 2020
Anna Pehoushek, Assistant Community Development Directorft'<
Kelly Ribuffo, Associate Planner(!/�
1. SUBJECT
2. SUMMARY
3. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
8 q n
g u re
•u,r
•y (C Gy
•a (y
P an,
DRC ITEM 2.-3 1 09/16/2020
5. EXISTING SITE
6. EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
7. ANALYSIS AND STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
o qm
g qu Historic Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne
Ug g
x
c cp x bg
Cit Apv #3,b th
sm m bg
8. ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
N vsry b q
9. PUBLIC NOTICE
N Pb Ne q j
10. ENVIRONMENT AL REVIEW
h pj v m v o rty,
cy x t v
Quy (QA)EQA 530 (Ex F)
11. STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS
T c "F " c b y
cs s A b "
F g," w i ..,
p , m , )t
F b
ul s , b k k
Th "F g " , t c
p (p f) g
e ; s i y F
F g C :
• T M p ()
• T I R i G i
DRC ITEM. 2-3 2 09/16/2020
F2 .
Pj b ally
b Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
the Treatment of Historic Properties. h
b p z l mpc
d u b ud fo
u a ltt f
b a
h lly
tg g t pcf
c qu g OMC
1 17.3).
j h y t th Historic
Preservation Design Standards for Old Towne. i mod n
s b x g b o
n .
12. CONDITIONS
j j d :
1.j v A k u b nc an
u At 2
(g 24 22 ) rt qu rd b
s a b s n
R A y b ubjc o
u bs q v b t C
2 Aft y v , s g rd n
e g y b u b ttd
DRC ITEM 2..3 3 09/16/2020
S 020 u i h
x (90)day
g t j .If
p ,
p g x e
S 6020
8 I z j x 24 appal a.
E OM S 1708060.
13. ATTACHMENTS
1 V M
2 S 8/2/2020
3 S s
R 439 E A
N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 5015-20 Sinchai Eye Care Sign
DRC ITEM 2.:s 4 09/16/2020
Vicinity Map
439 E. Chapman Avenue
DRC No. 5015-20
lf) - ' i
I
�
\
/��-----------------�
f \ ( } 0 I I 0 "q" I
I I I
I "q'" - I I
I "q'" 134 ( I
I I I
I I I
I I I
I I I
•
i'
I
I
I
I
I
1'
I
o- I
C') I
� J I -- ---- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- __ _..,,, ... '
N
ORANGE= CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE
YELLO = NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE
s
City of Orange
Community Development Department
ATTACHMENT NO. 1
DRC NO. 5015-20;
SINCHAI EYE CENTER MONUMENT SIGN
VICINITY MAP
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
(&+$30$1$9(
25$1*(&$
3
6,1&+$,(<(&(17(5
&86720(5
0$5<%(7+6,1&+$,
(&+$30$1$9(
25$1*(&$
3
/$1'/25'
'28%/()$&(121,//80,1$7('02180(176,*1
7$%/(2 )&217 (1 76
&29(5
'28%/()$&(02180(176,*1
0$7(5,$/$1'&2/256
)5$0,1*$1')227,1*'(7$,/
6,7(0$3
ATTACHMENT NO. 2
DRC NO. 5015-20;
SINCHAI EYE CENTER MONUMENT SIGN
SIGN PLANS (DATE STAMPED 08/24/20)
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
6,1&+$,(<(&(17(5
(&+$30$1$9(
25$1*(&$
6LQFKDL(\H&HQWHU2UDQJHB1R
'$1,(/%$/7$=$5 3$*(
^U
',(*2%(51$/ ',(*2%(51$/
47<[
'28%/()$&(02180(176,*1 čŏăĥąĘŊāĚġĀĘ
64)227$*( 64)7$
(1'9,(:
352326('(/(9$7,213+272
(;,67,1*(/(9$7,213+272
(&+$30$1$9(
(&+$30$1$9(
«
B1RQ,OOXPLQDWHG0RQXPHQWB3HU
0
6,1&+$,(<(&(17(5
(&+$30$1$9(
25$1*(&$
6LQFKDL(\H&HQWHU2UDQJHB1R
Ò7+,&.$/80,180
Ò7+,&.$/80,180
Ò%586+('$/80,180
Ò63$&(56
0
0
0
0$18)$&785( ,167$//
'28%/()$&(121
,//80,1$7('02180(176,*1
'$1,(/%$/7$=$5 3$*(
!^U#
',(*2%(51$/
0$7(5,$/$1'&2/256
3067%'
3067%'678&&2
3$,170$77+(:6
%586+$/80,180
3
3
3
B1RQ,OOXPLQDWHG0RQXPHQWB3HU
(1'9,(:
30
0
03
03
3
127( (;7(51$//,*+7,1*6285&(72%(&203/(7('%<&/,(17$1'2527+(56
(&+$30$1$9(
30
0303
00
03
6LQFKDL(\H&HQWHU2UDQJHB1R
'$1,(/%$/7$=$5 3$*(
"^U#
',(*2%(51$/
)5$0,1*$1')227,1*6$''/('(7$,/
(1'9,(:
0
0
0
Ò$/80,180648$5(78%(
Ò67((/3,3(
6$''/('(7$,/'
'
'
ò$/80
$1*/()5$0,1*
66
7+58%2/7
6,1&+$,(<(&(17(5
(&+$30$1$9(
25$1*(&$
B1RQ,OOXPLQDWHG0RQXPHQWB3HU
0
6LQFKDL(\H&HQWHU2UDQJHB1R
0
ąąĘ
6,1&+$,(<(&(17(5
(&+$30$1$9(
25$1*(&$
6LQFKDL(\H&HQWHU2UDQJHB1R
'$1,(/%$/7$=$5 3$*(
#^U#
',(*2%(51$/
6,7(0$3
02180(176,*1
1257+
B1RQ,OOXPLQDWHG0RQXPHQWB3HU
«
Attachment 3: Color Samples
PMS 401 C PMS Cool Gray 1 C
ATTACHMENT NO. 3
DRC NO. 5015-20;
SINCHAI EYE CENTER MONUMENT SIGN
COLOR SAMPLES
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
PRIMARY RECORD
Page 1 of
*b. USGS 7.5' Quad:Date:T R 1/4 of 1/4 of Sec B.M.
d. UTM:mE/mN
e. Other Locational Data:
P1. Other Identifier:
*P2. Location:
c. Address:439 Zip:92866
(Give more than one for large and/or linear resources)
(Describe resource and its major elements. Include design, materials, condition, alterations, size, setting, and boudnaries. Continues on Pg.3.)
;;;
Zone '
and (P2b and P2c or P2d. Attach a location map as necessary.)
City:-E CHAPMAN Orange
*P3a. Description:
*P3b. Resource Attributes:
(List attributes and codes)
Reconnaissance
(Describe)
(Cite survey report and other sources, or enter "none.")
*Attachments:Continuation Sheet(s)Building, Structure, and Object Record
(Name, affiliation, and address)
(View, date, accession #)
*P6. Date Constructed/ Age and Source:
D. Gest, P. LaValley, D.
Matsumoto
*P7. Owner and Address:
*P8: Recorded by:
*P10. Survey Type:
*P11. Report Citation:
DPR 523A (1/95)*Required Information
*Resource Name or #:CHAPMAN_E_439__APN_039-254-12
(Assigned by Recorder)
*P9. Date Recorded:
May, 2005
1965
Primary #
HRI #111479
Date:
NRHP Status Code 6Z
Trinomial ORA
Other Listings:
Review Code:Reviewer:
Orange *a. County:
P5b. Description of Photo:
Unrestricted
3
Site*P4. Resources Present:Building Object Element of District Other (Isolates, etc.)DistrictStructure
Not for Publication
District Record
Photograph Record
Location Map
Artifact Record
Archaeological Record
NONE
Linear Feature Record Rock Art RecordMilling Station Record
Other (List):
Materials:Frame - Metal siding
AVE
Chattel Architecture
13417 Ventura Blvd.
Sherman Oaks, CA 91423
PrehistoricHistoric Both
,#
2005
Orange County Assessor Records (2005). Chattel Architecture (2005)
Historic Resources Survey. AEGIS (1991) Historic Building Inventory
Update.
ATTACHMENT NO. 4
DRC NO. 5015-20;
SINCHAI EYE CENTER MONUMENT SIGN
DPR FORM FOR 439 E. CHAPMAN AVE.
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
B1. Historic Name:Unknown
B3. Original Use:COM B4. Present Use:SOC/RELG
*B5. Architectural Style:Contemporary
*B6. Construction History:(Construction date, atlerations, and date of alterations)Date of Construction:1965
*B9. Architect or Builder:Unknown
Period of Significance:Old Towne: Postwar Development (c. 1945-1975)
*B10. Significance:Property Type:Commercial
(Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.)
*B8. Related Features:
Date:Original Location:*B7. Moved?
ArchitectureTheme:Area:City of Orange
Structural Integrity:
(List attributes and codes)
*Date of Evaluation:September, 2005
B11. Additional Resource Attributes:
(This space reserved for official comments.)
*B14. Evaluator:Robert Chattel
B13. Remarks:
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD
*B12. References:
*NRHP Status Code 6Z
Primary #
HRI #111479
YesNo Unknown
Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or #:CHAPMAN_E_439__APN_039-254-12
(Assigned by Recorder)
PrehistoricHistoric Both
B2. Common Name:
Applicable Criteria:N/A
Orange Daily News.
(Sketch Map with North arrow required.)
DPR 523B (1/95)*Required Information
Opportunities:
Status change since 1991 Survey: None.
Site Integrity:
(Continues on Pg.3.)
State of California - The Resources Agency
DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION
CONTINUATION SHEET
Description of Photo:
Primary #
HRI #111479
Trinomial ORA
Recorded by:
Date Recorded:May, 2005
P3a. Description (Continued from Pg.1):
DPR 523L (11/98)*Required Information
UpdateContinuation
Page 3 of 3
B6. Construction History (Continued from Pg.2):
Lot Acre:0.2008
Principal Building Sqft:2216
Planning Zone:O-P # of Stories:1
Years Surveyed:1991, 2005
General Plan:PFI
# of Units:1
B13. Remarks (Continued from Pg.2):
1991
D. Gest, P. LaValley, D. Matsumoto
Chattel Architecture
13417 Ventura Blvd.
Sherman Oaks, CA 91423
*Resource Name or #:CHAPMAN_E_439__APN_039-254-12
(Assigned by Recorder)
Listed in National Register:1997
# of Buildings:1