Loading...
03-04-20 605 E. Glendale Avenue - Coykendall Residence (DRC 5001-20)AGENDA ITEM DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE March 4, 2020 TO: THRU: FROM: CHAIR SKORPANICH AND MEMBERS OF THE DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE Anna Pehoushek, Assistant Community Development Director� Kelly Ribuffo, Associate Planner� 1. SUBJECT 2. SUMMARY 3. BACKGROUND INFORMATION M Cy Sof Perty Lco:6 .G G P D L Dy t -/(LO) Z c:Sgy d (8) xg ope 31 q gfmy ece a 449 qur fot a ae A pli:N P Dn w Cmm (C)Pj Rw Ne 4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION pp m xg d etr th g fe d f c E ameaw Hstrc Distrt. g fes j •ti f s f 435 q f e fo ar •of xp f •Io w f f ym DRCITEM 1 03/04/2020 5. EXISTING SITE 6. EXISTING AREA CONTEXT b H D 7. ANALYSIS AND STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES Iu :e u T Orange Eichler Design Standards OS)fy ma sic u cry q m b rv.ni b o x 992 uc F Bd d rv,e w y uu d d A eu,w lttl q t l a ou, g u . I ff i y a e Gl e A I : Rc e S H O y v c s c l l H D C H t s qul i o l H P rva ff k k qu r d y u : • R f ry u (); a • R DRCITEM 2 03/04/2020 8. ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION 9. PUBLIC NOTICE 10. ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW 11. STAFF RECOMMENDATION AND REQUIRED FINDINGS d md lyss i k z c d g"ds ,(. rt,r ,)p p g u y s a T Fg"h pv (d p f)T s d yg pc;d g y t g DRC : •O M (OMC •I R D G •H P rv D S O T (d O T g Sd OTDS) •O g h D S (O ) g B F m F R • I e Od H c , sd a g / y OMC 7 0 070 F. P DRC c , d OD S DRCITEM 3 03/04/2020 Orange Eichler Design Standards. Orange Eichler Design Standards. (d b ih g m rv x C 11F4) j j fill ia Gu b 12. CONDITIONS T f : e p p b d m 2 (ap ry 18 )rt qrd y o y Dsign C A sbj o v y C y p g h o p o m D p D C m Dm D e s d b h e DRCITEM 4 03/04/2020 .I p , g g Gme S 6 7 I z pj 4 f E m OMC 17800 13. ATTACHMENTS 1 Vy M Aeu 2/18/20 3 L o E 4 S Ph 5 E M LJ-7 4(R)I BP #3067 4 M c o P 7 DPR F 05 E G A N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 5001-20 Coykendall Residence DRCITEM 5 03/04/2020 Vicinity Map 605 E. Glendale Avenue DRC No. 5001-20 M LI) LI) 0. M N M "q" 0 M "q" LI) LI) LI) -o "O "O "O NDALE AVE 184 1843 1844 1843 1828 J- 1829 1830 1829 Cl) w J- 0 Cl) 1814 Cl) 1815 1816 � 1815 0 0 0 0 1804 0 _J � 1801 1802 z 1801 � N RED= CONTRIBUTING HISTORIC RESOURCE YELLO = NON-CONTRIBUTING RESOURCE s City of Orange Community Development Department ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 5001-20; COYKENDALL RESIDENCE VICINITY MAP March 4, 2020 DRC Meeting BUILDING DIVISION RECEIVED FEB 18, 2020 CITY OF ORANGE ATTACHMENT NO. 2 DRC NO. 5001-20; COYKENDALL RESIDENCE ARCHITECTURAL PLANS (DATED 02/18/20) March 4, 2020 DRC Meeting PLANNING DIVISION RECEIVED JAN O 6 2020 CITY OF ORANGE hat q l h d p om re r. S, 11� an ,/&�r k ATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC NO. 5001-20; COYKENDALL RESIDENCE LETTER OF EXPLANATION March 4, 2020 DRC Meeting STRATOS FORM ARCHITECTURE INTERIORS Date: Job Number: November 14, 2019 19-28 Coykendall Residence - Photo Study 605 E. Glendale Ave. Orange, CA 92865 #1 605 E. Glendale Ave. -- Subject Property -- South Facade AITACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 5001-20; COYKENDALL RESIDENCE SITE PHOTOGRAPHS March 4, 2020 DRC Meeting 275 SOUTH GLASSELL STREET, ORANGE, CALIFORNIA 92866 TEL: 714 628-0777, FAX: 714 628-0797; WWW.STRATOSFORM.COM STRATOS FORM IS A DIVISION Of FOX GROUP ARCHIHCTS, INC. #2 619 E. Glendale Ave. – South Façade -- East of Subject Property #3 545 E. Glendale Ave. – South Façade -- West of Subject Property # 4 Side Yards of 1843 N. Woodside St and 1844 N. Winlock St.-- Across the Street of Subject Property #5 Side Yard of 1843 N. Woodside St. – Across the Street and West of Subject Property # 6 Side Yard of 1844 N. Winlock St. – Across the Street and East of Subject Property #7 Subject Property – East Façade #8 Subject Property – North Façade #9 Subject Property – West Façade Views of a neighboring Eichler house with the same floor plan that our proposal emulates: #10 729 E. Glendale --Front Elevation #11 729 E. Glendale --Oblique +­ _c 0) Q) -0 (/) (/) (/) 0 0) •• Q) �� .... u c (/) l,U _Q .... 0 c Q) 0-:2 �5 z- •• 0 Ill 1,; � Q) +­ ;> � 0 O Q) - - (/) .,, u -0 c - Q) ·- 0 x 3-0 ·- ·- '--1- 0 - ,._ N O c [.� 0 0 t ��� i.: � Q) ..c c .... 0 Oz Vl -e 0 ""O c: 0 vi c 0) "vi Q) Q I.. .s ..c: u w 'Q) O'l c e 0 'C:fl ID ·.•• 03 a, 0 c ....... .,_ 0 � rn ... 0 0 � a. ,i-::- a, c :s "U 0 u a c 0 ·..::: =a � "'O O ctz ((Ji) c _....... 0 � � E ...._.. •.. •• E 0 � 1:;w '"O 0 .: .� oes .. C} c N .... E .I: u,, .., a © I a.= :::, r- u c ... :J ... 0 CJ.-- c-Q ... u_ PRIMARY RECORD ORA 6Z D # -· _B.M. ----- ----- D D D D D ist atbes ad codes)---------------------------·----------------- (Cit survy port d h oc ,tr "o .") ec ().h l chic r () Hic Ro urcs Sve . 2 o 14 Vw e si# 9 4 c D D D (Nm fflo ,d addrss) Mar Msh ,H c r rv i Pl Ci of a g .hap a v . ra g ,CA 98 Ju 25 (Dscrib ) Rcaisac mens D D D D :=] D D D D L: 523A (1/95 q t ATTACHMENT NO. 7 DRC NO. 5001-20; COYKENDALL RESIDENCE DPR FORM FOR 605 E. GLENDALE AVENUE Mch 4,2020 DRC Meeting B1. Historic Name:Unknown B3. Original Use:RES B4. Present Use:RES *B5. Architectural Style:Mid-Century Modern *B6. Construction History:(Construction date, atlerations, and date of alterations)Date of Construction:1964 *B9. Architect or Builder:Eichler Homes Period of Significance:Eichler Tract (c. 1959 - 1965) *B10. Significance:Property Type:Residence (Discuss importance in terms of historical or architectural context as defined by theme, period, and geographic scope. Also address integrity. Continues on Pg.4.) *B8. Related Features: Date:Original Location:*B7. Moved? ArchitectureTheme:Area:City of Orange Structural Integrity:Good Condition - High level of alteration as of 2005. (List attributes and codes) *Date of Evaluation:September 2005 B11. Additional Resource Attributes: (This space reserved for official comments.) *B14. Evaluator:Robert Chattel B13. Remarks: State of California - The Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION BUILDING, STRUCTURE, AND OBJECT RECORD *B12. References: *NRHP Status Code 6Z Large front facing gable roof installed with possible second story addition. Garage doors replaced, recessed entry infilled, one window added to front elevation. Primary # HRI # YesNo Unknown Page 2 of 3 *Resource Name or #:GLENDALE_E_605__APN_374-211-04 (Assigned by Recorder) PrehistoricHistoric Both B2. Common Name: Applicable Criteria:N/A Orange Daily News. Eichler Tract Brochures and miscellaneous Eichler materials from the Orange Public Library. (Sketch Map with North arrow required.) DPR 523B (1/95)*Required Information Opportunities Status change since 1991 Survey: Not previously surveyed. Site Integrity: (Continues on Pg.3.) State of California - The Resources Agency DEPARTMENT OF PARKS AND RECREATION CONTINUATION SHEET Primary # HRI # Trinomial ORA Recorded by: Date Recorded:June 2015 P3a. Description (Continued from Pg.1): DPR 523L (11/98)*Required Information UpdateContinuation Page 3 of 3 B6. Construction History (Continued from Pg.2): Lot Acre:0.2054 Principal Building Sqft:2375 Planning Zone:R-1-8 # of Stories:1 Years Surveyed:2005, 2015 General Plan:LDR # of Units:1 B13. Remarks (Continued from Pg.2): 2005 Marissa Moshier, Historic Preservation Planner City of Orange 300 E. Chapman Ave. Orange, CA 92866 *Resource Name or #:GLENDALE_E_605__APN_374-211-04 (Assigned by Recorder) Listed in National Register: # of Buildings:1 Description of Photo: