09-16-20 426 W. Almond Avenue - Orange Packing House (DRC 4890-16)AGENDA ITEM
DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE
September 16, 2020
Anna Pehoushek, Assistant Community Development Director�
Marissa Moshier, Historic Preservation Planne�
1. SUBJECT
2. SUMMARY
3. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
a (Saa Fe
a)
m p b 9,
q
a ca t R N 896
u o J 7
4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
ad j
•q ry h
•o y,ft t
u bd b g
a m
DRCITEM31_ 1 09/16/2020
5. EXISTING SITE
sctn
ff d
6. EXISTING AREA CONTEXT
y i a S F ailrad
Od D y ,ncluding
i p rt prt
,
7. ANALYSIS AND STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES
Sff q h D y vlpmnt
h pjc.
:
p eil f th dck,
g v R q i df y
P ft p k pp
ft S v "a l
" ft S AX.X.
pt f r a
. f t pc kng
r u p v.I
a p k g
S D -2 a
2: L
t p m
L . I m . T DRC
m p g w v , e
a g p k e th
pa C
DRC ITEM s.: 2 09/16/2020
8. ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION
9. PUBLIC NOTICE
10. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Categorical Exemption:
kng b
a tt t g
akg u oa pkg pv w
w
Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties ( SOI
Standards) H P gn O T T
p v q Ep.
11. STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS
T j was ap P g ,g
a qu g w M P vw Saff
m a D gg a a
a ata ,ig
Pa N 2 )
12. CONDITIONS
T apa b wg :
1.Th j s y w P
u N f N 48 6 n
P vw N 088 16
13. ATTACHMENTS
1 V M
S Pg
3 Pag m N -
4.Pag M g ,2
g w M , 7 22
6 Pj P 02
DRC ITEM 3.\ 3 09/16/2020
cc: Leason Pomeroy, 111
LP3 Architecture, LLC
158 N. Glassel! Street, #201
Orange, CA 92866
Lp3arch@aol.com
Al Ricci
alricci@riccirealty.com
N:\CDD\PLNG'Applications\Design Review\DRC 4890-16 Orange Packing House\DRC\DRC Staff Report 2-DRC 4890-16 Orange Packing House
2020-09-16.docx
DRCITEM s.t 4 09/16/2020
Vicinity Map
426 W. Almond Avenue
DRC No. 4890-16 & MNSP No. 0889-16
N
s
City of Orange
Community Development Department
ATTACHMENT NO. 1
DRC NO. 4890-16; ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
VICI N ITV MAP
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
THE HISTORIC PACKING HOUSE SITE DEVELOPMENT
426 West Almond Avenue, Orange, California
LP3 architecture, Inc. November 17, 2016
ATTACHMENT NO. 2
DRC NO. 4890-16; ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
SITE PHOTOGRAPHS
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
isir Martinztht the following
relutin b pted:
WHERES th Planning mmisi h uthrity pr Org Municpal de (OMC
l d t n t t t n liti n r le o
r th s et n t Ol i t is i t
WHERE i i Minr it l i
le p li in r e ith t r ins t O
s n i Mi it i
pr in ti r r ri tt l
S si i it i
t th r isins al n t al c
in e l t il e etr ti
e i ie tte n t p li t n une 17 2020,
vew he pr j,an mmn p to t P annin mmii wit 5 0 vot;
WHERES,the annin mmiin nut l rtis ub ing on
Augu 3,2 at hich t int est s ns h prtunityt tti fy i e i uprt of
or oppos ti n t e gn i No. -d ir it P i 1 upo
p operty s i in Exhiit , tt e hert in rpr t hre in
NOW,HEREFORE,BE I REO LVE tt t Plannigmmisi r s D si n
Rvw o. 4 90 6 an Minr it Pl e . itin h d and
co struc i n of pa kin , s ing, s iilit y impr nts n r p rty
locat d at 426 W. lmon as n the f l win finin :
ATIACHMENT NO. 3
DRC NO. 4890-16; ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
PC RESOLUTION NO. 19-20
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
SECTION 1- FINDINGS
&
F
artm .
t ppve
a dsgn,c d /em by DRC vg by
jc (OMC 1710070.F.l).
Th p j frm wi H Dign Sar
Ol Twn,ar egn f j within h Twn
Hiri stri Th j nfrm wi l l S
F Dp Scfi l rv itri rty
o Th p al tially ft p
of l.al l f
wi .
po ar l l
h
ar
o o
2.In y Natonal Rgse Hit tr,te p k mi it Sty
th Interir's tad gu (OMC 17.1007F.2)
f rm wi H l
l wi h Sy of I's
Sad T f Htc Pp (SOI Snd)rm
SOI Sd,p l
T f he h
h
p h i wi h ar h
e fun p
kingh u rm 9 10 w f tur ,
ng c ft ,wl tr hi ri rial ar z th
ui di wil fr ri Th p
rm wi SOI S.
hisic
caracr f king hou s.g rial rj ar in kping
wi h hisry th prty th qui rs th ric Dtrict.
Th rj rt the x ld Twn
Mi s s s
r c s
d s th s
c c s
pv f fe q ec tr ti,b o-a
ff-
r s
r u
p ris th D s
r sit
4 ity sv vb ad pj
r r s s
a a
a s g th
q s
5.pj ha bn gd y ig u z advs
vm ff
a e .t
al y
las 31 -Hri R ur R n/R )
bilding
imvm ar on wth ar th wi ve damg hi
marial in nfrman w th Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of
Historic Properties an H rv Dg Sar r Od wne.Th n
w qire
CN 3 CONDIIO O
O
d
m q
v
b D d S
am v
a v g g
an g m e bm th
m D m
a w v
e m D m a
d w n b
n e al
d g .
b e
w d th d v
a arm
d m b
ar b
C 'n e l m fy
cm ,,or prd in
5 D gn ew N 9 -M e N 08 6
d f es within tw m a al .ime xt
gr up ar ,ur OM S 7 8 60
6.Bui in rm a b ain a tru q d ty f
O C mmuni D artm 'D F ur t
q ir bd rmi v thi
uant
Gvrnmen Cod n 662 tu writt ti f t fes
nd/o exns plan y fi nity (90)y p erid
commeng from a v f i
e e
e r p 6
n n p y
o n ni v i
o
sc g g
an p f
p t
an (v d
e t f n e
iso c n i
e g
e C
ne v
an e rm fi h j re ar
an sub f r w i rp gr ri kg lx.
Th interp e p w -tur rie d
th ry rus agri ultur an f ki g hu
h e .Th pv g h v d pv y s
Rv w mmitt p tal .I p
uane u fi p
12 Te f x g h h d
een t hr ugh me an rn v m r al
fo he m sto p rti T tm wn l
ov f u rmi t an a
bu din rmt fi th j
13. The an an n g p , gh in h f th
ext ev on b v p y mmunity v men
ire o to f rmi .Th v mmitt m y
ro d a re mm mm ty ve ir em
14.
16.
with
IX O c t an Sp
17. ri bg rmi s,.quir rr t
al fi ,fci f mmuniy
Ss Dir
18. Pr bing rmi uan,fi h rj u
andp ar alts qir f S-wa g.
Fir
9.P g P f al
ir ff f f
rmi
P
P g s w
y f S d
w t ar ,t
Sfi c
w r an
h w O fi
An P P h ri
uan g P a
P
i b G d rm Pi r artm n ri
t art li arig and gru gr
4 All w rm a Grg P
v w.r ty n w ,G g
Al t ructu B P (B P )q y rp
h G di P qi tur wn n th g P
h th Qy g P
ais.
28.P buldg rm u p n nao
and/lo f o xin c a sys t caio
an f a desgn th n pans pp y W
29.P ssu f rtfi cc th p b snsib
n p y
n
s
l o n s i
s cns
s n th p ls
c
d in .
P s n c s
o ai n n p
P c n .b
.
n s s fo
o f b
n n s
e x
n c
u u n c f
s cs
fi ys s th q ir by h
W vs.T a a v cs tru i
n .
3 5 P bd p u cn um w rm n
gn,wning urf n ur r trc ur ar no
b v w rvis y an quir by h
isn .
6 P u g rmi ss ,s al pn b f inig
o al f th ary hm g f al b li
w nstrun o
40.A as furt ys p mming tru 'il
g m mi
mp f p y th War
Dvin Cty Og G W Cnsru N and
41 ri rt f ,furni
gul g x
-un q
W Qty
4 f mi rity
W d i
W D
f
unf i
f
,
C
ty an
D
f
lum dr gr ar rm
v
in wn am
wn am y tur ari tat,
G y -rm o ai q uir
tru tu T C B
1.
J. nr to
Pl W prt rt pj'al
BMP ih he
j'WQ
43 Pi uanc certificates y shll
demr fw W Dart:
P
p u B i e
'
l
i rt
W D prt P r
p W P n n
P p W
u p y the
P nni g y O y :
AYES:
NOES:
Sp n V -Gw W art z,nd Vsquez
N
. � 'fur== Ch.D e Simpson,annmg ommission ,i
r-17-h
D
Exhibit A
Legal Description
in
12,
to in
east and
Lot in
,o Miscellane Mas,recrds s Orang unty,alifornia,bing the pint of
north the line &
Railway right o way; thne east 88.24 fet along the nrth line of Marietta Place to the
southeast comer of L 9 in said tract; then uth to nrthast in
nce feet alng th south lin of ai Marietta ce o the nrthwest omr f
in d n n the &
o way to point b
That Manetta Place s n t
d as th ,map
Page 5 of s cell us aps,enc west 44 t to th u west com of sd
Lot ;thenc uth 0 to th rthwest comer sai ;th nce east 44 feet o th
n e st com f Lot 8; e rth 40 eet to suthas c m ,poin of
b ginning
Assessr'arcelNo:90...651-05
cd Sc
uu 3 020
7:00 p.m.
.1 S cd de t 7:02 p.m.
.2 m flg l.
h S,Vc-Glw Cmmisiners Martinez,
Vzquz d
V Glgow d publ rto f g.
St n cv c m pub.
Ne
1.6 Ne
1.7
.
.1 ly ,0
w d u 20 2020 m wrtt:
MN C Wll
D V-Glw
AY Vc-Glgw C rtz Vzquez nd Willits
S
No
RRIED
ATTACHMENT NO. 4
DRC NO. 4890-16; ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
PC MEETING MINUTES (DATED 08/03/20)
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
-d:
Ru f h nng mm f t y f O Rw N.
4890-16 and Mi S N.88-16 hi pckig
u cug u k c,,
ccby p prty 46 W..
h c c h i ni
u p ud -
Ru Rb h p c ii
h u h d h i
y u h h u
p.k n
h c g c n ac
h h Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties
(SOI Standards) h t
p bc u
d c cn
rty ,bf
h u wg
c c h
h t h c h h r u a
wh a qu y.
I h nifi ?W mm
hd 'h p b u fi ?h D g
Rw mm tt m h cu h h hi uc n
cu b h wu c t h f h p y,n t
wi b h p '.
k qu h d g
mmu ty e ur
2
MOTION CARRIED
MOTION:
SECOND:
AYES: s Ws,Martiez,Vzquz
NOES: N
MOTION CARRIED
4. ADJOURNMENT: 7:41 PM
x Pnn M My gs 17,2020,
7:p
nn Pk,
3
3.1 DESIGN REVIEW NO. 4890-16- ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
w rm firm
cnn ru p y
tr ru
v fi p ttp v y
d trutu t t a
Thre fi gr y q th
gn
Th ru ki t t
;f fl
d fi e s d .
e
tw 1 019;fi ?
rm
rt
•I H
F
ptu .
ATIACHMENT NO. 5
DRC NO. 4890-16; ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
DRC MEETING MINUTES (DATED 06/17 /20)
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting
A mm
Rw N 49-6-H fi
:
ftp f gn
vm u c bb v
x rn DR
rm
MOTON:
SC:
AYS:
NOS:
ABAIN:
RECESS: 7:34 to 7:41 p.m.
F
Im
rm rp rm a F
Ne
N
MOTION CARRIED
P
ATTACHMENT NO. 6
DRC NO. 4890-16; ORANGE PACKING HOUSE
PROJECT PLANS (DATE STAMPED 08/31/20)
Sept. 19, 2020 DRC Meeting