Loading...
08-21-19 159 N. Shaffer Street- Malloy Garage (DRC 4975-19)AGENDA DATE: To: THRU: FROM: SUBJECT: SUMMARY DESIGN REVIEW COMMITTEE AGENDA ITEM AUGUST 21, 2019 Anna RECOMMENDED ACTION - FINAL DETERMINATION BACKGROUND INFORMATION 3022R846yanniru2cf24qoryyvxfl Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page2 o/6 PUBLIC NOTICE ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW Categorical Exemption: PROJECT DESCRIPTION ttaEXISTING SITE crty,5q,-ryyrn,ru9-triOwnHtri,duxrty,.Thufrn4araI7,yylanniCmmsso.janlupprovaltofyflthruhbxtturro lsthe araEXISTING AREA CONTEXT rtthafurrunz16rtriariamyaHtrithjpnary rn.,mmral Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 3 of6 EVALUATION CRITERIA in 1. Architectural Features. 2. Landscape. Signage. Secondary Functional and Accessory Features. ng,trrmaniqpdannwhichyc()ANALYSIS/STATEMENT OF THE ISSUES --6znandtheparkin-famygnthararcmptbexgudHfffitiiityffrkthDRCICFYkHPrvDgn Sangn farry urth(p33-Narry dn angn histriy[ ] Nry hind Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 4 o/6 hm6).rthjtraartrwjgv7k(pyth)30(py)jwythrrtktrthitriprtwng'tywitrl,HewilyrykffqthahDRCtyakojdqfiADVISORY BOARD RECOMMENDATION NyqDgn RREQUIRED FINDINGS fi"F" akzakaking"akFi" drathrfyd(.virnmedum,.)anunrtrtFbtwaki"F" i 5 Design Review (OMC17.10070G.)INigHi,theSecreryof'SGu(M17.10.07G.).3jgnmtyhgllycostent,grgniifi,leesgn,qfig(OM7.0.07.G. 3)4.FnfilmifityfgfinlDesgnG,w()imblw,mas,,ugoehcexiggh(MC7007.G.4)CONDITIONS be Gthp,thnulvpasruniprvhhangpanthq3fialfircgtruumBrhchk Design Review Committee Staff Report August 21, 2019 Page 6 o/6 ATTACHMENTS Irv928@ryHrury@N:\CDD\PLNG\Applications\Design Review\DRC 4975-19 Malloy Garage\StaffReport- DRC 4975-19- Malloy Garage.docx Vicinity Map 159 N. Shaffer Street DRC No. 4975-19 N s City of Orange ATTACHMENT N0.1 DRC NO. 4975-19; MALLOY GARAGE VICINITY MAP August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting Community Development Department gpprty,dagxtTfizBy,'rygovyofxlIrymuntogdEponShff5opdpryhRtwpSffyrydAinsgddykvxta.RyddtwoudvgnmNxtyyMyqpttTyggd,yTUPSggdgATTACHMENT NO. 2 DRC NO. 4975-19; MALLOY GARAGE APPLICANT LETTER OF EXPLANATION August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting 0 c tyBuwe'kyryMglpjyyWkygyhgrge.kyOw:MicheMaloyR:SbmittaforGaragCostrcto159N.SaffrStretOageCA92866 � 0 (D Q V) - -· - cc 0 :::, --< <, .,, co c .... 0 -· - -c Cl. 0 ::0 en (D CD 3 c.. 0 z Cl. (D CD - -· � :l co G) Vl (D Q � .... < Q -· r'\ (Q (D CD V) 0 � r1> "' lE' :::J ..._ CQ !:. c:: :::0 -� r1> 3 0 c. f � :i' 1.C v, r1> < ;:;· r1> "' � "Tl 0 -, 3 0 � (1) r-+ OJ (1) r-+ (1) f-1. < l/1 OJ U) r-+ z 0 � V> 0 � -+, OJ (1) � x v, -, r-+ V> � r-+ O'Q -, (1) (1) r-+ OQ z ro "'O OJ ro x ::r "'""I -· OJ :E Vl 0 OQ l"'T l"'T ro :E :J 0 er 0 OQ 0 ro 0 ::r --+, -· a. 0 :E a. Vl 3 0 ro -· 0 :J a. ro a. l"'T :J I -· Vl n OQ OJ OJ a. - l"'T l"'T :J 0 "C OQ l"'T "'""I ::r O :J -· "C Vl Vl O l"'T Vl Vl OJ -· ro ro a. a. :J a. OQ 0 :J � Z::s -o - ro v, ::r aj :E arc � OJ 8" l"'T v, ro O 0 "C a. --+, er � o OJ rn l"'T ::s v, ro "C a.n x ::r � 3 � � �- "C ::s" n n o OQ O OJ !:!::!. ::r 3 l"'T �- 0 "C 0 0 3 0 l"'T :J "" Vl ::r "'""I � 1,1 .-..: vi" 0 0 "'""I O :J 0 ::!1 0 :J ::!1 OQ :J OJ OQ l"'T 3� OJ O l"'T "C ro o :::::!. Vl OJ ro - a. "'""I 0 0 ::!1 :J OQ 3 OJ l"'T ro "'""I -· OJ n ,-+ c ..., ro c.. 3 OJ ,-+ ro ..., OJ ""O 3 ..., m c.. ro x ..., � 0 ""O <" ro n OJ ro ..., OJ ::J :E o::;· � c.. OJ ,-+ c.. [ -c 0 :E c.. O"' 3 � ..., ..., OJ ""' <" R- H :E ro :::r OJ :E -c OJ '< OJ ::J c.. -0 :::r 0 ,-+ 0 0 --n m x v, ,-+ -· ::J O'Q OJ ::J c.. -0 :::r 0 ,-+ 0 0 --n ro x v, ,-+ -· ::J O'Q ..., s ere � B 3 al :E c � � n 3 n O ::J zr � c v, "Q. ro 3 ::J n vi" ::J --n ,-+ v, ..., C OJ O ri3 ::J � ::J c.. c.. ""O .; 3 ""O ..., OJ O"' OJ O ..., ::::!. OJ �- ""O c.. n �o � ""' ::::!. 8 ro :E OJ < c.. OJ ro ""O OJ z v, -0 -· ,-+ ro n ro tr ,-+ ""O :E n 0 c ..., ,-+ -· ,-+ ..., 0 v, 0 0 ro ""O ro ::J 0 c.. 0 n OJ O'Q v, ,-+ --n ro -· O'Q ro OJ 0 ..., c.. ::J OJ x OJ O'Q OJ ..., v, O'Q OJ - OJ ,-+ ro O'Q -· ..., O'Q ro ::J c.. OJ OJ O'Q O O'Q ..., c.. O'Q OJ o ro O'Q O OJ ..., ,-+ ro 0 ..., 0 ..., OJ 0 � 3 c.. I O'Q Ill "' 0 ro u5· :::, OJ 0 .._ ,-+ ttl ..., c: n c:: zr :0 ·l) Ill 3 0 c, !E. I s· lO v, Ill < ;::;· � n 0 ""'I :J ([) ""'I ::r 0 3 ([) . z� �"'C � � 3' � 0 ,-+ :1E c OJ O 0 :J :J v, O a. a. 0 a. ,-+ :E -+, ,-+ ::::::!. ([) ""'I 3 :J x 3 a. tn' OJ O !:!". ,-+ :E :J ([) ............. OQ �- a. :E !:!". 0 0 :J O O OQ ""'I a. OJ OQ ""C OJ ""C ""'I ""'I OJ O OQ ""C ([) ""'I ,-+ a:;· 0 ,-+ c ([) v, OJ ([) ""'I ,-+ ([) ::r OJ v, tn' OJ ,-+ ,-+ :::::'!. ""C 3 a OJ ""C ,-+ 0 v, ([) a. Cl � ti> "' IC. ::J --. 0::, s, a: zo ti> -� 3 0 a. � I s· IQ v, n, < ;:;· � n :::J V> ""C 0 r-+ n ., ., c 0 c 0 3 ., n "'C "'C r-+ 0 :::J 0 c V> V> ., m ., m I OJ a. r-+ ., m )> n m m n 0 -+, r-+ :::J m x c n ., V> OJ m r-+ r-+ - "'C 0 :::J m r-+ (.J.J OQ :::J -+, 0 C'"� 0 ., ., :::::!. -e m m n OQ :::J :::J ;,;.- OJ r-+ a. r-+ ., m � m < ., OJ r-+ OQ -· O OJ :::J OQ OJ r-+ m V> :::J a. CJ .,, "' IC. ::, .._ ex, !::. c:: ::0 .,, 3 0 a. lb 5· lO VI lb < ;::;· lb "' �- ""C a. ., m o "'C 0 0 -+, V> -c m ., a. 0 "'C ct 0 :::J v, n m -· a. :::J OQ OQ OJ OJ ., r-+ OJ V> OQ O m c r-+ :::::r CJ � Ill v, u:i' :::, ...... a, c: a: :,:, ·l) Ill 3 0 c. � I s· IQ V'I 11> < ;:;· ffi �OQ )> u, OJ a. U) ., '--· OJ OJ z OQ n • rt> rt> (./) ::, ::, ::::r O r-t OJ ;::i ::::r � ::::r 0 ., 0 3 (./) -+i rt> r-t OJ ., rt> ::, rt> a. r-t � OQ )> u, OJ a. U) ., '--· OJ OJ zOtl n rt> rt> (./) v, ::, ::::r 0 r-t OJ c ::::r � r-t 0 ::::r 3 ., 0 (./) -+i rt> r-t OJ ., rt> ::, rt> a. r-t )> n n (1) ::J ,-+ m x CD o ,-+ (1) 0 r 0 -, .... a· )> go :i" -, () UJ ij "O @' QJ ;:,,;;:: g. -· ::J ::i ,-+ 0 n o m 0 0 )> 0 iil 0 ..... -, 00 -...J m x ,-+ (1) -, -· 0 � o -, §- ij I .... QJ go -· :i" m ::J --f UJ "O x ,-+ =r ,-+ n m Ql (1) :::!: 0 -, 0 ::i -· 0 0 0 o -, -, m 0 ij � 0 QJ (ri -· co ::J 00 ,-+ 0 n 0 0 -, Vl � � "' u:i' :J ...... co !:. a: :0 flJ . l 3 0 c. � s: '° v, flJ < ;:;· 11> "' City of Orange - Design Review Committee Final Meeting Minutes for December 21, 2016 Page 7 of 14 (5) DRC 4849-16 - Malloy Residence 624 (714)744-7243, & Public Comments: u:opprprryturthrigb'AknpromfurmommbrtpttrnftrrnOldhraryuraCurr,pmnthflargnmtegarguwowrtyATTACHMENT NO. 4 DRC NO. 4975-19; MALLOY GARAGE DRC MINUTES (12/21/16) August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting 9-16,Mysc,wthhfigcdshfprtSECOND: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: AMcrmttnAnnDrmttRrtImbTMCrmkNMOTION FAILED. mmMImbddvohePlannngCisifDRN9-6,MyRsc,whhfiingandcndtnnthetartwthhfwgddcd:ThfchthsinggarghxssthwantcnushhficawsuprtbyhOTowneDegnStandard.SECOND: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: TMcrmkAnnMcrmtt,TmcrmckanrtImbodnCaxNMOTION CARRIED. 3. NEW HEARING: 3.1 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT NO. 3022-16 AND DESIGN REVIEW NO. 4849-16 - MALLOY RESIDENCE LOCATION: NOTE: 159 N. SHAFFER STREET Secretary of the Interior's Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (Secretary's Standards). Secretary's Standards, wquiRECOMMENDED ACTION: PmmuN17d,byDiscussion: MariM,rvannpjrvaffrtmmkdaffffdg;ffrtw'dflr;ktruturwv;kdfwrnrthprtfi;kwwrf;wfi;kdwfifwtruhiriwunSecretary of Interior's Standards; prtdmmfl.Thpwkffpwas Jfhiaitwgnpdraivgn p2 ATTACHMENT NO. S DRC NO. 4975-19; MALLOY GARAGE PC MINUTES (02/06/17) August 21, 2019 DRC Meeting thu;aff'rimmfraablfthDR;thtrututribunanthufwtt;ththsgnst159rthShffShOT,ghimwasgyxpEQA,hhhhd:1. DfApp3 hRmngsothegbbhxOTIO:SECOND:AYES:OES:ABSET:mmrrGCmmrr,GGSpWsNNOTIOARRIE3