The URL can be used to link to this page

09-18-19 154 S. Shaffer Street - St. John's Courtyard (DRC 4981-19)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM SEPTEMBER 18, 2019 Anna SUMMARY RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION niIn(urifiPan)(P-1(S))EmGthiRtyntruc4,withadjacnurtyfrmgsargStJohnsanuramu,umandmniffirtyz6,923 qyarDPUBLIC NOTICE qgn Design Review Committee Staff Report September 18, 2019 Page 2 of6 ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (SOI Standards) PROJECT DESCRIPTION kwiakurttruvungranitruturgnnWkHTprtkarwioturun•BnhNksrthrtyAn nhmundjthThnsunsingwinnjb.•Lg.ariyanargrnrthurtfithphebckurtyttGtrwiaiEXISTING SITE ssurtywJuConsrvtory (oy church paro.cGRtykugconstrucd 1914 and iary gnNPexvg, aiLttGgntrtrktwkTharge. JhnLuheran ambtwvan. ChpvStrfftrIWkum constructd 1927 and thr scbunitrffiWkum kurtyUndr tht. Jo's thran SpfiPan, sqsswithHtPrvgn SOT Design Review Committee Staff Report September 18, 2019 Page 3 of6 EXISTING AREA CONTEXT EVALUATION CRITERIA 17 .10.070 1. Architectural Features. 2. Landscape. kiakpar3Signage. Agngwiin(ri4Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. ,dainrmaniuiann,hichhiygANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES fffijtru,anunfrjTartriJhnuramanwignurtytynidaProjcnsanttrt Design Review Committee Staff Report September 18, 2019 Page 4 o/6 ADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION REQUIRED FINDINGS xtriSJhn'LuramgnrpturmtthacbarturtyrtyrnwxgartrikpSryfI'SaGul(OMC.00G2)PrjectuneinfrmHOTwnynfrmSOIS.In nfrmwiSar9SIS,wturarfrgtryhsturzurribuigson tht. Jhn'Lutan CurIn rm10ecturecanounfuturamgig stryangn tur, matrialaneign f thhisric camufffrhisnfrmSOIS.3Thepjctdesguputyugully,itegraeddegnthemeandiontetlifipppblgnsada,anirquefis(OM1..G. 3 Design Review Committee Staff Report September 18, 2019 Page 5 o/6 ).tyfIfillRdDlCONDITIONS armtyffigyfrtyaiyarisurmxCty'crmaifuturyCyuntyartm'uFaiurbiqirrmthi6Izxirtwty-urfrExgrOM708060PannixunuPrmar Design Review Committee Staff Report September 18, 2019 Page 6 o/6 ATTACHMENTS :SJhn'Cur4SaffrtrOg,C866SaniSrmTrrIngr366WhPTC780<ani@rrgr>N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4981-19 St John's Courtyard\StaffReport- DRC 4981-19 - St Johns Courtyard.docx Vicinity Map 185 S. Center Street DRC No. 4981-19 N s City of Orange Community Development Department ATTACHMENT NO. 1 DRC NO. 4981-19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARD VICINITY MAP September 18, 2019 DRC Meeting 30-ll.!181935 lilRliJI 038·30;1.. 0RA eoaa 1s ®QiarUstlngs. G:RHR and, NHu:, IP qµe tN&740 (Ref;. ;f.9!1.0011.520) Ravlaw Gacia: Datil: #: # D ,maerias,cot,atrati,size,setig,aburies.Ctie,3.idiiiiubygpnnpponAgbn(6)(P26)--wegwnowLitattriesacoe)D D D D D Ctesurvprtaeure,et"e."Ouys(20)Ai(205)HiicevyAEI(1)gIveyUpaeHegOngunyI(2)Ovy.bp2005 (Vew,ae,ace#)*6CtS4 D D *wAd*B:eedbyNme,ffiltio,anades)D.vyDM47 VBv.nOs142*9dAp20*0SurveyTyp(Describe)RnAttmenD D D D D D D D D hpD Li:D523A(1/95qnormaiATTACHMENT NO. 2 DRC NO. 4981-19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARD HISTORIC RESOURCE SURVEY FORM September 18, 2019 DRC Meeting #: ------------------------------------ * Historic O Prehistoric O Both No O Yes O Unknown ---------------- ------------------------------------ addIegrityCtinueonPg.4.)-------------------------..-. -------------- owky,msutatsin93,uni14espqsShnsuthrarsgg18oryItsdyGedrwhurcsdAttb(listattributesandcodes)-------------------------------------------------------------- *RcD"AWkI...".96mmyHcyade , Amse Uy"fgH" ocr(90.3) g& yMp(59091922, 9)83.mark(ContinusonPg.3.)s99y: o. y. SkcMapwilhNorthrrowreqied.)*814Evau:Re*DfEvlutnSpmbr, 5 r(Tlaceeservedffficicomets)DPR 5238 (1/95) *equfrm��-��-'-��""-��-� ARI!#' 30-1.5'8935 03830iL 0RA #: (Assigned by Recorder) � Continuation D Update ��-- # # aDpdfg1l 1 1 Dpnfhb,gtentroofanda.agagakfaThemainentryispf-ppupopatacapitalslhpmsbdgfeatuetrefoilandqufysdggd(h)dabethemainentryandgsbugsdg.DPR 523L (11/98) *Inorm Pr:lmaey� l:IRI# Trnnomlal 30-i!.589'3'5 (:)3•83011. � Page 4 of 4 Recorded by: D. D. Date Recorded: ---------------------------------- � Continuation O Update *Resource Name or #: (Assigned by Recorder) 810. Significance (Continued from Pg.2): wOg--,F,DGD,Bm,DkKgThgCtg& MgCpysbsfccngeca0,eveafhaimnvwgbEgsGAlstuarexcnavcdcO.cgfecaTcng,npa,pbbyhfdmkgwwafcxpgy.Tcrcipranoobgdngxpsfcn.Pypffa,aww,wefmFBrC.fMp,M.TgasssppfrnyfppsdfWWII.DPR 523L (11/98) *Required Information P- HRl1# ,Sfiiftis, llll24'4!$ ORA D . - - -- D ��- .CntiueonPg.3.)eoldt7.,WHlMmfdt5.d.TliltetoMdvivltywisrongRvivfTWeMmiu,,diningroom,tiyT(P1)mmirLttriucod)D D D O D h(Ilae,etc.)bpofto25(View,secess#)*6CtdAgo97�HcD PhoriD h*wAd*Bcdby(Nme,affillUon,andaddress)D.G,PLvey,D.mtli7VBlvdm,9423*prtCtaCurvyreportrr".")netys(20)Ar(200)RcvyGI(9)tBldigIvoyU.Hggy,I()gicSurvy.9pi,25*0SrvyTyp(Describe)RiAtthts:DR 2A (9) D NOD LcMp � iSh(s) � g, ru, Ojct RecorD Ahgl D D LaFaRD Millig SRerd D Rock rt Record D ArtaD haphD Oh(L): qrm #: � Historic O Prehistoric O Both No D Yes D Unknown -------------- _ --------------------------------------------------------------. Pg.4.) ------ itionalResourcettributes:*81813.RarkPg.a.) with :*814Evaua:RbtCal*DatfEvaluatonSpmb,l(This rrvnetsJI DPR 5238 (1/95) *Rqerm Rrlmacy1# (i)E(A D �----------------------------� #: (Assigned by Recorder) 2 1 I# fBugZP-I# fA0# tsrinBuqft:ripti(g.)budgnbwbikwgpiydfibiwnbidf.ApyhgsbywfenewnninbTsfffnfcdnlppdppwnoalffauingnddprpnssnstsmnwinwwcnaguapnssfcd86.uHry(Cud.DPR 523L (11/98) *qdrm ettier ll.'JjtiiJgs: li>iiti: #: B.M. -· -- D # *a. �� tinusnPg3lM4ffd55.mTJPsttsplx,gwthhbddWklsds,twybteiynd(HP2),(Pl)--psogLttridcodD D D D D (Crvyreportth,""uycd(5)ttA()HvyGI()BdIvyUdouy,I()ovy2 O O 5 (Viw,acssi#)D D (Name,affllaUn.andaddrssDGs,Lvly,0MltVBlvd.,42p,Typ(Describe)ttmts:D D D D dD LFudD MillgincordD ockArtRecordD rtD hpedD {L:qInrm BRI# #: •es. ._. __ � Historic O Prehistoric O Both No O Yes D Unknown ._.___________ ---------------------------------. •es. ._. .... icsco.Aldsstegrity.CiPg.4.)------------ ies:& 8AiiRcAtt(Listttributeacoes)_ . *82.& 83emrk(CtiuesP.3.)j<SkelchMapwith Northarmwreqr.)*814.EvRb*DofEvalunSpmb,25(Ticersrvfrfficiacommets.)DPR 5238 (1/95) *qdrm �nmar.y� l:fRll# D.ll! 4a,5 ORA O Update � Continuation �� (Assigned by Recorder) 19 91 l 2 1 te)fTbopatsymmey,dfypjptcohichsdy.Ay.g,pgfyFnoa.etydotgwfkdygd,F!IUtsSqft6R5L(11/98} *RqIrm • t err or n INTEGRATION & ,. ' Letter of Explanation Company Name: St. John's Lutheran Church 154 South Shaffer Street Orange, CA 92866 714-288-4411 pgyk,()yrtleheoxsdgrtasy,CeggDeiokppkxp13661 Wheeler Place I Tustin I CA I 92780 714-724-9814 I www.terrainintegration.com ATTACHMENT NO. 3 DRC NO, 4981-19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARD APPLICANT LETTER OF EXPLANATION September 18, 2019 DRC Meeting Product I nfiormatiolil Size: Weight: Material: Reinforcing: Drain Hole: Hardware: Planter 1iF 4123 48" Dia. x 36" H 1,320 Lbs. Reinforced concrete 3/8" Dia. steel rebar (1) 2" Dia. drain hole (3) 5/8" Dia. lifting inserts Finish Options Standard -Exposed Aggregate -Weatherstone Note: Lifting inserts are to ONLY be used when planter is EMPTY Date: 7/10/15 ATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4981-19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARD MATERIAL SPECIFICATIONS September 18, 2019 DRC Meeting PRODUCT DETAILS SKATE FA135 IFA Serles - Surface Mount Alumlnuml 0 0 @ 1547 N. cuvamaca. El Caion. CA 92020 Tel 619-447-6374 Fax 619-447-6396 Descripdon: rsrt2 I 2.5800 I"' {o sctJoJ . ' . ==--��--=-"'"°"o ti'. - I � 0 N 0 - Product Spacing: I B" from end pkmten/walb and opp,oximately 36" centan. • _ .... f'inkh: oU 0< Smart Pins Use in with two-portimparsisnapoxy.(shown in Clear Anodized) Material: 606-6Finish: Htmvllhg.lmmfipisncldpIClzHiz.Corner Radius: 4gOutside Dimensions: "(x-)x-/8)Anchoring: AffRLUSnUsanhorsnjit-rtpxy.Product Spacing: 8mpxiy6eDapplytj z w w 0:: o Cl) w o z w LL ro ...... c 0 N ...... 0 I 0.0 c t) c ro 1n Q) Q) ...... LL --' _, c( u. ' PLAN L � l l ·� - VI I- z :E I- w =:, I :E :::;; Q w -W "' �I o � :::;; --' w � ' z 00 c( ,:ta.. � Cl w .. !::::! VI -- VI --' w z 1r: :E I- =:, I I- :::;; Q I - w C!l �I w :::;; --' I w ' z � � 1r: ·__..--,- - "' w > � _,.,..., i.-: � ii: lO w +r > ,/, I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I > I I I I I I I I u. "' I I I I I I I" w > I I I I I I I f I I.J I I L.I -'.- '---- ___ ..J ELEVATION FREESTANDING HORIZONTAL - FENCE I SCREEN WI "@N@12".."Kgreenscreen® ,#GEDED@BTIBT& BBNV,O& :INBQBOFOOFE/:FYFFTLALAT'BG�"Kgreenscreen® ,I!) greenscreen 1743 S. La Cienega Blvd. Los Angeles CA 90035 T- 800.450.3494 www.greenscreen.com I I r I I I I I I 1------+----- I I I " r----y •r ,,, ,, I I , I I� PLAN I SECTION '°:.-:_":.-:.-:.-:.-:.-:.-:.-:.-:_, greenscreen®'°:.-:_; ,rs "'O (l) ....... c :::::, 0 ::?; ....... VI 0 a, a. u a. ro c (/) >< Q. M M ...J ,-t O � CJ z - 1- z :::> 0 � "Atl/2" ELEVATION 0 #5133X SNAP CLIP - POST MOUNTED ...J ...J � ® greenscreen rn.cm ATTACHMENT NO. 5DRC NO. 4981-19; ST. JOHN'S COURTYARDPLANS (DATE STAMPED 11/12/19)September 18, 2019 DRC MeetingPLANNING DIVISION RECEIVED SEP 12 2019CITY OF ORANGE